Follow TV Tropes

Page Action: Megaton Punch Re Do

Go To

What would be the best way to fix the page?

At issue:

The page Megaton Punch shows a misuse of at least 75%. The current definition for the trope is "girl comedic punch with extreme force, Armor Piercing Slap that hurts the reciever no matter the real strength the characters have, probably making the reciever a Twinkle In The Sky".

However people use it meaning "powerful non comedic punches".

A rename for the current definition has already been proposed and accepted. The proposals here are about what to do with the page. Propose no names, please. Vote up the proposals you like, vote down those that you don't. More than one may take place in the end if they aren't mutually exclusive. If you think you've got a better idea please add it to the crowner.

Showing 4 of 4. Hide items with lower scores.

This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.

This decission was already made in the thread. It's redundant.

Rename trope to make the current definition more clear that it is a type of Slapstick Gag (name to be determined in another crowner)

Move the Misuse of "super powerful punch" to the existing trope Punched Across the Room. Most of them fit, and the few that don't can be fit in because Tropes Are Flexible, or can be YKTTW'ed as another trope.

Make Megaton Punch a page about any kind of powerful punches.

Pro: It would be the easiest way to deal with the problem.

Make Megaton Punch a page about any kind of powerful punches and merge it with Punched Across the Room.

Pro: Punched Across the Room is a trope about powerful punches too, where the person punched gets thrown back. Since punches in fiction usually cause that, having Punched Across the Room may be seen as The Same But More Specific.

Con: There are examples where the enemy stays where it is after the punch. Merging would mean having to rename not only the wiks for the current definition of Megaton Punch, but also those from Punched Across the Room.