Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 53 (click to see context) from:
* BewareTheNiceOnes: Subverted. The second wife eventually gains the courage to give reasonable orders to her new serving staff - as soon as she becomes [[spoiler: an accessory to murder.]] When Mrs. Danvers complains that it's now how "Mrs. de Winter" did things, the narrator reminds her that ''she'' is Mrs. de Winter and this is how she likes to order her meals.
to:
* BewareTheNiceOnes: Subverted. The second wife eventually gains the courage to give reasonable orders to her new serving staff - as soon as she becomes [[spoiler: an accessory to murder.]] When Mrs. Danvers complains that it's now not how "Mrs. de Winter" did things, the narrator reminds her that ''she'' is Mrs. de Winter now and this is how she likes to order her meals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 33 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalHeroism: The musical does this to Maxim by [[spoiler:eliminating his murder of Rebecca.]] By extension, this removes the potentially psychotic element from [[spoiler:his wife's decision to help him,]] helping to make her more sympathetic and heroic after TheReveal. It portrays her as becoming a confident woman that doesn't take Mrs. Danvers's bullying any longer so that the audience can root for her. She and Maxim [[spoiler: are seen as very happy together and kiss at the end]], which is much clearer than the ambiguous future of their relationship in the novel.
to:
* AdaptationalHeroism: The musical musical, much like the 1941 movie, does this to Maxim by [[spoiler:eliminating his murder of Rebecca.]] By extension, this removes the potentially psychotic element from [[spoiler:his wife's decision to help him,]] helping to make her more sympathetic and heroic after TheReveal. It portrays her as becoming a confident woman that doesn't take Mrs. Danvers's bullying any longer so that the audience can root for her. She and Maxim [[spoiler: are seen as very happy together and kiss at the end]], which is much clearer than the ambiguous future of their relationship in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* DoubleStandardAbuseFemaleOnMale: [[spoiler:Rebecca {{exploited}} this, having emotionally abused Maxim and sexually harassed Frank, knowing that due to societal conventions, neither would want to talk about it publicly. The fact that she played the perfect ProperLady in public only added to this; the idea that a woman, much less perfect, kind, elegant Rebecca, could torment a ''man'' would be seen as absurd, and Frank especially would, at best, be assumed to be lying if he said he didn't want any part of whatever went on between him and Rebecca, and at worst, be assumed to have been the aggressor. The narrative itself makes it clear that Rebecca's actions were awful regardless of gender.]]
Changed line(s) 137 (click to see context) from:
* LittleBlackDress: The second Mrs De Winter tries to impress Maxim by dressing up in a black dress she found in a fashion magazine, but he's put off because he can tell it's not her style.
to:
* LikeBrotherAndSister: The second Mrs. de Winter develops this dynamic with Maxim's attorney and close friend Frank. He's immediately welcoming to her and she quickly grows very comfortable around him, and while he's a reserved fellow, it's clear he returns the affection. She trusts Frank enough to confide in him about her insecurities regarding her marriage and ask him about matters she doesn't want to go to Maxim with. Favell, seeing how close they are, tastelessly accuses them of having an affair, but it's clear to the reader that Mrs. de Winter doesn't feel that way about Frank at all.
* LittleBlackDress: The second MrsDe de Winter tries to impress Maxim by dressing up in a black dress she found in a fashion magazine, but he's put off because he can tell it's not her style.
* LittleBlackDress: The second Mrs
Changed line(s) 139 (click to see context) from:
* LoveForgivesAllButLust: An interesting variation: The female lead spends the first half of the book moping because she thinks her husband is still in love with his (dead) first wife instead of her. Cue {{wangst}}. [[spoiler: But then it's revealed that he hated his first wife, and he actually murdered her. Murder? No problem! He doesn't love that minx; he loves me! (To be fair, it's presented like his first wife was The Vamp with absolutely no moral code and masterfully provoked him to do it... but still.)]]
to:
* LoveForgivesAllButLust: An interesting variation: The female lead spends the first half of the book moping because she thinks her husband is still in love with his (dead) first wife instead of her. Cue {{wangst}}. [[spoiler: But then it's revealed that he hated his first wife, and he actually murdered her. Murder? No problem! He doesn't love that minx; he loves me! (To be fair, it's presented like his first wife was The Vamp TheVamp with absolutely no moral code and masterfully provoked him to do it... but still.)]]
