Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs How to Ruin Children's Entertainment - A Journey through the Pokemon movies
wehrmacht2014-02-16 20:46:39

Go To


Before I start this off I think it might be prudent to give a brief overview of my history with the franchise, my general opinions on it and how that might color my experience.

I was alive and well during the late 90's and at just the right age to be swept up by the children's fads of the era, which of course included Pokemon. I watched the anime pretty religiously as a child, sunk countless hours into Pokemon Red and Crystal, and owned a few cards though I never really got into the TCG.

I stopped watching the anime around the end of Hoenn. This was due to multiple reasons, but I think the most important ones were probably the following:

  • I gradually stopped watching TV in general. As I spent more time on the internet I realized that I essentially had all the entertainment I could ever want at my fingertips, which killed my desire to ever turn on my TV again if it isn't to play games or watch movies with someone on a big screen. I generally dislike most television programs anyway, and anything I want to watch is on netflix/DVD or available through more questionable means.

  • My interest in Pokemon waned as the fad died down. I wouldn't really get into the series again until the release of Platinum and Pokemon Black and White, which reinvigorated my interest in the franchise. It's not really a great game series, and I wish game freak would take more risks in their formula within the main games, but I am fond of it all the same and think there is potential in it for both gameplay and decent stories.

  • Funnily enough, it was at the time where catching up with the anime was the easiest that I realized it wasn't something I was interested in.

Because frankly, I think the Pokemon anime is kind of awful. It's an incredibly dull, predictable, ho-hum show that offers me pretty much nothing. The characters are stale, the plotlines are predictable, repetitive and uninteresting, and most of the characters don't even age accordingly. It's really just a soulless marketing tool for the games to me. There are so many better anime, even when you just look at the mon genre by itself. Naru Taru, Digimon Tamers, and Monster Rancher are all way better. Even within the franchise itself, Pokémon Origins and Pokémon Special are way more engaging and deserving of people's time. Of course, different people watch their media to fulfill different needs, so more power to anyone who enjoys the Pokemon anime. If anything, I'm glad it makes SOMEONE happy. It just doesn't give me what I want out of my media at this point.

Liveblogging seasons of the anime I haven't yet seen sounded like an interesting project at first, but then I realized it'd take way too long and honestly isn't worth it since I'm pretty much guaranteed to not enjoy it anyway. It isn't even really that good a source of Snark Bait, as it's mostly just a dull, lifeless show rather than something offensively bad.

...the movies, on the other hand, could actually be done feasibly without wasting too much of my time. I've never actually seen any movie past the third one. I have read plot summaries long ago and am aware of some details of certain movies as a result, but I only remember them vaguely. I have actually heard good things about a few of them, so I'm more than willing to give the movie franchise as a whole a chance, especially if they are supposedly better than the anime.

So what this is essentially going to be is me reviewing each of the Pokemon movies, from the very first one to the latest one (which at the time of this writing is Genesect and the Legend Awakened). A new movie featuring event legendary Diancie has been announced, and I am sure by the time I'm done there will be more released. I don't really plan on covering the theatrical shorts that accompany most of these movies, nor the made For TV movies and specials; I may at some point, but I'd really just like to reach my initial goal first. Anything else is just bonus material.

As for whether I'm going to go with sub or dub, I plan to go with subs for at least the first three movies, since i've seen the dubs for them already and they're pretty fresh in my mind still. From there on out it's going to be a matter of how much the following movies were altered in dubs by comparison, or simply the availability of the material. In the absence of a good subbed copy, the dub will have to do.

I'm going to try and be as fair as I can, but I don't really think I'm TOO difficult to please. There are lot of things I enjoy greatly that I consider very flawed (pokemon in general being one of them). With that said, I'm not going to neglect being critical of it just because they're "kids' films". If something stinks, then it stinks and I'm going to say so.

No guarantees on when this is going to be done as I'm just starting a new semester at school, and I have other hobbies which take precedence. I also like to make sure I have all my thoughts in order and neatly organized before posting (I've already seen the first movie again and am writing up a skeleton of its review as I type this).

Feel free to chime in if you have anything to say, whether it's interesting background information, factual errors on my part, or disagreements. Keep in mind that I don't mean to belittle anyone for enjoying any movie in particular, no matter how critical of it I may seem. At the end of the day personal enjoyment is subjective, and I can't invalidate your feelings towards something you genuinely like. The best I can do is try to substantiate my opinions, present my case, and see if you agree or not.

So strap in, and let's have fun watching some Pokemon.

Comments

Tuckerscreator Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 15th 2014 at 12:44:32 PM
It would have made a lot more sense if Mewtwo had brought Ash back to life rather than pulling that Deus Tear Machina. I agree that the prologue of the movie is definitely where it's at its best.

Another reason why the film was critically panned isn't because it isn't very accessible to new viewers. Hit the ground running, no explanation of what these "pokey-mans" are.

Also, have you seen the TGWTG reviews of the Pokemon films? They've only gotten up to the third one so far but they're fun and critical and could be useful to you in revealing additional points of critique.
wehrmacht Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 15th 2014 at 1:01:05 PM
@Tuckerscreator: actually I think you have a good point about the film not being too accessible. That's something that didn't occur to me at all when evaluating the film, and it probably bears saying that some familiarity with the series is required to really enjoy this movie.

I haven't seen the TGWTG reviews; I knew Doug Walker had reviewed this movie, but wasn't aware that he had gone farther and done the next two. I'll check them out.
Tuckerscreator Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 15th 2014 at 3:21:58 PM
Indeed, Roger Ebert's review of this film even opens with him admitting he can't figure out anything about what the franchise is, even though he tried.

It's not actually Doug reviewing, it's three associates of his: That Dude in the Suede, Linkara, and Jew Wario. Their collaborative review is pretty helpful because they're fans of the series, so they don't have to spend the majority of the film(s) confused at what anything is.
Kaoz Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 16th 2014 at 2:28:58 PM
Nice observation on the part of Mewtwo's deserved top billing status as the actual protagonist, since the movies are (obviously) in large part just sidestories for Ash's story. In fact despite Ash (and friends) being the vehicle of climax for the movies as a whole, it could be argued that only two actually focus on him in a important story context at all.

I see that the insular nature of its western release has already been mentioned so I'll stay mum on that. As for the movie's overall quality, I'll agree that it set a high mark with its atypically serious theme that most of the films (whose main goal appears to be a fun hour of legendary fluff and explodey bits... not that that's neccesarily a bad thing) don't come close to matching. However a few of them do, in my opinion of course.

Lastly on the Mew issue, "its"? lack of any discernible personality is the major thing that does bother me about the 1st dub, more so than the other changes... but thats next post. So, it may seem weird for it to have such a superior attitude, but hey it's better than nothing right?
Top