Line #56 Main/EasyCommunication


1	[[quoteright:350:[[Webcomic/AwkwardZombie https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/easycommunication_7178.png]]]]
2	[[caption-width-right:350:Extreme screaming solves everything.]]
3
4	->''"Our friend Darius III silently waves his hand to mean ‘archers shoot!’ and also ‘chariots, charge!’ and then also ‘everyone else, charge!’"''
5	-->-- On the film ''Film/{{Alexander}}'', [[https://acoup.blog/2022/06/03/collections-total-generalship-commanding-pre-modern-armies-part-ii-commands/ Total Generalship: Commanding Pre-Modern Armies, Part II: Commands]]
6
7	In real life, a general cannot immediately give orders to a unit and have them react instantaneously. Messages have to be sent through TheChainOfCommand to colonels, majors and finally captains, lieutenants and corporals have to be reached, and finally the orders need to be received by the soldiers in the field. In some jurisdictions, the higher command such as a general ranks legally ''cannot'' give orders to privates in the field, and are bound to relay them to the commander of that specific operation. This is doubly true for ancient times.
8
9	In strategy games, on the other hand, this doesn't happen. When you, the general, click the screen, the orders are instantly transmitted from thought to deeds by the soldiers. Its as if there's some kind of psychic hive-mind link from HQ to the unit receiving the order. Particularly jarring in ancient settings when a general can give orders to soldiers a town away. That general must have one hell of a loud voice, or a very good herald! Pre-radio militaries developed various methods to cope with this problem prior to the invention of radio telephony, such as [[BlowThatHorn trumpets, bugles]], drums, fifes, flags, banners, and standards that modern militaries relegate to use on the parade grounds, but these were once genuinely used for transmitting signals.
10
11	Even so, this cannot explain the rapidity and accuracy with which orders are carried out in most games. Some argue that if building a command center or a town hall in your average RTS takes 90 seconds tops, then order transmission times must have been scaled down by a similar factor. One could also take the view that the player is controlling the entire command structure rather than just the top level commander. Thus, the player giving orders to an unit on the other side of the world is the local commander taking action, for all that this local commander knows more about the overall state of affairs than they really should.
12
13	Triply strange when the orders are relayed in an environment where receiving them would be very hard (dead zones, BleakBorderBase in a remote
14	area, caves that block radio signals, stormy weather). And if the player has allies, those manage to feed them intelligence data (up to and including firing blind using only the allies' laser "target painting") with zero delays or misunderstanding. Yes, even in settings where these allies may be aliens, robots, foreigners etc., who you'd expect to have multiple language barriers (and sometimes the only communication between them story-wise being murdering each other).
15
16	Admittedly this comes under AcceptableBreaksFromReality, as it would be annoying to wait for your orders to filter down through the proper chain of command. It's also justified in the vast majority of science-fiction settings where the author can invent an instant communication technology.
17
18	What is less forgivable is when the soldiers seem to be completely dependent on the player for orders, sometimes not responding even when under fire from a long ranged unit. There are reasons for soldiers being designed this way: a unit could come under long-ranged fire, respond, and get lured into an ambush. But its still annoying to see your unit get whittled down to nearly no health because you happened to not be around to give the order and the unit just refuses to do anything to save itself. This tends to fall under ArtificialStupidity.
19
20	The small-scale variation of this which pops up in {{Tactical Shooter}}s is SquadControls; generally more justifiable, as the squad tend to be within the PC's earshot/eyeline, but can [[TheGuardsMustBeCrazy raise questions]] if you're playing a StealthBasedMission.
21
22	Closely related to EasyLogistics. Much like CommandAndConquerEconomy only this applies to units instead of buildings being dependent on the players orders. Usually, all three tropes will be present together.
23
24	----
25	!!Examples
26
27	This is so common in strategy games that it may be best to save examples for aversions or particularly blatant examples of the trope.
28
29	[[folder:Blatant Examples]]
30	* ''VideoGame/AgeOfEmpiresII'' had the defensive orders, which were useful if you wanted a unit to not stray too far away from a position. Unfortunately, some hostile units could fire further than the distance the defensive unit was scripted to respond to aggressively. The result was that the unit would just stand there and get peppered to death.