Changed line(s) 152 (click to see context) from:
* TheNicknamer: Rebecca seemed to have been one. She called Manderley Manders, Mrs. Danvers Danny and Maxim Max. Maxim does not seem to care much for the nickname, at least after her death when it reminds him of her. The narrator thinks this means she was close with Mrs. Danvers and Maxim, and wishes that she could use Max herself.
to:
* TheNicknamer: Rebecca seemed to have been one. She called Manderley Manders, "Manders", Mrs. Danvers Danny "Danny", and Maxim Max."Max". Maxim does not seem to care much for the nickname, at least after her death when it reminds him of her. The narrator thinks this means she was close with Mrs. Danvers and Maxim, and wishes that she could use Max herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hardsplit Series.Rebecca 1997
Changed line(s) 23,24 (click to see context) from:
Other adaptations include a 1938 radio dramatization on Creator/OrsonWelles' ''Campbell Playhouse'', a 1939 stage play, a 1979 miniseries on Creator/TheBBC starring Creator/JeremyBrett, a 1983 opera, a 1997 miniseries on Creator/{{ITV}} starring Creator/CharlesDance as Maxim de Winter and Creator/DianaRigg as Mrs. Danvers, a 2008 miniseries on [[Creator/{{RAI}} RAI1]] and a 2006 stage musical.
to:
Other adaptations include a 1938 radio dramatization on Creator/OrsonWelles' ''Campbell Playhouse'', a 1939 stage play, a 1979 miniseries on Creator/TheBBC starring Creator/JeremyBrett, a 1983 opera, [[Series/Rebecca1997 a 1997 miniseries miniseries]] on Creator/{{ITV}} starring Creator/CharlesDance as Maxim de Winter and Creator/DianaRigg as Mrs. Danvers, a 2008 miniseries on [[Creator/{{RAI}} RAI1]] and a 2006 stage musical.
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* AccidentalMurder: In the musical, [[spoiler: Maxim pushed Rebecca and she fell, though he says he's not entirely sure whether it was an accident or not.]] In the 1997 miniseries, [[spoiler:he strangled her to death after she provoked him.]]
to:
* AccidentalMurder: In the musical, [[spoiler: Maxim pushed Rebecca and she fell, though he says he's not entirely sure whether it was an accident or not.]] In the 1997 miniseries, [[spoiler:he strangled her to death after she provoked him.]]
Deleted line(s) 86 (click to see context) :
* DiedLaughing: [[spoiler:Rebecca, in the 1997 miniseries. ''As Maxim choked her to death.'']]
Deleted line(s) 172 (click to see context) :
* RedemptionEqualsAffliction: Downplayed in the 1997 version; Maxim saves the life of Mrs. Danvers at the cost of slight scarring and a limp.
Deleted line(s) 179 (click to see context) :
* SaveTheVillain: In the 1997 TV series, Maxim runs upstairs to save Mrs. Danvers from the fire.
Deleted line(s) 182 (click to see context) :
* SexualKarma: Played with in the 1997 miniseries. Maxim and the narrator are shown the morning after ''finally'' consummating their marriage, several months into it, blissfully reclining in one another's arms and treating one another with a newfound earthy affection. [[spoiler:This is also the morning after the narrator learned that Maxim killed Rebecca- and in this version, it was by ''strangling her to death in a fit of anger''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hardsplit Rebecca 2020
Changed line(s) 25,26 (click to see context) from:
A new adaptation was filmed for Netflix, directed by Ben Wheatley (''Film/HighRise'', ''[[Film/FreeFire2017 Free Fire]]'', ''Film/KillList'') and starring Creator/LilyJames as the second Mrs. de Winter, Creator/ArmieHammer as Maxim de Winter and Creator/KristinScottThomas as Mrs. Danvers. It premiered on October 21st 2020, the day before what would have been Joan Fontaine's 103rd birthday.
