Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / Magnolia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Creator Chosen Casting is when the casting of an adaptation is influenced by the creator of the work being adapted; an original character written for a specific actor is not an example


* CreatorChosenCasting: Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wrote the script with Creator/PhilipBakerHall and Creator/WilliamHMacy in mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Names The Same is no longer a trope.


* NamesTheSame: The gay barfly (played by [[Series/RowanAndMartinsLaughIn Henry Gibson]]) is named "[[Characters/GilligansIsland Thurston Howell]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer Trivia. See X Source Cleanup.


* QuoteSource:
** DarkAndTroubledPast
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BillingDisplacement: Where's Creator/AlfredMolina? Oh, there he is. In one scene early on in the film. Despite of this, he is even credited above Melora Walters.

to:

* BillingDisplacement: Where's Creator/AlfredMolina? Oh, there he is. In one scene early on in the film. Despite of this, he is even credited above Melora Walters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorChosenCasting: Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wrote the script with Creator/PhillipBakerHall and Creator/WilliamHMacy in mind.

to:

* CreatorChosenCasting: Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wrote the script with Creator/PhillipBakerHall Creator/PhilipBakerHall and Creator/WilliamHMacy in mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorChosenCasting: Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wrote the script with Creator/PhillipBakerHall and Creator/WilliamHMacy in mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* QuoteSource:
** DarkAndTroubledPast
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProductionPosse: Many of the film's major and minor actors return from Creator/PaulThomasAnderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''; the only exceptions among the former are Creator/TomCruise, Jason Robards, and Jeremy Blackman.

to:

* ProductionPosse: Many of the film's major and minor actors return from Creator/PaulThomasAnderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''; the only exceptions among the former are Creator/TomCruise, Jason Robards, Creator/JasonRobards, and Jeremy Blackman.

Added: 163

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BillingDisplacement: Where's Creator/AlfredMolina? Oh, there he is. In one scene early on in the film. Despite of this, he is even credited above Melora Walters.



* TheDanza: Luis Guzman has a role as a contestant on "What Do Kids Know?" named Luis Guzman.
* DeletedRole: Orlando Jones' role, as "The Worm"--the father of the rapping boy and also the murderer of the man in the closet--was left on the cutting room floor. This makes Dead Guy in Closet's Murder an Unreveal and makes the boy's presence in the film more or less random. In the final cut Jones appears only as the [[InTheHood mysterious hooded]] pedestrian that Officer Jim chases before losing his gun.

to:

* TheDanza: Luis Guzman Creator/LuisGuzman has a role as a contestant on "What Do Kids Know?" named Luis Guzman.
* DeletedRole: Orlando Jones' Creator/OrlandoJones' role, as "The Worm"--the father of the rapping boy and also the murderer of the man in the closet--was left on the cutting room floor. This makes Dead Guy in Closet's Murder an Unreveal and makes the boy's presence in the film more or less random. In the final cut Jones appears only as the [[InTheHood mysterious hooded]] pedestrian that Officer Jim chases before losing his gun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigNameFan: Creator/IngmarBergman was a fan of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Creator/DebraWinger was considered for the role of Linda Partridge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RealLifeRelative: The WWDK Show Director's Assistant is played by William Mapother, Creator/TomCruise's real-life cousin.

to:

* RealLifeRelative: The WWDK Show Director's Assistant is played by William Mapother, Creator/WilliamMapother, Creator/TomCruise's real-life cousin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/PhilipSeymourHoffman, who had mostly played creeps, jerks and losers up until then, plays NiceGuy Phil Parma.

to:

* ** Creator/PhilipSeymourHoffman, who had mostly played creeps, jerks and losers up until then, plays NiceGuy Phil Parma.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Creator/PhilipSeymourHoffman, who had mostly played creeps, jerks and losers up until then, plays NiceGuy Phil Parma.

Added: 1295

Changed: 1

Removed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActingForTwo: Pat Healy plays two characters in the movie: Sir Edmund William Godfrey, who is murdered by the three thieves in the first scene, and the young pharmacist Julianne Moore yells at.
* BigNameFan: Creator/IngmarBergman was a fan of the film.
* CastTheRunnerUp: According to Creator/ThomasJane, he was supposed to play two different characters in the film. But the scheduling overlapped with ''Film/UnderSuspicion'' so he was only available for the brief cameo as the young Jimmy Gator.



