Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / InhumansVsXMen

Go To



** After Ms. Marvel and the others Nuhumans others learned that the X-Men were fighting to prevent the extinction of their species and STILL wonder who the good guys were, many people drew comparisons with [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU this scene]].

to:

** After Ms. Marvel and the others other Nuhumans others learned that the X-Men were fighting to prevent the extinction of their species and STILL wonder who the good guys were, many people drew comparisons with [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU this scene]].



** Except this ignores that the inhumans have been well aware of terrigen's effect on non-inhumans, at the least since post House of M. Any ignorance to the public threat of terrigen is a retcon. Not to mention the actually dubious acts of inhumans, such as setting flase flag operations to garner public sympathy using well known militant mutants. Also, Black Bolt lost his marriage and throne but seems none worse for wear running a night club with no further punishments. They may not be ''actively'' malicious but at the least the inhumans are being actively ''irresponsible'' with regard to how their actions impact non-Inhumans, which isn't really out of character for them.

to:

** Except this ignores that the inhumans have been well aware of terrigen's effect on non-inhumans, at the least since post House of M. Any ignorance to the public threat of terrigen is a retcon. Not to mention the actually dubious acts of inhumans, such as setting flase false flag operations to garner public sympathy using well known militant mutants. Also, Black Bolt lost his marriage and throne but seems none worse for wear running a night club with no further punishments. They may not be ''actively'' malicious but at the least the inhumans are being actively ''irresponsible'' with regard to how their actions impact non-Inhumans, which isn't really out of character for them.


* BaseBreakingCharacter: [[spoiler:Emma Frost post-FaceHeelTurn. Many believe that this is just the culmination of a a long line of bad stories for Emma and destroying a perfectly awesome character. However, others believe that Emma was never as reformed as Emma fans have made her out to be and her becoming evil again is something many fans feel that she's always been heading back to.]]

to:

* BaseBreakingCharacter: [[spoiler:Emma Frost post-FaceHeelTurn. Many believe that this is just the culmination of a a long line of bad stories for Emma and destroying a perfectly awesome character. However, others believe that Emma was never as reformed as Emma fans have made her out to be and her becoming evil again is something many fans feel that she's always been heading back to.]]

Added DiffLines:

** Except this ignores that the inhumans have been well aware of terrigen's effect on non-inhumans, at the least since post House of M. Any ignorance to the public threat of terrigen is a retcon. Not to mention the actually dubious acts of inhumans, such as setting flase flag operations to garner public sympathy using well known militant mutants. Also, Black Bolt lost his marriage and throne but seems none worse for wear running a night club with no further punishments. They may not be ''actively'' malicious but at the least the inhumans are being actively ''irresponsible'' with regard to how their actions impact non-Inhumans, which isn't really out of character for them.


* FanonDiscontinuity: How a bunch of people felt about Emma's FaceHeelTurn following these events. That the one other instance of Emma wearing the infamous outfit seen at the end of the even was a never released cover for ComicBook/SecretEmpire and that Emma is wearing her white motiff outfits post-Secret Empire makes people feel it even falls under CanonDiscontinuity.

to:

* FanonDiscontinuity: How a bunch of people felt about Emma's FaceHeelTurn following these events. That the one other instance of Emma wearing the infamous outfit seen at the end of the even event was a never released never-released cover for ComicBook/SecretEmpire and that Emma is wearing her white motiff motif outfits post-Secret Empire makes people feel it even falls under CanonDiscontinuity.


** Marvel promoting the [=ResurreXion=] mini-event before the event even started. [=ResurreXion=] will see the X-Men getting a total revamp and bring the extinction threats to an end and the X-Men will concentrate on being heroes. This announcement has been met with much joy from X-Men fans, seeing how the franchise has been dealing with extinction level events and group in-fighting for more than 10 years now since the ComicBook/HouseOfM.

to:

** Marvel promoting the [=ResurreXion=] mini-event before the event even started. [=ResurreXion=] will see started, which saw the X-Men getting books get a total revamp and bring brought the extinction threats to an end and the X-Men will concentrate on being heroes.end. This announcement has been met with much joy from X-Men fans, seeing how the franchise has been dealing with extinction level events and group in-fighting for more than 10 years now since the ComicBook/HouseOfM.


* FanonDiscontinuity: How a bunch of people feel about Emma's FaceHeelTurn following these events. That the one other instance of Emma wearing the infamous outfit seen at the end of the even was a never released cover for ComicBook/SecretEmpire and that Emma is wearing her white motiff outfits following Secret Empire makes people feel it even falls under CanonDiscontinuity.

to:

* FanonDiscontinuity: How a bunch of people feel felt about Emma's FaceHeelTurn following these events. That the one other instance of Emma wearing the infamous outfit seen at the end of the even was a never released cover for ComicBook/SecretEmpire and that Emma is wearing her white motiff outfits following Secret post-Secret Empire makes people feel it even falls under CanonDiscontinuity.

