The second sequel to Urban Legend, released in 2005 Direct-to-DVD.
This time, murders are committed by an actual urban legend character, and the main characters must find a way to stop her. Stars Kate Mara and features her sister Rooney Mara in a cameo.
This film has the examples of:
- Body Horror: Heather's death recreates the urban legend of a spider laying its eggs in a sleeping person's cheek.
- Continuity Nod: The urban legend murders from the first two films are mentioned.
- Grievous Bottley Harm: Bloody Mary kills Buck with a broken bottle.
- Leitmotif: The signal that Bloody Mary is coming is Niki Haris' "I Will Always Be There" starts playing… which is the last song she heard before her death.
- Room Full of Crazy: Grace has a room full of drawings based on urban legends.
- Sins of Our Fathers: Background of the film, as the characters from the older generation got Mary killed, and she's now killing the newer one.
- Trapped In a Tanning Bed: One of the students, Roger, is killed by being locked in a tanning bed set very high. By the time they get it open, he's reduced to a charred skeletal corpse.