Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / EdisonsConquestOfMars

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: If the Martians didn't already cross this in Literature/WarOfTheWorlds, one of the first things we are told in the book is that the surviving invaders blew up the entirety of New York City, killing tens of thousands of people in the process, to get the necessary amount of propulsion to returm home in their ships.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: If the Martians didn't already cross this in Literature/WarOfTheWorlds, one of the first things we are told in the book is that the surviving invaders blew up the entirety of New York City, killing tens of thousands of people in the process, to get the necessary amount of propulsion to returm return home in their ships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The book treats genocide as something regrettable and horrible ''even when done out of desperation, as a last resort''. Considering the time period in which it was written, this is remarkably forward-thinking. The fact that the book treats this outcome not as triumph, but as a tragedy, provides a refreshing contrast to the infamous genocides that would follow not even 50 years after this book's publishing.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: ''Animation/WarOfTheWordsGoliath'' feels very much like an InterQuel between ''War of the Worlds'' and this book. OneWorldOrder in 1914? Check. Reverse-engineered martian goodies? Check. Martian invasion of America? Check. Earth wants to invade Mars right on back? Check.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: ''Animation/WarOfTheWordsGoliath'' ''Animation/WarOfTheWorldsGoliath'' feels very much like an InterQuel between ''War of the Worlds'' and this book. OneWorldOrder in 1914? Check. Reverse-engineered martian goodies? Check. Martian invasion of America? Check. Earth wants to invade Mars right on back? Check.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: ''Animation/WarOfTheWordsGoliath'' feels very much like an InterQuel between ''War of the Worlds'' and this book. OneWorldOrder in 1914? Check. Reverse-engineered martian goodies? Check. Martian invasion of America? Check. Earth wants to invade Mars right on back? Check.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fanon}}: Some readers have theorised that it wasn't actually Edison, but rather his rival UsefulNotes/NikolaTesla who invented the Disintegrator used to combat the Martians. Edison had a self-admitted tendency of stealing other people's work, and such a device seems more like Tesla's style. (He did believe in aliens, and he ''did'' try to build a DeathRay in RealLife (using electrified mercury droplets and a sprayer) - though as far as we know he never made it work.)

to:

* {{Fanon}}: Some readers have theorised that it wasn't actually Edison, but rather his rival UsefulNotes/NikolaTesla who invented the Disintegrator used to combat the Martians. Edison had a self-admitted tendency of stealing other people's work, and such a device seems more like Tesla's style. (He did believe in aliens, and he ''did'' try to build a DeathRay in RealLife (using using electrified mercury droplets and a sprayer) high-pressure aerosol sprayer - though as far as we know he never made it work.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fanon}}: Some readers have theorised that it wasn't actually Edison, but rather his rival UsefulNotes/NikolaTesla who invented the Disintegrator used to combat the Martians. Edison had a self-admitted tendency of stealing other people's work, and such a device seems more like Tesla's style. (He did believe in aliens, and he ''did'' try to build a DeathRay in RealLife - though as far as we know he never made it work.)

to:

* {{Fanon}}: Some readers have theorised that it wasn't actually Edison, but rather his rival UsefulNotes/NikolaTesla who invented the Disintegrator used to combat the Martians. Edison had a self-admitted tendency of stealing other people's work, and such a device seems more like Tesla's style. (He did believe in aliens, and he ''did'' try to build a DeathRay in RealLife (using electrified mercury droplets and a sprayer) - though as far as we know he never made it work.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While it becomes a bit of a BrokenAesop later, the first chapters has all surviving nations declaring peace on Earth ''[[HeartwarmingMoments and explicably ending all discrimination based on race and religion!]]'' [[OlderthanTheyThink Yes, this was written in 1898.]]

to:

** While it becomes a bit of a BrokenAesop later, the first chapters has all surviving nations declaring peace on Earth ''[[HeartwarmingMoments ''[[SugarWiki/HeartwarmingMoments and explicably ending all discrimination based on race and religion!]]'' [[OlderthanTheyThink Yes, this was written in 1898.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a trope


* JustForFun/XMeetsY: Film/IndependenceDay [[IndependenceDayResurgence and its' sequal]] meets Film/StarshipTroopers... as a nineteenth century RealPersonFic.

