Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / StarTrekVoyagerS7E20NaturalLaw

Go To



* ValuesDissonance: We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a [[Recap/StarTrekS2E5TheApple group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology]].

to:

* ValuesDissonance: ValuesDissonance:
**
We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a [[Recap/StarTrekS2E5TheApple group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology]].



-->'''Janeway:''' Did you ever consider allowing the Ocampa to care for themselves?
-->'''Caretaker:''' They're children.
-->'''Janeway:''' Children have to grow up. We're explorers too. Most of the species we've encountered have overcome all kinds of adversity without a Caretaker. It's the challenge of surviving on their own that helps them to evolve. Maybe your children will do better than you think.

to:

-->'''Janeway:''' --->'''Janeway:''' Did you ever consider allowing the Ocampa to care for themselves?
-->'''Caretaker:''' --->'''Caretaker:''' They're children.
-->'''Janeway:''' --->'''Janeway:''' Children have to grow up. We're explorers too. Most of the species we've encountered have overcome all kinds of adversity without a Caretaker. It's the challenge of surviving on their own that helps them to evolve. Maybe your children will do better than you think.


** It sure was lucky for Chakotay and Seven that this was not in fact a "Feeders of Vaal" situation or they wouldn't have made it through the first night.

to:

** *** It sure was lucky for Chakotay and Seven that this was not in fact a "Feeders of Vaal" situation or they wouldn't have made it through the first night.night.
** Not to mention Captain Janeway in the [[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS1E1Caretaker pilot episode]].
-->'''Janeway:''' Did you ever consider allowing the Ocampa to care for themselves?
-->'''Caretaker:''' They're children.
-->'''Janeway:''' Children have to grow up. We're explorers too. Most of the species we've encountered have overcome all kinds of adversity without a Caretaker. It's the challenge of surviving on their own that helps them to evolve. Maybe your children will do better than you think.


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: As reviled as Chakotay/Seven is, this episode could have laid some groundwork for it, so that it doesn't just HAPPEN in the series finale, considering the two are trapped on a planet for a good chunk of the episode. Instead, nothing is even remotely explored on the subject.
* ValuesDissonance: We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: As reviled as Chakotay/Seven is, this episode could have laid some groundwork for it, so that it doesn't just HAPPEN [[CrackPairing HAPPEN]] in the series finale, considering the two are [[LockedInARoom trapped on a planet planet]] for a good chunk of the episode. Instead, nothing is even remotely explored on the subject.
* ValuesDissonance: We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a [[Recap/StarTrekS2E5TheApple group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology.technology]].

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: As reviled as Chakotay/Seven is, this episode could have laid some groundwork for it, so that it doesn't just HAPPEN in the series finale, considering the two are trapped on a planet for a good chunk of the episode. Instead, nothing is even remotely explored on the subject.


* ValuesDissonance: We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology.technology.
** It sure was lucky for Chakotay and Seven that this was not in fact a "Feeders of Vaal" situation or they wouldn't have made it through the first night.

Added DiffLines:

* ValuesDissonance: We all know what Captain Kirk would have done if he'd encountered a group of people whose development was being held in stasis by alien technology.

Showing 6 edit(s) of 6

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report