History YMMV / SouthParkS4E2CartmansSillyHateCrime2000

** When Cartman threw the rock at Tolkien, it wasn't under racist intentions, but because he thought Tolkien called him fat even after being warned not to. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions.]]

** When Cartman threw the rock at Token, it wasn't under racist intentions, but because he thought Token called him fat even after being warned not to. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions.]]
** Then comes [[Recap/SouthParkThePandemicSpecial The Pandemic Special]], where Token gets (deliberately) shot by cops and is taken to the hospital. Unlike Cartman, who would actually get punished for his crime, the SPPD officers [[KarmaHoudini suffer no consequences]].

** When Cartman threw the rock at Tolkien, it wasn't under racist intentions, but because he thought Token called him fat even after being warned not to. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Tolkien, with actual racist intentions.]]
** Then comes [[Recap/SouthParkThePandemicSpecial The Pandemic Special]], where Tolkien gets (deliberately) shot by cops and is taken to the hospital. Unlike Cartman, who would actually get punished for his crime, the SPPD officers [[KarmaHoudini suffer no consequences]].

** Kyle and the others point out how the term "Hate Crime" is being used far too liberally. In the Season 19 premier, Kyle would find himself on the receiving end of the clearest definition of a hate crime (ironically from people who would be against such things if they bothered to find out about Kyle's Judaism).

** When Cartman threw the rock at Token, it wasn't under racist intentions, but because he thought Token called him fat even after being warned not to. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions.]]
** Then comes [[Recap/SouthParkThePandemicSpecial The Pandemic Special]], where Token gets (deliberately) shot by cops and is taken to the hospital. Unlike Cartman, who would actually get punished for his crime, the SPPD officers [[KarmaHoudini suffer no consequences]].

** In "Casa Bonita" Cartman beats up Jimmy - a handicapped child who just happens to be white - and suffers zero consequence.

* HilariousInHindsight: Clyde being a HollywoodPudgy somewhat foreshows his appearance in ''WesternAnimation/SouthParkPostCovid'' when he's shown to be significantly overweight as an adult.

** When Cartman threw the rock at Token, it wasn't under racist intentions. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions.]]
*** Then comes [[Recap/SouthParkThePandemicSpecial The Pandemic Special]], where Token gets shot by cops and is taken to the hospital. Unlike Cartman, who would actually get punished for his crime, the SPPD officers [[KarmaHoudini suffer no consequences]].

** Due to many courts decided not to press charges, which didn't help that many opponents on hate crimes were inspired from said episode, the episode came across as a far-right propaganda.

** Butters spouts very misogynistic statements in this episode but is otherwise only sexist in "Lice Capades", and even then it was only a throwaway remark. Come Season 20, he becomes a misogynist.

** When Cartman threw the rock at Token, it wasn't under racist intentions. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions that time.]]
** Butters spouts out very misogynistic statements in this episode but is otherwise only sexist in "Lice Capades", and even then it was only a throwaway remark. Come Season 20 when he develops into a straight-up bigot against women.

* HilariousInHindsight: Twenty years after the episode had a TakeThat at ''WesternAnimation/{{Animaniacs}}'', Trey Parker is announced as one of the cast members of the show's Hulu reboot.

* HilariousInHindsight: Twenty years after the episode had a TakeThat at ''WesternAnimation/{{Animaniancs}}'', Trey Parker is announced as one of the cast members of the show's Hulu reboot.

* HollywoodPudgy: Clyde is said to be the second fattest kid despite appearing as the same size as the others.

** Butters spouts out very misogynistic statements in this episode but is otherwise not sexist in future episodes. Come Season 20 when he develops into a straight-up bigot against women.

* HarsherInHindsight: When Cartman threw the rock at Token, it wasn't under racist intentions.
[[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions that time.]]

* HarsherInHindsight: When Cartman threw the rock at Token, it wasn't under racist intentions. [[Recap/SouthParkS17E3WorldWarZimmerman Come Season 17, Cartman would shoot Token, with actual racist intentions that time.]]

* HollywoodPudgy: Clyde is said to be the second fattest kid despite appearing as the same size as the others.
* UnfortunateImplications: The boys are able to get Cartman pardoned by pointing out that hate crime law is a "savage hypocrisy" since all forms of crime are based on some sort of hate, and that the laws only encourage discrimination by punishing one group of people more harshly than another because of their race.

* HollywoodPudgy: Clyde is said to be the second fattest kid despite appearing as the same size as the others.