Added: 432

Changed: 268

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from main page


* ValuesResonance: While it becomes a bit of a BrokenAesop later, the first chapters has all surviving nations declaring peace on Earth ''[[HeartwarmingMoments and explicably ending all discrimination based on race and religion!]]'' [[OlderthanTheyThink Yes, this was written in 1898.]]

to:

* ValuesResonance: ValuesResonance:
**
While it becomes a bit of a BrokenAesop later, the first chapters has all surviving nations declaring peace on Earth ''[[HeartwarmingMoments and explicably ending all discrimination based on race and religion!]]'' [[OlderthanTheyThink Yes, this was written in 1898.]]



--> "It gives me much pleasure," he said, "to offer, in the name of the nations of the Old World, this tribute of our admiration for, and our confidence in, the genius of the New World. Perhaps on such an occasion as this, when all racial differences and prejudices ought to be, and are, buried and forgotten, I should not recall anything that might revive them; yet I cannot refrain from expressing my happiness in knowing that the champion who is to achieve the salvation of the earth has come forth from the bosom of the Anglo-Saxon race."

to:

--> ---> "It gives me much pleasure," he said, "to offer, in the name of the nations of the Old World, this tribute of our admiration for, and our confidence in, the genius of the New World. Perhaps on such an occasion as this, when all racial differences and prejudices ought to be, and are, buried and forgotten, I should not recall anything that might revive them; yet I cannot refrain from expressing my happiness in knowing that the champion who is to achieve the salvation of the earth has come forth from the bosom of the Anglo-Saxon race.""
* JustForFun/XMeetsY: Film/IndependenceDay [[IndependenceDayResurgence and its' sequal]] meets Film/StarshipTroopers... as a nineteenth century RealPersonFic.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV


* AssholeVictim: The Martian Monarch, who is shot dead by Colonel Smith after [[WouldHitAGirl beating down a Martian woman]] for ''[[DisproportionateRetribution accidentally bumping into him!]]'' Ania then claims that he was more responsible for the Martians' atrocities than anyone else, which would make him the ultimate BigBad of both this story and [[Literature/WarOfTheWorlds Well's original novel.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: The Martian Monarch, who is shot dead by Colonel Smith after [[WouldHitAGirl beating down a Martian woman]] for ''[[DisproportionateRetribution accidentally bumped into him!]]'' Ania then claims that he was more responsible for the Martians' atrocities than anyone else, which would make him the ultimate BigBad of both this story and [[Literature/WarOfTheWorlds Well's original novel.]]

to:

* AssholeVictim: The Martian Monarch, who is shot dead by Colonel Smith after [[WouldHitAGirl beating down a Martian woman]] for ''[[DisproportionateRetribution accidentally bumped bumping into him!]]'' Ania then claims that he was more responsible for the Martians' atrocities than anyone else, which would make him the ultimate BigBad of both this story and [[Literature/WarOfTheWorlds Well's original novel.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Fanon}}: Some readers have theorised that it wasn't actually Edison, but rather his rival UsefulNotes/NikolaTesla who invented the Disintegrator used to combat the Martians. Edison had a self-admitted tendency of stealing other people's work, and such a device seems more like Tesla's style. (He did believe in aliens, and he ''did'' try to build a DeathRay in RealLife - though as far as we know he never made it work.)


Added DiffLines:

* MemeticMutation: The story might be responsible for introducing the term "ReverseThePolarity" to the science-fiction genre.

