Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Birthright

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Enforced. The splatbooks did not provide character alignments for most of the provided [=NPCs=] characters, stipulating that [=GMs=] should feel free to set the alignments and objectives of the characters in ways that made sense for the campaign.


Added DiffLines:

* CultClassic: ''Birthright'' sold poorly and was ultimately cancelled shortly after the Creator/WizardsOfTheCoast takeover for that reason. However, its unique mechanics and themes encouraging politics, intrigue, and empire-building over hack-and-slash adventuring made it stand out amongst other tabletop RPG settings and it developed a small but loyal following as a result. To this day, there are still regular calls for [=WotC=] to revisit the setting and update the mechanics for the current ruleset.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[NotSoWellIntentionedExtremist Rhuobhe]] loathed how humans once mistreated elven forests and became a notorious hunter of them, earning the name Manslayer for his [[FantasticRacism savage zeal]]. Joining Azrai to [[KillAllHumans exterminate humankind]], Rhuobhe was the only elf who didn't desert him when it became clear what a monster Azrai was. Establishing his own nation, Rhuobhe seeks to kill humans, even helping to manipulate wars to trick them into killing one another. Rhuobhe even declares once he has killed every human man, woman and child, he will move on to goblins as well, even willing to torture and kill any elves who disagree with his genocidal mania, openly stating that he would see every elf dead if it meant humankind's extermination.

to:

** [[NotSoWellIntentionedExtremist Rhuobhe]] loathed how humans once mistreated elven forests and became a notorious hunter of them, earning the name Manslayer for his [[FantasticRacism savage zeal]]. Joining Azrai to [[KillAllHumans exterminate humankind]], Rhuobhe was the only elf who didn't desert him when it became clear what a monster Azrai was. Establishing his own nation, Rhuobhe seeks to kill humans, even helping to manipulate wars to trick them into killing one another. Rhuobhe even declares once he has killed every human man, woman and child, he will move on to goblins as well, even willing to torture and kill any elves who disagree with his genocidal mania, openly stating that he would see every elf dead if it meant humankind's extermination.extermination.
* ScrappyMechanic: The almost-literal SuperpowerLottery that is Bloodline powers. Some of them are so weak they're basically useless, some of them are so powerful they can wreck entire campaigns, some of them are just completely opposed to a given player's class and concept, and they're all on the same table and determined randomly. [[TheCorruption Azrai's powers]] in particular can potentially leave someone unplayable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!The Comic
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not ymmv


* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/IHateFairyland''. They both [[{{Deconstruction}} deconstruct]] the "child lost in magical world" genre by showing the child grown to adulthood in the magical world, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a cartoonish CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.
* InexplicablyIdenticalIndividuals: When Lore was the Chosen One, he looked exactly like Mikey. His [[spoiler:true form is just a white haired Mikey wearing a crown.]]



* SlidingScaleOfVillainEffectiveness: God-King Lore ranks ''High''. High enough that five of the most powerful mages in Terrenos came to the conclusion that keeping up the fight was so pointless that the only alternative was to escape to another world and lock the door behind them. High enough to not just defeat the ChosenOne raised from childhood for the sole purpose of killing him, but [[BreakThemByTalking break his will]] and turn him into [[FallenHero Lore's own assassin]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* WhatAnIdiot: Kylen immediately attacks Mastema after Michael told him that she is a traitor to Lore. He believes the words of an sworn enemy rather than his long standing ally rather than demand an explanation from her. The ensuing confusing ends up leading to [[spoiler:Michael breaking free and killing Kylen, all because of the latter was too much of an hothead]].

to:

* WhatAnIdiot: Kylen immediately attacks Mastema after Michael told him that she is a traitor to Lore. He believes the words of an sworn enemy rather than his long standing ally rather than demand an explanation from her. The ensuing confusing ends up leading to [[spoiler:Michael breaking free and killing Kylen, all because of the latter was too much of an hothead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.

Added DiffLines:

*CompleteMonster: [[GodEmperor God-King Lore]] was once TheChosenOne who saved the world of Terrenos. [[FallenHero Succumbing to lust for power and his own sadism]], Lore [[EvilOverlord enacted a nightmarish dictatorship]] where countless innocents were murdered, tortured, and subjected to further atrocities. Seeking to bring his rule to Earth, Lore seemingly seduces the young hero Mikey to his cause, binding him to a Nevermind spirit that tortures him should he think of betraying Lore while having Mikey hunt down and kill the Mages--including Lore's own daughter Mastema--keeping Terrenos apart from Earth. Keeping Mikey's mentor Rook as a tortured slave for years, Lore gleefully launches an invasion of Earth to massacre most of its population, showing how far a hero can fall.

Added: 1431

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.


