Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / StupidScientist

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''How They're Going to Die''': Doing that thing where they treat the [[CuteMonster monster like it's cute]] but then it rips their face off.\\

to:

-->'''How They're Going to Die''': Doing that thing where they treat the [[CuteMonster [[AdmiringTheAbomination monster like it's cute]] but then it rips their face off.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/TheBirds'', the main characters meet an ornithologist who is in complete denial over the title creatures flocking together to attack humans.

to:

* In ''Film/TheBirds'', the main characters meet an ornithologist who is in complete denial over the title creatures flocking together to attack humans. One bird attack later, [[BreakTheHaughty she is also keeping one eye on the sky]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->-- '''Ogilvy''', ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898''. ([[Music/JeffWaynesMusicalVersionOfTheWarOfTheWorlds But still]], [[AlienInvasion they come…]]])

to:

-->-- '''Ogilvy''', ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898''. ([[Music/JeffWaynesMusicalVersionOfTheWarOfTheWorlds But still]], [[AlienInvasion they come…]]])
come…]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->-- '''Ogilvy''', ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898''

to:

-->-- '''Ogilvy''', ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898''
''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898''. ([[Music/JeffWaynesMusicalVersionOfTheWarOfTheWorlds But still]], [[AlienInvasion they come…]]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheStrangeCaseOfDoctorJekyllAndMrHyde'': The "great Dr. Lanyon, who lives in Cavendish Square, that citadel of medicine", was one of the oldest friends of Dr. Jekyll, but for the last ten years he has seen little of him, due to Jekyll’s '"unscientific balderdash". Jekyll is very disappointed by Lanyon, because Lanyon calls his theories "scientific heresies" and considers Lanyon "an excellent fellow... but a hide-bound pedant for all that; an ignorant, blatant pedant". Consider that Dr. Jekyll has three doctorates, he is a FRS (Fellow of the Real Society) [[note]]FRS has been described by The Guardian newspaper as ''the equivalent of a lifetime achievement Oscar''.[[/note]] and a famous doctor, in other words, Dr. Jekyll is a respected colleague and not just an [[TheCuckoolanderWasRight eccentric, insane or paranoid person who also happens to be right]]. At chapter nine, Dr. Lanyon pays the ultimate price for this error [[spoiler:when he witnesses Mr. Hyde mix up the transformation potion right before his eyes and take it to return to being Dr. Jekyll, but not before indulging a moment to mock Lanyon for his own mockery of Jekyll's work. The shock of this [[GodMadFromTheRevelation eventually kills him]].]]

to:

* In ''Literature/TheStrangeCaseOfDoctorJekyllAndMrHyde'': ''Literature/TheStrangeCaseOfDrJekyllAndMrHyde'': The "great Dr. Lanyon, who lives in Cavendish Square, that citadel of medicine", was one of the oldest friends of Dr. Jekyll, but for the last ten years he has seen little of him, due to Jekyll’s Jekyll's '"unscientific balderdash". Jekyll is very disappointed by Lanyon, because Lanyon calls his theories "scientific heresies" and considers Lanyon "an excellent fellow... but a hide-bound pedant for all that; an ignorant, blatant pedant". Consider that Dr. Jekyll has three doctorates, he is a FRS (Fellow of the Real Society) [[note]]FRS has been described by The Guardian newspaper as ''the equivalent of a lifetime achievement Oscar''.[[/note]] and a famous doctor, in other words, Dr. Jekyll is a respected colleague and not just an [[TheCuckoolanderWasRight eccentric, insane or paranoid person who also happens to be right]]. At In chapter nine, Dr. Lanyon pays the ultimate price for this error [[spoiler:when he witnesses Mr. Hyde mix up the transformation potion right before his eyes and take it to return to being Dr. Jekyll, but not before indulging a moment to mock Lanyon for his own mockery of Jekyll's work. The shock of this [[GodMadFromTheRevelation eventually kills him]].]]him]]]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheStrangeCaseOfDoctorJekyllAndMrHyde'': The "great Dr. Lanyon, who lives in Cavendish Square, that citadel of medicine", was one of the oldest friends of Dr. Jekyll, but for the last ten years he has seen little of him, due to Jekyll’s '"unscientific balderlash". Jekyll is very disappointed by Lanyon, because Lanyon calls his theories "scientific heresies" and considers Lanyon "an excellent fellow... but a hide-bound pedant for all that; an ignorant, blatant pedant". Consider that Dr. Jekyll has three doctorates, he is a FRS (Fellow of the Real Society) [[note]]FRS has been described by The Guardian newspaper as ''the equivalent of a lifetime achievement Oscar''.[[/note]] and a famous doctor, in other words, Dr. Jekyll is a respected colleague and not just an [[TheCuckoolanderWasRight eccentric, insane or paranoid person who also happens to be right]]. At chapter nine, Dr. Lanyon pays the ultimate price for this error.

to:

