Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / JirelOfJoiry

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


** The DefiledForever trope is also avoided. Jirel isn't married, is said to have had several lovers in the past, and the stories never try to use SlutShaming against her or pain her as any less awesome because of it. At least where Pav and Andred are concerned, their respective chapters make it clear that consent is important and that [[IHaveYouNowMyPretty the way they treat Jirel]] is ''not'' okay.

to:

** The DefiledForever trope is also avoided. Jirel isn't married, is said to have had several lovers in the past, and the stories never try to use SlutShaming against her or pain paint her as any less awesome because of it. At least where Pav and Andred are concerned, their respective chapters make it clear that consent is important and that [[IHaveYouNowMyPretty the way they treat Jirel]] is ''not'' okay.

Added: 4

Changed: 28

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[Administrivia/TropesAreTools However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: OnceOriginalNowCommon: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[Administrivia/TropesAreTools However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.



** The DefiledForever trope is also avoided. Jirel isn't married, is said to have had several lovers in the past, and the stories never try to use SlutShaming against her or pain her as any less awesome because of it. At least where Pav and Andred are concerned, their respective chapters make it clear that consent is important and that [[IHaveYouNowMyPretty the way they treat Jirel]] is ''not'' okay.

to:

** The DefiledForever trope is also avoided. Jirel isn't married, is said to have had several lovers in the past, and the stories never try to use SlutShaming against her or pain her as any less awesome because of it. At least where Pav and Andred are concerned, their respective chapters make it clear that consent is important and that [[IHaveYouNowMyPretty the way they treat Jirel]] is ''not'' okay.okay.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Requires Word Of God confirmation


* AuthorsSavingThrow: Hard to say if it was intentional, but after the QuestionableConsent in the ''Black God'' duology, ''The Dark Land'' and ''Hellsgarde'' both have Jirel set clear boundries and treat the villains' sexual assaults as inherently heinous acts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut


* FoeYay: Jirel has had this with quite a few of her adversaries.
** Her "relationship" with Guillaume is a rather dark example, as it starts with him forcefully kissing her after conquring her castle, and later has her giving him a KissOfDeath which damns his soul to a realm worse than Hell. (Though she later regrets and undoes this punishment.)
** Jarasme has quite the chemistry with the heroine, with both women being utterly ''obsessed'' with defeating each other. She's quite attractive to boot, and the attention this recieves in the narration almost gives the impression that Jirel is EatingTheEyeCandy.
** Pav and Andred both have quite a thing for Jirel, [[VillainousCrush though this is very one-sided.]]
** Jirel calls Guy of Garlot "pretty" to his face, and may even have been planning to seduce her as part of her plan. [[NotDistractedByTheSexy Guy however shows no interest in her whatsoever.]]
** While it really doesn't have time to go anywhere, Jirel and Northwest Smith develop quite a mutual appreciation for each other during their brief time together. They do however team up pretty early and cease being foes at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
insufficient context.


* TooGoodToLast: Only received half the amount of stories her Northwest Smith tales got, and there's just enough material to give the character some personality and a definitive style.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
boring Invincible Hero is being changed to Invicible Hero per TRS


** Overall, the series strikes a good balance of making Jirel a badass who triumphs at the end, [[EarnYourHappyEnding but only after tons of physical and psycological strain.]] This becomes all the more impressive when you consider how many later FeministFantasy heroines have fallen into the traps of becoming either a FauxActionGirl or a BoringInvincibleHero.

to:

** Overall, the series strikes a good balance of making Jirel a badass who triumphs at the end, [[EarnYourHappyEnding but only after tons of physical and psycological strain.]] This becomes all the more impressive when you consider how many later FeministFantasy heroines have fallen into the traps of becoming either a FauxActionGirl or a BoringInvincibleHero.an InvincibleHero.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[TropesAreNotBad However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[TropesAreNotBad [[Administrivia/TropesAreTools However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NightmareFuel: Being a DarkFantasy taking cues from Creator/HPLovecraft, this naturally pops up from time to time. When it happens... let's just say it lives up to [[SurrealHorror the "weird" part]] of WeirdFiction.

to:

* NightmareFuel: Being a DarkFantasy taking cues from Creator/HPLovecraft, this naturally pops up from time to time. When it happens... let's just say it lives up to [[SurrealHorror the "weird" part]] of WeirdFiction.weird fiction.

Added: 981

Changed: 368

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityLockout: ''Jirel Meets Magic'' features a CallBack or two to ''Black God's Kiss'', but -- unlike ''Black God's Shadow'' -- it doesn't explain the events of that story at all, leaving any reader who started here [[note]] For unknown reasons, at least one collection ''did'' in fact start with ''Jirel Meets Magic'' [[/note]] in the dark.

to:

* ContinuityLockout: ''Jirel Meets Magic'' features a CallBack or two to ''Black God's Kiss'', but -- unlike ''Black God's Shadow'' -- it doesn't explain the events of that story at all, leaving any reader who started began here [[note]] For unknown reasons, at least one collection ''did'' in fact start with ''Jirel Meets Magic'' [[/note]] in the dark.



* NightmareFuel: Being a DarkFantasy taking cues from Creator/HPLovecraft, this naturally pops up from time to time. When it happens... let's just say it lives up to [[SurrealHorror the "weird" part]] of WeirdFiction.