31	** If you order peasants to build a building, and they are fired upon while doing so, they'll walk away until they're out of range, then return to try to construct the building again. If you order a dozen peasants to work on the same building, often they'll be able construct the building before they all die. But if there's only one or two peasants, often they'll just walk back and forth, getting shot at, without ever doing any work on the building, until they die.
32	* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquer'' games have this in spades, if an enemy attacks from outside their detection range they'll just stand there slowly dying, without even thinking to move away.
33	** The ''[[VideoGame/CommandAndConquerGenerals Generals]]'' series added an auto-retaliation option that let players allow their units to attack enemies who engaged them from outside their sight range. Being able to rapidly communicate with the soldiers is actually justified in the setting by the EVA units relaying orders quickly and decisively to the troops in the field.
34	** The first ''[[VideoGame/CommandAndConquerRedAlert Red Alert]]'' had an interesting case: most units would not auto-acquire targets unless set to "guard", and would never auto-acquire a building (although this is so they don't destroy anything you wanted to ''steal''). Worse, a particular elite unit, Tanya, could ''never'' be put into guard mode, and had to be directed for every shot - but, with her healthy range and high damage against infantry, she needed something to hinder her. This will actually become extremely frustrating in one particular Allies mission, which is filled with fast-running dogs that come in packs. Hope you're a fast clicker or you'll be seeing that mushroom cloud quite a lot.
35	* Though not a strategy game, this is gratuitously played straight in the ''Warriors'' series (''VideoGame/DynastyWarriors'' ''et al''), where hostile commanders can apparently have a ''real-time conversation'' from opposite ends of a raging battlefield.
36	* In Paradox's games like ''VideoGame/EuropaUniversalis'' and ''VideoGame/CrusaderKings,'' armies and ships anywhere on Earth will receive orders instantly, even if they are surrounded or on the other side of the planet. Everything in the world visible to any friendly unit is immediately visible to the player. In the economic side of the game there are at least penalties to exploiting the resources of distant lands.
37	** ''VideoGame/EuropaUniversalis IV'' is rather inconsistent in regards to your agents (Merchants, Colonists, Generals, Missionaries and Diplomats). Traders take a certain amount of time to reach a trade center depending on distance of the trade node to your capital, and a similar thing occurs with Colonists. Generals can be instantly assigned to and switched between armies no matter how distant they are, and similarly your missionaries will instantly start converting heretic or heathen provinces anywhere in your empire. Diplomats will instantly ''deliver'' messages and alliances but take a certain amount of time to come back based on the distance between the two capitals.
38	* Both blatantly displayed and averted in ''{{VideoGame/Evony}}''. On one hand, you can apparently receive news from players miles away instantly. In the medieval world. On the other hand, armies take realistic amounts of time to travel from place to place. (A real headache for alliances whose members are not close together.)
39	* Some of the ''Franchise/FireEmblem'' games (particularly [[VideoGame/FireEmblemTheBlazingBlade 7]], [[VideoGame/FireEmblemNewMysteryOfTheEmblem 12]], [[VideoGame/FireEmblemAwakening 13]], and [[VideoGame/FireEmblemFates 14]]) make the commander an entity to represent the player who can issue someone orders from any distance. Most of the other games simply make the player a NonEntityGeneral (though ''FE 4'' has the oddity of units cross country coordinating).
40	* ''VideoGame/ForTheKing'': Quest-related [=NPCs=] can somehow have conversations with each other and the {{Player Character}}s cross-country when events are triggered, despite the pseudo-medieval setting. [=PCs=] still need to meet [=NPCs=] or deliver messages in person when quests demand it -- perhaps the reception is spotty.
41	* ''VideoGame/TotalWar'' is particularly vulnerable to FridgeLogic regarding this. A group of knights that are completely embroiled in a chaotic mix of friendly and hostile forces will, at the orders of a general half a battlefield away, break off, reform (a very difficult task for cavalry) and then can be ordered by the same general to circle round the enemy army and attack from the rear. The units in this game also don't respond when under missile attack, but in this case its justified as a group of infantry suddenly charging out to attack some archers would throw a players strategy out of kilter and possibly result in the loss of the battle.