* In ''Literature/TheStrangeCaseOfDoctorJekyllAndMrHyde'': The "great Dr. Lanyon, who lives in Cavendish Square, that citadel of medicine", was one of the oldest friends of Dr. Jekyll, but for the last ten years he has seen little of him, due to Jekyll’s '"unscientific balderlash".balderdash". Jekyll is very disappointed by Lanyon, because Lanyon calls his theories "scientific heresies" and considers Lanyon "an excellent fellow... but a hide-bound pedant for all that; an ignorant, blatant pedant". Consider that Dr. Jekyll has three doctorates, he is a FRS (Fellow of the Real Society) [[note]]FRS has been described by The Guardian newspaper as ''the equivalent of a lifetime achievement Oscar''.[[/note]] and a famous doctor, in other words, Dr. Jekyll is a respected colleague and not just an [[TheCuckoolanderWasRight eccentric, insane or paranoid person who also happens to be right]]. At chapter nine, Dr. Lanyon pays the ultimate price for this error. error [[spoiler:when he witnesses Mr. Hyde mix up the transformation potion right before his eyes and take it to return to being Dr. Jekyll, but not before indulging a moment to mock Lanyon for his own mockery of Jekyll's work. The shock of this [[GodMadFromTheRevelation eventually kills him]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* An odd example of this can be found in scientists who are tricked by psychics, with people like Uri Gellar sometimes beating a few of them. James Randi, a skeptic inquirer who was trained as a stage magician and exposed Gellar and others like him, noted that scientists aren't really trained to detect misdirection from con artists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting a big chunk of natter and complaining


** Which is why it is stupid, anyway. We are talking about a super high-profile project, that no one has ever attempted before, comprising a park of dangerous animals for which the world knows next to nothing, and there is only ONE person responsible for the security system? This is one lousy security system and management of a project. The investors must be equally stupid to even allow this. It was a disaster waiting to happen rather than unpredictability, as described by Ian Malcolm.
*** The story tries to chalk it off with Hammond's obsession with automation, though "spared no expense" appears to be a big, fat lie, in any case. The book goes even further to the incredibly stupid mistakes made in the name of saving money or protecting the dinosaurs at the expense of human safety due to their monetary value. The AccidentalAesop ends up being "capitalism ruins science", not "life finds a way".

Added: 246

Changed: 37

Removed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Comics]]

to:

[[folder:Comics]][[folder:Comic Books]]



* The Doctor from ''Webcomic/TheStupiders'', who not only didn't notice the extreme side effects of his work on the population of Earth, but suggested he should "fix" any so-called issues by creating more of what caused the problem to begin with!






* The quoted example is from ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds'' by Creator/HGWells. Ogilvy, a "well-known astronomer", says that to the narrator at the beginning of the book, right when [[AlienInvasion Martian cylinders are heading to Earth.]] [[HilariousInHindsight Nice]]. To be fair, however, Ogilvy is trying to be rational, and at that point in the story he may be more accurately described personality-wise as an AgentScully.

to:

* The quoted example is from ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds'' ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898'' by Creator/HGWells. Ogilvy, a "well-known astronomer", says that to the narrator at the beginning of the book, right when [[AlienInvasion Martian cylinders are heading to Earth.]] [[HilariousInHindsight Nice]]. To be fair, however, Ogilvy is trying to be rational, and at that point in the story he may be more accurately described personality-wise as an AgentScully.



* ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'': the overwhelming majority of the Adeptus Mechanicus tends to show this kind of behavior, notably in regards to the Necrons. They will happily position major facilities over tomb-worlds and attempt to wake up sleeping Necrons which they see as agents of the Machine God, [[RobotWar without ever thinking of what happens when a sentient lifeform is detected by the Necrons...]]

to:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'': the ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'': The overwhelming majority of the Adeptus Mechanicus tends to show this kind of behavior, notably in regards to the Necrons. They will happily position major facilities over tomb-worlds and attempt to wake up sleeping Necrons which they see as agents of the Machine God, [[RobotWar without ever thinking of what happens when a sentient lifeform is detected by the Necrons...]]Necrons]]...



* The ''[[WebAnimation/DorklyOriginals Dorkly]]'' article, “[[http://www.dorkly.com/post/60847/these-8-characters-are-definitely-going-to-die These Eight Characters are Definitely Going to Die]]”, includes in the list, "The Scientist".
-->'''How They’re Going to Die''': Doing that thing where they treat the [[CuteMonster monster like it’s cute]] but then it rips their face off.
-->'''Why''': Because [[ScienceIsBad doing experimental research and gathering evidence is the very height of man’s hubris]].

to:

* The ''[[WebAnimation/DorklyOriginals Dorkly]]'' article, “[[http://www.article "[[http://www.dorkly.com/post/60847/these-8-characters-are-definitely-going-to-die These Eight Characters are Definitely Going to Die]]”, Die]]" includes in the list, "The Scientist".
-->'''How They’re They're Going to Die''': Doing that thing where they treat the [[CuteMonster monster like it’s it's cute]] but then it rips their face off.
-->'''Why''':
off.\\
'''Why''':
Because [[ScienceIsBad doing experimental research and gathering evidence is the very height of man’s hubris]].man's hubris]].
* The Doctor from ''Webcomic/TheStupiders'', who not only didn't notice the extreme side effects of his work on the population of Earth, but suggested he should "fix" any so-called issues by creating more of what caused the problem to begin with!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Dr. Mobius is briefly mentioned in the intro as being expected to refute claims that Tiberium is dangerous. He is fascinated with its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, ignoring his surroundings or even basic rules of safety to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic". However, when later he learns of the disastrous effect Tiberium had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that it was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.

