A nice, but very weak old lady who is a huge Survivor fan.
First Cooking Mama fan character.
- Ascended Fangirl
- The Load
- Nice Girl: Considered too nice for the game by her teammates, which is why they kept Gus over her.
A blatant Sonic recolor who believes that speed is the key to winning the game.
Second Sonic the Hedgehog fan character.
- Flat Character: Admitted by the author.
- Jerk Jock
-
Shocking Elimination: A 2-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1 vote towards him. - We Hardly Knew Ye: Had almost no screentime or characterization.
A cute young anime girl with creepy blue eyes.
First Lucky Star fan character.
A kid who seemed nice at first, but eventually lived up to the name of his series.
First Bully fan character.
- Bald of Evil: Shaved head, but still.
- Took a Level in Jerkass: This leads to his elimination.
A green haired demon with control over fire. Was close to being in control of the Brawns tribe until the Tribal Swap.
First Devil May Cry fan character.
- Disc-One Final Boss: Was the grandmaster of the game who had it all planned out... until the Tribal Swap, which took away every iota of power he had, and promptly got him voted out.
- Laser-Guided Karma: He tormented Chris with the threat of spilling his relationship with Kris; guess what happened when all three were put on the same tribe...
- Only Sane Man: At least compared to the rest of his tribe.
- Playing with Fire: When he is voted out, he toys with Jeff and keeps his torch lit after numerous attempts to extinguish it.
- You Gotta Have Green Hair
An alien who is interested in studying humans and never shows emotion. Despite this he ends up being nice.
First Destroy All Humans! fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars.
- Aliens Speaking English
- Bizarre Alien Biology: His freakishly-long purple tongue scares Jeff Probst.
- Everyone Calls Him "Barkeep": Al's real name is F'Kiulty Strung VX. He goes by Al, short for Alien, because it's easier for earthlings to pronounce.
- Rubber-Forehead Aliens
- The Stoic: To the point of parody.Bitsy: Al, the truth is...Al: What?Bitsy: I already found one of the idols.(beat)Bitsy: Uh, I can't tell by your face. Are you happy, shocked, excited, or angry?
An ape who is obsessed with strength.
First Donkey Kong fan character.
- A Death in the Limelight
- Everything's Better with Monkeys
- Jerk Jock: Averted.
- Ship Tease: With Polly.
An unstable girl who loses it once she's betrayed by her allies.
First Naruto fan character.
- Girl Posse: With Mary.
- My Death Is Just the Beginning: Upon quitting, reveals every single secret on the show.
- Non-Gameplay Elimination
- Rage Quit
A (somehow) blond puffball who is always thinking about betraying his current allies.
First Kirby fan character.
- Chronic Backstabbing Disorder
- Sixth Ranger Traitor: To the Al/Bitsy alliance and to the main brawn alliance. He gets voted out because of this.
A purple bird who attempts to lead her tribe.
Second Animal Crossing fan character.
- How Much Did You Hear?
- Karmic Death: Kept Bitsy over Max... only to be promptly blindsided by Bitsy.
- Ship Tease: With Spike.
- Shocking Elimination
An incredibly bitchy woman who has a blinding hatred for anything non-human.
First Love Hina fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars.
- Alpha Bitch
- Cluster F-Bomb: If should be noted that, in season one, most of the real bad language was censored out (sometimes for laughs). Along comes Mary...
- Fantastic Racism: Mary cannot stand anything that isn't human.
- Jerkass
A sweetheart dingo who is constantly victimized by Mary.
First Crash Bandicoot fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars.
- Nice Girl
- Odd Friendship: With Al.
- Token Good Teammate: Of the Brains tribe.
An aged war veteran who has invaluable survival skills.
First Advance Wars fan character.
- Cool Old Guy
- Game-Breaking Injury
- Thanatos Gambit: He guilt-trips the "Good People" alliance into voting him out after he sprains his arm, succeeding in keeping their initial target Ellise in the game and exposing the so-called "Good People" as hypocrites at Tribal Council for almost refusing to vote out an injured old man in need of medical help over a healthy woman.
- What The Hell "Good People" Alliance: Gus is always very quick to call out the "Good People" alliance on the fact that they are a very big bunch of hypocrites.