42	** The second half of the trope is subverted in the case of units with the Impetuous trait (usually knights and similar elite units), who can [[ArtificialInsolence decide to charge the enemy on their own.]] They invariably do so when least convenient to the player - isn't it just ''swell'' when the linchpin of your defensive line leaves a gaping hole in it in order to charge some dirty peasants halfway across the field? TruthInTelevision, too: that's pretty much how the French lost Crécy.
43	** Some units will also refuse to break off while pursuing targets, which can wreck things if you need those Feudal Knights to rush over and guard your archers from enemy cavalry, or you need to get your Scottish Highlanders around the enemy to flank those soldiers who are winning the battle against your dismounted knights.
44	[[/folder]]
45
46	[[folder:Aversion]]
47	* Interestingly played with in ''VideoGame/{{Achron}}'': giving units commands in the past or the future costs chronoenergy. This leads to an interesting game mechanic of assigning units commanders to create chains of command: you can minimize chronoenergy expenditure by just giving orders to commanders and letting them communicate your orders to their underlings.
48	* Faction leaders in ''VideoGame/BrutalLegend'' giver orders to their units by shouting, and this has a limited range. A significant portion of multiplayer combat involves flying to and fro in the battlefield and giving commands. There are two universal commands: the Rally Army solo, which summons all units via ThePowerOfRock, and the Rally Flag, which creates a flag for newly created units to seek.
49	* In ''VideoGame/CenturionDefenderOfRome'', during battles you can only change the orders of the units who are within the leader's range of voice (and each leader has a different one).
50	* ''VideoGame/{{Dominions}}'' probably comes as close to averting this as possible. Instead of commanding your soldiers in battle, you give orders (formation, battle plan, spells to cast, contingencies, etc…) to each unit in a region, and they then carry out the battle automatically whenever they attack or are attacked. In addition, if you want any information to base your plans on, you must scout out a region, organize an attack, and hope your intelligence is still good by the time it launches. To get reliable intel is almost impossible without special spies that not every nation has access to or spells that costs valuable magic gems. Some scrying spells even risk your casting mage's mind.
51	* In the original ''VideoGame/Dune1992'' PC game, initially you have to travel places to check on progress or issue orders, but as Paul's psychic ability increases you can contact outposts from further away, only becoming limitless after a forced plot evolution. The Dune universe does have a weird alternative to radio, but that isn't used ''either''.
52	* Usually played straight in ''VideoGame/EmpireEarth'', being an RTS, but one level has an in-universe justification where you send a spy to give the enemy fake movement orders, redirecting fuel supplies to prevent them from building units.
53	* Optional in ''Fields of Glory'', a simulation of the climactic battles of Napoleon's Hundred Days campaign. Depending on the difficulty setting, units would take a certain amount of time to respond to your orders, which was explicitly justified on the basis that it would take time for orders to be relayed from the commander to the unit.
54	* The squad sergeants in ''VideoGame/FullSpectrumWarrior'' respond quickly, getting their orders over radio, but there's still a delay as they need to verbally relay those orders to their fireteams before they move or shift fire.
55	* Averted in ''VideoGame/GratuitousSpaceBattles''. You can design the ships, giving them whatever weapons, engines, etc. you think will be most useful or economical, you choose what ships to deploy to the battlefield, their starting formations, and can even give each ship some general orders like "Stick Together" or "Stay near this ship" or "Retreat when badly damaged" or whatever. Once you hit the start button though, you can either sit back to watch the show, or go out for a beer, as either method will have equal impact on the battle. It can be maddening to watch some of your ships do something mind-bogglingly stupid and have no ability at all to tell them about it.
56	* In ''VideoGame/GraviteamTactics'', the command system simulates wire and radio communications as a prerequisite for orders to be carried out correctly. Commanders of on-map artillery need communications links back to their guns if they want to direct fire on visible targets. Some platoons now have a dedicated wire-laying squad to establish wire links. Certain vehicles may use a limited range radio, or just a radio receiver in lieu of a regular radio.