to:

* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Dr. Mobius is briefly mentioned in the intro during a talk show as being expected to refute claims that Tiberium is dangerous. He is fascinated with its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, ignoring his surroundings or even basic rules of safety to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic".safety. However, when later he learns of the disastrous effect Tiberium had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that it was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Although a scientific genius and child prodigy, dr. Mobius is notoriously absent minded, as he focuses on his scientific research so much that he ignores his surroundings or even basic rules of safety. This trait has given him the doubtful honor of having risked his life more times than the average GDI commando, without actually stepping on the frontlines, to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic". He is fascinated with Tiberium and its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, while the player soon discovers that humans die horribly when walking in Tiberium fields. He's briefly mentioned in the intro as being expected to refute claims that Tiberium is dangerous. However, when later he learns of the disastrous effect this crystal entity had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that Tiberium was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.

to:

* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Although a scientific genius and child prodigy, dr. Dr. Mobius is notoriously absent minded, briefly mentioned in the intro as he focuses on his scientific research so much being expected to refute claims that he ignores his surroundings or even basic rules of safety. This trait has given him the doubtful honor of having risked his life more times than the average GDI commando, without actually stepping on the frontlines, to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic". Tiberium is dangerous. He is fascinated with Tiberium and its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, while ignoring his surroundings or even basic rules of safety to the player soon discovers point that humans die horribly when walking in Tiberium fields. He's briefly mentioned in the intro Kane refers to him as being expected to refute claims that Tiberium is dangerous. "an obvious lunatic". However, when later he learns of the disastrous effect this crystal entity Tiberium had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that Tiberium it was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Although a scientific genius and child prodigy, dr. Mobius is notoriously absent minded, as he focuses on his scientific research so much that he ignores his surroundings or even basic rules of safety. This trait has given him the doubtful honor of having risked his life more times than the average GDI commando, without actually stepping on the frontlines, to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic". He is fascinated with Tiberium and its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, while the player soon discovers that humans die horribly when walking in Tiberium fields. However, when he learns of the disastrous effect Tiberium had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that Tiberium was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.

to:

* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Although a scientific genius and child prodigy, dr. Mobius is notoriously absent minded, as he focuses on his scientific research so much that he ignores his surroundings or even basic rules of safety. This trait has given him the doubtful honor of having risked his life more times than the average GDI commando, without actually stepping on the frontlines, to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic". He is fascinated with Tiberium and its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, while the player soon discovers that humans die horribly when walking in Tiberium fields. He's briefly mentioned in the intro as being expected to refute claims that Tiberium is dangerous. However, when later he learns of the disastrous effect Tiberium this crystal entity had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that Tiberium was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Video Games]]
* ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerTiberianDawn'': Subverted. Although a scientific genius and child prodigy, dr. Mobius is notoriously absent minded, as he focuses on his scientific research so much that he ignores his surroundings or even basic rules of safety. This trait has given him the doubtful honor of having risked his life more times than the average GDI commando, without actually stepping on the frontlines, to the point that Kane refers to him as "an obvious lunatic". He is fascinated with Tiberium and its mutagenic properties, putting enthusiasm and almost gleeful fascination into its research, while the player soon discovers that humans die horribly when walking in Tiberium fields. However, when he learns of the disastrous effect Tiberium had on plants and animals, he changes his approach entirely, warning that Tiberium was potentially the greatest threat to humanity ever. He then dedicates himself to finding a cure for Tiberium-affected humans.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Kary Mullis won the Nobel prize in chemistry for his work on the Polymerase Chain Reaction, a precious laboratory technique to amplify DNA fragments in a sample. He was also a denier of global warming, the ozone hole, and HIV, and a supporter of astrology and parapsychology.
** Some of his arguments when criticizing those scientific issues were initially reasonable, for example he wanted for stronger proof that HIV was causing AIDS in humans during the late 80s/early 90s (when the scientific community had started not long time before to understand the disease), and lamented that the attitude when he was asking to other scientists for more info was that of an AppealToAuthority and DoYouTrustMe. But he didn't take into account that certain arguments were out of his field of expertise and he couldn't fully grasp what consisted in enough proof to insiders (like atmospheric physics); and whenever there was a situation that he deemed not convincing enough he didn't say "I want more evidence for now we can't get conclusions" but strongly supported a "therefore it's false" stance. Then, when he was effectively answered or presented with even new experimental evidence for any of these issues, he simply dismissed anything while never questioning quacks like Christine Maggiore (for whom he wrote the preface to her HIV-denialist book). He applied two weights and two different measures when using skepticism.

Top