Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Pannic Reads Stuff He Hates
Pannic2014-02-09 14:24:19

Go To


Why is the Chapter Title and Header Aligned Left?

So I was gonna liveblog on Partially Kissed Hero, but I decided to put it off for a bit because A. I'm putting off Project Horizons too much as it is and B. Oh for fuck's sake, PKH is so abominably shitty that the entire entry would be nothing but bile and I don't feel like being completely negative right now.

I think I've gotten softer. I mean, hell, a few months ago I did a positive blog post about some things I genuinely liked in the original Fallout: Equestria.

But there will be more time to talk about my retroactive quasi-softening on FOE when I get to PKH. Onto chapter 3 of Project Horizons.

So our protagonists stay with the orphans in the school until the next morning (I'd think they'd probably want to sleep somewhere that isn't full of rotting carcasses, but what do I know) and Blackjack's all healed from getting shot at. Protagonist gets shot at a lot. Littlepip 2.0 indeed. There's a bit where Blackjack looks at some ministry mare posters.

We get some stuff with Scoodle showing them the ropes about scavenging, and then she proceeds to give advice and exposition. On the exposition font, she proceeds to list several of the story's relevant factions, including the Crusaders, the Finders, the raiders, the Reapers (who are like raiders but bigger and badder), the Enclave, DJ Pon3 (oh fuck she's a character in this story), the Society, the Steel Rangers, the Enclave, the College/Eggheads, aaaaand Ghouls. I have been informed that this is NOT the complete faction list for the fic.

Then there's some back and forth between Scoodle and one of the kids about war backstory 'n' things, with the usual disagreements to give the sense that nobody really understands everything. That's a nice touch.

Speaking of Ghouls, Blackjack waltzes into a boneyard and a bunch of ghouls come up. Scoodle dies horribly, because after the original story I really wanted more violence against children.

We also meet Silver Spoon, who is glowing and we're given a big of black comedy where Silver Spoon is crazy and Blackjack claims to be Diamond Tiara. They hug and this means that Blackjack is irradiated. All the while Scoodle is getting munched on by zombies. The black comedy is actually pretty good.

That passes and everyone who isn't dead proceeds. The kids ditch our two main idiots and Blackjack proceeds to be angst and mope. She and P-21 have a spat.

“They left…” How profoundly insightful I’d become since I’d fucked up.

“Yeah. A little bit ago,” he replied evenly as he looked along the road. “I think there’s a house up there. We can rest and take care of you.”

“I don’t want to be taken care of,” I muttered softly.

“I’m sorry, did you say something?” P-21 walked in front of me, his sure blue eyes bearing down into mine. “Sometimes we don’t get what we want,” he said as he nudged me towards a single story house beside the road. “Sometimes we don’t get to sit around and have pity parties for our mistakes. Sometimes we just have to keep going because, otherwise, we might as well just die.”

“That’s what…” I started to say.

He hit me hard enough to knock me on my side. I stared up into the sky and felt my guts churn and my pupils contract. “I’m sorry. Were you about to say you wanted to die? Is that it?” he said as he glared down at me. “If you were this weak, you should have just given yourself to Deus and been done with it.”

“I killed Scoodle!” I yelled up at him. It felt like a confession.

“Yeah! You did, you fucking idiot!” he screamed back down at me. “Didn’t I tell you to listen to her? Didn’t you say to me that I know what’s right when it comes to this sort of thing? But she’s dead, Blackjack, and unless you wallowing in pity or dying will somehow magically bring her back to life then this is accomplishing nothing except indulging in your own selfish wishes!”

P-21 kind of confuses me. Maybe that makes sense 'cause he's a confused individual himself. It's weird. Maybe I find their dynamic less compelling on a re-read. Maybe I just find that this passage doesn't really sound like people actually talking.

I slowly opened my eyes, looking into his. He hated me. I hated me. Yet no matter how much I wanted to be done, I had to admit that he was right. Me dying right now wouldn’t bring back Scoodle. It wouldn’t right some great cosmic wrong and fix anything. It would just be another corpse in the wastelands. “I’m so sorry,” I whispered softly.

“Then prove it, Blackjack. Live and don’t ever fuck up like that again. Learn from this, because if you ever kill another pony through stupidity then I will fucking end you.” He shoved his head under my shoulders and turned me over so I no longer stared into that terrible void above… only now I had an equally vast void within and I couldn’t look away from it.

So why does P-21 stay with her? I can understand him not murdering her on account of saving his life, but I dunno, from his perspective mightn't it have made more sense for him to knock her out and run off to freedom with U-21? Maybe he wants to help the other stallions in the stable or something. I dunno. I'm confused.

