Follow TV Tropes

Following

History NightmareFuel / AChristmasCarol2009

Go To



* This movie is '''full''' of [[JumpScare jump scares]].



* Once Marley has given his warning, he leaves through the window and drags Scrooge towards it... where he sees the streets of London FILLED with screaming ghosts of tortured souls, some bound to their own tortures. One is seen banging his head on the cinder block he is chained to, and another flies around a homeless woman clutching her child to keep it warm, shouting how he wishes he could help. Jesus.

to:

* Once Marley has given his warning, he leaves through the window and drags Scrooge towards it... where he sees the streets of London FILLED with screaming ghosts of tortured souls, some bound to their own tortures. One is seen banging his head on the cinder block he is chained to, and another flies around a homeless woman clutching her child to keep it warm, shouting how he wishes he could help. Jesus.



* The death scene of the Ghost of Christmas Present, which is more disturbing than in any other adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, still laughing all the while'', and then crumbles to dust.

to:

* The death scene of the Ghost of Christmas Present, which is more disturbing than in any other adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, [[DieLaughing still laughing all the while'', while]]'', and then crumbles to dust.


* Ignorance and Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a [[SerialKiller vicious knife-wielding criminal]] and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straitjacket and dragged away screaming (which was [[TruthInTelevision a common fate]] for "women of loose morals", either for their families to get them out of the way or as a result of syphillis).

to:

* Ignorance and Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a [[SerialKiller vicious knife-wielding criminal]] and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straitjacket and dragged away screaming (which was [[TruthInTelevision a common fate]] for "women of loose morals", either for their families to get them out of the way or as a result of syphillis). And they are ''laughing'' as they quote Scrooge's line back to him, "Are there no prisons? Are there no workhouses?"


* Ignorance and Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a vicious knife-wielding criminal and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straitjacket and dragged away screaming (which was [[TruthInTelevision a common fate]] for "women of loose morals", either for their families to get them out of the way or as a result of syphillis).

to:

* Ignorance and Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a [[SerialKiller vicious knife-wielding criminal criminal]] and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straitjacket and dragged away screaming (which was [[TruthInTelevision a common fate]] for "women of loose morals", either for their families to get them out of the way or as a result of syphillis).


** An overlooked moment is shown when the ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sits on the staircase with Scrooge when he's watching the Cratchit family reminisce about Tiny Tim. You can see the ghost's hand on the wall behind Scrooge's head. In any other Christmas movie, this would be a gesture of comfort, but here, the gesture screams "Don't you dare look away, look at what you've done" and looks like the ghost is holding Scrooge's head so he won't be able to look away.

to:

** An overlooked moment is shown when the ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sits on the staircase with Scrooge when he's watching the Cratchit family reminisce about Tiny Tim. You can see the ghost's hand on the wall behind Scrooge's head. In any other Christmas movie, this would be a gesture of comfort, but here, the gesture screams "Don't you dare look away, look at what you've done" and looks like the ghost is [[ForcedToWatch holding Scrooge's head head]] so he won't be able [[ICantLookGesture to look away. away.]]


* Ignorance and Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a vicious knife-wielding criminal and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straitjacket and dragged away screaming.

to:

* Ignorance and Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a vicious knife-wielding criminal and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straitjacket and dragged away screaming.screaming (which was [[TruthInTelevision a common fate]] for "women of loose morals", either for their families to get them out of the way or as a result of syphillis).

Added DiffLines:

** An overlooked moment is shown when the ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sits on the staircase with Scrooge when he's watching the Cratchit family reminisce about Tiny Tim. You can see the ghost's hand on the wall behind Scrooge's head. In any other Christmas movie, this would be a gesture of comfort, but here, the gesture screams "Don't you dare look away, look at what you've done" and looks like the ghost is holding Scrooge's head so he won't be able to look away.

Added DiffLines:

* Once Marley has given his warning, he leaves through the window and drags Scrooge towards it... where he sees the streets of London FILLED with screaming ghosts of tortured souls, some bound to their own tortures. One is seen banging his head on the cinder block he is chained to, and another flies around a homeless woman clutching her child to keep it warm, shouting how he wishes he could help. Jesus.
* The Ghost of Christmas Past is presented as a candle with a face inside its flame, which is even more UncannyValley than everyone else - particularly with the creepy whisper he speaks in.


