Follow TV Tropes

Following

History NightmareFuel / BlackMirrorWhiteChristmas

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ending especially gets dark very quickly...To clarify, Joe's cookie confesses the murder of his ex-girlfriend's father and indirectly causing her daughter's death and is left there, completely alone. To add insult to injury, one of the cops speeds up his perception of time, making one minute in the real world correspond to 1000 years for the cookie! And leaves him like that all of Christmas Day with one annoying song with the volume turned way up! That's right: he has to suffer more than one million years alone, with the full knowledge of what he has done and also knowing he's not real, with the most ironic soundtrack in the history of ever. It's safe to say this could be [[AndIMustScream the most accurate depiction of Hell ever portrayed]] without any supernatural element.

to:

* The ending especially gets dark very quickly...To clarify, Joe's cookie confesses the murder of his ex-girlfriend's father and indirectly causing her daughter's death and is left there, completely alone. To add insult to injury, one of the cops speeds up his perception of time, making one minute in the real world correspond to 1000 years for the cookie! And leaves him like that all of Christmas Day with one annoying song with the volume turned way up! That's right: he has to suffer more than one million years alone, with the full knowledge of what he has done and also knowing he's not real, the frozen corpse of the little girl whose death he accidentally caused in plain sight through the window, and with the most ironic soundtrack in the history of ever. It's safe to say this could be [[AndIMustScream the most accurate depiction of Hell ever portrayed]] without any supernatural element.

Added: 315

Removed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%Image removed via crowner in the Moments Images Cleanup Thread: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php?crowner_id=t7kf52t8
%%https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=1642193091068711500

%%Please do not add a new image without going through the Image Suggestion thread or starting a new Image Pickin' thread



[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/john_hamm.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:[[Film/HoneyIShrunkTheKids Honey, I Shrunk You]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The second segment features a woman getting a 'cookie'. It's an implant that learns how a person thinks, in order to perform tasks exactly as the owner does. However, the problem is that the cookie believes they ARE that person. This results in the cookie refusing to work. Solution? Their perception of time is sped up. They believe they have spent days, weeks, months even, alone with nothing to do. And this is a digital copy, so they can't age or die. By the end, they are left a broken shell of their former self, condemned to an endless 'life' of slavery.

to:

* The second segment features a woman getting a 'cookie'. It's an implant that learns how a person thinks, in order to perform tasks exactly as the owner does. However, the problem is that the cookie believes they ARE that person. This results in the cookie refusing to work. Solution? Their perception of time is sped up. They believe they have spent days, weeks, months even, alone with nothing to do. And this is a digital copy, [[AndIMustScream so they can't age or die.die]]. By the end, they are left a broken shell of their former self, condemned to an endless 'life' of slavery.

Removed: 1302

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Unrelated tangent; there's no indication that Roko's Basilisk was a direct inspiration, or that Brooker has ever heard of the concept. (Also, Roko's Basilisk is dumb as hell)


** The worst part? The fate of the cookies is lifted from a thought experiment called [[https://slate.com/technology/2014/07/rokos-basilisk-the-most-terrifying-thought-experiment-of-all-time.html Roko's basilisk.]] First conceived by a user named Roko on the Blog/LessWrong forums, it starts from the assumption that the creation of artificial intelligence will lead to TheSingularity and a technological utopia. The resulting AI, therefore, would feel incentivized to punish those who opposed its creation, deciding that they had prolonged the suffering of humanity as a whole. Since people can only be killed once, and some of the people who opposed it may already be dead when the AI emerges, the AI will decide to create digital copies of its targets to torture, kill, and resurrect for all eternity. Since we don't know if we're living in one of the AI's simulations or not, it's best to support the creation of AI to make sure that, when it does come, it doesn't try to send us to digital {{Hell}}. Effectively a form of Pascal's wager for techno-utopians, the users of Less Wrong [[BrownNote found the idea]] [[ThingsManWasNotMeantToKnow so disturbing]] that the site's owner Creator/EliezerYudkowsky banned all discussion of it and left Roko a message denouncing him for even coming up with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, imagine that someone you know/used to know does something to get "blocked by the system" and the first you find out about it is them getting "fuzzed out" in your old pictures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rechecked my math.


