TVTropes Now available in the app store!
Open

Follow TV Tropes

Crowner

Go To

PageAction: BaseBreakingCharacter
10th Jun '19 9:45:29 AM

Crown Description:

Base Breaking Character has stagnated, with the cleanup thread raising issues of the trope rules being too narrow to adequately document a real fanbase phenomenon. How should we fix the issue? Note that these options are not inherently mutually exclusive.
   26 (Yeas:28 Nays:2) 14.00 : 1
Allow "historical" examples for debates that were once strong but have ended or fandoms that have died.
   24 (Yeas:24 Nays:0)
Rewrite the description to have examples place more emphasis on why a character is divisive rather than the nature of the arguments they create.
   16 (Yeas:19 Nays:3) 6.33 : 1
Axe Rule 2 (the "Middle Ground" rule).
   -2 (Yeas:8 Nays:10)
Establish a devoted thread to approving Base-Breaking Character entries.
   -15 (Yeas:2 Nays:17)
Top