* The death scene of the Ghost of Christmas Present, which is more disturbing than in any other adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, [[spoiler:he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, still laughing all the while'', and then crumbles to dust.]]

to:

* The death scene of the Ghost of Christmas Present, which is more disturbing than in any other adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, [[spoiler:he he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, still laughing all the while'', and then crumbles to dust.]]


* The beginning of the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come scene involves Scrooge being chased by his own funeral wagon, driven by ghostly horses complete with RedEyesTakeWarning.

to:

* The beginning of the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come scene involves Scrooge being chased by his own Marley's funeral wagon, driven by ghostly horses complete with RedEyesTakeWarning.


* The beginning of the Ghost of Christmas Future scene involves Scrooge being chased by his own funeral wagon, driven by ghostly horses complete with RedEyesTakeWarning.

to:

* The beginning of the Ghost of Christmas Future Yet to Come scene involves Scrooge being chased by his own funeral wagon, driven by ghostly horses complete with RedEyesTakeWarning.RedEyesTakeWarning.
* The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is a LivingShadow, and is almost never seen in 3D, being up against the wall, floor, in Scrooge's shadow, or slithering across bedsheets as it tries to make Scrooge look at his own corpse.


* The entire Ghost of Christmas Future scene, involving Scrooge being chased by his own funeral wagon, driven by ghostly horses complete with RedEyesTakeWarning.

to:

* Marley's corpse at the very beginning of the movie has two coins placed over his eyes while his glasses are turned up on his forehead. The entire Ghost of Christmas Future scene, involving overall look is somehow creepier than when Scrooge being chased steals the coins back.
* The whole scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced
by throwing his ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own funeral wagon, driven by jaw'' and, still needing to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds.
** Even worse is his very first appearance: after Scrooge approaches the door to his home, he drops his keys. After bending down to pick them up, he is surprised to see a green
ghostly horses face (Marley) in the door knocker. Reaching out to touch it, we are then greeted with the horrifying sight of '''''his eyes and mouth suddenly opening, complete with RedEyesTakeWarning.his teeth flying out and a very loud bang'''''. Many have commented that this is the scariest jump scare in the film, and for ''very good'' reason.



* The whole scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced by throwing his ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own jaw'' and, still needing to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds.
** Even worse is his very first appearance: after Scrooge approaches the door to his home, he drops his keys. After bending down to pick them up, he is surprised to see a green ghostly face (Marley) in the door knocker. Reaching out to touch it, we are then greeted with the horrifying sight of '''''his eyes and mouth suddenly opening, complete with his teeth flying out and a very loud bang'''''. Many have commented that this is the scariest jump scare in the film, and for ''very good'' reason.

to:

* The whole beginning of the Ghost of Christmas Future scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced involves Scrooge being chased by throwing his own funeral wagon, driven by ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own jaw'' and, still needing to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds.
** Even worse is his very first appearance: after Scrooge approaches the door to his home, he drops his keys. After bending down to pick them up, he is surprised to see a green ghostly face (Marley) in the door knocker. Reaching out to touch it, we are then greeted with the horrifying sight of '''''his eyes and mouth suddenly opening,
horses complete with his teeth flying out and a very loud bang'''''. Many have commented that this is the scariest jump scare in the film, and for ''very good'' reason.RedEyesTakeWarning.