** To put that into perspective, in the 26 seconds it took for the officers to exchange that information, 433 years and four months have gone by in the cookie, and Roy Wood has wished it would be Christmas every day[[note]]as a point of reference, the song is 4 minutes, 37 seconds long[[/note]] roughly ''49,366,839'' times.
*** It gets even worse when you [[FridgeHorror do more thinking]]. They left it on overnight. Assuming they left the station at around 5PM and came in the next day at around 8AM, that means it was left on for 15 hours. In that time, not only would '''900,000 years''' have passed, but the number of times "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday" played? Roughly '''''102,463,537,906 times'''''.

to:

** To put that into perspective, in the 26 seconds it took for the officers to exchange that information, 433 years and four months have gone by in the cookie, and Roy Wood has wished it would be Christmas every day[[note]]as a point of reference, the song is 4 minutes, 37 seconds long[[/note]] roughly ''49,366,839'' ''49,367,073'' times.
*** It gets even worse when you [[FridgeHorror do more thinking]]. They left it on overnight. Assuming they left the station at around 5PM and came in the next day at around 8AM, that means it was left on for 15 hours. In that time, not only would '''900,000 years''' have passed, but the number of times "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday" played? Roughly '''''102,463,537,906 '''''102,531,612,996 times'''''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The worst part? The fate of the cookies is lifted from a thought experiment called [[https://slate.com/technology/2014/07/rokos-basilisk-the-most-terrifying-thought-experiment-of-all-time.html Roko's basilisk.]] First conceived by a user named Roko on the Blog/LessWrong forums, it starts from the assumption that the creation of artificial intelligence will lead to TheSingularity and a technological utopia. The resulting AI, therefore, would feel incentivized to punish those who opposed its creation, deciding that they had prolonged the suffering of humanity as a whole. Since people can only be killed once, and some of the people who opposed it may already be dead when the AI emerges, the AI will decide to create digital copies of its targets to torture, kill, and resurrect for all eternity. Since we don't know if we're living in one of the AI's simulations or not, it's best to support the creation of AI to make sure that, when it does come, it doesn't try to send us to digital {{Hell}}. Effectively a form of Pascal's wager for techno-utopians, the users of Less Wrong [[BrownNote found the idea]] [[ThingsManWasNotMeantToKnow so disturbing]] that the site's owner Creator/EliezerYudkowsky banned all discussion of it and left Roko a message denouncing him for even coming up with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Don't forget Matt. He is blocked by '''all of humanity'''.]] Everyone else sees him as a red static blurb, and it's evident that [[ParanoiaFuel someone might want to make him pay...

to:

** Don't forget Matt. He is blocked by '''all of humanity'''.]] Everyone else sees him as a red static blurb, and it's evident that [[ParanoiaFuel someone might want to make him pay...]]

Changed: 2140

Removed: 405

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moments subpages (such as Heartwarming, Tearjerker etc.) are Spoilers Off pages. Also fixed up some Word Cruft


* The first segment: a young man tries to romance an attractive outsider, only to discover [[spoiler:she's an undiagnosed schizophrenic, and believing she has found a kindred spirit, forces him to drink poison before killing herself with it as well.]]
* The second segment features a woman getting a 'cookie'. It's an implant that learns how a person thinks, in order to perform tasks exactly as the owner does. However, the problem is that [[spoiler:the cookie believes they ARE that person. This results in the cookie refusing to work. Solution? Their perception of time is sped up. They believe they have spent days, weeks, months even, alone with nothing to do. And this is a digital copy, so they can't age or die. By the end, they are left a broken shell of their former self, condemned to an endless 'life' of slavery.]]

to:

* The first segment: a young man tries to romance an attractive outsider, only to discover [[spoiler:she's she's an undiagnosed schizophrenic, and believing she has found a kindred spirit, forces him to drink poison before killing herself with it as well.]]
well.
* The second segment features a woman getting a 'cookie'. It's an implant that learns how a person thinks, in order to perform tasks exactly as the owner does. However, the problem is that [[spoiler:the the cookie believes they ARE that person. This results in the cookie refusing to work. Solution? Their perception of time is sped up. They believe they have spent days, weeks, months even, alone with nothing to do. And this is a digital copy, so they can't age or die. By the end, they are left a broken shell of their former self, condemned to an endless 'life' of slavery.]]



*** WordOfGod is that [[spoiler: [[http://www.vulture.com/2016/10/black-mirror-charlie-brooker-reveals-most-depressing-cut-scene.html there was actually a scene written showing this happening to Cookie!Greta]] -- she watched Real Greta reading a story to 'their' son, knowing she'd never be with her child again. It was cut for being too bleak. ''In Black Mirror.'']]

to:

*** WordOfGod is that [[spoiler: [[http://www.vulture.com/2016/10/black-mirror-charlie-brooker-reveals-most-depressing-cut-scene.html there was actually a scene written showing this happening to Cookie!Greta]] -- she watched Real Greta reading a story to 'their' son, knowing she'd never be with her child again. It was cut for being too bleak. ''In Black Mirror.'']] ''



** Also, congrats to ''[[Recap/BlackMirrorWhiteChristmas White Christmas]]'' on being the first Christmas special to feature [[spoiler:a man accidentally murdering his ex-partner's father in a fit of rage]]. Good job!

to:

** Also, congrats to ''[[Recap/BlackMirrorWhiteChristmas White Christmas]]'' on being the first Christmas special to feature [[spoiler:a a man accidentally murdering his ex-partner's father in a fit of rage]].rage. Good job!



