Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ValuesDissonance / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on work content


** Modern audiences will find it pretty strange that everyone (except [[DeanBitterman Mr. Strickland]]) seems generally okay with a teenage boy being friends with an eccentric, reclusive older man. George and Lorraine never make any acknowledgment of Marty hanging out with Doc Brown.
** The fact that the Doc was willing to work with terrorists (albeit to rip them off) is treated ''relatively'' lightly by comparison to how it almost certainly would have been post-9/11. This is jarring to a 21st-century audience. Whilst it comes with predictably brutal consequences ([[spoiler:it gets better]]), demonstrating why exactly messing around with terrorists is a bad idea, Marty seems much more shocked that the time machine is nuclear-powered and the Doc had to (illegally) acquire plutonium to power it than the precise details of how.

to:

** Modern audiences will find it pretty strange that everyone (except [[DeanBitterman Mr. Strickland]]) seems generally okay with a teenage boy being friends with an eccentric, reclusive older man. George and Lorraine never even make any acknowledgment of Marty hanging out with Doc Brown.
** The fact that the Doc was willing to work with terrorists (albeit to rip them off) is treated ''relatively'' lightly by comparison to how it almost certainly would have been post-9/11. This is jarring to a 21st-century audience. Whilst it comes with predictably brutal consequences ([[spoiler:it gets better]]), better thanks to time travel]]), demonstrating why exactly messing around with terrorists is a bad idea, Marty seems much more shocked that the time machine is nuclear-powered and the Doc had to (illegally) acquire plutonium to power it than the precise details of how.



** Also to modern audiences, the implication that Music/ChuckBerry, one of the pioneering African American musicians, was inspired to write one of his most famous songs by hearing a white kid play it seems problematic. Although Marty only knew it because Chuck Berry played it because he still wrote the song in the timeline Marty came from, so it's really a situation of [[StableTimeLoop Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing...]]

to:

** Also to modern audiences, the implication that Music/ChuckBerry, one of the pioneering African American musicians, was inspired to write one of his most famous songs by hearing a white kid play it seems problematic. Although Marty only knew it because Chuck Berry played it because he still wrote the song in the timeline Marty came from, so it's really a situation of [[StableTimeLoop Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing...]]from and since the film doesn't run on StableTimeLoop, that suggests he would still have come up with it on his own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Blacula}}'': Many of the comments regarding the two CampGay characters in the beginning are definitely a product of a less enlightened era. The fact that the cops dismiss their deaths because they are gay is downright offensive to modern viewers.

Added: 276

Changed: 4

Removed: 294

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/IndianaJonesAndTheRaidersOfTheLostArk'': the opening scene of Indy stealing the idol is still iconic, but a 21st century audience is a lot more likely to be uncomfortable with the depiction of Indigenous people as violent savages, and the guy who steals their sacred object as a hero.



* In ''Film/ThePhiladelphiaStory''

to:

* In ''Film/ThePhiladelphiaStory''''Film/ThePhiladelphiaStory'':


Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/RaidersOfTheLostArk'': The opening scene of Indy stealing the idol is still iconic, but a 21st century audience is a lot more likely to be uncomfortable with the depiction of Indigenous people as violent savages, and the guy who steals their sacred object as a hero.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/UnFlic'' ''(A Cop)'' was made in France in 1972. One of Commissioner Coleman's informants is a woman who wears a lot of makeup. He brings her into the station because he's not happy with the quality of her snitching, and she is revealed to be transgender when he tells her (paraphrased) "Get your hair cut and start wearing men's clothes, or I'll charge you with being a transvestite." This is suggestive not just of widely-held prejudices, but widely-held prejudices ''with the force of law''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/MaryPoppins'', being set in TheEdwardianEra, has some DeliberateValuesDissonance, but also a regular example in that Admiral Boom uses the term "Hottentots". This would ''not'' fly today, as that was used to refer to a tribe in Botswana. In the UK, the BBFC re-rated the film to PG in 2024 as a result of this.

to:

