Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / HaruhiSuzumiyaMikuruAsahina

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Which means she is also [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Kamina]]'s relative, with LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya being the distant past of TTGL....

to:

* Which means she is also [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Kamina]]'s relative, with LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya Literature/HaruhiSuzumiya being the distant past of TTGL....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wick cleaning


*** Someone with an old-fashioned (and by that I mean almost feudal) and sexually innocent view of the world might. IncestIsRelative after all. (Okay, I just love that trope name).

to:

*** Someone with an old-fashioned (and by that I mean almost feudal) and sexually innocent view of the world might. IncestIsRelative after all. (Okay, I just love that trope name).

Changed: 168

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving from Analysis page



to:

* Maybe that's why she can't interact with Kyon in a sexual way, because future Kyon would be cheated on and Mikuru would be cheating too.



[[WMG:Mikuru is really Kyon's sister via Main/TimeTravel.]]

to:

[[WMG:Mikuru is really Kyon's sister via Main/TimeTravel.TimeTravel.]]



* This theory, unfortunately, is undermined by the vast difference in personalities. Kyon's little sister is, to put it mildly, [[Main/GenkiGirl a little fireball]]. Unless she suffered some dramatic trauma, it seems unlikely that she would grow up into the pathologically timid Mikuru.
** A variation that accounts for this is that ''Mikuru is Kyon's sister from an Main/AlternateUniverse where Kyon died''. Possibly, the presence of Haruhi has prevented it in this timeline; also possibly, she's going to ''cause'' it.

to:

* This theory, unfortunately, is undermined by the vast difference in personalities. Kyon's little sister is, to put it mildly, [[Main/GenkiGirl [[GenkiGirl a little fireball]]. Unless she suffered some dramatic trauma, it seems unlikely that she would grow up into the pathologically timid Mikuru.
** A variation that accounts for this is that ''Mikuru is Kyon's sister from an Main/AlternateUniverse AlternateUniverse where Kyon died''. Possibly, the presence of Haruhi has prevented it in this timeline; also possibly, she's going to ''cause'' it.



*** Someone with an old-fashioned (and by that I mean almost feudal) and sexually innocent view of the world might. Main/IncestIsRelative after all. (Okay, I just love that trope name).

to:

*** Someone with an old-fashioned (and by that I mean almost feudal) and sexually innocent view of the world might. Main/IncestIsRelative IncestIsRelative after all. (Okay, I just love that trope name).



* Jossed. She admits to being conditioned to the point that she physically couldn't say anything she's not supposed to, but at least once in the novels some information gets declassified; Mikuru is actually surprised she can answer the question, but she clearly knew it all along. Also, Future Mikuru comments on how disturbing it is to go back to the past and see all the little differences from how she remembered it; apparently, the entire organisation has Main/RippleEffectProofMemory.

to:

* Jossed. She admits to being conditioned to the point that she physically couldn't say anything she's not supposed to, but at least once in the novels some information gets declassified; Mikuru is actually surprised she can answer the question, but she clearly knew it all along. Also, Future Mikuru comments on how disturbing it is to go back to the past and see all the little differences from how she remembered it; apparently, the entire organisation has Main/RippleEffectProofMemory.
RippleEffectProofMemory.



[[WMG:Asahina (Big) is actually from the same time period as Asahina (Small) because Asahina (Small) decided to stay in the past with the SOS Brigade and thus took [[Main/TheSlowPath The Long Way]] back to her time period.]]

to:

[[WMG:Asahina (Big) is actually from the same time period as Asahina (Small) because Asahina (Small) decided to stay in the past with the SOS Brigade and thus took [[Main/TheSlowPath [[TheSlowPath The Long Way]] back to her time period.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** So [[spoiler: [[EvilCounterpart Ryoko]]]] [[WellIntentionedExtremist is]] [[GoodIsNotNice Uriel]]? Where does Tsuruya fit into all this? She [[OneMarioLimit can't be]] [[Literature/TheBookOfMormon Joseph Smith]], and I don't yet know enough about [[MemeticMutation LOLFANG-tan]]'s business with the SOS Brigade to pinpoint her place in this.