57	* ''VideoGame/KnightsOfHonor'' subverts the second half of this trope with your knights who will charge any unit within range, this can get grisly as entire groups of knights fall to the pitchforks of rabble. This is actually quite historically accurate in some medieval armies. Knights, particularly French knights, were notoriously impetuous, and several battles in history were lost due to undisciplined, glory-hungry knights insisting on being the first into battle. The French knights at Agincourt and Crecy were notorious for this.
58	* ''VideoGame/{{Majesty}}'' averts this by not giving you direct control of "your" units at all - the best you can do is to post bounties for exploring locations or killing monsters, and whether the various heroes respond to them will depend on their own stats, morale, character type, and whether the bounty is sufficient to cover the effort involved. On the other hand, they'll respond to bounties as soon as you post them, so it's still in effect to some degree.
59	* Ditto for the [=iOS=] port of ''VideoGame/MasterOfOrion'' called ''VideoGame/StarbaseOrion''. Unlike the original game, which played this trope straight (and justified it by having {{Subspace Ansible}}s), the port only allows you to give behavioral orders prior to the battle and initial targets. So you ''can'' tell all your ships to kill a specific enemy ship first, but after that they use their behavior settings to determine the next target. If a battle happens to run longer than a certain time limit, you are given the option of amending the orders for the next turn. You also may not redirect your fleets in FTL, although you may hire a leader who is a master at communications, granting you this (buggy) ability.
60	* ''VideoGame/MechCommander'' and its sequel have orders being issued and followed instantaneously. However, this is revealed to be an aspect of the software and the command setup. In both instances, the player is a company commander, but can assign orders to any unit because of the explicit use of real-time satellite communications between the Mechcommander officer and the unit being controlled--the opening not only has Commander Harrison talking the leader of his unit to relay orders, but also to individual pilots when he splits them up. This becomes FridgeBrilliance when ''Mechcommander'' is played alongside a contemporary ''VideoGame/MechWarrior'' game--the move orders of ''Mechcommander'' are the equivalent of assigned navigation waypoints in ''Mechwarrior'', while issuing new attack or defend orders is simply the equivalent of getting new mid-mission objectives as a pilot.
61	* In ''VideoGame/{{Powermonger}}'' orders to your other captains are sent by carrier pigeon. If you like you can scroll the map and watch the bird fly to its destination.
62	* ''VideoGame/{{Praetorians}}'' plays this straight mostly, but if your units get embroiled in battle with another unit, you won't be able to give them orders until the hostile unit is dead.
63	* Averted somewhat in ''VideoGame/SignalOps'' as while your troops are controlled directly using television screens, they have to be in your radio range to actually see what they're doing, if the radio dies then you have to give a "retreat" order to the radio man to recharge the radio at the last used power source and constantly recharing the radio/setting it up on power sources that can increase it's range while attached is a big part of the gameplay .
64	* Slytherine's strategy game ''Spartan'' designed their mechanics with this specifically in mind. At the start of the battle it's possible to form your troops up and give them general strategy decisions (advance deep behind the enemy and flank) but once the battle is started it becomes impossible to relay orders more complex than retreat and rally.
65	* In ''VideoGame/SwordOfTheStars'' Humans and Zuul cannot relay orders to fleets in [[{{Hyperspace}} nodespace]] because the signals wouldn't be able to catch up to the ships in time. The Tarka need to research a specific technology before they are able to communicate with ships in transit. Inside of battles, ships often take time to respond to orders (though this is more due to physical concerns rather than delays in communication) and can be set to a number of stances that limit or increase their personal initiative. However, human and Zuul ships can enter battle in nodespace, which means you can still give them orders while they're a non-entity in real space. It's also mentioned [[AllThereInTheManual in the manual]] that interstellar communication is ''far'' from instantaneous for most of the races. The [[BeePeople Hivers]] and the [[LizardFolk Tarka]] are able to do so via their PortalNetwork and SubspaceAnsible, respectively. Humans have to leave relay bouys near the nodes in order to re-transmit messages through nodespace. Of course, that still means that it takes a ''long'' time for a message to be sent even two systems away (if nodes are located far from each other). The [[SapientCetaceans Liir]] use "stutter-probes" to record audio-messages using their Fleetsong battle language and send them to their destination. Since the probes are much smaller than ships, they can teleport much faster (of course, how do you send a probe to a ship teleporting at FTL speeds).[[note]]Technically, neither is moving at FTL at all. They just teleport minute distances really, really fast, and the comm probes can do it even faster.[[/note]] The [[PlanetLooters Zuul]] and the [[AncientAstronauts Morrigi]] don't really get an explanation for how they're able to do interstellar communications.