A young woman who is notable for almost never speaking throughout the season, despite being perfectly capable.
First Haruhi Suzumiya fan character.
- Informed Ability: The cast always complained about how she talks too much, even though we never see her say a word. The same trope applies for her "under-the-radar" game.
- Motor Mouth: Double subverted. While she was still in the game, characters would complain that she talks too much, but the audience doesn't hear any of it. Then comes her jury speech...
- Ms. Fanservice: Likely the reason why she was cast and never said anything.
- No-Damage Run
- Out of Focus: She's a parody of the tendency to ignore women on Survivor.
- Shocking Elimination: A victim of the purple rock tiebreaker.
- Take That!: As stated above, her character mocks the sexist tendencies of the Survivor producers.
A rocker dude who hates the strategic side of the game, and prefers to just go with the flow.
First Guitar Hero fan character.
- All Men Are Perverts
- The Casanova: Ryan starts relationships with multiple girls and he forgets about the previous one as soon as he moves on.
Kris's twin, whom with he constantly bickers, but ultimately loves.
First Ace Attorney fan character with his twin, Kris.
- Black-and-White Morality: The "Good People Alliance" was founded on this, Chris wanting a "nice person" to win.
- The Cameo: Came back as Kris's visitor in Battle of the Tribes.
- Hypocrite: And the same alliance ultimately ends up being full of this, with Chris as the ringleader: he refuses to vote out an injured contestant on the grounds that he'd be easier to beat at immunity, he allows Vinnie of all people into his fold despite the fact that he just backstabbed his own allies (the very reason the alliance voted Bitsy out in the first place), and is generally just a bad person with high opinions of himself.
- Jerk Jock
- Knight Templar
The main villain of the season, who constantly is changing alliances and voting out former allies.
First Grand Theft Auto fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars and Season 16: Blood VS Water.
- Batman Gambit: A master of this.
- Big Bad
- The Chessmaster: Vinnie can be considered the first true villain of the series.
- Chronic Backstabbing Disorder
- Intergenerational Friendship: With Ellise.
- Laughably Evil
- Manipulative Bastard
- Smug Snake: See quote above.
- True Final Boss
Chris's twin, whom with she constantly bickers, but ultimately loves.
First Ace Attorney fan character with her twin, Chris.
Came back for Season 10: Battle of the Tribes.
- Action Girl: Tied with Ker for most female challenge wins, although not in a streak like Ker.
- Poor Communication Kills: Despite tying for the most immunities achieved at that point in the series (actually tied with Hogan) , she does a really really bad job of trying to prove herself at Tribal Council.
- Sibling Yin-Yang: In contrast to her brother's Black-and-White Morality mindset, she's more pragmatic and rational.
- Spanner in the Works:
Word of God says Chris would have won if she hadn't been placed on to the show.
A nice catgirl who is generally well-liked by everyone.
First Inuyasha fan character.
- Cat Girl
- Gag Boobs: Only Shaniqua has bigger ones.
- Last of Her Kind: The only Brawn and the only member of the "Good People" alliance in the final four.
- Ms. Fanservice
- Nice Girl
- Token Good Teammate: Is the only member of the "Good People" alliance who's not a major hypocrite or backstabber.
A doctor who tends to be very bossy, yet is nice once you get to know her.
First Trauma Center fan character.
- All of the Other Reindeer: After Bitsy is blindsided.
- The Chessmaster
- Dark Horse Victory
- The Dragon: To Vinnie, initially.
- Guile Hero
- Earn Your Happy Ending
- Foil: An older female heroine to contrast Sky's younger male semi-antagonist.
- Heel–Face Turn
- Intergenerational Friendship: With Vinnie.
- The Plan: Her plan at the Final 7 tribal council to keep Kris and Vinnie in the game and upset the "Good People" alliance: Ellise won a vital immunity, but instead of keeping it at Tribal Council, she gives it to Kris - after the vote, she plays her hidden immunity idol, forcing Vinnie to play his immunity idol. After the votes are cast, none of the votes count at all, and this forces a tiebreaker between all four core members of the "Good People" alliance, with Denise being voted off. This not only ensures that Vinnie flips back to her side, and Kris with him, but also starts the downfall of the "Good People".
- Redemption Quest
- Sole Survivor: The second and the first woman to win.
