Line #20 Main/ToolsOfSapience


1	[[quoteright:350:[[Literature/LittleFuzzy https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/little_fuzzy_4.jpg]]]]
2
3	%% Launched per YKTTW https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=j552xazjr9t42dcesuw6gv0i
4	This trope is all about creatures (humanoid or otherwise) who are denoted as "people" by their use of accessories such as tools, regardless of the characters being otherwise nude.
5
6	A pet animal might commonly wear a collar, but would not normally wear a coin pouch, tools, a weapon or a timepiece. Accessories of that kind would normally be a clear indication of "personhood" for the wearer, regardless of the character being otherwise nude.
7
8	The heroic space explorer is on an alien planet which seems to at least be able to sustain life as we know it. Perhaps the explorer is a scientist examining a soil sample outside her space tent. Suddenly there's a noise and the explorer looks up to behold one of the weird native lifeforms staring at her from the edge of the clearing.
9
10	"I wonder what that animal wants?" thinks the explorer. Then she realises: The creature, although otherwise nude, is wearing a belt holding a small sack, a hammer and a dagger!
11
12	The heroic space explorer is about to make FirstContact!
13
14	If the character uses the accessories for their intended purpose, this would be an even more decisive indicator that the character is a person and not an animal.
15
16	This is a subtrope of FunnyAnimal but this trope occurs when the being is initially presumed to be non-sapient by both protagonists and audience and the being's sapience is revealed by its artifacts.
17
18	Related to both HalfDressedCartoonAnimal and AccessoryWearingCartoonAnimal but this trope is not limited to cartoon characters and is limited to non-clothing accessories.
19
20	Compare LetsMeetTheMeat.
21
22	----
23	!!Examples:
24
25	[[foldercontrol]]
26
27	[[folder:Comic Strips]]
28	* ''ComicStrip/TheFarSide'' had one comic with a bipedal cow standing behind a table, showing off a bunch of lumpy stone objects. The caption just read, [[CowTools "Cow tools."]] \
29	In a ''Far Side'' retrospective book, Gary Larson said this particular strip got him more inquiries than any other in his career, from people wondering what the heck the comic was supposed to be about. The answer is that Larson recalled the topic of tool use from an anthropology course, and the fact that real-life apes use tools, and that got him thinking: "Ape tools are rather primitive in comparison to human tools. If ''cows'' used tools, how primitive would those be?"
30	[[/folder]]
31
32	[[folder:Films -- Animation]]
33	* In ''WesternAnimation/LiloAndStitch'', Stitch is mistaken for a dog after he loses his laser guns (despite having six limbs) and then Lilo later realizes that Stitch is intelligent when he does things like riding a bike and building elaborate models of San Francisco.
34	[[/folder]]
35
36	[[folder:Films -- Live-Action]]
37	* Chewbacca of the ''Franchise/StarWars'' franchise wears a bandolier over his shoulder and handles various repair tools and weapons, which helps visually affirm that he's a technology-using alien and not some sort of bipedal beast in spite of his only vocal sounds being grunts, growls and roars.
38	* Averted in ''Film/TheCatFromOuterSpace'' (1978). An alien that looks like a cat is stranded on Earth. His super-computer/communication device looks like a glowing cat collar, so he is mistaken for a common house cat.
39	[[/folder]]
40
41	[[folder:Literature]]
42	* [[DiscussedTrope Discussed]] at various points in ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}''. Andalites repeatedly justify their superiority by describing alien species as "sub-sentient," most prominently the slave Gedds native to the Yeerk homeworld, but also Hork-Bajir, which have their own culture, tools, society, and musical tradition - [[PerfectPacifistPeople but no weapons]] [[{{Arcadia}} or technology]]. When [[GoingNative Aldrea]] discovers this after living among the Hork-Bajir, it casts doubt in her mind as to how many other species the Andalites brushed off this way, [[DefectorFromDecadence leading to her defection]].
43	* In the Literature/HonorHarrington universe, the Treecats of Sphinx (small, six-limbed arboreals) were originally thought to be nonsapient. It began to dawn on the human colonists that they were wrong when they were seen to use stone-age tools (chipped stone hand-axes and woven nets).
44	* In ''Literature/AliceInWonderland'', the main story begins when Alice sees a rabbit with a pocketwatch and waistcoat and follows to investigate.