So Blackjack has to recover from radsickness. In between feeling guilty and being unconscious she has bad dreams. And the line "I saw Deus laughing at me as he sawed off my PipBuck with a chainsaw penis."

She comes to and sees the Spritebot for Watcher.

Why is Watcher showing up here? Okay, I can believe he might give a word of advice to a newcomer out of the stable about "hey, go in this direction if you don't want to die," but this is a bit odd. I mean, he didn't really do much for Littlepip until she'd gone and done that stuff with the slavers and the orphans. Here he gives her a big speech.

I carefully raised my head. The spritebot wasn’t transforming into some face eating nightmare. “Watcher?”

“Yeah. That’s me. What about you, Blackjack? Is this it? Is this the point where the Wasteland breaks you?” The spritebot looked particularly solemn as it hovered before me. “Yeah. That’s me. What about you, Blackjack? Is this it? Is this the point where the Wasteland breaks you?” The spritebot looked particularly solemn as it hovered before me.

How's this for the FOE drinking game: Take a shot every time someone talks about the wasteland breaking people.

And so he gives her a big fucking speech here.

Carefully I pushed myself up and covered my face with my hooves. “I fucked up, Watcher.”

“You’re not the first. And if I can be blunt, your fuck-up only killed one filly. I’ve known ponies whose fuck-ups killed millions. So on the grand scale of fuck-ups, I think you’re overrating yourself.” Slowly I dropped my hooves from my face to look at the little machine as it went on. “So I’m asking you: is this it? Are you just a pony that wallows in self-pity and kicks herself for a mistake, or not? Because if this is it, then I’ll leave you be. I can’t help you. You can’t help anypony.”

It would have been easy to just fold right then. But as I sat on the edge of the bed, damn me, I couldn’t help smiling as I looked at the machine. I reeked of vomit, crap, blood, and despair but I still felt my lips curl mirthlessly as I looked at the device. “Are you on that grand scale of fuck-ups too, Watcher?”

There was a long pause, and I wondered if I’d offended him to the point that he would just wash his hooves of me. “Yeah. I am.”

“Did your fuck-up kill someone who didn’t deserve it?” There was silence and I knew he wouldn’t answer. He didn’t have to. I sat there for a minute longer, looking at my hooves. “I was so proud when I saved those girls from those raiders. Now…” I closed my eyes and grit my teeth. It would be so easy just to give up. Fold the hand. Cash in the chips. Quitters might not go bust, but they’d also never make it big. I opened my eyes as I looked right at the machine, wondering what Watcher’s face looked like right now. Finally, I asked softly, “So how do I move on, Watcher?”

“You do everything you can to make up for it, knowing that you’ll never succeed in getting rid of the guilt. You devote yourself to spending every second trying to do better despite the fact that it will never be enough. And you pray with every single good act you do that somehow when your life is over that your lifetime will come close to making up for the wrong you committed.” Watcher spoke so clear and true that I couldn’t stop smiling and crying at the same time.

“Well. That sounds like a plan,” I whispered. “So where do I start?”

I look forward to doing a compare-and-contrast with the angst from the original.

Also, I find it funny we're getting these lines from Spike, who uncritically latched onto everything Littlepip did. And repeated use of the word "carefully."

So the next day there's another action scene with Radigators and banter between Blackjack and P-21. BJ needs Radaway but she doesn't want to have to rely on P-21 for it so action scene happens. You know, I notice that a lot of this story so far involves BJ needing to have men (namely P-21 and Watcher) tell her what to do. But then the entire point of these action scene is that BJ doesn't want to have to be nannied by P-21. Hey, remember when I bitched about the gender stuff in FOE? Boy, was that stupid. Stay tuned for Partially Kissed Hero, which is downright misogynistic!

Whatever. Action scene blah blah blah.

This would normally be the point where I would die and P-21 would take over and probably do the Wasteland a lot more good. There was just one catch: I wasn’t done paying for a little teal pony.
Blimey. And I've been told this isn't even the start of the real angst.

After that's done, we get a thing from P-21 about how Stable 99 was terrible. Oh yeah, this is what I liked about their dynamic. Thanks for reminding me.

And we get a neat thing from P-21 where he says that what he really wanted to be was a teacher.

“I wanted to be a teacher,” he finally said softly.

“A teacher?” I winced at the skepticism in my voice. I just couldn’t imagine a male doing… that.

“Yes, a teacher.” He examined one rusty lock on the second, jammed in the screwdriver, and gave it a hard twist. With a pop, it opened right up. “Before I was P-1 I tried to learn all I could about arcane sciences. That was how I knew Duct Tape so well; I studied off her as she went through training. I thought that if I knew enough that maybe the Overmare would let me teach. I would have been fine doing both jobs.” He opened up the crate and took out two empty syringes and two boxes of some kind of canned meat. “Know what the Overmare said? She said she’d let me teach sex education in my breeding rotation.”