to:

*** So [[spoiler: [[EvilCounterpart Ryoko]]]] [[WellIntentionedExtremist is]] [[GoodIsNotNice Uriel]]? Where does Tsuruya fit into all this? She [[OneMarioLimit [[JustForFun/OneMarioLimit can't be]] [[Literature/TheBookOfMormon Joseph Smith]], and I don't yet know enough about [[MemeticMutation LOLFANG-tan]]'s business with the SOS Brigade to pinpoint her place in this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She [[GettingCrapPastTheRadar got crap past the radar]]. Itsuki can fight celestials, but can't tell the difference between them and a human.

to:

** She [[GettingCrapPastTheRadar got crap past the radar]]. Itsuki can fight celestials, but can't tell the difference between them and a human.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And [[Manga/MahouSenseiNegima Chao Lingshen]] is her best friend or OddCouple roomate, who inexplicably used outdated spells based on [[LanguageOfMagic Latin]] instead of [[LanguageOfMagic Microsoft SQL]]? I want this to be true ''so'' much.

to:

* And [[Manga/MahouSenseiNegima [[Manga/NegimaMagisterNegiMagi Chao Lingshen]] is her best friend or OddCouple roomate, who inexplicably used outdated spells based on [[LanguageOfMagic Latin]] instead of [[LanguageOfMagic Microsoft SQL]]? I want this to be true ''so'' much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Page was cut.


Alas, Kyon's love is to forever go unrequited. Miss Asahina (big) didn't refuse Kyon's kiss because she didn't want to endanger the universe by way of Haruhi's jealousy. It's because she's [[LipstickLesbian just not into that]]. Apparently, all those "cosplay sessions" had an [[RapeIsLove effect]] on her. The penultimate proof is in the above reference to Snow Mountain Syndrome, in which all the other characters have the [[{{doppelganger}} objects of their affection]] show up in their rooms to seduce them, while Haruhi shows up in Mikuru's room.

to:

Alas, Kyon's love is to forever go unrequited. Miss Asahina (big) didn't refuse Kyon's kiss because she didn't want to endanger the universe by way of Haruhi's jealousy. It's because she's [[LipstickLesbian just not into that]]. Apparently, all those "cosplay sessions" had an [[RapeIsLove effect]] effect on her. The penultimate proof is in the above reference to Snow Mountain Syndrome, in which all the other characters have the [[{{doppelganger}} [[{{Doppelganger}} objects of their affection]] show up in their rooms to seduce them, while Haruhi shows up in Mikuru's room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The shared gesture is fairly common, actually, not something specific to Mikuru. For another example, see [[SayonaraZetsubouSensei Chiri's disturbing variation,]] when she tries to become a {{Dojikko}}. There are lots more, but that was the first that came to mind.

to:

** The shared gesture is fairly common, actually, not something specific to Mikuru. For another example, see [[SayonaraZetsubouSensei [[Manga/SayonaraZetsubouSensei Chiri's disturbing variation,]] when she tries to become a {{Dojikko}}. There are lots more, but that was the first that came to mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Wasn't the reason she expected Kyon to know about the mole because [[StableTimeLoop he told her younger self about it]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Mikuru and Kyon have a romantic relationship in the future.]]
There is a lot of evidence to point towards the two having had a relationship at some point in the future. When Asahina the Elder first meets Kyon, she seems surprised that Kyon doesn't remember the star shaped mole on her breast. This alludes that at some point in the future, Kyon sees her breasts suggesting that they had a relationship. Asahina the Elder also gives Kyon the permission to touch her breats, and kiss her past self while sleeping. Her flirtiness implies that they have romantically broken the ice at some point in the future, as she talks to him as if he were a past lover. Throughout the series, there is a lot of romantic chemistry between Kyon and the younger Asahina, further suggesting this as a possibility.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And [[MahouSenseiNegima Chao Lingshen]] is her best friend or OddCouple roomate, who inexplicably used outdated spells based on [[LanguageOfMagic Latin]] instead of [[LanguageOfMagic Microsoft SQL]]? I want this to be true ''so'' much.