* The ending especially gets dark very quickly...
** To clarify, [[spoiler:Joe's cookie confesses the murder of his ex-girlfriend's father and indirectly causing her daughter's death and is left there, completely alone. To add insult to injury, one of the cops speeds up his perception of time, making one minute in the real world correspond to 1000 years for the cookie! And leaves him like that all of Christmas Day with one annoying song with the volume turned way up! That's right: he has to suffer more than one million years alone, with the full knowledge of what he has done and also knowing he's not real, with the most ironic soundtrack in the history of ever.]] It's safe to say this could be [[AndIMustScream the most accurate depiction of Hell ever portrayed]] without any supernatural element.
** To put that into perspective, in the 26 seconds it took for the officers to exchange that information, [[spoiler:433 years and four months have gone by in the cookie, and Roy Wood has wished it would be Christmas every day[[note]]as a point of reference, the song is 4 minutes, 37 seconds long[[/note]] roughly ''49,366,839'' times]].
*** It gets even worse when you [[FridgeHorror do more thinking]]. [[spoiler:They left it on overnight. Assuming they left the station at around 5PM and came in the next day at around 8AM, that means it was left on for 15 hours. In that time, not only would '''900,000 years''' have passed, but the number of times "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday" played? Roughly '''''102,463,537,906 times'''''.]]

to:

* The ending especially gets dark very quickly...
**
quickly...To clarify, [[spoiler:Joe's Joe's cookie confesses the murder of his ex-girlfriend's father and indirectly causing her daughter's death and is left there, completely alone. To add insult to injury, one of the cops speeds up his perception of time, making one minute in the real world correspond to 1000 years for the cookie! And leaves him like that all of Christmas Day with one annoying song with the volume turned way up! That's right: he has to suffer more than one million years alone, with the full knowledge of what he has done and also knowing he's not real, with the most ironic soundtrack in the history of ever.]] It's safe to say this could be [[AndIMustScream the most accurate depiction of Hell ever portrayed]] without any supernatural element.
** To put that into perspective, in the 26 seconds it took for the officers to exchange that information, [[spoiler:433 433 years and four months have gone by in the cookie, and Roy Wood has wished it would be Christmas every day[[note]]as a point of reference, the song is 4 minutes, 37 seconds long[[/note]] roughly ''49,366,839'' times]].
times.
*** It gets even worse when you [[FridgeHorror do more thinking]]. [[spoiler:They They left it on overnight. Assuming they left the station at around 5PM and came in the next day at around 8AM, that means it was left on for 15 hours. In that time, not only would '''900,000 years''' have passed, but the number of times "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday" played? Roughly '''''102,463,537,906 times'''''.]]



** Don't forget [[spoiler:Matt. He is blocked by '''all of humanity'''.]] Everyone else sees him as a red static blurb, and it's evident that [[ParanoiaFuel someone might want to make him pay...]]

to:

** Don't forget [[spoiler:Matt.Matt. He is blocked by '''all of humanity'''.]] Everyone else sees him as a red static blurb, and it's evident that [[ParanoiaFuel someone might want to make him pay...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/john_hamm.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:[[Film/HoneyIShrunkTheKids Honey, I Shrunk You]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[center:[-'''[[NightmareFuel/BlackMirror Nightmare Fuel]]'''-]]]
[[center:[-[[NightmareFuel/BlackMirrorSeriesOne Series One]]-] -- [-[[NightmareFuel/BlackMirrorSeriesTwo Series Two]]-] -- [-'''Christmas Special'''-] -- [-[[NightmareFuel/BlackMirrorSeriesThree Series Three]]-] -- [-[[NightmareFuel/BlackMirrorSeriesFour Series Four]]-]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The tone throughout the overarching narrative, with main characters Joe and Matt sitting in a cabin just talking, is constantly unsettling, due to the lack of almost any sound apart from their voices.
* FridgeHorror: the Zed-Eyes (technological contact lenses) are worn by everyone and cannot be removed. But what if somebody hacked into them? They could see everything. And you'd never even know.
* The first segment: a young man tries to romance an attractive outsider, only to discover [[spoiler:she's an undiagnosed schizophrenic, and believing she has found a kindred spirit, forces him to drink poison before killing herself with it as well.]]
* The second segment features a woman getting a 'cookie'. It's an implant that learns how a person thinks, in order to perform tasks exactly as the owner does. However, the problem is that [[spoiler:the cookie believes they ARE that person. This results in the cookie refusing to work. Solution? Their perception of time is sped up. They believe they have spent days, weeks, months even, alone with nothing to do. And this is a digital copy, so they can't age or die. By the end, they are left a broken shell of their former self, condemned to an endless 'life' of slavery.]]
** Matt's complete nonchalance about the whole ordeal suggests he did this multiple times.
** It's also pretty scary from the perspective of users who don't know what they're really getting into. If your "cookie" finally snaps, what sort of revenge could they get on you? Could they lock you in your house? Scald you in your shower? Blow out the pilot light and gas you? How much power are they trusted with? And you probably already have devices/applications which learn your habits and preferences. As smarter versions are developed, will we in the real world eventually be condemning intelligent consciousnesses to predicting when we'll want our toilet seats warmed up for us?
** It's also stated that "Cookies" that go irreparably insane are used as {{NPC}}s and enemy characters in video games. Ouch...
** Another FridgeHorror thought here is that plenty of these cookies have to be made from parents. Heck, aside from schedule freaks like Greta, parents are the number one candidate. Imagine a cookie, who thinks it IS the person, never being able to really talk to their kid or kids again...
*** WordOfGod is that [[spoiler: [[http://www.vulture.com/2016/10/black-mirror-charlie-brooker-reveals-most-depressing-cut-scene.html there was actually a scene written showing this happening to Cookie!Greta]] -- she watched Real Greta reading a story to 'their' son, knowing she'd never be with her child again. It was cut for being too bleak. ''In Black Mirror.'']]
* The third segment introduces the idea of blocking people in real life using Zed-Eyes where all that either of you see is an inaudible shadow. It can be left on indefinitely, until death. It also covers offspring AND all media of the subject (such as photos). Just imagine never being able to see or hear a loved one till they're dead and gone...
** It's also legal to "block" someone indefinitely, even when they believe you have a child with them, denying all custody and visitation rights unilaterally.
** Also, congrats to ''[[Recap/BlackMirrorWhiteChristmas White Christmas]]'' on being the first Christmas special to feature [[spoiler:a man accidentally murdering his ex-partner's father in a fit of rage]]. Good job!
** Also, [[FridgeLogic keep in mind that blocking obscures a person's body language and their voice]]. If you blocked someone, you would have ''very'' little warning if they tried to physically attack you.
* The ending especially gets dark very quickly...
** To clarify, [[spoiler:Joe's cookie confesses the murder of his ex-girlfriend's father and indirectly causing her daughter's death and is left there, completely alone. To add insult to injury, one of the cops speeds up his perception of time, making one minute in the real world correspond to 1000 years for the cookie! And leaves him like that all of Christmas Day with one annoying song with the volume turned way up! That's right: he has to suffer more than one million years alone, with the full knowledge of what he has done and also knowing he's not real, with the most ironic soundtrack in the history of ever.]] It's safe to say this could be [[AndIMustScream the most accurate depiction of Hell ever portrayed]] without any supernatural element.
** To put that into perspective, in the 26 seconds it took for the officers to exchange that information, [[spoiler:433 years and four months have gone by in the cookie, and Roy Wood has wished it would be Christmas every day[[note]]as a point of reference, the song is 4 minutes, 37 seconds long[[/note]] roughly ''49,366,839'' times]].
*** It gets even worse when you [[FridgeHorror do more thinking]]. [[spoiler:They left it on overnight. Assuming they left the station at around 5PM and came in the next day at around 8AM, that means it was left on for 15 hours. In that time, not only would '''900,000 years''' have passed, but the number of times "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday" played? Roughly '''''102,463,537,906 times'''''.]]
** Ordinarily, he would likely be {{driven to suicide}}, but since he's a digital being, that's probably not even possible. Instead, he's [[AndIMustScream stuck there with no escape]]. Poor guy can't even stop the music from playing... (He tried. Every time he smashed the radio in the digital room, it respawned, and the music got ''louder''.)
** Don't forget [[spoiler:Matt. He is blocked by '''all of humanity'''.]] Everyone else sees him as a red static blurb, and it's evident that [[ParanoiaFuel someone might want to make him pay...]]
----

Top