open/close all folders
The protagonist of Rubber (Wo)man and Michael and Troy's daughter.
- Played by: Sierra McCormick
- FaceHeel Turn: In Part One, she is just a normal teenage girl, and seemed like a decent enough person, but then she murders the girls who bullied her and, by Part Two, she is willing to murder innocent people who didn't do anything to her.
- Played by: Gavin Creel
- Played by: Matt Bomer
MayaA student at Westfield High in Scarlett's class.
- Played by: Paris Jackson
Ruby McDanielScarlett's girlfriend.
- Played by: Kaia Gerber
- Sadist: She gets pleasure out of making people suffer, including innocent people.
Dr. Andi Grant
Andi GrantA therapist hired by Troy and Michael for Scarlett.
- Played by: Merrin Dungey
- The Determinator: Even in death, she won't stop doing her job.
AdamA contractor hired by Troy to renovate the Murder House.
- Played by: Aaron Tveit
- Asshole Victim: He tries to blackmail Michael and Troy into having sex with him, and murders Martin, so he really had it coming when Ruby stabbed him.
- Played by: Belissa Escobedo
RowenaA student at Westfield High.
- Played by: Ashley Martin Carter
NicoleA student at Westfield High.
- Played by: Valerie Loo
ErinA student at Westfield High.
- Played by: Selena Sloan
- Played by: Harrison Xu
- Played by: Abraham Luna
- Played by: Davee Youngblood
- Asshole Victim: It is pretty satisfying when Scarlett murders him.
- Played by: Madison Bailey
- Uncertain Doom: Rabbit Rabbit is displayed as a "Trending New Title" on her computer while she and Chad aren't paying attention, and what happens after isn't shown before the episode ends.
- Played by: Rhenzy Feliz
- Uncertain Doom: Rabbit Rabbit is displayed as a "Trending New Title" on Kelley's computer while he and Kelley aren't paying attention, and what happens after isn't shown before the episode ends.
- Played by: Adrienne Barbeau
- Played by: Naomi Grossman
- Cassandra Truth: She was right about the movie Rabbit Rabbit causing people to become violent and kill each other.
- Played by: John Carroll Lynch
- Played by: Amy Grabow
- Played by: Ben J Pierce
- Played by: Leonardo Cecchi
- Played by: Kyle Red Silverman
- Played by: Catherine Adell
- Played by: Brandon Papo
The Naughty List
- Played by: Kevin McHale
- Token Good Teammate: The only member who isn't completely unlikable.
- Played by: Dyllon Burnside
- Played by: Charles Melton
- Played by: Nico Greetham
- Played by: Taneka Johnson
- Played by: Billie Lourd
- Batman Gambit: Once she finds out that BA'AL isn't real (at least not the one she saw), and that Matt planned it to get her out of his life, she summoned the real BA'AL and had him kill Matt's friends and have Matt framed for it, and let him rot in prison.
- Played by: Ronen Rubenstein
- Asshole Victim: He set up a whole elaborate scheme make his wife believe that a demon was trying to take her baby's soul, so she would accidentally injure him and get her sent to a mental hospital and out of his life. He ends up in prison after being wrongfully convicted of murdering his friends, and Liv lets him rot in prison.
- Pet the Dog: The one moment he shows he has a conscience is when he warns Liv not to go to their house because there's an actual demon there, although, unbeknownst to Matt, she is actually working with him.
- Played by: Michael B Silver
- Played by: Virginia Gardner
- Played by: Vanessa Williams
- Played by: Kimberly Drummond
- Played by: Chad James Buchanan
- Played by: Jake Choi
- Played by: Misha Gonz Cirkl
- Played by: Dane DiLiegro
- Big Red Devil: When not covered in shadow, he looks like a tall, imposing red demon.
- Mystical Pregnancy: Can give fertility to women, allowing Liv to have a child. Except that was the result of Matt allowing himself to release sperm at that time. The real one Liv summons can do this, although he does it in a...different way.
- Real After All: No one seems to believe Liv when BA'AL starts to target her child. Until it was revealed that Matt and his friends gaslit Liv to get her out of his life. Then she summons the actual BA'AL, using the "fake" ritual made by Bernadette.
- Played by: Cody Fern
- Played by: Aaron Tveit
- Played by: Tiffany Dupont
- Played by: Blake Shields
- Played by: Nicolas Bechtel
MichelleRory's mother, a video game developer.
- Played by: Mercedes Mason
StevenMichelle's ex-husband and Rory's father.
- Played by: John Brotherton
ConnieA character in the video game based on the Murder House. She visited the house with her boyfriend, Dylan.
- Played by: Noah Cyrus
DylanA character in the video game based on the Murder House. He visited the house with his girlfriend, Connie.
- Played by: Adam Hagenbuch
Tim WilliamsThe realtor. He is a character in the video game based on the Murder House.
- Played by: Tom Lenk