Follow TV Tropes

Following

Alternative Character Interpretation / The Last of Us

Go To

Since The Last of Us has complex characters who face decisions without clear right or wrong choices, it's natural for people to draw their own conclusions about what motivates them. Be warned: all spoilers for the first game are unmarked.

    open/close all folders 
    The Ending 
  • Is Joel a noble Papa Wolf for rescuing Ellie from certain death, or an ultimately selfish man motivated by the fear of losing another daughter? Or has he just lost all faith in humanity to the point that he feels humanity doesn't deserve saving and is willing to damn them all for daring to take another little girl's life, considering what happened to his daughter in the prologue?
  • Is Marlene a stressed, desperate leader who feels the ends justifies the means, or a Broken Bird ground down by the horrors of what the world has become and simply didn't have the strength of will to resist the urges of her people?
  • Consider the sheer speed with which the Fireflies decide to scoop out Ellie's brain, potentially ruining their only vaccine source. Is it because the Fireflies are just that good at medicine, or is it desperation mixed with scientific incompetence? Considering that the spores "grow all over the brain," harvesting Ellie's entire brain seems incredibly drastic when a simple biopsy could be just as useful for research without having to murder a child.
  • When Ellie asks Joel whether he's telling the truth about what happened while she was unconscious, was she asking Joel to lie to her? Or is she begging him to protect her from that last bit of guilt? Word of God states that she knows he is lying to her, and as a result, she feels robbed of choice and it has ended her trust in him.
  • Even if a vaccine had been successfully made, would the Fireflies really have distributed it quickly and/or fairly to people? They were on extremely bad terms with the military, immediately decided to kill an unconscious child, and it's ultimately implied that they wanted to kill Joel after he delivered Ellie because He Knows Too Much. Their goal may have been noble, but in the end, it would appear that they might have kept a potential vaccine to themselves or at most have distributed it in small dosages to chosen clients, which, when the word got out, would have caused mankind to turn even more on each other due to fighting over it.
  • To add to the above, the Zombie Apocalypse rampaged for 20 years; could the world be considered too far gone for a vaccine to really have made that much of a difference? Anyone who's already infected (save for maybe early-stage Runners) is almost certainly too far gone for a vaccine to cure them. And even if the vaccine could cure them, it's not like the infected will just sit quietly and allow a cure to be administered (hope someone has a dart gun). The vaccine would likely be best effective as a prevention, and since the human population is sparse, finding someone who could administer the vaccine before the victim turned would likely be a daunting task. Not to mention that it would take at least a few centuries to produce enough humans who are immune to the infection in order to rebuild society into what it once was. While Joel's main motive was that he didn't want his substitute daughter to die, he may have also concluded that a cure was pointless at this stage, further backed up by the fact that he starts having second thoughts about delivering Ellie to the Fireflies before they reach the hospital.

    David 
  • Was David a Bitch in Sheep's Clothing all along, or was he the decent guy he first introduces himself as, who merely snapped when realizing there was no use attempting to get along with strangers who in return did nothing but break his fingers and kill his men and was forced to resort to cannibalism to survive? Then again, he showed his paedophilic tendencies before he snapped and the other Cannibals call Ellie his "newest pet", implying he did such things before. Alternatively, is his Ax-Crazy personality during his and Ellie's Boss Fight due to the (supposed) infection from her bite showing its symptoms?
    • Interestingly, Nolan North (David's voice actor)'s own interpretation of David is that he genuinely cares for his group and indeed had good intentions towards Ellie to begin with, with her being a glimmer of hope for him similar to the way she is for Joel, but threw all morality out the window the more she fought against him.
    • David apparently kept young girls as "entertainment" before Ellie, who all might have been naive and trusting of his kind and polite act in difference to Ellie who flat out refuses to join him. Nolan North even hinted that David might have viewed Ellie as different and considered her to be someone he eventually could have children with to increase his group's numbers. Another possible interpretation of his reaction to Ellie's defiance is that David is Not Good with Rejection.
    • Nolan North specifically says, "He's not trying to rape her or anything. At first."
  • Ellie breaking David's finger. A badass or stupid move, considering there was no way she could have gotten a hold of his keys and she only escapes him and James within an inch of her life as a result? A better solution would probably have been to pretend she would join him, and then escape after he let her out. Though it might just boil down to her having acted rashly out of anger or panic.
  • A lot of players interpret Ellie's sullen attitude at the start of the Spring chapter to be the result of her ordeal with David, when at that point, it's been at least a couple of months since it happenednote  and Word of God hints more towards her simply being down about her and Joel's journey almost being over. Joel will also comment that she seems "extra quiet today", meaning she was acting depressed that particular day.

    Tommy 
  • While he's clearly a good man at heart who cares for his family and friends and wants to rebuild the world on a small scale, Tommy can come across as rather self-righteous and condescending to Joel. He doesn't seem to appreciate even the intent behind whatever Joel did to try and keep him alive, and rather than deny it was necessary, he just flippantly tells him it "wasn't worth it", which makes it seem like he thinks he's too good for him. It also comes across as him having a sort of double standard, considering that Maria seems to wear the pants in their relationship and be about as protective of him as Joel apparently used to be, and yet he's never shown to complain.
  • Why did Tommy leave the Fireflies? Joel implies that it's because Tommy got bored and quit, but was that the truth or just sour grapes from big brother? From what little we see of Tommy, he doesn't seem like the type of person who'd give up on a cause he believed in, and he still believes in saving humanity, even though he's taking a different route than the Fireflies are (creating a new humanity instead of restoring the old), so maybe this is the first hint that the Fireflies might not be as noble as we're led to believe.

    Other Characters 
  • Sam gets infected and doesn't tell the others. Why? The obvious answer would be that he's worried they'd kill him if he did, (perhaps not his brother, but he wouldn't know about Joel), but another possibility is that, considering how overprotective Henry is of him, Sam was devastated at not being able to 'stay safe' per his brother's wish and didn't want to face him.
    • There’s also his last discussion with Ellie. He asks her if she believes people who become infected go to Heaven and ends the conversation with saying he doesn’t believe in Heaven like her. Did he actually mean it or was he reconsidering his beliefs because he knew he was going to turn any minute and he hoped he was going to a better place when he dies?
  • Is Bill an eccentric in-universe Crazy Survivalist, or the game's Only Sane Man (except for maybe Tommy and his ilk)? His justified paranoia allowed him to make a house out of an entire town, and he accurately predicts the dangers of Joel's relationship with Ellie. He also noticeably avoids the game's running theme of doing controversial things to protect those you love, even while he's clearly grieved by Frank's death.

Top