* WhatAnIdiot: Kylen immediately attacks Mastema after Michael told him that she is a traitor to Lore. He believes the words of an sworn enemy rather than his long standing ally rather than demand an explanation from her. The ensuing confusing ends up leading to [[spoiler:Michael breaking free and killing Kylen, all because of the latter was too much of an hothead]].

to:

* WhatAnIdiot: Kylen immediately attacks Mastema after Michael told him that she is a traitor to Lore. He believes the words of an sworn enemy rather than his long standing ally rather than demand an explanation from her. The ensuing confusing ends up leading to [[spoiler:Michael breaking free and killing Kylen, all because of the latter was too much of an hothead]].hothead]].

!!Dungeons and Dragons setting
*CompleteMonster:
** [[BastardBastard Raesene]] was once the illegitimate son of the King of Andu. Slowly succumbing to [[AmbitionIsEvil a hunger for power]] and the growing rage inside him, Raesene joined the dark god [[GodOfEvil Azrai]] and massacred his own people. Becoming the Gorgon upon absorbing some of Azrai's essence, he carved out the kingdom the Gorgon's Crown where he focuses on brutal conquest, harvesting bloodlines to kill their users and take them via Bloodtheft. Desiring to [[TakeOverTheWorld take the entire world for his own]], the Gorgon brutally [[RapePillageAndBurn exterminates entire kingdoms]] that resist him.
** [[NotSoWellIntentionedExtremist Rhuobhe]] loathed how humans once mistreated elven forests and became a notorious hunter of them, earning the name Manslayer for his [[FantasticRacism savage zeal]]. Joining Azrai to [[KillAllHumans exterminate humankind]], Rhuobhe was the only elf who didn't desert him when it became clear what a monster Azrai was. Establishing his own nation, Rhuobhe seeks to kill humans, even helping to manipulate wars to trick them into killing one another. Rhuobhe even declares once he has killed every human man, woman and child, he will move on to goblins as well, even willing to torture and kill any elves who disagree with his genocidal mania, openly stating that he would see every elf dead if it meant humankind's extermination.

Added: 754

Changed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, pinning their murders on him just to make him look like a national threat]].

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: MoralEventHorizon:
**
Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, pinning their murders on him just to make him look like a national threat]].threat]].
** [[spoiler:Mastema]] when she reveals her true plans: [[spoiler:Allow both Earth and Terrenos to be destroyed by the unstable barriers so she can create an new world. Despite her [[NotSoWellIntentionedExtremist allegedly noble reasons]] to prevent Lore from invading Earth and turning it into an hell hole like Terrenos, this is proven to be nothing more of an [[ItsAllAboutMe product of her own egomania]] when provided with the [[TakeAThirdOption option to reinforce the barriers between worlds]] instead of having them destroyed and ''she still refuses it'']].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SlidingScaleOfVillainEffectiveness: God-King Lore ranks ''High''. High enough that five of the most powerful mages in Terrenos came to the conclusion that keeping up the fight was so pointless that the only alternative was to escape to another world and lock the door behind them. High enough to not just defeat the ChosenOne raised from childhood for the sole purpose of killing him, but [[BreakThemByTalking break his will]] and turn him into [[FallenHero Lore's own assassin]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/IHateFairyland''. They both [[{{Deconstruction}} deconstruct]] the "child lost in magical world" genre by showing the child grown to adulthood in the magical world, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.

to:

* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/IHateFairyland''. They both [[{{Deconstruction}} deconstruct]] the "child lost in magical world" genre by showing the child grown to adulthood in the magical world, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful cartoonish CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/IHateFairyland''. They're both {{Deconstruction}}s of the "child lost in magical world" genre, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.

to:

* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/IHateFairyland''. They're They both {{Deconstruction}}s of [[{{Deconstruction}} deconstruct]] the "child lost in magical world" genre, genre by showing the child grown to adulthood in the magical world, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/{{IHateFairyland}}''. They're both {{Deconstruction}}s of the "child lost in magical world" genre, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.

to:

* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/{{IHateFairyland}}''.''ComicBook/IHateFairyland''. They're both {{Deconstruction}}s of the "child lost in magical world" genre, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DuelingWorks: Not exactly "duelling" since they're published by the same company, but it makes an interesting companion piece to ''ComicBook/{{IHateFairyland}}''. They're both {{Deconstruction}}s of the "child lost in magical world" genre, they're both violent and gory, and both feature highly morally ambiguous protagonists. However, while ''I Hate Fairyland'' is a BlackComedy set in a colourful CrapsaccharineWorld which the protagonist is trapped in and trying to escape, ''Birthright'' is a serious UrbanFantasy story set on Earth which the protagonist is trying to bring the magical world into.
* InexplicablyIdenticalIndividuals: When Lore was the Chosen One, he looked exactly like Mikey. His [[spoiler:true form is just a white haired Mikey wearing a crown.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TearJerker: The ending of Issue #25 is a crushing DownerEnding since [[spoiler:Mikey's family has turned away from him after learning of his true allegiance to Lore and refused him to go near his newborn daughter, his little brother is kidnapped by TheDragon, one of the mages has gone missing, he is now a wanted terrorist by US authorities for several murders pinned on him by Kylen and the barriers between Earth and Terrenos are so thin that who knows what else will come from the other side]].

to:

* TearJerker: The ending of Issue #25 is a crushing DownerEnding since [[spoiler:Mikey's family has turned away from him after learning of his true allegiance to Lore and refused him to go near his newborn daughter, his little brother is kidnapped by TheDragon, one of the mages has gone missing, he is now a wanted terrorist by US authorities for several murders pinned on him by Kylen and the barriers between Earth and Terrenos are so thin that who knows what else will come from the other side]].side]].
* WhatAnIdiot: Kylen immediately attacks Mastema after Michael told him that she is a traitor to Lore. He believes the words of an sworn enemy rather than his long standing ally rather than demand an explanation from her. The ensuing confusing ends up leading to [[spoiler:Michael breaking free and killing Kylen, all because of the latter was too much of an hothead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Issue #24 has [[spoiler:Kallista the Pale Rider finally being introduced into the narrative after only appearing in flashbacks in the most horrifying manner: after Mikey kills Kylen, the barriers are weakened enough for beings from Terrenos to cross over into Earth and she does so by possessing Kylen's recently deceased body and ''tears it apart to reveal her true self underneath it.'' And to make matters worse, her appearance is nothing short of an HumanoidAbomination worse than Mikey when the Nevermind takes control]].

to:

** Issue #24 has [[spoiler:Kallista the Pale Rider finally being introduced into the narrative after only appearing in flashbacks in the most horrifying manner: after Mikey kills Kylen, the barriers are weakened enough for beings from Terrenos to cross over into Earth and she does so by possessing Kylen's recently deceased body and ''tears it apart to reveal her true self underneath it.'' And to make matters worse, her appearance is nothing short of an HumanoidAbomination worse than Mikey when the Nevermind takes control]].control]].
* TearJerker: The ending of Issue #25 is a crushing DownerEnding since [[spoiler:Mikey's family has turned away from him after learning of his true allegiance to Lore and refused him to go near his newborn daughter, his little brother is kidnapped by TheDragon, one of the mages has gone missing, he is now a wanted terrorist by US authorities for several murders pinned on him by Kylen and the barriers between Earth and Terrenos are so thin that who knows what else will come from the other side]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mastema using her magic to interrogate [[spoiler:Mikey]] in Issue #23 has her twisting and stretching his body apart like rubber.

to:

** Mastema using her magic to interrogate [[spoiler:Mikey]] in Issue #23 has her twisting and stretching his body apart like rubber.rubber.
** Issue #24 has [[spoiler:Kallista the Pale Rider finally being introduced into the narrative after only appearing in flashbacks in the most horrifying manner: after Mikey kills Kylen, the barriers are weakened enough for beings from Terrenos to cross over into Earth and she does so by possessing Kylen's recently deceased body and ''tears it apart to reveal her true self underneath it.'' And to make matters worse, her appearance is nothing short of an HumanoidAbomination worse than Mikey when the Nevermind takes control]].

Added: 392

Changed: 543

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NightmareFuel: God-King Lore's design is extremely disturbing to look at. His face is seemingly flayed and his muscles are ''made out of maggots''.
** The Diviner is a cleansing spirit that twists all life around it with the sole purpose to destroy Lore's demons. The effects can range from individuals being possessed, corpses being reanimated to fight and they will not stop until their enemies are killed.

to:

* NightmareFuel: NightmareFuel:
**
God-King Lore's design is extremely disturbing to look at. His face is seemingly flayed and his muscles are ''made out of maggots''.
maggots''. [[spoiler:Its made less terrible by the fact that is not his true form - he looks like a normal human, and that appearance in question is his GameFace]].
** The Diviner is a cleansing spirit that twists all life around it with the sole purpose to destroy Lore's demons. The effects can range from individuals being possessed, corpses being reanimated to fight and they will not stop until their enemies are killed.killed.
** Mastema using her magic to interrogate [[spoiler:Mikey]] in Issue #23 has her twisting and stretching his body apart like rubber.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: One of the disguised mages from Terrenos crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, pinning their murders on him and making him look like a national threat]].

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: One of the disguised mages from Terrenos Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, pinning their murders on him and making just to make him look like a national threat]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Agent Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, just so their murders are pinned on him, making him look like a national threat and getting bigger forces to bring him down]].

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Agent Kylen One of the disguised mages from Terrenos crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, just so pinning their murders are pinned on him, him and making him look like a national threat and getting bigger forces to bring him down]].threat]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Agent Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, just so their murders are pinned on him.]]

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Agent Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, just so their murders are pinned on him.]]him, making him look like a national threat and getting bigger forces to bring him down]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoralEventHorizon: Agent Kylen crosses it when [[spoiler: he slaughters a whole SWAT team that tried and failed to capture Mike alive, just so their murders are pinned on him.]]
* NightmareFuel: God-King Lore's design is extremely disturbing to look at. His face is seemingly flayed and his muscles are ''made out of maggots''.
** The Diviner is a cleansing spirit that twists all life around it with the sole purpose to destroy Lore's demons. The effects can range from individuals being possessed, corpses being reanimated to fight and they will not stop until their enemies are killed.

Top