Added: 171

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: The Martian Monarch, who is shot dead by Colonel Smith after [[WouldHitAGirl beating down a Martian woman]] for ''[[DisproportionateRetribution accidentally bumped into him!]]'' Ania then claims that he was more responsible for the Martian's atrocities than anyone else, which would make him the ultimate BigBad of both this story and [[Literature/WarOfTheWorlds Well's original novel.]]

to:

* AssholeVictim: The Martian Monarch, who is shot dead by Colonel Smith after [[WouldHitAGirl beating down a Martian woman]] for ''[[DisproportionateRetribution accidentally bumped into him!]]'' Ania then claims that he was more responsible for the Martian's Martians' atrocities than anyone else, which would make him the ultimate BigBad of both this story and [[Literature/WarOfTheWorlds Well's original novel.]]


Added DiffLines:

** If not the above, then the Martians probably crossed it when they commited genocide on their own slaves for something which wasn't even their fault in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AssholeVictim: The Martian Monarch, who is shot dead by Colonel Smith after [[WouldHitAGirl beating down a Martian woman]] for ''[[DisproportionateRetribution accidentally bumped into him!]]'' Ania then claims that he was more responsible for the Martian's atrocities than anyone else, which would make him the ultimate BigBad of both this story and [[Literature/WarOfTheWorlds Well's original novel.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: If the Martians didn't already cross this in Literature/WarOfTheWorlds, one of the first things we are told is that the surviving invaders blew up the entirety of New York City, killing tens of thousands of people in the process, to get the necessary amount of propulsion to returm home in their ships.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: If the Martians didn't already cross this in Literature/WarOfTheWorlds, one of the first things we are told in the book is that the surviving invaders blew up the entirety of New York City, killing tens of thousands of people in the process, to get the necessary amount of propulsion to returm home in their ships.

Added: 1716

Changed: 165

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SoBadItsGood: Some readers enjoy the book simply because of how ''[[CrackFic insane]]'' it is.

to:

** It doesn't help that the humans also commit genocide to win the war, even if it's a last resort which they ''do'' feel bad about.
* MoralEventHorizon: If the Martians didn't already cross this in Literature/WarOfTheWorlds, one of the first things we are told is that the surviving invaders blew up the entirety of New York City, killing tens of thousands of people in the process, to get the necessary amount of propulsion to returm home in their ships.
* SoBadItsGood: Some readers enjoy the book simply because of how ''[[CrackFic insane]]'' it is.is.
* ValuesDissonance: Edison's army consists of 2000 of the brightest people on the planet. Naturally, all of them are male. (Though they are joined by Aina - a female SixthRanger - later, at which point it merely becomes a very extreme example of TheSmurfettePrinciple.)
* ValuesResonance: While it becomes a bit of a BrokenAesop later, the first chapters has all surviving nations declaring peace on Earth ''[[HeartwarmingMoments and explicably ending all discrimination based on race and religion!]]'' [[OlderthanTheyThink Yes, this was written in 1898.]]
** There is also the Prince of Wales, who ''does'' praise the Anglo-Saxons of America (for being, basically, the decendants of Britain) but does everything he can to not talk down to any other people.
--> "It gives me much pleasure," he said, "to offer, in the name of the nations of the Old World, this tribute of our admiration for, and our confidence in, the genius of the New World. Perhaps on such an occasion as this, when all racial differences and prejudices ought to be, and are, buried and forgotten, I should not recall anything that might revive them; yet I cannot refrain from expressing my happiness in knowing that the champion who is to achieve the salvation of the earth has come forth from the bosom of the Anglo-Saxon race."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: This story postulates that human civilisation orginated with an aryan master race. Back then, this was considered a plausible scientific theory, and the story otherwise has an anti-racist message. However, it can be difficult for modern readers to not cringe at this, as it isn't just a case of DatedHistory, but also disturbingly similar to claims made by the Nazis to justify their own racist beliefs.
* SoBadItsGood: Some readers enjoy the book simply because of how ''[[CrackFic insane]]'' it is.

Top