* As said in the ''Film'' page, this movie is '''full''' of [[JumpScare jump scares]].
* The entire Ghost of Christmas future scene, involving Scrooge being chased by his own funeral wagon, driven by a ''literal'' pair of Night Mares (complete with RedEyesTakeWarning).
* The death scene of [[spoiler: the Ghost of Christmas Present, which is more disturbing than in any other adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, still laughing all the while'', and then crumbles to dust.]]
* On that note...Ignorance and Want.
** Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a vicious knife-wielding criminal and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straightjacket and dragged away screaming.
* The whole scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced by throwing his ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge (and the audience) by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own jaw'' and, still needed to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds. ''Eeeeeesh.''
** Even worse is his very first appearance: after Scrooge approaches the door to his home, he drops his keys. After bending down to pick them up, he is surprised to see a green ghostly face (Marley) in the door knocker. Reaching out to touch it, we are then greeted with the horrifying sight of '''''his eyes and mouth suddenly opening, complete with his teeth flying out and a very loud bang'''''.
*** Many have commented that this is the scariest jump scare in the film, and for ''very good'' reason.

to:

* As said in the ''Film'' page, this This movie is '''full''' of [[JumpScare jump scares]].
* The entire Ghost of Christmas future Future scene, involving Scrooge being chased by his own funeral wagon, driven by a ''literal'' pair of Night Mares (complete ghostly horses complete with RedEyesTakeWarning).
RedEyesTakeWarning.
* The death scene of [[spoiler: of the Ghost of Christmas Present, which is more disturbing than in any other adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, he [[spoiler:he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, still laughing all the while'', and then crumbles to dust.]]
* On that note...Ignorance and Want.
**
Want. Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a vicious knife-wielding criminal and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straightjacket straitjacket and dragged away screaming.
* The whole scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced by throwing his ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge (and the audience) by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own jaw'' and, still needed needing to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds. ''Eeeeeesh.''
sounds.
** Even worse is his very first appearance: after Scrooge approaches the door to his home, he drops his keys. After bending down to pick them up, he is surprised to see a green ghostly face (Marley) in the door knocker. Reaching out to touch it, we are then greeted with the horrifying sight of '''''his eyes and mouth suddenly opening, complete with his teeth flying out and a very loud bang'''''.
***
bang'''''. Many have commented that this is the scariest jump scare in the film, and for ''very good'' reason.reason.
----


* The death scene of [[spoiler: the Ghost of Christmas Present. Arguably the most disturbing and faithful scene to the original novel than in any other adaptation.]]

to:

* The death scene of [[spoiler: the Ghost of Christmas Present. Arguably the most Present, which is more disturbing and faithful scene to the original novel than in any other adaptation.adaptation. As in the novel, he rapidly ages, but instead of just disappearing when his time is up, he ''clutches his heart in pain'' with each chime as the clock strikes 12, then collapses. Then he ''turns into a skeleton, still laughing all the while'', and then crumbles to dust.]]



** When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straightjacket and dragged away screaming.

to:

** Instead of just being shown as two starving, ragged children, they also age before Scrooge's eyes into the type of adults that such children become if they're not saved. When Ignorance grows up, he becomes a vicious knife-wielding criminal and is locked away in jail. When Want is shown as a grown-up woman (most likely a prostitute), she is strapped in a straightjacket and dragged away screaming.


* The whole scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced by throwing his ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge (and the audience) by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own jaw'' and, still needed to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds. ''Eeeeeesh.''

to:

* The whole scene with Jacob Marley. He's introduced by throwing his ghostly safes through Scrooge's door, he floats in midair, his eyes rarely focus - and that's just his general appearance. He's constantly scaring Scrooge (and the audience) by screaming and howling, and at one point he ''dislocates his own jaw'' and, still needed to vent his anger, he jerks it up and down with a whole lot of cracking sounds. ''Eeeeeesh.''''
** Even worse is his very first appearance: after Scrooge approaches the door to his home, he drops his keys. After bending down to pick them up, he is surprised to see a green ghostly face (Marley) in the door knocker. Reaching out to touch it, we are then greeted with the horrifying sight of '''''his eyes and mouth suddenly opening, complete with his teeth flying out and a very loud bang'''''.
*** Many have commented that this is the scariest jump scare in the film, and for ''very good'' reason.

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/christmas_carol_disneyscreencapscom_1984.jpg]] [[caption-width-right:350:And you dare to say that this is "a movie for kids".]]
* As said in the ''Film'' page, this movie is '''full''' of [[JumpScare jump scares]].

Showing 15 edit(s) of 20

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report