Ouch.

So yeah, we're getting more stuff out of P-21. Though I can't help but feel that this early in the story it's a little too much a little too soon. Then again, the story needs something apart from exposition and fight scenes, and this does nicely to develop their relationship. And I'm sure there's plenty more stuff P-21's got buried down that'll get dredged up in this story. But yeah, I like it. Gets him a sympathy point, and given he's kind of a gruff asshole type he needs all the sympathy he can get.

But fuck the thing's oozing with sex. Maybe it's hypocritical to complain about this and not the violence (actually it isn't, 'cause I'm complaining plenty about the violence) but there's just something sleazy… then again, the starting setting is basically a rape factory, so I guess sleaze is just gonna be there as part of the plot.

Wait a minute, how does he study off of her while she's training? Did she like to have sex while on the job? Are the foals not segregated? I'd think the foals would be segregated, otherwise that runs the distinct possibility of them empathizing with each other and thus kinda not wanting to do the whole "rape factory" setup. I'm confused again.

And… wait, that's the chapter? Huh. That wasn't as long as I thought. It also wasn't as painful as the note at the end of the last chapter warned. Sweet. And now that I'm caught up to where I was, we can liveblog onwards! Huzzah!

Comments

CDRW Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 9th 2014 at 3:10:11 PM
I don't have anything to say, but I'm pitching in a comment just to let you know that I read your liveblog.
Unknownlight Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 9th 2014 at 7:12:21 PM
Project Horizons has a very Project Horizons-y feel to it. I find these early chapters interesting simply because they have the characters interacting and doing stuff before the Project Horizonsy-ness hits. It get gets better once that happens, but it becomes a noticeably different story.

Onwards to further Horizons! Fare thee well!
IcyShake Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 9th 2014 at 7:53:38 PM
You hit on most of the points that stood out to me. Silver Spoon was one thing I enjoyed about the chapter, and I likewise thought that the P-21/Blackjack "teacher" scene was a good one, but apparently I found the way he pointed out that there wasn't anything Blackjack wanted to do that being forced into security kept her from doing to be more memorable.

I didn't think so much about the difference in how Watcher handled Blackjack, in large part because it'd been so long since I read Fo E.

And, yes, this chapter and the next couple are relatively short and perhaps less dense when compared to the first and later chapters.
Seraphem Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 9th 2014 at 8:45:08 PM
So yeah... how the hell would they know about The Enclave?

And, yeah that, sounded... nothing like Spike, at all, and, your also right, made no damn sense for him to be that interested that quickly.
Pannic Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 9th 2014 at 9:44:10 PM
Pretty sure that the surface folk knew who the Enclave were. They've got posters up - recall that Calamity sees one and gets pissy about it. Murky Number Seven also operates under the assumption that the ponies know who the Enclave are, which is the source of a lot of racism Murky faces.
Sereg Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 10th 2014 at 3:28:09 AM
Yeah, I was not really sold on this. But, I wasn't for FOE at the time either, so I have to give it a chance.
Seraphem Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 10th 2014 at 5:56:09 AM
No, they didn't see anything about the Enclave. The poster was a war time bit about the pegasus military, but nothing about The Enclave, since that didn't exist until after the war. It simply made Calamity make a remark about them. The only way anyone on the surface could know about the Enclave prior to their arrival, is having talked to a Dashite, so it was hardly common knowledge. Especially not to the extant some street rat would feel the need to include them in a list of factions given they have no presence, no barring and no, anything at all to do with the surface. So yeah no reason he should know about them.

General unease and resentment toward pegasi, I could see, but The Enclave specifically.. doesn't really work.
Unknownlight Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 10th 2014 at 3:06:07 PM
The Wasteland ponies know that pegasi live above the clouds, that's firmly established. Whether they know anything else about them, or that those pegasi are called "the Enclave" is another matter, but I'm not picky enough to care.
Unknownlight Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 10th 2014 at 3:08:38 PM
Actually, no, Wastelanders probably do know about the Enclave. After all, Homage knows about the Enclave, so I'm sure she's talked about them in her broadcasts at some point.
ILSS Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 10th 2014 at 4:10:48 PM
Despite there not being a note anywhere stating that edits have been made, I'm pretty sure portions of Chapter 3 were rewritten at some point. I don't have a copy old enough to check. As you noted, P-21 is more supportive and open towards her than makes sense, because Somber rewrote their exchanges in the tone he’d gotten used to over the course of several dozen chapters of character development.

You know, I notice that a lot of this story so far involves BJ needing to have men (namely P-21 and Watcher) tell her what to do.
You're a perceptive guy. Three chapters of one fic, and you've noticed an undercurrent that flows through all of Somber's writing.
Top