* ValuesResonance: Overall, the series strikes a good balance of making Jirel a badass who triumphs at the end, [[EarnYourHappyEnding but only after tons of physical and psycological strain.]] This becomes all the more impressive when you consider how many later FeministFantasy heroines have fallen into the traps of becoming either a FauxActionGirl or a BoringInvincibleHero.

to:

* ValuesResonance: ValuesResonance:
**
Overall, the series strikes a good balance of making Jirel a badass who triumphs at the end, [[EarnYourHappyEnding but only after tons of physical and psycological strain.]] This becomes all the more impressive when you consider how many later FeministFantasy heroines have fallen into the traps of becoming either a FauxActionGirl or a BoringInvincibleHero.BoringInvincibleHero.
** The DefiledForever trope is also avoided. Jirel isn't married, is said to have had several lovers in the past, and the stories never try to use SlutShaming against her or pain her as any less awesome because of it. At least where Pav and Andred are concerned, their respective chapters make it clear that consent is important and that [[IHaveYouNowMyPretty the way they treat Jirel]] is ''not'' okay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooGoodToLast: Only received half the amount of stories her Northwest Smith tales got, and there's just enough material to give the character some personality and a definitive style.

to:

* TooGoodToLast: Only received half the amount of stories her Northwest Smith tales got, and there's just enough material to give the character some personality and a definitive style.style.
* ValuesResonance: Overall, the series strikes a good balance of making Jirel a badass who triumphs at the end, [[EarnYourHappyEnding but only after tons of physical and psycological strain.]] This becomes all the more impressive when you consider how many later FeministFantasy heroines have fallen into the traps of becoming either a FauxActionGirl or a BoringInvincibleHero.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityLockout: ''Jirel Meets Magic'' features a CallBack or two to ''Black God's Kiss'', but -- unlike ''Black God's Shadow'' -- it doesn't explain the events of that story at all, leaving any reader who started here [[note]] For unknown reasons, at least one collection ''did'' in fact include ''Jirel Meets Magic'' first [[/note]] in the dark.

to:

* ContinuityLockout: ''Jirel Meets Magic'' features a CallBack or two to ''Black God's Kiss'', but -- unlike ''Black God's Shadow'' -- it doesn't explain the events of that story at all, leaving any reader who started here [[note]] For unknown reasons, at least one collection ''did'' in fact include start with ''Jirel Meets Magic'' first [[/note]] in the dark.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContinuityLockout: ''Jirel Meets Magic'' features a CallBack or two to ''Black God's Kiss'', but -- unlike ''Black God's Shadow'' -- it doesn't explain the events of that story at all, leaving any reader who started here [[note]] For unknown reasons, at least one collection ''did'' in fact include ''Jirel Meets Magic'' first [[/note]] in the dark.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Hard to say if it was intentional, but after the QuestionableConsent in the ''Black God'' duology, ''The Dark Land'' and ''Hellsgarde'' both have Jirel set clear boundries and treat the villains' sexual assaults as inherently heinous acts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[TropesAreNnotBad However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[TropesAreNnotBad [[TropesAreNotBad However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.

Added: 2178

Changed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FoeYay: Jarasme has quite the chemistry with the heroine, and she's quite attractive to boot.

to:

* FoeYay: Jirel has had this with quite a few of her adversaries.
** Her "relationship" with Guillaume is a rather dark example, as it starts with him forcefully kissing her after conquring her castle, and later has her giving him a KissOfDeath which damns his soul to a realm worse than Hell. (Though she later regrets and undoes this punishment.)
**
Jarasme has quite the chemistry with the heroine, and she's with both women being utterly ''obsessed'' with defeating each other. She's quite attractive to boot.boot, and the attention this recieves in the narration almost gives the impression that Jirel is EatingTheEyeCandy.
** Pav and Andred both have quite a thing for Jirel, [[VillainousCrush though this is very one-sided.]]
** Jirel calls Guy of Garlot "pretty" to his face, and may even have been planning to seduce her as part of her plan. [[NotDistractedByTheSexy Guy however shows no interest in her whatsoever.]]
** While it really doesn't have time to go anywhere, Jirel and Northwest Smith develop quite a mutual appreciation for each other during their brief time together. They do however team up pretty early and cease being foes at all.
* ItsTheSameNowItSucks: "Sucks" may be a bit harsh, but the series has been criticized for getting quite formulatic at times, which may a reason for its' relatively short length.
* JerkassHasAPoint: Jirel seemingly TookALevelInJerkass at some point before her last story, which has her [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech chew out her guards for their cowardice early on.]] Though given how [[TheGuardsMustBeCrazy unhelpful]] they've been throughout the series, her frustration is pretty understandable.
* {{Narm}}: The AmbiguouslyBrown Guy of Garlot being referred to as "Black Guy", given that "guy" has now exclusively taken on a meaning of being a casual way of saying "man."
* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: It can be hard for modern readers to really appreciate how novel the series was at the time, given that the ActionGirl has become such an innate part of the genre that most fantasy games lets the player [[PurelyAestheticGender outright choose the gender of their protagonist.]] [[TropesAreNnotBad However,]] while the stories may come across as somewhat {{Troperiffic}} today, they are still considered ''good'' stories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FoeYay: Jarasme has quite the chemistry with the heroine, and she's quite attractive to boot.
* TooGoodToLast: Only received half the amount of stories her Northwest Smith tales got, and there's just enough material to give the character some personality and a definitive style.

Top