Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MaternalInstinctMLP

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeHorror:
** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push him away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye as her husband hitting her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from, not to mention that his mother Danauria uses the same method of discipline on him. Children are more observant than adults often realize...
*** The anecdote about the servant's husband hitting her, even though it was made up to avoid explaining that Pupa accidentally kicked her in the face for tying her obi too tightly, also implies that DomesticAbuse might be considered normal in changeling society, given that nochangeling seems disturbed by the explanation.
** Pupa's mental disability means that she will probably never be able to function as well as a normal adult. She is expected to marry Morphin (who is neurotypical) when she grows up, in order to continue her family's bloodline. This raises several disturbing questions:
*** It is very unlikely that an adult Pupa would even have the ability to understand the concept of sex, much less consent to it. If Pupa can't consent to sex, but the Roachanov bloodline has to continue with her no matter what, will Morphin be pressured by his family [[MaritalRapeLicense into impregnating her anyway]] "for the future of the Roachanov dynasty"?
*** With other members of the Roachanov royal family having similar inbreeding-related defects, it is very likely that there have been previous family members, and possibly even other royal heirs, who also suffered from mental disabilities. Have any of them been pressured, coerced, or outright forced into having sex with whatever partner their family chooses for them in order to continue the bloodline?
*** Assuming Pupa can even conceive and carry a pregnancy to term, ''how high'' is the likelihood that a child of two closely related individuals, one mentally impaired and both severely deformed from centuries of inbreeding, would themselves inherit their parents' defects? (Let's just say "very".)
* FridgeSadness: Why does Chrysalis keep her distance from Pupa and bury herself in her work? She's lost so many children already, it's likely that she's (subconsciously or otherwise) afraid of getting attached to Pupa and then losing her too. Not to mention Pupa's many illnesses mean that her dying early is a strong possibility.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** One, it is very unlikely that an adult Pupa would even have the ability to understand the concept of sex, much less consent to it. If Pupa can't consent to sex, but the Roachanov bloodline has to continue with her no matter what, will Morphin be pressured by his family [[MaritalRapeLicense into impregnating her anyway]] "for the future of the Roachanov dynasty"?
*** Two, with other members of the Roachanov royal family having similar inbreeding-related defects, it is very likely that there have been previous family members, and possibly even other royal heirs, who also suffered from mental disabilities. Have any of them been pressured, coerced, or outright forced into having sex with whatever partner their family chooses for them in order to continue the bloodline?
*** Three, assuming Pupa can even carry a pregnancy to term, ''how high'' is the likelihood that a child of two closely related individuals, one mentally impaired and both severely deformed from centuries of inbreeding, would themselves inherit their parents' defects? (Let's just say "very".)

to:

*** One, it It is very unlikely that an adult Pupa would even have the ability to understand the concept of sex, much less consent to it. If Pupa can't consent to sex, but the Roachanov bloodline has to continue with her no matter what, will Morphin be pressured by his family [[MaritalRapeLicense into impregnating her anyway]] "for the future of the Roachanov dynasty"?
*** Two, with With other members of the Roachanov royal family having similar inbreeding-related defects, it is very likely that there have been previous family members, and possibly even other royal heirs, who also suffered from mental disabilities. Have any of them been pressured, coerced, or outright forced into having sex with whatever partner their family chooses for them in order to continue the bloodline?
*** Three, assuming Assuming Pupa can even conceive and carry a pregnancy to term, ''how high'' is the likelihood that a child of two closely related individuals, one mentally impaired and both severely deformed from centuries of inbreeding, would themselves inherit their parents' defects? (Let's just say "very".)

Added: 331

Removed: 347

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** More like Fridge Sadness, but why does Chrysalis keep her distance from Pupa and bury herself in her work? She's lost so many children already, it's likely that she's (subconsciously or otherwise) afraid of getting attached to Pupa and then losing her too. Not to mention Pupa's many illnesses mean that her dying early is a strong possibility.


