History NightmareFuel / Valentine

* Jeremy Melton/Adam Carr is a combination of this trope and ParanoiaFuel. On the one hand he's intelligent, convincing, good at keeping a polite facade, doesn't break under pressure (he even does a convincing job of ''pretending'' to crack), but has no compunctions about enacting a killing spree over a crime against him that barely anyone remembers.

* Adam behaves increasingly unstable over the film's last few minutes due to apparently going on a bender, where we see why Kate was hesitant about going back to him as he shifts from asking politely, to mildly threatening, to placating. While this particular episode appears to have been PlayingDrunk due to being able to shoot and his more calculated murders throughout the third act, it offers a lot of speculation as to how much of his drunken behavior was an act or even the embittered Jeremy personality leaking back in.

* Adam behaving increasingly unstable over the film's last few minutes due to apparently going on a bender, where we see why Kate was hesitant about going back to him. While this particular episode appears to have been PlayingDrunk due to being able to shoot and his more calculated murders throughout the third act, it offers a lot of speculation as to how much of his drunken behavior was an act or the Jeremy personality leaking back in.

* Jeremy Melton/Adam Carr is a combination of this trope and ParanoiaFuel. On the one hand he's intelligent, convincing, good at keeping a polite facade, doesn't break under pressure (he even does a convincing job of ''pretending'' to crack), and has no compunctions about enacting a killing spree over a crime against him that barely anyone remembers.

* Jeremy Melton[[spoiler:/Adam Carr]] is a combination of this trope and ParanoiaFuel. On the one hand he's intelligent, convincing, good at keeping a polite facade, doesn't break under pressure (he even does a convincing job of ''pretending'' to crack), and has no compunctions about enacting a killing spree over a crime against him that barely anyone remembers.

* [[spoiler: Shelley's death while trapped in the morgue. It's pretty clear that she's panicking throughout the entire scene.]]
* [[spoiler: Lily's death at the art exhibition. The scene is already a disorientating maze of shifting pictures and flashing lights and just when Lily rounds a corner, she gets shot by arrows until she gets shot over a railing into a dumpster, screaming all the way down.]]
* [[spoiler: Paige's death in the hot tub; the killer traps her in the hot tub and starts stabbing at her with the drill as she struggles for air. After stabbing her in the shoulder, the killer just throws the power drill into the hot tub, electrocuting her. The original version of this scene had her skin melting off.]]
* [[spoiler: Ruthie's]] death by having her head dropped on a large shard of glass. This one is accompanied by a SickeningCrunch. Unlike most of the other victims, the killer didn't have a beef with her, she was just in the wrong place at the wrong time by walking in on the killer while he was DisposingOfABody.
* [[spoiler:Gary's death]] is quite brutal even though he's an AssholeVictim; the killer finds he's broken into Kate's apartment, picks up an iron, then burns his face with the iron and [[BludgeonedToDeath keeps hitting him]]. The uncut footage has the killer just hitting him over and over again (offscreen) until the scene changes.

* [[spoiler:Gary's death]] is quite brutal even though he's an AssholeVictim; the killer finds he's broken into Kate's apartment, picks up an iron, then burns Gary's face with the iron and [[BludgeonedToDeath keeps hitting him]]. The uncut footage has the killer just hitting him over and over again (offscreen) until the scene changes.

* Jeremy Melton is walking ParanoiaFuel. Given that the gals haven't seen him for years and how badly they hurt him with the FrameUp, any guy they know could have a grudge against them.

* The film's final shot which underscores the ParanoiaFuel example above. [[spoiler:Adam just killed the killer (who is unmasked as Dorothy), the cops are on their way, and he and Kate share a hug. Show's over right? Then Adam's nose starts bleeding, meaning that the person Kate thinks she knows best is a vicious SerialKiller.]]

* [[spoiler: Paige's death in the hot tub. The original version of this scene had her skin melting off.]]

* Gary's death is quite brutal even though he's an AssholeVictim; the killer finds he's broken into Kate's apartment, picks up an iron, then burns Gary's face with the iron and [[BludgeonedToDeath keeps hitting him]]. The uncut footage has the killer just hitting him over and over again (offscreen) until the scene changes.

''They’ll need dental records to identify you''."]]

* The killer's mask is rather unnerving to look at, somewhere in the UncannyValley.

[[caption-width-right:350:“RosesAreRedVioletsAreBlue\\
''They’ll need dental records to identify you''.”]]

* [[spoiler: Lily's death at the art exhibition. The scene is a disorientating maze of shifting pictures and flashing lights and just when Lily rounds a corner, she gets shot by arrows until she gets shot over a railing into a dumpster, screaming all the way down.]]

* [[spoiler: Ruthie's]] death by having her head dropped on a large shard of glass. This one is accompanied by a SickeningCrunch. Unlike most of the over victims, the killer didn't have a beef with her, she was just in the wrong place at the wrong time.

* [[spoiler: Shelley's death while trapped in the morgue.]]
* [[spoiler: Lily's death at the art exhibition.]]

* [[spoiler: Ruthie's]] death by having her head dropped on a large shard of glass.

* The killer's mask.

* [[spoiler: Paige's death in the hot tub.]]

* [[spoiler: Paige's death in the hot tub.]]

''They’ll need Dental Records to identify you''.”]]

[[caption-width-right:350:“RosesAreRedVioletsAreBlue ''They’ll need Dental Records to identify you''.”]]

[[caption-width-right:350:“RosesAreRedVioletsAreBlue... ''They’ll need Dental Records to identify you''.”]]

* The killer's mask.