* DeletedRole: Orlando Jones's role, as "The Worm"--the father of the rapping boy and also the murderer of the man in the closet--was left on the cutting room floor. This makes Dead Guy in Closet's Murder an Unreveal and makes the boy's presence in the film more or less random. In the final cut Jones appears only as the [[InTheHood mysterious hooded]] pedestrian that Officer Jim chases before losing his gun.

to:

* DeletedRole: Orlando Jones's Jones' role, as "The Worm"--the father of the rapping boy and also the murderer of the man in the closet--was left on the cutting room floor. This makes Dead Guy in Closet's Murder an Unreveal and makes the boy's presence in the film more or less random. In the final cut Jones appears only as the [[InTheHood mysterious hooded]] pedestrian that Officer Jim chases before losing his gun.gun.
* MidDevelopmentGenreShift: This was originally supposed to be a short and intimate film. But the more Creator/PaulThomasAnderson worked on the characters the more intricate it became. So the plot expanded from there.



* PlayingAgainstType: Creator/JohnCReilly was tiring of always playing heavies so he asked Creator/PaulThomasAnderson to write him a part in which he falls in love with a girl.



* RetroactiveRecognition: That's Creator/PattonOswalt as the croupier in the second story of the prologue.



* UncreditedRole: According to her official site, Creator/MiriamMargolyes asked not to be credited in this film due to the size of her role.



** Debra Winger was considered for Linda Partridge.


Added DiffLines:

* WriteWhatYouKnow: According to Philip Baker Hall, the scene where Frank T.J. Mackey visits Earl Partridge on his deathbed is loosely based on Creator/PaulThomasAnderson's experiences of watching his father, the late WABC-TV announcer Ernie Anderson, die of cancer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RetroactiveRecognition: That's Creator/PattonOswalt as the croupier in the second story of the prologue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NamesTheSame: The gay barfly (played by [[Series/RowanAndMartinsLaughIn Henry Gibson]]) is named [[Characters/GilligansIsland "Thurston Howell."]]
* ProductionPosse: Creator/TomCruise and Jason Robards are the only principal players who did not also appear in Creator/PaulThomasAnderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''.
* RealLifeRelative: The Wwdk show directors assistant im this movie is played by William Mapother who is Creator/TomCruise's cousin in real life.
* ThrowItIn: According to Creator/PhilipSeymourHoffman, during the deathbed scene, everything after Frank's 'I'm not going to cry for you' was improvised by Creator/TomCruise. Cruise didn't feel the scripted lines worked and Creator/PaulThomasAnderson told Cruise to think of when his own father died and to let it move him. During the next take Cruise broke down sobbing, resulting in the scene seen in the film. Hoffman stated Phil's reaction to Frank sobbing was his own, since he didn't know Cruise would enter such a zone and he felt the purity of Cruise's emotion.

to:

* NamesTheSame: The gay barfly (played by [[Series/RowanAndMartinsLaughIn Henry Gibson]]) is named [[Characters/GilligansIsland "Thurston Howell."]]
"[[Characters/GilligansIsland Thurston Howell]]".
* ProductionPosse: Creator/TomCruise Many of the film's major and Jason Robards are the only principal players who did not also appear in minor actors return from Creator/PaulThomasAnderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''.
''Film/BoogieNights''; the only exceptions among the former are Creator/TomCruise, Jason Robards, and Jeremy Blackman.
* RealLifeRelative: The Wwdk show directors assistant im this movie WWDK Show Director's Assistant is played by William Mapother who is Mapother, Creator/TomCruise's cousin in real life.
real-life cousin.
* ThrowItIn: According to Creator/PhilipSeymourHoffman, during the deathbed scene, everything after Frank's 'I'm not going to cry for you' was improvised by Creator/TomCruise. Cruise didn't feel the scripted lines worked worked, and Creator/PaulThomasAnderson told Cruise to think of when his own father died and to let it move him. During the next take Cruise broke down sobbing, resulting in the scene seen in the film. Hoffman stated Phil's reaction to Frank sobbing was his own, since he didn't know Cruise would enter such a zone and he felt the purity of Cruise's emotion.



** Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wanted to cast Creator/BurtReynolds for an unspecified role. But Reynolds became angry with Anderson during the promotional tour for ''Film/BoogieNights'' and turned the role down.
** Creator/DebraWinger was considered for Linda Partridge.
** Along with the scenes further explaining The Worm, there were many other scenes and dialogue exchanges included in the script but not used for the final film, including:
*** A scene in which Jimmy talks with Paula, the dancer he is sleeping with in the opening credits.
*** Extended dialogue between Gwenovier and Frank, about "Subjective human experience and terrible things", which was referenced in the final cut but not shown.

to:

** Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wanted to cast Creator/BurtReynolds for an unspecified role. But Reynolds became had become angry with Anderson during the promotional tour for ''Film/BoogieNights'' and turned the role down.
** Creator/DebraWinger Debra Winger was considered for Linda Partridge.
** Along with the scenes further explaining The Worm, there were many other scenes and dialogue exchanges included in the script but not used for the final film, including:
including:
*** A scene in which Jimmy talks with Paula, the dancer he is sleeping having sex with in the opening credits.
sequence.
*** Extended dialogue between Gwenovier and Frank, about "Subjective human experience and terrible things", which was referenced in the final cut but not shown.



*** Further explanation during Earl's monologue concerning the reasons why he mistreated his first wife.
*** The tone of Frank's confrontation with his father is considerably different, with him showing less hostility, more genuine sympathy and concern, and attempting to wake him up.
*** It is made clear in the script that Jimmy doesn't survive the fire in his house caused by the destroyed television.

to:

*** Further explanation during Earl's monologue concerning the reasons why he mistreated his first wife.
*** The tone of Frank's confrontation with his father is considerably different, with him showing less hostility, more genuine sympathy and concern, and attempting to wake him up.
up.
*** It is made clear in the script that Jimmy doesn't survive the fire in his house caused by the destroyed television.

Added: 1170

Changed: 552

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeletedScene: [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse We never really find out]] what was going on with the dead guy in the closet, or what the boy's confusing rap monologue ("I just told you who did it!") is about, or who "The Worm" is. In fact The Worm, played by Orlando Jones, is the boy's father, and the murderer. All his scenes were cut from the film, and he appears only as the mysterious hooded pedestrian Officer Jim chases before Jim loses his gun. Especially notable in that this is a rare deleted scene that's not available on any DVD release.

to:

* DeletedScene: [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse We never really find out]] what was going on with DeletedRole: Orlando Jones's role, as "The Worm"--the father of the dead guy rapping boy and also the murderer of the man in the closet, or what closet--was left on the cutting room floor. This makes Dead Guy in Closet's Murder an Unreveal and makes the boy's confusing rap monologue ("I just told you who did it!") is about, or who "The Worm" is. In fact The Worm, played by Orlando Jones, is presence in the boy's father, and film more or less random. In the murderer. All his scenes were final cut from the film, and he Jones appears only as the [[InTheHood mysterious hooded hooded]] pedestrian that Officer Jim chases before Jim loses losing his gun. Especially notable in that this is a rare deleted scene that's not available on any DVD release.gun.



* WhatMightHaveBeen:

to:

* WhatMightHaveBeen: WhatCouldHaveBeen:


Added DiffLines:

** Along with the scenes further explaining The Worm, there were many other scenes and dialogue exchanges included in the script but not used for the final film, including:
*** A scene in which Jimmy talks with Paula, the dancer he is sleeping with in the opening credits.
*** Extended dialogue between Gwenovier and Frank, about "Subjective human experience and terrible things", which was referenced in the final cut but not shown.
*** A brief dialogue between Jim and Claudia after he asks her on a date, in which they both find they have the same favorite restaurant.
*** We see what happens to Stanley between the events of that day's game show, and him talking to his sleeping father.
*** Further explanation during Earl's monologue concerning the reasons why he mistreated his first wife.
*** The tone of Frank's confrontation with his father is considerably different, with him showing less hostility, more genuine sympathy and concern, and attempting to wake him up.
*** It is made clear in the script that Jimmy doesn't survive the fire in his house caused by the destroyed television.
*** We see Marcie's confession for what happened to the "guy in the closet".

Added: 1074

Changed: 907

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorBacklash: Creator/PaulThomasAnderson admitted that he finds the film far too long now, and would have cut some of the story lines from the finished product. He never specified what stories he would have cut. In an interview with Marc Maron in January of 2015, he was asked if he had the opportunity to re-cut the film. He replied, "I'd slice that thing down. It's way too fucking long. It's unmerciful how long it is." He added that "maybe a few" trajectories in the film's plot lines could've been eliminated.