Added DiffLines:

* FridgeSadness: Why does Chrysalis keep her distance from Pupa and bury herself in her work? She's lost so many children already, it's likely that she's (subconsciously or otherwise) afraid of getting attached to Pupa and then losing her too. Not to mention Pupa's many illnesses mean that her dying early is a strong possibility.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Uncanny Valley is IUEO now and the subjective version has been split; cleaning up misuse and ZCE in the process


* UncannyValley: Anychangeling can tell Prince Morphin is a mean piece of work just by looking at him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie: [[BreakTheCutie Princess Pupa.]]

to:

* TheWoobie: [[BreakTheCutie Princess Pupa.]]Pupa]] is a mentally and physically disabled filly who just wants her mother's love.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye as her husband hitting her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from, not to mention that his mother Danauria uses the same method of discipline on him. Children are more observant than adults often realize...

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her him away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye as her husband hitting her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from, not to mention that his mother Danauria uses the same method of discipline on him. Children are more observant than adults often realize...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The anecdote about the servant's husband hitting her, even though it was made up to avoid explaining that Pupa accidentally kicked her in the face for tying her obi too tightly, also implies that DomesticAbuse might be normalized in the Changeling Kingdom, given that nochangeling seems disturbed by the explanation.

to:

*** The anecdote about the servant's husband hitting her, even though it was made up to avoid explaining that Pupa accidentally kicked her in the face for tying her obi too tightly, also implies that DomesticAbuse might be normalized considered normal in the Changeling Kingdom, changeling society, given that nochangeling seems disturbed by the explanation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The anecdote about the servant's husband hitting her, even though it was made up to avoid explaining that Pupa accidentally kicked her in the face for tying her obi too tightly, also implies that DomesticAbuse is normalized in this setting, given that nobody seems disturbed by the explanation.

to:

*** The anecdote about the servant's husband hitting her, even though it was made up to avoid explaining that Pupa accidentally kicked her in the face for tying her obi too tightly, also implies that DomesticAbuse is might be normalized in this setting, the Changeling Kingdom, given that nobody nochangeling seems disturbed by the explanation.

Added: 298

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband hit her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from, not to mention that his mother Danauria uses the same method of discipline on him. Children are more observant than adults often realize...

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying as her husband hit hitting her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from, not to mention that his mother Danauria uses the same method of discipline on him. Children are more observant than adults often realize...realize...
*** The anecdote about the servant's husband hitting her, even though it was made up to avoid explaining that Pupa accidentally kicked her in the face for tying her obi too tightly, also implies that DomesticAbuse is normalized in this setting, given that nobody seems disturbed by the explanation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband hit her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from. Children are more observant than adults often realize...

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband hit her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from.from, not to mention that his mother Danauria uses the same method of discipline on him. Children are more observant than adults often realize...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband hit her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from.

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband hit her for putting on a dress he didn't like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from. Children are more observant than adults often realize...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband didn't like the way she dressed and hit her, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from.

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband hit her for putting on a dress he didn't like the way she dressed and hit her, like, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband didn't like the way she dressed and hit her, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. Not to mention that Morphin's mother Danauria punishes him for hitting Pupa...by hitting him.

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband didn't like the way she dressed and hit her, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. Not to mention that Morphin's mother Danauria punishes him for hitting Pupa...by hitting him. That's probably where Morphin picked it up from.

Added: 270

Changed: 689

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pupa's mental disability means that she will probably never be able to function as well as a normal adult. She is expected to marry her cousin Morphin (who is neurotypical) when she grows up, in order to continue her family's bloodline. This raises several disturbing questions:

to:

** Pupa's playdate with her cousin Morphin goes horribly wrong when he hits her in the face for touching him when she tries to push her away. Although he gets punished for it, the story shows that in changeling society, expressing your displeasure with someone of lower rank by hitting them in the face is normal, such as a servant explaining her black eye by saying her husband didn't like the way she dressed and hit her, or the palace's head groomer hitting her daughter for accidentally cutting the wrong lock off Chrysalis' mane. Not to mention that Morphin's mother Danauria punishes him for hitting Pupa...by hitting him.
** Pupa's mental disability means that she will probably never be able to function as well as a normal adult. She is expected to marry her cousin Morphin (who is neurotypical) when she grows up, in order to continue her family's bloodline. This raises several disturbing questions:

Top