66	** There's also the issue of Command And Control facilities during battle. If all your [=CnC=] ships present are crippled or destroyed, your reinforcements start arriving at a trickle, and you lose the ability to issue commands from the tactical overlay, forcing you to more or less eyeball weapon ranges, asteroid blind spots, ect.
67	* In the American Civil War tactical game ''VideoGame/TakeCommand'', messengers on horse are sent out from the field headquarters to the battallions with the planned orders, and these messengers can be killed by the enemy.
68	* A narrative rather than gameplay example: ''VideoGame/TalesOfBerseria'', being a HighFantasy, has no telecommunications, and the ability to travel faster than conventional means is effectively nonexistent. Combine this with the near-world-dominating Abbey being quite happy to suppress information, and news travels very slowly. Velvet's team exploits this; for the first third of the game, despite being [[UnusuallyUninterestingSight extremely distinctive]], they're able to travel pretty much unquestioned because they keep ahead of news of the havoc they've been wreaking, FacialCompositeFailure is in effect, or their targets have been so classified the Abbey isn't even willing to tell their own rank and file about a given incident.
69	** This is also why Aifread's pirates can keep operating despite the Abbey having total control of the shipping lanes. They have the loyalty of a flock of Sylphjays, birds which act as perfectly reliable message carriers. Compared to how hard it is to otherwise get a message out to a ship at sea, the pirate fleet can coordinate and run rings around any patrols.
70	* The non-responsiveness problem is averted in ''VideoGame/{{Warcraft}} III'': not only are units able to acquire and attack on their own, the "autocast" feature means that they will use certain abilities whenever appropriate. For instance, a Priest left alone with a group of units would automatically heal any injuries. The autoretaliation debuted in Warcraft ''[[OlderThanTheyThink II]]'', if not the first; it also had the feature of an attacking unit revealing itself through the FogOfWar.
71	** Also, Blizzard RTS games were some of the first to implement a "Hold Position" order, where a unit would stay in one spot and engage anything that came into range, but would not leave its position if attacked from range. This was useful if you were massing forces for an attack and didn't want them getting pulled into battle prematurely by enemy units trying to kite them into an ambush.
72	** And averted during one of the Undead levels where there's an optional quest to kill an elf from Sylvanas' base trying to BringNewsBack to Silvermoon. By game mechanics this would be redundant, as your adjutant unit warns you when your allies are in battle.
73	** The expansion's orc campaign is kicked off when Rexxar encounters a dying orc and agrees to deliver his scouting report to Thrall. GameplayAndStorySegregation again, since you can always see what the unit does.
74	* ''VideoGame/WarhammerDarkOmen'' has the variant where you can command units normally, but once engaged in melee the only way to get them out is if one side or the other breaks. You can deliberately order a unit to break, which is generally a very bad idea considering that routing units take large losses and are [[NintendoHard nigh]] [[PermanentlyMissableContent irreplaceable.]]
75
76	!!Non-Video Game Examples:
77	* This is mentioned in Creator/TomClancy's novel ''The Bear and The Dragon'' and explains why treating actual people in this manner is a bad idea.
78	* While usually played straight in ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer}}'', with the exception of fleeing units, the Orcs and Goblins are an aversion - while they will usually do what you decide they should, most units in the list have a special rule that makes them periodically ''ignore'' your orders and settle down to kick each other for a while.
79
80	[[/folder]]
81
82	[[folder:Justifications]]
83	* Anything with massively advanced communications or PsychicPowers can be expected to use something like this.
