Line #45 Film/WithoutWarning1994


1	[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/without_warning_cbs_1994_emiwcqbv9eqmkv_01.png]]
2	[[caption-width-right:350:CBS' original broadcast title screen.]]
3
4	->''"Fifty-six years ago tonight, America was shaken to it's [sic] core by 'War of the Worlds', Orson Welles' classic radio broadcast about an alien invasion of Earth from Mars. Many americans believed visitors from outer space had actually landed and there was nationwide panic. It was the most startling radio broadcast of all time.''
5
6	->''"On tonight's anniversary of "War of the Worlds", CBS presents another story... Perhaps as disturbing and equally alarming.''
7
8	->''"What you are about to see is pure fiction. It is not actually happening. But could events depited in this special program someday take place?''
9
10	->''"Judge for yourself."''
11
12	-->--'''CBS' introductory graphic/voiceover'''' prior to the broadcast of the film.
13
14	''Without Warning'' is a Creator/{{CBS}} MadeForTVMovie from 1994, directed by Robert Iscove, that [[WeInterruptThisProgram interrupts the regularly scheduled program]] with a [[PhonyNewscast breaking news story]] about a [[DeathFromAbove meteor impact]] in Wyoming that is quickly joined by bizarre phenomena (including an apparent Rapture) and a pair of other meteor impacts in France and China which, together with the first, form a pattern that appears to some scientists as [[ColonyDrop deliberate]].
15
16	Like Creator/OrsonWelles' 1938 radio production of ''Radio/TheWarOfTheWorlds'', this movie is a PhonyNewscast that was broadcast on [[UsefulNotes/AllHallowsEve Halloween]], and allegedly more than a few people were taken in by the realism. This wasn't the first time American network TV had aired a realistic newscast: in 1983 a nuclear terrorism incident was dramatized in ''Film/SpecialBulletin''.
17
18	Not to be confused with [[Film/WithoutWarning1980 the 1980 sci-fi film of the same name]].
19
20	----
21	!!This film has the examples of:
22
23	* AlliterativeTitle: '''W'''ithout '''W'''arning
24	* AndMissionControlRejoiced: [[spoiler:For about a minute. (See HopeSpot.)]]
25	* ApocalypticGagOrder: The government tries to keep quiet about the third wave of impactors coming to Earth, but this is defied by Dr. Mandel, who quits his work and announces the incoming doom in an impromptu news conference before leaving to live what he believes are his final hours with his family.
26	* ApocalypseHow: Class 5-6. [[spoiler:Best case scenario still involves millions of deaths by ColonyDrop barrage. Worst case scenario is total extinction.]]
27	* ArtisticLicenseHistory:
28	** Zig-zagged. At roughly the halfway mark, the White House press secretary mentions that the president has directed NASA to look for objects which might enter the atmosphere. While NASA didn't start doing that until late the following year, someone on the production staff must've asked the right person about it, because the telescope named in the show as having spotted the second impactor is indeed the one NASA would use when they started their program in 1995. It should be noted that at no point is a year ever actually given for the events of the film, so anyone watching a rebroadcast or DVD in 1995 or later wouldn't notice the discrepancy.
29	** It is stated repeatedly that the aliens are responding to the plaque attached to the ''Pioneer 11'' spacecraft, which contained information about human life on Earth. However, the illustrations of the "plaque" are actually a graphic of the Arecibo radio telescope message. Anyone who has any knowledge of the history of space exploration (or anyone who bothers to look it up) will know that the two look nothing alike. This is particularly insulting, given that this is an important plot point. On top of it all, the message relayed by the aliens is a parroting of one of the voice recordings sent up with the ''Voyager'' probes, not ''Pioneer'', though the source is correctly identified.
30	* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: A scientist, named Dr. Avram Mandel, regards the destruction of the second impactor as a declaration of war against the aliens, who have at that point announced their presence by repeatedly bombing our planet with asteroids, killed two innocent people including one little girl in order to send a message, and (possibly) kidnapped the entire population of a small rural town in Wyoming. While it's admittedly an extreme point of view, some might consider such behavior to constitute an act of war in its own right, an attitude arguably borne out by [[spoiler:the aliens responding to initial defensive action by attempting to disable the capability thus demonstrated, and responding to ''further'' defensive action by attempting to ''murder everyone on the planet''. Truly, what else could they be but misunderstood space angels?]]
31	* ArtisticLicensePhysics:
32	** A near-real-time "infrared image" of one of the first impact craters has the northeast quadrant of the crater in sharply delineated shadow, which a true infrared image of a fresh crater wouldn't, but a recolor of a visible-light image would. For bonus points, such a shadow would only appear in a ''daylight'' shot; for double super special bonus points, the shadow in the image is far too high for the declination of the sun in northern Wyoming in late October.