* ''Film/MaryPoppins'', being set in TheEdwardianEra, has some DeliberateValuesDissonance, but also a regular example in that Admiral Boom uses the term "Hottentots". "Hottentots", an antiquated slur against the native Khoekhoe of South Africa. This would ''not'' fly today, as that was used to refer to a tribe in Botswana. today for obvious reasons. In the UK, the BBFC re-rated the film to PG in 2024 as despite the word becoming a result of this.CurseOfTheAncients by the 21st century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/MaryPoppins'', being set in TheEdwardianEra, has some DeliberateValuesDissonance, but also a regular example in that Admiral Boom uses the term "Hottentots". This would ''not'' fly today, as that was used to refer to a tribe in Botswana.

to:

* ''Film/MaryPoppins'', being set in TheEdwardianEra, has some DeliberateValuesDissonance, but also a regular example in that Admiral Boom uses the term "Hottentots". This would ''not'' fly today, as that was used to refer to a tribe in Botswana. In the UK, the BBFC re-rated the film to PG in 2024 as a result of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Also to modern audiences, the implication that Music/ChuckBerry was inspired to write his most famous song by hearing a white kid play it ([[NothingButHits Most famous song in *modern times*]] as Berry was an established, popular musician with a history of hit records years before "Johnny B. Goode" was released). Although Marty only knew it because Chuck Berry played it because he still wrote the song in the timeline Marty came from, so it's really a situation of [[StableTimeLoop Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing...]]

to:

** Also to modern audiences, the implication that Music/ChuckBerry Music/ChuckBerry, one of the pioneering African American musicians, was inspired to write one of his most famous song songs by hearing a white kid play it ([[NothingButHits Most famous song in *modern times*]] as Berry was an established, popular musician with a history of hit records years before "Johnny B. Goode" was released).seems problematic. Although Marty only knew it because Chuck Berry played it because he still wrote the song in the timeline Marty came from, so it's really a situation of [[StableTimeLoop Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing Chuck Berry influencing Marty influencing...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected information.


* In America, many people were surprised that the [[Film/FiftyShadesOfGrey film adaptation]] of ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'' didn't get an NC-17 rating right out of the gate given the source material's notorious sexual content. Other countries did give it their maximum ratings, while some either heavily edited the sexual material or [[BannedInChina banned the film outright]]. There was, however, one conspicuous exception: UsefulNotes/{{France}}, where it sailed through with a ''12'' certificate, roughly equivalent to a PG or a PG-13. Moreover, as [[Series/LastWeekTonightWithJohnOliver John Oliver]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9t3TzSnwCn4 noted]], there was controversy within the [[MediaWatchdog National Centre of Cinematography]] (CNC) over this rating... namely, that some thought it was ''too high'', and that it should've been given the all-ages U certificate. Apparently, the CNC thought that the sex scenes were tame, not particularly shocking, and even "schmaltzy" compared to the content of France's own erotic films, with only the BDSM themes pushing it out of all-ages territory.

to:

* In America, many people were surprised that the [[Film/FiftyShadesOfGrey film adaptation]] of ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'' didn't get an NC-17 rating right out of the gate given the source material's notorious sexual content. Other countries did give it their maximum ratings, while some either heavily edited the sexual material or [[BannedInChina banned the film outright]]. There was, however, one conspicuous exception: UsefulNotes/{{France}}, where it sailed through with a ''12'' certificate, roughly equivalent to a PG or a PG-13. Moreover, as [[Series/LastWeekTonightWithJohnOliver John Oliver]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9t3TzSnwCn4 noted]], there was controversy within the [[MediaWatchdog National Centre of Cinematography]] (CNC) over this rating... namely, that some thought it was ''too high'', and that it should've been given the all-ages U TP certificate. Apparently, the CNC thought that the sex scenes were tame, not particularly shocking, and even "schmaltzy" compared to the content of France's own erotic films, with only the BDSM themes pushing it out of all-ages territory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/TwiceRoundTheDaffodils'', Ian gives Nurses Catty and Beamish {{Forceful Kiss}}es with no warning as his tuberculosis makes him very horny. While Chris pulls him off the latter, Ian gets no proper punishment for his actions.

