See HERE for the characters of Julie, Ray and the Fisherman.
Karla Wilson
Julie's best friend and roommate. She encourages Julie to go on a trip to the Bahamas with her and their friends. She is aware of the killings in the first film but was unaware of the events that led up to them.
- Action Survivor: Was seemingly killed by Ben Willis, but later revealed to have survived.
- Brutally Honest: Loud and outspoken.
- Deadpan Snarker
- Determinator: Still puts up a chase, even falling through the roof of a greenhouse and dealing with an injured ankle afterwards.
- Genki Girl: While Julie is more reserved and not as sociable as she was in the first film, Karla is the wild party girl who loves to have fun and encourages Julie during the Bahamas trip.
- No One Could Survive That!: Falling through the roof of the greenhouse and still managed to escape the Fisherman.
- Shipper on Deck: Despite Julie and Ray dating, she constantly tries to set her up with Will.
- Token Minority Couple: With Tyrell.
Will Benson
One of Julie's new friends who joins her on the trip to the Bahamas. During the trip, he grows close to Julie. Later revealed to be the son of Ben Willis and his accomplice in his second murder spree. He is accidentally killed by his father in the final fight.
- Alliterative Name: His real name: Will Willis.
- Dogged Nice Guy: Averted.
- The Dragon: To his father
- Meaningful Name: Will Benson, as in "Ben's son"
- Nice Guy: Nope.
Tyrell Martin
Karla's boyfriend, who goes on the trip to the Bahamas. He doesn't believe Julie's story about Ben at first, but when he actually sees dead bodies and finds someone tried to kill Julie, he gets involved. He is later killed by Ben before the climax.
- Impromptu Tracheotomy: Stabbed through the throat from behind by the Fisherman.
- Token Minority Couple: With Karla.
- Tempting FateTyrell: I'm tired, I'm hungry and I'm fucking horny, and so far I have not seen any psycho killers.