33	** Sharp, clear photos of phenomena on Earth's surface are said to have been taken by the Hubble space telescope. Hubble can't clearly image anything on Earth; it is after all a ''space'' telescope, and its orbital speed and imaging hardware are both tightly optimized for that role. Terrestrial imagery is what spy and weather satellites are for. If anything, Hubble might have been used to try and image one of the incoming "meteors" but even that is unlikely.
34	** Nuclear warheads are repeatedly used to vaporize large asteroids before they can hit Earth; at least one rock is shown to be there before the blast, and gone after. Various characters in the film express doubts as to whether this will work, which is sensible of them, because it wouldn't. In fact, it wouldn't twice over: on the one hand, it wouldn't vaporize the impactor, and on the other, even if it did, it would only reduce the total impact energy by whatever minuscule deceleration it managed to impart. Exchanging one large impactor for many small ones doesn't help in that regard, no matter how small they are; each still carries kinetic energy proportional to its fraction of the total original mass. The only meaningful difference is that, instead of one big hole in the ground and a corresponding plume of ejecta, that kinetic energy is liberated directly into the atmosphere, heating it up with probably rather bad results in its own right. (On the other hand, a large impactor hitting the Arctic ice sheet would very likely cause a tsunami, so breaking it up might be the better option.)
35	** Related to the above, a nuclear missile vaporizes one of the impactors mere moments before it hits a major city. It's close enough for the reporter and everyone else to see it in the sky. In fact they're looking ''right at it'' at the moment a nuclear weapon explodes and detonates it. In reality, being blinded by the flash would have been the least of their worries, given they would most likely have been vaporized by the blast.
36	** Whoever's behind the attacks is implied, albeit somewhat loosely, to be responding in real time to the actions of people on Earth; for example, [[spoiler:after the second impactor is destroyed over the pole, the third wave targets the world's three most important capitals.]] Given that the whole show plays out in less than an hour and a half, that nothing aside from the asteroids themselves is detected in near-Earth space, and the extremely low (~14km/s, lower for the big ones) velocity with which the impactors arrive, this speed and flexibility of response strongly suggests some kind of "cloaking" capability on the part of the unseen aliens, which would be necessary both to station a ship close enough to observe the response to each wave of impactors, and to place the asteroids themselves close enough to Earth to land them at the observed times without having them spotted much earlier than they are.
37	* AsHimself: To lend authenticity to the PhonyNewscast, (then) well-known newacasters Sander Vanocur and Bree Walker appear as themselves, and Creator/ArthurCClarke appears for an in-universe interview. (Unfortunately, acting does not appear to have been among Dr. Clarke's many attainments; where in interviews he was generally quite lively and engaging, here he comes off rather flat.) A couple of other recognizable reporters appear in press conference scenes. Averted, however, by having a well-known TV actress (Creator/JaneKaczmarek) play Vanocur's co-anchor and an actor well known for his appearances in ''Franchise/StarTrek'' (Creator/JohnDeLancie) play one of the reporters.
38	* BlandNameProduct: The news network is not mentioned by name, and the logo is similar to, but distinct from, the CBS "eye", looking instead more like the ''ComicBook/GreenLantern'' logo. This example is notable in that the motivation is not to avoid trademark infringement—CBS would naturally have had the right to use its own logo—but to make it more obvious to viewers that what they were seeing isn't real.
39	* BlueAndOrangeMorality: The aliens appear to operate on this, as they don't seem to understand how or why bombarding the planet in an attempt to communicate could be interpreted as hostile.
40	* BrokenAesop: When SufficientlyAdvancedAliens peacefully introduce themselves by peacefully bombing our planet with peaceful asteroids, we shouldn't defend ourselves, because such warlike behavior might provoke them to peacefully recreate the K-T extinction event several times over to [[RocksFallEveryoneDies peacefully get rid of us.]] Peacefully, of course.
41	* CaughtUpInTheRapture: Among many strange things that the aliens do throughout the film, they kidnap an entire townful of people. Comparisons to the Rapture are made InUniverse, which is a little on the nose in light of [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt what happens later]].
42	* ColonyDrop: The meteors are initially conjectured [[spoiler:and later confirmed]] to have been launched at Earth by an extraterrestrial intelligence.
43	* DeadlineNews: [[spoiler:What the entire film-slash-"live broadcast" ends up becoming]].