Added: 1791

Changed: 763

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking


* ''Film/{{JFK}}'': The film takes a very Pro-Conspiracy Theory view/attitude towards [[WhoShotJFK the JFK Assassination]]. However, in the decades after the film's release, largely as a result of the rise of the Internet, there was a massive rise in disingenuous & completely false conspiracy theories that proved to be incredibly dangerous for the people they are targeting/blaming. And that's without mentioning [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capitol_attack the infamous 2021 US Capitol Attack]], which was ''fueled'' by conspiracy theories and led (directly or indirectly) to nine deaths, hundreds of injuries, and more than a thousand individual charges. It goes without saying that the film's messages would not sit well with much of today's audiences.

to:

* ''Film/{{JFK}}'': ''Film/{{JFK}}'':
**
The film takes a very Pro-Conspiracy Theory view/attitude towards [[WhoShotJFK the JFK Assassination]]. However, in the decades after the film's release, largely as a result of the rise of the Internet, there was a massive rise in disingenuous & and completely false conspiracy theories that proved to be incredibly dangerous for the people they are targeting/blaming. And that's without mentioning [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_6_United_States_Capitol_attack the infamous 2021 US Capitol Attack]], which was ''fueled'' by conspiracy theories and led (directly or indirectly) to nine deaths, hundreds of injuries, and more than a thousand individual charges. It goes without saying that the film's messages would not sit well with much of today's audiences.audiences.
** In reality, a lot of the specific ideas presented in the film were initially spread by the KGB in the 1960s as a way to undermine the credibility of the U.S. government. The idea of someone taking a Russian disinformation campaign this seriously plays a lot different now, especially given Stone's personal track record of doing just that in other projects like ''The Untold History of the United States'' or ''The Putin Interviews''.
** From the time of the actual assassination until years after the film was made, the idea of a disturbed young man murdering a target of opportunity for no greater motive than FameThroughInfamy remained a rather unfamiliar, unsettling, and thus unbelievable idea to the general public, underpinning the film's supposition that there must've been more behind Kennedy's death. Modern audiences, however, more than a generation after the Columbine massacre when such self-aggrandizing slayings have become almost mundane, might be more accepting that Oswald could indeed have acted alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/Bedazzled2000'': The wish that makes Elliot an author makes him brilliant, charming, successful and handsome -- only for the joke to make him gay and living with a male partner. In modern eras of increased LGBTQIA+ issues, awareness and representation framing being gay as a joke wouldn't go over well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/BlazingSaddles'': Written by Creator/MelBrooks and Creator/RichardPryor, the kings of NWordPrivileges. The whole point of the filmias to take every trope of the standard American Western, a dozen more from Hollywood films in general, and [[DeconstructiveParody nuke them all]], ''particularly'' the racist parts. It's rated as one of the best comedies of all time, but Brooks fully admits it could never be made today because of the N-bombs, gay jokes, and Jews cast as Native Americans [[note]]which was done to mock the fact it actually was [[TruthInTelevision once standard practice in Hollywood]][[/note]].

to:

* ''Film/BlazingSaddles'': Written by Creator/MelBrooks and Creator/RichardPryor, the kings of NWordPrivileges. The whole point of the filmias film is to take every trope of the standard American Western, a dozen more from Hollywood films in general, and [[DeconstructiveParody nuke them all]], ''particularly'' the racist parts. It's rated as one of the best comedies of all time, but Brooks fully admits it could never be made today because of the N-bombs, gay jokes, and Jews cast as Native Americans [[note]]which was done to mock the fact it actually was [[TruthInTelevision once standard practice in Hollywood]][[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheBigStore'' (1941)': There's a part of the "Sing While You Sell" musical sequence that pans to a part of the store selling cotton sheets. The attendants are black men in cotton-picking attire, who are carrying decorative cotton plants. There is a cutout in the background that almost looks like a "mammy", and they sing a jolly song about how cotton is harvested, all to the tune of "Old Folks at Home". Given the year this came out, we should count ourselves lucky they got Black actors to play the part instead of white guys in {{Blackface}}.

to:

* ''Film/TheBigStore'' (1941)': (1941): There's a part of the "Sing While You Sell" musical sequence that pans to a part of the store selling cotton sheets. The attendants are black men in cotton-picking attire, who are carrying decorative cotton plants. There is a cutout in the background that almost looks like a "mammy", and they sing a jolly song about how cotton is harvested, all to the tune of "Old Folks at Home". Given the year this came out, we should count ourselves lucky they got Black actors to play the part instead of white guys in {{Blackface}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/MeanGirls'', [[AlphaBitch Regina Goerge]] very casually uses the word "retarded" as an insult in various occasions. While the word in question is being said by a villain, the fact that nobody bats an eye when she says it wouldn't be acceptable nowadays since the word is now regarded as an slur towards mentally disabled people.

