Follow TV Tropes

Biggest Complaint: Total Drama Island

Go To

Here's the place to let the world know about something that doesn't work about this show, trope, or author. As the votes roll in, you'll be able to see if it is also a problem for other folks.

Showing 43 of 43. Hide items with lower scores.

The complete fladerization and character derailment of almost every character in the second season.

Having Lightning being the winner instead of having Cameron as the Intended winner (As he was in the lead in the poles) in the American version of the Finale of "Revenge of the Island"

Making Gwen/Duncan canon, less because of my own personal dislike of it, more because it was handled terribly, would create an obvious flame war that no one wanted, and, personally, I actually think the fans of said pairing deserved much better development than what they got in the end.

Chris bringing back two campers who where rightfully voted off (Eva and Izzy) over someone who was "Voted off" by someone tampering with the votes in the first season. (Courtney).

Not having "Revenge of the Island" aired in the US in 2011 due to an earthquake in Tohoku Japan.

Not creating new fresh characters for season 2..

Having Dawn voted off in "Revenge of the Island" thanks to Scott.

Having Owen win in the Canon ending of Island.

Sundae Muddy Sundae 2: Lies, Cries, and One Big Prize

Leaving behind the somewhat "not entirely realistic but still funny" Island episodes for "we were high when we wrote this" Revenge episodes

Having "Revenge of the Island" and All Stars last only 13 episodes.

Alejandro ultimately being little more than Justin 2.0

Ed McDonald

Scott taking a level in dumbass in All Stars.

Mal becoming an Anti-Climax Boss in the finale of All Stars.

Curing Mike's MPD with a push of a button.

Sugar Boo Boo

Izzy somehow being voted out over Heather in TDI

TDAS Finale: Mr. and Mrs Bland

Having Izzy getting beat up by Mal.

Not letting Cody win in World Tour.

Dakota's Mutation.

The sinking of Camp Wawanakwa.

Spoiling most of Pahkitew Island via Leaks.

Total Drama not having a Japanese nor German dub.

Pretty much everything that happened with Ezekiel in Season 3 onward.

Not bringing back any of the FEMALE CONTESTANTS from past "Total Drama" seasons for "The Ridonculous Race". The only returning contestants that year were all GUYS: Owen, Noah, Geoff, and Leonard.

Total Drama Daycare—where the cast are now toddlers—is announced as "Season 6".

Making Justin a villain

Having DJ bring his whole team down because of the Curse he put on himself in Egypt in World Tour.

Having Camp Wawanakwa sunk.

The entirety of All-Stars (especially the last three episodes).

Beth giving the Gophers a three challenge losing streak thanks to her "Souvenir" she retrieved from Bony Island.

Ending Gwen's Relationship with Duncan.

Duncan winning TDA, since Geoff, Bridgette, Leshawna, Lindsay, and Trent couldn't vote for Beth for various reasons.

None of the "Revenge of the Island" characters were participants on "The Ridonculous Race".

Not letting any of the original characters back to compete in "Revenge of the Island".

Not bringing Gwen back in the competition after being eliminated in "Action" and "World Tour".

Not letting every contestant voted off in Island vote for the winner.

Having Cameron get so far.

Not having Ezekial compete as one of the fourteen contestants in All Stars.

Having two black male contestants as the finalists in Revenge of the Island.