44	* DeathFromAbove: Meteors raining from space with unusual precision.
45	* DeathOfAChild The young 8-year-old girl dies, [[spoiler:and then the rest of humanity. The entire town that was abducted is mentioned to have included children, though]].
46	* DownerEnding: [[spoiler:[[EverybodyDiesEnding As far as it looks before the broadcast is interrupted by a meteor impact, the entire world is doomed to destruction]].]]
47	* TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt: [[spoiler:The final destination of the Earth, as it shows above]].
48	* ExtremelyShortTimespan: The movie (not counting potential ad time) takes an hour and a half and events are presented as apparently taking place in RealTime. This leads to a few minor plot holes considering how quickly some events are presented.
49	* EventTitle: ''Asteroid: Fire from the Sky''. This name was given to him after the newscast had told all the information about the asteroids. The news anchor drops the title change before they went to commercials, which causes the banner to change. For viewers who were watching the movie and began to follow it later, they could be confused with this title.
50	* EverybodyDiesEnding: [[spoiler:In defending ourselves from alien first contact (mostly because it ''didn't'' look like first contact), we have proven ourselves to be hostile to them, and their immediate retaliation completely annihilates the world.]]
51	* FaceDeathWithDignity: While the entire rest of the cast go through [[HeroicBSOD a severe case of wide-eyed shell-shock]] as they see the world end, Vancour calmly assures people that the news broadcast will continue for as long as possible.
52	* FakeOutOpening: The presentation begins as a murder mystery film, starring Loni Anderson in a cameo, which itself is titled ''Without Warning''. Quickly, it is at first interrupted by a short special bulletin hosted by Sandy Hill, [[WeInterruptThisProgram before it is interrupted again for good by the newscast]].
53	* FoundFootage: Just a dab, showing the first impactor on its way down. Compared with [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpmXyJrs7iU more recent non-fictional examples of a certain meteor entering the atmosphere]], the SFX team's efforts are surprisingly creditable; the only really obvious error is that a real meteor comes down a lot slower than you'd think. Curiously, a later StockFootage clip ''shows'' a real meteor coming down at a plausible rate. Why the FoundFootage clip doesn't is anyone's guess.
54	* GovernmentCoverup: Of the third wave of impactors. It doesn't last very long thanks to Dr. Mandel.
55	* HeroicSacrifice: Two F-16s dispatched to shoot down the second impactor are destroyed seconds before their nuclear-armed rockets hit it. Despite their deaths, the mission is successful, and the impactor destroyed.
56	* HopeSpot: The nuclear weapons launched at the third wave of meteors successfully neutralize the threat to Washington, Moscow, and Beijing. [[spoiler:Cue a rather silent MassOhCrap moments later, when ''hundreds'' of new meteors are detected hurdling down, dooming all life on Earth.]]
57	* HorrorDoesntSettleForSimpleTuesday: The entire situation occurs, from initial impact [[spoiler:to the total annihilation of humanity]], [[ExtremelyShortTimespan over the course of an hour and a half (not counting ad time)]] of a Halloween evening. This is another element of the ShoutOut to the Mercury Theater radio version of ''Radio/TheWarOfTheWorlds''.
58	* HumansAreBastards: Heavily implied, despite frankly quite measured defensive responses throughout; there is, after all, nothing unreasonable about defending one's planet against unprovoked and deadly attack. The [[AliensAreBastards opposing perspective]] doesn't get so much as a moment's worth of air time; neither do the possibilities that this is a [[PoorCommunicationKills tragic breakdown in communication]] or an example of BlueAndOrangeMorality. It is all but stated that the human race is entirely at fault for daring to try to defend ourselves.
59	* IgnoredExpert: Dr. Avram Mandel, an expert in alien intelligence, mentions that he repeatedly said that the aliens were peaceful from the moment he was called by the government, but in the face of the obvious, he was ignored... he says this [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere as he leaves for his home to spend what he thinks are his final hours with his family]], [[spoiler:which gave him some more time than the rest of the planet]].
60	* InscrutableAliens: Dr. Avram Mandel, the Ignored expert, insists that the aliens are peaceful even when it's clear that they work on BlueAndOrangeMorality. The one thing that is absolutely sure is that they never provide an explanation or even so much as appear in person.
61	* JiveTurkey: Downplayed, but still present, in a "man on the street" interview with a young black college student.
62	* PhonyNewscast: The story is told in such a format as a deliberate homage to ''Radio/TheWarOfTheWorlds''.
63	* PoorCommunicationKills: [[spoiler:The whole apocalyptic mess could have easily been avoided if the aliens had found a less destructive way of announcing their presence or at least if the military hadn't decided to shoot first and ask questions later]].