to:

* And [[MahouSenseiNegima [[Manga/MahouSenseiNegima Chao Lingshen]] is her best friend or OddCouple roomate, who inexplicably used outdated spells based on [[LanguageOfMagic Latin]] instead of [[LanguageOfMagic Microsoft SQL]]? I want this to be true ''so'' much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Which means she is also [[TengenToppaGurrenLagann Kamina]]'s relative, with LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya being the distant past of TTGL....

to:

* Which means she is also [[TengenToppaGurrenLagann [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Kamina]]'s relative, with LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya being the distant past of TTGL....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


She was just fiddling with some strange alien technology she found one day and accidentally made a time machine out of it.

to:

She was just fiddling with some strange alien technology she found one day and accidentally made a time machine out of it.it.
* Don't you just hate when your just a home microwaving banana's and suddenly you accidentally make a time machine
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Mikuru's spaciness is because of her memory intentionally being "[[QuantumLeap swiss-cheesed]]" to prevent paradox.]] She's the tool of the Future to change the Past. Having her memory change with each change would cause undue stress, so she's intentionally "dumbed down." Note her future self, who is also her Superior, doesn't have this problem in the slightest.

to:

[[WMG:Mikuru's spaciness is because of her memory intentionally being "[[QuantumLeap "[[Series/QuantumLeap swiss-cheesed]]" to prevent paradox.]] She's the tool of the Future to change the Past. Having her memory change with each change would cause undue stress, so she's intentionally "dumbed down." Note her future self, who is also her Superior, doesn't have this problem in the slightest.

Added: 414

Changed: 598

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Offering a counter-argument to one WMG.



to:

* This Troper suspects that they only ''appear'' rare because they have been subjected to intense psychological conditioning not to reveal their true nature to prevent creating paradoxes, and are extensively trained to behave as though they were, in fact, "normal" inhabitants of the era that they are assigned to. (This also explains why Mikuru half-jokingly says that her true age is also "classified information"--that information, too, has been subjected to mental blocks so as not to reveal that Mikuru was trained to act like a native of the late 20th/early 21st century as much as possible.)
** Which, logically, means that future agents probably have intense psychological blocks against "going native" in the times they're assigned to--which is the 'real' reason why Mikuru can't get involved in a romantic/sexual relationship with Kyon, as much as she obviously wants to. It's not just that she fears Haruhi's jealousy, it's also because doing so would cause her to prefer our present to her own time...

Added: 182

Changed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Time travel is so immensely difficult that only a few people can either handle the stress or survive having the TPDD inserted in their brains.
* The faction only picks people who are easily manipulated to do what the faction wants.
* They're rare because few people are so trustworthy as to not break the Time-Space Continuum.


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Except that [[spoiler:she did a similar (albeit sightly different) promise to Kyon: that when the time comes she ''will be the one saving Kyon-kun''. A priomise he knows Mikuru will fulfill.]]

to:

** Except that [[spoiler:she did a similar (albeit sightly different) promise to Kyon: that when the time comes she ''will be the one saving Kyon-kun''. A priomise promise he knows Mikuru will fulfill.]]




to:

** There is a lot of evidence to this not being a throwaway line, too; the books and the anime alike are incredibly meticulous about details; nothing happens or is just said for no real reason. There's always meaning. Absolutely everything happens for a reason. Faeiries are also a lot more morally ambiguous, just like the older Asahina. They're tricksters by nature and often wander into LiteralGenie territory. You can't trust them. It might mean nothing (which is ironic coming off what I just said), but I remember watching the anime (something I just finished doing once more), and every time I do, there's something Asahina does that just seems... off to me. It's something that she does that never, to my recollection, happens again. Ever. It's when Asahina wants to tell Kyon that she's from the future. She suddenly rushes ahead of him and turns to talk to him. What I always find utterly peculiar is that she's suddenly extremely serious in both voice and expression. As far as I remember, at no other time does she ever act or look that serious again. Usually she stumbles over herself trying to ask him to do something for her (such as travel back in time during Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody) or can't articulate it (as in Endless Eight). While it's vital he understand, it's still odd that any other time it's extremely important that Kyon understand something she's never serious again. Did her mask slip?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* I also want to contribute something: Kyon tells Haruhi he has a thing for ponytails, and as pointed out on the Fridge Horror page, Kyon's little sister also wears her hair in a ponytail. Perhaps he has a thing for ponytails because he's attracted to Mikuru, unaware she's his sister, but subconsciously aware of it and so associates ponytails with things he likes on a girl he finds attractive?