to:

* In ''Film/MeanGirls'', [[AlphaBitch Regina Goerge]] George]] very casually uses the word "retarded" as an insult in various occasions. While the word in question is being said by a villain, the fact that nobody bats an eye when she says it wouldn't be acceptable nowadays since the word is now regarded as an slur towards mentally disabled people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Summer Nights", as Website/CollegeHumor [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9eHdb2bR9g brutally parodied]]:

to:

** "Summer Nights", as Website/CollegeHumor Creator/{{Dropout}} [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9eHdb2bR9g brutally parodied]]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the movie ''Film/BridgetJonesDiary'', which came out in 2001, Bridget gets groped and sexually harassed a ''lot'', from her boss to her CreepyUncle Geoffrey and Mr. Fitzherbert stares at her tits so much she calls him "Tits Pervert." Generally, Bridget either takes it or just treats it like a tiresome nuisance. In the New Tens, especially with the Me Too movement, this would not fly and she would be expected to call men out on it.

to:

* In the movie ''Film/BridgetJonesDiary'', which came out in 2001, Bridget gets groped and sexually harassed a ''lot'', from her boss to her CreepyUncle Geoffrey and Geoffrey. Mr. Fitzherbert stares at her tits so much that she calls him "Tits Pervert." Generally, Bridget either takes it or just treats it the groping like a tiresome nuisance. In the New Tens, especially with the Me Too movement, this would not fly and she would be expected to call men out on it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/{{Braveheart}}'', Prince Edward is a homosexual as well as a fashion-obsessed wimp and incapable ruler. Many of these details are taken from history, and the film never implies that Edward's sexuality is what makes him a wimp, but the portrayal strays close to negative stereotypes of homosexual men and would raise eyebrows in today's political climate. While gay-rights advocates called the movie out in 1995 (particularly for the death of his lover being PlayedForLaughs), they were mostly ignored.

to:

* In ''Film/{{Braveheart}}'', Prince Edward (Edward II of England) is a homosexual as well as a fashion-obsessed wimp and an incapable ruler. Many of these details are taken from history, and the film never implies that Edward's sexuality is what makes him a wimp, but the portrayal strays close to negative stereotypes of homosexual men and would raise eyebrows in today's political climate. While gay-rights advocates called the movie out in 1995 (particularly for the death of his lover being PlayedForLaughs), they were mostly ignored.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheBigStore'': There's a part of the "Sing While You Sell" musical sequence that pans to a part of the store selling cotton sheets. The attendants are black men in cotton-picking attire, who are carrying decorative cotton plants. There is a cutout in the background that almost looks like a "mammy", and they sing a jolly song about how cotton is harvested, all to the tune of "Old Folks at Home". Given the year this came out, we should count ourselves lucky they got Black actors to play the part instead of white guys in {{Blackface}}.

to:

* ''Film/TheBigStore'': ''Film/TheBigStore'' (1941)': There's a part of the "Sing While You Sell" musical sequence that pans to a part of the store selling cotton sheets. The attendants are black men in cotton-picking attire, who are carrying decorative cotton plants. There is a cutout in the background that almost looks like a "mammy", and they sing a jolly song about how cotton is harvested, all to the tune of "Old Folks at Home". Given the year this came out, we should count ourselves lucky they got Black actors to play the part instead of white guys in {{Blackface}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheBigStore'': There's a part of the "Sing While You Sell" musical sequence that pans to a part of the store selling cotton sheets. The attendants are black men in cotton-picking attire carrying decorative cotton plants, with a cutout in the background that almost looks like a "mammy", and they sing a jolly song about how cotton is harvested, all to the tune of "Old Folks at Home". Given the year this came out, we should count ourselves lucky they got Black actors to play the part instead of white guys in {{Blackface}}.

to:

* ''Film/TheBigStore'': There's a part of the "Sing While You Sell" musical sequence that pans to a part of the store selling cotton sheets. The attendants are black men in cotton-picking attire attire, who are carrying decorative cotton plants, with plants. There is a cutout in the background that almost looks like a "mammy", and they sing a jolly song about how cotton is harvested, all to the tune of "Old Folks at Home". Given the year this came out, we should count ourselves lucky they got Black actors to play the part instead of white guys in {{Blackface}}.

Top