Added DiffLines:

* FanonDiscontinuity: How a bunch of people feel about Emma's FaceHeelTurn following these events. That the one other instance of Emma wearing the infamous outfit seen at the end of the even was a never released cover for ComicBook/SecretEmpire and that Emma is wearing her white motiff outfits following Secret Empire makes people feel it even falls under CanonDiscontinuity.


** The X-Men, while what's happening is clearly bad for them there's the fact that they didn't share this knowledge with the Inhumans, nor even consider it before attacking,and there's the fact the X-Men put the Royal family in [[EldritchLocation Limbo]] as a way of "safely" detaining them. Though considering how the Inhumans reacted last time someone meddled with a Terrigen cloud makes it more understandable why the X-Men did not bother sharing this knowledge with the Inhumans

to:

** The X-Men, while what's happening is clearly bad for them there's the fact that they didn't share this knowledge with the Inhumans, nor even consider it before attacking,and there's the fact the X-Men put the Royal family in [[EldritchLocation Limbo]] as a way of "safely" detaining them. Though considering how the Inhumans reacted [[ComicBook/DeathOfX last time time]] someone meddled with a Terrigen cloud makes it more understandable why the X-Men did not bother sharing this knowledge with the Inhumans


** The X-Men, while what's happening is clearly bad for them there's the fact that they didn't share this knowledge with the Inhumans, nor even consider it before attacking,and there's the fact the X-Men put the Royal family in [[EldritchLocation Limbo]] as a way of "safely" detaining them.

to:

** The X-Men, while what's happening is clearly bad for them there's the fact that they didn't share this knowledge with the Inhumans, nor even consider it before attacking,and there's the fact the X-Men put the Royal family in [[EldritchLocation Limbo]] as a way of "safely" detaining them. Though considering how the Inhumans reacted last time someone meddled with a Terrigen cloud makes it more understandable why the X-Men did not bother sharing this knowledge with the Inhumans


* AssPull: The very try of making this a balanced conflicted feels incredibly forced, as the Inhumans ''did'' know that the Terrigen was fatal to the mutants. Beast had been working with them on a solution for months. That they act this surprised now makes no sense.

to:

* AssPull: The very try attempt of making this a balanced conflicted feels incredibly forced, as the Inhumans ''did'' know that the Terrigen was fatal to the mutants. Beast had been working with them on a solution for months. That they act this surprised now makes no sense.

Added DiffLines:

* AssPull: The very try of making this a balanced conflicted feels incredibly forced, as the Inhumans ''did'' know that the Terrigen was fatal to the mutants. Beast had been working with them on a solution for months. That they act this surprised now makes no sense.

Added DiffLines:

*** It had previously been revealed in ''All-New Inhumans'' that there was another Inhuman settlement on Earth, known as Utolan, which possessed ready access to the more controllable form of Terrigen Mist. This means the destruction of the cloud ''wouldn't'' mean the end of all Terrigenesis on the planet, but none of the Inhumans actually acknowledge this, seeing the cloud as the only way to create new Inhumans.


** After Ms. Marvel and the others Nuhumans others learned that the X-Men were fighting to prevent the extinction of their species and still provide to wonder who the good guys were, many people drew comparisons with [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU this scene]].

to:

** After Ms. Marvel and the others Nuhumans others learned that the X-Men were fighting to prevent the extinction of their species and still provide to STILL wonder who the good guys were, many people drew comparisons with [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU this scene]].


** After Ms. Marvel and the others Nuhumans others learned that the X-Men were fighting to prevent the extinction of their species and still provide to wonder who the good guys were, many people drew comparisons with [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU this scene]].



* {{Narm}}: After the nuhumans learn that the mists are going to make the planet toxic to mutantkind, and that the X-Men are fighting to stop that from happening, a horrified Ms. marvel asks 'Who are the good guys?' When the answer should be pretty obvious, and it comes across as another failed attempt by Marvel to create GrayAndGrayMorality.

to:

* {{Narm}}: After the nuhumans learn that the mists are going to make the planet toxic to mutantkind, and that the X-Men are fighting to stop that from happening, a horrified Ms. marvel Marvel asks 'Who are the good guys?' When the answer should be pretty obvious, and it comes across as another failed attempt by Marvel to create GrayAndGrayMorality.


** O5!Iceman was seen as this by some people. While most agree a teenager falling in love for the first time while coming to grips with their newly discovered sexuality is a very hard thing and would do and say some dumb things, him offering to betray the X-Men for his Inhuman boyfriend ([[Anvilicious named Romeo]]) while also calling Cyclops a monster long after Cyclops' alleged MoralEventHorizon turned out to [[InformedWrongness barely even qualify as rude]] struck a cord with some people.

to:

** O5!Iceman was seen as this by some people. While most agree a teenager falling in love for the first time while coming to grips with their newly discovered sexuality is a very hard thing and would do and say some dumb things, him offering to betray the X-Men for his Inhuman boyfriend ([[Anvilicious named Romeo]]) [[note]]The very subtly-named Romeo[[/note]] while also calling Cyclops a monster long after Cyclops' alleged MoralEventHorizon turned out to [[InformedWrongness barely even qualify as rude]] struck a cord with some people.

Showing 15 edit(s) of 137

Top