45	* Creator/ABertramChandler's "Literature/TheCage": Survivors from a crashed starship (on a planet where clothes don't survive due to some aggressive fungus) are captured by aliens and put in a zoo. Attempts to convince the aliens they are sapient by making baskets or [[FirstContactMath demonstrating mathematics]] fail. But when they build a cage and put an [[CallASmeerpARabbit alien mouse]] into it... well, only sapient beings are bastards enough for that.
46	* In the ''Literature/LittleFuzzy'' novels, the first indication that the Fuzzies were sapient was their use of sharpened sticks to kill invertebrate prey.
47	* One of the countless hominids on Literature/{{Ringworld}} was a borderline-sapient species which, while unable to use fire in their aquatic habitat, did use flaked stone tools (a borderline example since it is never stated whether or not the species wears clothes).
48	* In ''Tarnsman of Literature/{{Gor}}'', Tarl meets a Nar, a member of the Spider People, who wears only a UniversalTranslator strapped to his thorax.
49	* {{Inverted}} in David Brin's ''Literature/{{Uplift}}'' series when humans are considered inferior to whales and dolphins because we are unable to do things without using tools.
50	* In Creator/AnneMcCaffrey's ''Decision at Doona'', human settlers on a new world encounter a village of intelligent cats. Both species assume the other is pre-sapient due to the primitive living conditions in each other's colonies. The aliens decide the humans are intelligent based on a child's ability to play games.
51	* In L. Neil Smith's Confederacy novels, there is an uplifted coyote named G. Howell Nuahuatl (the G. stands for Greenriver). He wears a vocoder collar, synced to the impulses in his cybernetically augmented brain, and a custom motile collar equipped with twin guns and ear pads to protect his hearing. In later stories, he uses a backpack that has a cybernetically-controlled hand.
52	* Discussed in Creator/JanetKagan's ''Literature/{{Hellspark}}'', in which a survey team are trying to figure out if the local birdlike aliens, which have never been seen using tools, are sapient. The protagonist points out that on some planets she's visited, the surveyors themselves might not necessarily be recognised as sapient tool-users because the nature of their tools would not be apparent -- for instance, an observer might note that they don't build fires for warmth, not knowing that their clothes have integrated heating elements. [[spoiler:This turns out to be the case with the birdlike aliens, which have a highly advanced technology they control by means not apparent to the survey team.]]
53	* In the fantasy trilogy ''Literature/TheBalancedSword'', one of the main characters is an Intelligent Toad who doesn't wear clothes but does wear a sword belt and a pack with his equipment in. Both are actually spelled to prevent people noticing them if he doesn't want them to, because in his line of work there are times when it's useful for people to ''not'' realize he's sapient.
54	* The so-called Beagles in ''Literature/TheLongEarth'' series are basically a race of WolfMen. Because they're furry, they don't need clothing, and because they lack opposable thumbs, they have a limited ability to use tools, but they still wear belts containing basic implements and weapons.
55	* ''Literature/TheSteerswoman'': The "[[OurDemonsAreDifferent demons]]" are initially described as animals, notable only for their [[StarfishAliens bizarre]] biology and extreme danger. After all, they don't use tools or wear clothes, and will casually kill and eat each other if no other food is available. So it floors Rowan when she realizes the "sculptures" they extrude aren't territory markers or oddly shaped egg-sacks (which some of them are), but a ''language'' perceived through their sonar, with its own grammar and ability to communicate abstract concepts. This discovery of sapience recontextualizes all their behavior up to that point.
56	[[/folder]]
57
58	[[folder:Live-Action TV]]
59	* ''Series/DoctorWho'': In the Fifth Doctor story "[[Recap/DoctorWhos19E3Kinda Kinda]]", the titular beings are initially thought to be non-sapient -- but the human scientist points out that their necklaces look remarkably like DNA double-helices.
60	* In ''Series/KamenRiderGaim'', one of the story's many NothingIsTheSameAnymore moments is triggered by the appearance of a blurry photo that seems to depict an [[HordeOfAlienLocusts Invess]] carrying a sword. [[spoiler:[[EvilutionaryBiologist Dr. Sengoku]] immediately has all records of the photo erased while he conducts his own investigation, fearing that if the Invess have [[MonsterLord "Overlords"]] smart enough to negotiate with humans, then this could ruin his plans to use their invasion for his own benefit.]]