84	* The EVA units of ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquer'' are noted as simplifying command of troops in the field, helping to justify that part of this trope. This does lead to some GameplayAndStorySegregation in ''[[VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianSun Tiberian Sun: Firestorm]]'' when the Brotherhood has no problems commanding units in the field for those two missions where neither CABAL nor a stolen EVA unit is available.
85	* Justified in ''VideoGame/{{Starcraft}}'' for the Zerg and Protoss factions because it is explicitly a psychic link. Also might be justified for the Terran faction - the lower units like marines, firebats etc., who are brainwashed, drugged soldiers in power armor. The higher units like armors, fliers etc. are experienced and ranked. Actually, whenever you select multiple units, one of them (the one with the highest rank) is selected as a "command unit", which communicates with you. And it is in the future with rather few units (max 12 units get commands at the same time) - radio is quite fine for that, especially when you consider that there is hardly any cover and that taking cover with a ton heavy walking behemoth is not all that easy or practical for most cases. And for heroes, it can be presumed they are making their own judgements. The Terrans use Adjutants to control their troops, so it's not infeasible that, in fact, the commander's interface literally looks like an RTS and the AI relays orders. For example, when the commander "selects" a marine and then "selects" an enemy to attack, what actually happens is that the Adjutant translates it into orders communicated through the marine's PowerArmor, via either voice or even by highlighting said enemy on the helmet's HUD. The real question here is who controls the units through the "RTS" overview screen in ''VideoGame/StarcraftII'' when Raynor is a playable unit on the battlefield, because the player is explicitly Raynor himself rather than some NonEntityGeneral. Usually, missions with Raynor as a playable unit involve him personally leading a small unit. He could just be literally ordering his squad around verbally.
86	* ''VideoGame/TotalAnnihilation'' and its SpiritualSuccessor ''VideoGame/SupremeCommander'' justify this - the entire army is robotic, so nigh-instant communications and perfect discipline are to be expected. They also partially avert the 'standing around uselessly' part of the trope - they will fire back at any unit in range unless ordered not to.
87
88	!!Non-Video Game Examples:
89	* ''FanFic/CivilizationVPeaceWalker'' justifies ''Civ''[='s=] easy long-distance orders to troops and diplomatic communication between factions with Kaz telling Snake that they have a huge cache of radios and batteries. [[spoiler:Later, when he confronts Snake, Nebuchadnezzar points out how odd it is that a selection of leaders from all over the world and all of history are able to perfectly understand each other, as evidence that none of what is happening is real.]]
90	* In ''Literature/EndersGame'', the Formics were like this due to a HiveMind, and humans compensated by learning how to create instant communication technology. [[spoiler:Ender in fact commented on how the game he was playing was unrealistic because of the instant communication, when unbeknownst to him, it was actually real. Bean realizes the game is real for this very reason in a later book, but never informs others.]] It also ''does'' filter through a chain of command, albeit brief, once he started training with his squad leaders. This is ''usually'' not a problem. In ''Literature/EndersShadow'', [[spoiler:Bean first realizes the truth after an instructor asks him about a book Bean supposedly checked out from the Battle School library involving ancient battle tactics of building multiple layers of defense structures. Bean, having used the book as a cover and only skimmed it (he has eidetic memory, though), tries to justify his interest in it, only to realize that it's nigh-impossible to defend a planet without a truly massive fleet (which the Buggers actually have), so the only viable option to humans is attack]].
91	* ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'' has sufficient squad-level comms, elite squad leaders, telepathic links and the like to keep their units coordinated, although how Orks handle it beyond "shouting a lot" is anyone's guess (no really, they're known to use orks with particularly loud voices to relay orders). Hilariously averted with one Apocalypse stratagem, however; it prevents players on a team from talking to each other while deploying, meaning that while the troops will be under control ''during'' the game, a fair number will be badly out of position because of where your ally put their tanks.
92	** Averted in ''[[VideoGame/DawnOfWar Dawn of War: Soulstorm]]'', where the Pathfinders supposed to be looking for the breach in the Tau base (you) don't report back, leading to the Tau concentrating their attacks on the last known transmission (which apparently wasn't "ARGH HELP"). This from the race that has pinpoint ''orbital attack satellites''.
93	[[/folder]]
94

Context Main / EasyCommunication