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She could just be lying, you know. Trying to make it seem like she comes form a much, much further future than she really does to keep her cover. I genuinely cannot ever see boats going away, because people like cruises and kayaking and fishing for pleasure and for work and other things that involve going on the water. There will always be a market for it, and in accordance to her above-mentioned lacklustre education, I also find it pretty hard to believe that someone living in '''''Japan''''', a bloody '''archipelago''' where seafood is a staple of Japanese diet, wouldn't know the ocean is salty. She's got to be lying.

to:

** She could just be lying, you know. Trying to make it seem like she comes form a much, much further future than she really does to keep her cover. I genuinely cannot ever see boats going away, because people like cruises and kayaking and fishing for pleasure and for work and other things that involve going on the water. There will always be a market for it, and in accordance to her above-mentioned lacklustre education, I also find it pretty hard to believe that someone living in '''''Japan''''', ''Japan'', a bloody '''archipelago''' ''archipelago'' where seafood is a staple of Japanese diet, wouldn't know the ocean is salty. She's got to be lying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** She could just be lying, you know. Trying to make it seem like she comes form a much, much further future than she really does to keep her cover. I genuinely cannot ever see boats going away, because people like cruises and kayaking and fishing for pleasure and for work and other things that involve going on the water. There will always be a market for it, and in accordance to her above-mentioned lacklustre education, I also find it pretty hard to believe that someone living in '''''Japan''''', a bloody '''archipelago''' where seafood is a staple of Japanese diet, wouldn't know the ocean is salty. She's got to be lying.
* I could be wrong, naysayers, but isn't it implied a number of times that nearly all of Mikuru's personality and quirks are ''completely fake'', especially when looking to her future self? She could very well be Kyon's Sister and just doing her best to fake a more sweet and innocent personality to draw attention away from that since Kyon's Sister is much more upbeat and fiery than meek and sweet Mikuru. As to when Mikuru asks if Kyon would have her because she's been defiled, it could just be part of the act, as she knows that since she's a time traveller AND because of Haruhi's feelings for Kyon that there can '''never''' be anything between herself and Kyon. Mikuru has a role to play, after all, for [classified information]. It's possible what she has to do is so very important that she holds more to her duty than anything else, including that Kyon is her older brother. And even so, who she really is is probably and most definitely classified information, especially because of who she's working with.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* they can't travel before a specific day ( Tanabata three years before the start of the series). they can travel to that day and any day after that no matter how far away from it they are (unless there is another limit that hasn't been mentioned) but they can't travel before that day at all (possibly because the world was created on that day). there already is an alien (Yuki) so Haruhi doesn't really need another one but she does need a time traveler which is what Mikuru is for (and we know she is one because she has taken Kyon back in time multiple times).

to:

* they can't travel before a specific day ( Tanabata three years before the start of the series). they can travel to that day and any day after that no matter how far away from it they are (unless there is another limit that hasn't been mentioned) but they can't travel before that day at all (possibly because the world was created on that day). there already is an alien (Yuki) so Haruhi doesn't really need another one but she does need a time traveler which is what Mikuru is for (and we know she is one because she has taken Kyon back in time multiple times).times).

[[WMG: Mikurus time-machine is home-made.]]
She was just fiddling with some strange alien technology she found one day and accidentally made a time machine out of it.

Top