64	* RealTime: Almost. Barring some commercial breaks, the whole movie follows the live broadcast from the moment the initial meteor impact is detected up until [[spoiler:the aliens' attack apparently destroys the broadcast center]]. However, the characters occasionally make statements about the timing of events that don't track (and would be impossible) with the runtime of the movie.
65	* TheReveal: The first meteor impacts [[spoiler:were in fact an attempt at first contact by an alien species, and, by destroying the follow-up impactor barreling toward the North Pole at the highest speed cited in the show, Earth has declared war on the aliens]].
66	* RiddleForTheAges: Whether or not the aliens abducted the town in Wyoming and why for.
67	* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Dr. Mandel responds to the coverup of the third impactor wave by resigning from NASA and announcing the incoming asteroids in an impromptu press conference.
68	* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Various members of MissionControl can be seen during the MassOhCrap running out of the room, presumably to spend their last moments with their family.
69	* ShootTheShaggyDog: [[spoiler:Mankind's efforts to protect itself from apparent annihilation only makes the aliens decide to do it for real.]] This does not shoots the shaggy dog, [[spoiler:it literally performs a ColonyDrop on the poor thing.]]
70	* ShoutOut:
71	** In addition to the choice of date and format, the first meteor impact is noted as sixty miles north of the fictional town of "Grover's Mill, Wyoming", a reference to ''Radio/TheWarOfTheWorlds'', in which the initial Martian landing site was Grover's Mill, New Jersey.
72	** The first broadcast of the film included a prologue and disclaimer that explicitly credited the older work.
73	** The quote from ''Theatre/JuliusCaesar'' at the very ending of the film.
74	--->[[spoiler:"The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves."]]
75	* ShownTheirWork: If you wanted to clobber multiple points along the same latitude, starting over the pole would be a reasonable way to do it.
76	* StarfishAliens: Seriously, ''what'' kind of people introduce themselves with a nice brisk ''planetary bombardment''? [[{{Series/V1983}} Alien snakes in latex]] have nothing on these guys!
77	* TechnoBabble: Mostly avoided, which is all to the good; an eerie high-pitched howl coming from the initial impactors is said to be "on the edge of the FM band", which isn't even the ''same kind of wave'' as audible sound, and to have its origin in a "pulsating charged ion field...of natural origin", which to make any sense at all would have to be a plasma of the sort that can't exist in ground-level atmosphere without an ongoing energy input and ideally some kind of containment. For comparison, the handiest example of an uncontained plasma at ground level is lightning, which does produce broadband radio interference, albeit concentrated far below the FM or even AM range and thus unlikely to produce the deleterious effect on air traffic that's mentioned in the show.
78	* ThisIsAWorkOfFiction: Disclaimers of this type were included at the start of the broadcast and following commercial breaks.
79	-->"'Without Warning' is a realistic depiction of fictional events. None of what you are seeing is actually happening."
80	* TwoHalvesMakeAPlot: On every impact site of the first barrage of meteors, one person survived, heavily injured and continuously saying gibberish. Right after the second barrage of meteors is shot down, they all die at the very same time and their gibberish is spliced together, [[spoiler:revealing that they are all saying a piece of the recording on the Voyager probes, ''inviting aliens to come to Earth'']].
81	* TheUnreveal: During the timeframe of the movie, we never learn anything about the impactor in the Gobi Desert - who was affected, who carried a part of the alien's message, etc. TruthInTelevision as, given the very short timeframe of the movie (everything happens over the course of only a few hours), there was simply not enough time for Chinese officials to follow-up on an event in a remote desert area, as opposed to the other two parts of the message that were relayed in locations more readily accessible.
82	* WeComeInPeaceShootToKill: [[spoiler:[[WhamLine The aliens found one of the Voyager probes, and were only trying to make first contact with Earth]].]] Unfortunately, their methods -- performing a ColonyDrop on equidistant spots on Earth that would cause ''tremendous'' damage upon potential impact, and following it up with ''another'' one which would produce a tsunami more destructive than any in recorded history -- provokes the armed forces of the United States to make a move which, while purely defensive, ''they'' saw as hostile. Cue TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt.
83	* WeInterruptThisProgram: The fake murder mystery presented at the beginning is preempted by the newscast.
84	* WhamLine: [[spoiler:"We declared war against them, people... We did it and they've just decided to respond... so may God have mercy on us all".]]
85
86	----
87	->''"Without Warning" was not an actual newscast. This was a fictional movie.''

Context Film / WithoutWarning1994