* ProductionPosse: Cruise and Robards are the only principal players who did not also appear in Anderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''.
* WhatMightHaveBeen: Creator/GeorgeCScott was offered the role of Earl Partridge, but turned it down because the script was, in his words, "..the worst fucking thing I've ever read. [[HypocriticalHumor The language is terrible]]."

to:

* ProductionPosse: Cruise Creator/TomCruise and Jason Robards are the only principal players who did not also appear in Anderson's Creator/PaulThomasAnderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''.
* WhatMightHaveBeen: RealLifeRelative: The Wwdk show directors assistant im this movie is played by William Mapother who is Creator/TomCruise's cousin in real life.
* ThrowItIn: According to Creator/PhilipSeymourHoffman, during the deathbed scene, everything after Frank's 'I'm not going to cry for you' was improvised by Creator/TomCruise. Cruise didn't feel the scripted lines worked and Creator/PaulThomasAnderson told Cruise to think of when his own father died and to let it move him. During the next take Cruise broke down sobbing, resulting in the scene seen in the film. Hoffman stated Phil's reaction to Frank sobbing was his own, since he didn't know Cruise would enter such a zone and he felt the purity of Cruise's emotion.
* WhatMightHaveBeen:
**
Creator/GeorgeCScott was offered the role of Earl Partridge, but turned it down because the script was, in his words, "..the worst fucking thing I've ever read. [[HypocriticalHumor The language is terrible]]."
" Creator/MarlonBrando was also considered for the role.
** Creator/PaulThomasAnderson wanted to cast Creator/BurtReynolds for an unspecified role. But Reynolds became angry with Anderson during the promotional tour for ''Film/BoogieNights'' and turned the role down.
** Creator/DebraWinger was considered for Linda Partridge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hey Its That Guy and Hey Its That Voice examples are being cut per TRS.


* HeyItsThatGuy:
** Creator/PattonOswalt is the Vegas croupier in the prologue.
** Rick Spector is [[Film/KillBill Buck, and he likes to fuck.]]
** [[Film/AChristmasStory Mother Parker]] is Rose Gator.
** [[Series/AgentsOfSHIELD Agent Coulson]] is one of the "What Do Kids Know?" floor directors.
** [[Series/BreakingBad ASAC George Mekert]] plays one of Frank T.J. Mackey's assistants.
** The Janitor from ''Series/{{Scrubs}}'' has a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo during the film's prologue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rick Spector is [[KillBill Buck, and he likes to fuck.]]

to:

** Rick Spector is [[KillBill [[Film/KillBill Buck, and he likes to fuck.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** PattonOswalt is the Vegas croupier in the prologue.

to:

** PattonOswalt Creator/PattonOswalt is the Vegas croupier in the prologue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[Film/AChristmasStory Mother Parker]] is Rose Gator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NamesTheSame: The gay barfly (played by [[Series/RowanAndMartinsLaughIn Henry Gibson]]) is named [[Characters/GilligansIsland "Thurston Howell."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[TheAvengers Agent Coulson]] is one of the "What Do Kids Know?" floor directors.

to:

** [[TheAvengers [[Series/AgentsOfSHIELD Agent Coulson]] is one of the "What Do Kids Know?" floor directors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[BreakingBad ASAC George Mekert]] plays one of Frank T.J. Mackey's assistants.

to:

** [[BreakingBad [[Series/BreakingBad ASAC George Mekert]] plays one of Frank T.J. Mackey's assistants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[BreakingBad ASAC George Mekert]] plays one of Frank T.J. Mackey's assistants.
** The Janitor from ''Series/{{Scrubs}}'' has a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo during the film's prologue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from the main page.

Added DiffLines:

* TheDanza: Luis Guzman has a role as a contestant on "What Do Kids Know?" named Luis Guzman.
* DeletedScene: [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse We never really find out]] what was going on with the dead guy in the closet, or what the boy's confusing rap monologue ("I just told you who did it!") is about, or who "The Worm" is. In fact The Worm, played by Orlando Jones, is the boy's father, and the murderer. All his scenes were cut from the film, and he appears only as the mysterious hooded pedestrian Officer Jim chases before Jim loses his gun. Especially notable in that this is a rare deleted scene that's not available on any DVD release.
* HeyItsThatGuy:
** PattonOswalt is the Vegas croupier in the prologue.
** Rick Spector is [[KillBill Buck, and he likes to fuck.]]
** [[TheAvengers Agent Coulson]] is one of the "What Do Kids Know?" floor directors.
* ProductionPosse: Cruise and Robards are the only principal players who did not also appear in Anderson's previous film, ''Film/BoogieNights''.
* WhatMightHaveBeen: Creator/GeorgeCScott was offered the role of Earl Partridge, but turned it down because the script was, in his words, "..the worst fucking thing I've ever read. [[HypocriticalHumor The language is terrible]]."

----

Top