61	[[/folder]]
62
63	[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
64	* The Shantor, [[IntelligentGerbil horse-like aliens]] from ''TabletopGame/FadingSuns'', were not thought sapient until they were seen wielding spears.
65	[[/folder]]
66
67	[[folder:Video Games]]
68	* ''VideoGame/DwarfFortress'': While sapient animal people abound in the game's more savage regions as well as underground, with some joining civilizations during world generation, the tribes of subterranean animal people are marked as being a cut above sapient wildlife (to the point of having their own civilization in the raw files). They can be distinguished from other sentient cave critters like gorlaks or gremlins by the fact that they can be found wielding weapons and shields carved out of the local wood-like cave fungi.
69	[[/folder]]
70
71	[[folder:Web Comics]]
72	* Invoked prospectively in ''WebComic/{{Freefall}}'', when Florence is asked how she would recognise a human being ([[ThreeLawsCompliant a very grave question]] for [[AIIsACrapShoot an experimental AI]]).
73	[[/folder]]
74
75	[[folder:Web Original]]
76	* In ''Website/{{Serina}}'', tools are frequently used by species that are either sapient or coming close to it. We're introduced to the world's first sophonts, the fork-tailed babbling jays, when they drive away a club-wielding bludgebird with flint knives.
77	** This is averted by one of the sapient species to evolve on the planet, the daydreamers. They're a marine species that completely lack manipulatory appendages whose culture is based entirely on memory and thought and aren't capable of tool use until given pre-made ones by the gravediggers but are still considered equals to them.
78	* ''Blog/HamstersParadise'': Tool use is often an indicator of higher intelligence but its not a hard-and-fast rule:
79	** The first sapient species to appear on the planet are the AlwaysChaoticEvil harmsters. Their pre-sapience ancestors developed increased intelligence to cope with physical weakness and would use their environment to be better hunters. Eventually they learned to speared existing fires to flush out prey and this allowed them to develop even better tool use until they become fully sapient.
80	** One of the first animals to utilize tools are the fisshors, which can use their elephant-like trunks to manipulate their environments in ways they can't do naturally such as sharpening sticks to use as fishing spears and using rocks to break insect mounds. One species in particular, the branchstaffer, learn to use tree branches as clubs against predators, they end up producing a sapient descendant that uses more sophisticated tools such as spears with stone tips.
81	** This is largely averted with the second intelligent species to evolve on the planet, the calliducyons. They're physically similar to earth canines in build and appearance which means they lack the prehensile appendages needed to make complex tools but they are still considered just as sapient as the harmsters and splintsters before them. However, they are still capable of tool use to a degree, such as using sharpened sticks as spears, they just [[HandyMouth have to use their mouth]].
82	[[/folder]]
83
84	[[folder:Real Life]]
85	* Conventional paleoanthropology divides prehistoric hominins between "pre-human" australopithecines and the early members of ''Homo'', the "human genus" by the employment of stone tools, although since skeletons of both have been found in association with stone tools, it's rather up in the air if australopithecines used tools too. Even prior to modern anthrolopogy, philosophers like [[Literature/ConfessionsSaintAugustine Augustine of Hippo]] said, when speculating on the possible existence of other beings, that if they wore clothes, used tools, domesticated animals etc. this would show they were sapient and (for Augustine) possessed souls.
86	* Subverted in the case of crows. Crows are known tool inventors and users. Some crows using human cars and traffic lights as nut crackers, others known to bend wire into shapes to help them access otherwise unreachable food. This has not translated to humanity considering them sapient.
87	* Played with in the case of cetaceans, most famously dolphins. While like all other non-human animals they aren't regarded as equivalent to humans, they are noted to be among the most intelligent non-human animals out there. Their aquatic environment and lacking many ways to manipulate their environment makes documented tool use much less common than with corvids or primates, yet despite this they've displayed behaviors like using sponges to forage by dragging it along the seafloor.
88	* One of the most reliable indicators of sapience is skeletons with evidence of healed fractures, specifically fractures that have healed well enough to suggest they were assisted in some way by outside medical care. Aside from putting paid to the Social Darwinist pet theory that caring for the "unproductive" is a recent phenomenon, this would be evidence of the complex, abstract problem-solving skills needed to realise the value of setting and splinting a broken bone.
89	[[/folder]]

Context Main / ToolsOfSapience