Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Earthlings

Go To



* CriticalResearchFailure: [https://web.archive.org/web/20201104185217/https://the-unpopular-opinions.tumblr.com/post/81308663040/this-is-an-opinion-brought-to-you-by-a-rancher This Tumblr post]] from a rancher asserts that the movie tries to extrapolate isolated incidents of animal abuse to farmers and ranchers in general being abusive, while noting that the allegedly-common practices described would be counterproductive in reality.

to:

* CriticalResearchFailure: [https://web.[[https://web.archive.org/web/20201104185217/https://the-unpopular-opinions.tumblr.com/post/81308663040/this-is-an-opinion-brought-to-you-by-a-rancher This Tumblr post]] from a rancher asserts that the movie tries to extrapolate isolated incidents of animal abuse to farmers and ranchers in general being abusive, while noting that the allegedly-common practices described would be counterproductive in reality.


* CriticalResearchFailure: [[http://the-unpopular-opinions.tumblr.com/post/81308663040/this-is-an-opinion-brought-to-you-by-a-rancher This Tumblr post]] from a rancher asserts that the movie tries to extrapolate isolated incidents of animal abuse to farmers and ranchers in general being abusive, while noting that the allegedly-common practices described would be counterproductive in reality.

to:

* CriticalResearchFailure: [[http://the-unpopular-opinions.[https://web.archive.org/web/20201104185217/https://the-unpopular-opinions.tumblr.com/post/81308663040/this-is-an-opinion-brought-to-you-by-a-rancher This Tumblr post]] from a rancher asserts that the movie tries to extrapolate isolated incidents of animal abuse to farmers and ranchers in general being abusive, while noting that the allegedly-common practices described would be counterproductive in reality.

Added DiffLines:

* CriticalResearchFailure: [[http://the-unpopular-opinions.tumblr.com/post/81308663040/this-is-an-opinion-brought-to-you-by-a-rancher This Tumblr post]] from a rancher asserts that the movie tries to extrapolate isolated incidents of animal abuse to farmers and ranchers in general being abusive, while noting that the allegedly-common practices described would be counterproductive in reality.

Added DiffLines:

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Aside from the lack of subtlety in its message, the documentary's [[GodwinsLaw equating modern human society with Nazis]] and farming/eating animals with the Holocaust would be incredibly off-putting (if not downright enraging) to a number of people.


* {{Squick}}: Oh, boy. Where to start...

to:

* {{Anvilicious}}: This is not a subtle movie. Whether it [[SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped works]] or [[{{Narm}} not]] depends on the individual.
* {{Squick}}: Oh, boy. Where to start...The footage of factory farms in general.


* IThoughtThatWas: It has nothing to do with aliens, despite the title.

to:

* IThoughtThatWas: It has nothing to do with aliens, despite the title. ----



** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into selling their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so people can wear their skin.

to:

** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into selling their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so people can wear their skin.skin.
----


** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into selling their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so someone can wear their skin.

to:

** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into selling their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so someone people can wear their skin.


** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into giving their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so someone can wear their skin.

to:

** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into giving selling their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so someone can wear their skin.


* TearJerker: Again, where to start...

to:

* TearJerker: TearJerker:
**
Again, where to start...start...
** It's not just the animals either. It's hard not to feel for the Hindus who were deceived into giving their beloved cows away to what they thought was a happy life. Little did they know the cows would have to endure hell on earth just so someone can wear their skin.

Added DiffLines:

* IThoughtThatWas: It has nothing to do with aliens, despite the title.
* {{Squick}}: Oh, boy. Where to start...
* TearJerker: Again, where to start...

Showing 10 edit(s) of 10

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report