to:
[[Film/Rebecca2020 A new adaptation adaptation]] was filmed for Netflix, Creator/{{Netflix}}, directed by Ben Wheatley (''Film/HighRise'', ''[[Film/FreeFire2017 Free Fire]]'', ''Film/KillList'') and starring Creator/LilyJames as the second Mrs. de Winter, Creator/ArmieHammer as Maxim de Winter and Creator/KristinScottThomas as Mrs. Danvers. It premiered on October 21st 2020, the day before what would have been Joan Fontaine's 103rd birthday.
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* AccidentalMurder: In the musical, [[spoiler: Maxim pushed Rebecca and she fell, though he says he's not entirely sure whether it was an accident or not.]] In the 2020 film, [[spoiler: Rebecca loaded the gun, put it in Maxim's hand, pushed the gun against her body and ''then'' taunted him into pulling the trigger.]] In the 1997 miniseries, [[spoiler:he strangled her to death after she provoked him.]]
to:
* AccidentalMurder: In the musical, [[spoiler: Maxim pushed Rebecca and she fell, though he says he's not entirely sure whether it was an accident or not.]] In the 2020 film, [[spoiler: Rebecca loaded the gun, put it in Maxim's hand, pushed the gun against her body and ''then'' taunted him into pulling the trigger.]] In the 1997 miniseries, [[spoiler:he strangled her to death after she provoked him.]]
Deleted line(s) 34,36 (click to see context) :
** Favell gets this in the 2020 film. In every other version he tries to cash in on his suspicions of Maxim by blackmailing him. In the 2020 film, he takes Maxim's check to the police as proof that Maxim murdered Rebecca.
* AdaptationalKarma: In the book, Mrs. Danvers escapes Manderly after she burns it to the ground. In the 2020 film, after burning Manderly and the boathouse, she jumps from the cliff to drown in the same waters where Rebecca's body was found.
* AdaptationalWimp: In every other version, Maxim responds to Favell's blackmail by calling the police. In the 2020 film, he caves and gives Favell the money. Unfortunately, this is the only version where Favell doesn't actually care about the money and Maxim ends up incriminating himself.
* AdaptationalKarma: In the book, Mrs. Danvers escapes Manderly after she burns it to the ground. In the 2020 film, after burning Manderly and the boathouse, she jumps from the cliff to drown in the same waters where Rebecca's body was found.
* AdaptationalWimp: In every other version, Maxim responds to Favell's blackmail by calling the police. In the 2020 film, he caves and gives Favell the money. Unfortunately, this is the only version where Favell doesn't actually care about the money and Maxim ends up incriminating himself.
Changed line(s) 47 (click to see context) from:
* AmbiguouslyGay: ... Mrs. Danvers, who is depicted as a lesbian as blatantly as the censors would allow, what with her caressing Rebecca's minks and lingerie, and talking about how Rebecca would undress in front of her and take a bath.
to:
* AmbiguouslyGay: ... AmbiguouslyGay:
** Mrs. Danvers, who is depicted as a lesbian as blatantly as the censors would allow, what with her caressing Rebecca's minks and lingerie, and talking about how Rebecca would undress in front of her and take a bath.
** Mrs. Danvers, who is depicted as a lesbian as blatantly as the censors would allow, what with her caressing Rebecca's minks and lingerie, and talking about how Rebecca would undress in front of her and take a bath.
Deleted line(s) 49 (click to see context) :
** The 2020 film has Mrs Danvers call Rebecca "The only person I loved".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21,22 (click to see context) from:
In 1940, Creator/AlfredHitchcock directed [[TheFilmOfTheBook the film version]], his first American project, which starred Creator/JoanFontaine and Creator/LaurenceOlivier. It received 11 UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}} nominations, winning for Best Picture and Best Cinematography (Black and White). It was the only Hitchcock film to win Best Picture, and Hitchcock didn't win Best Director--he never did, in fact, and had to settle for a lifetime achievement Oscar late in life.
to:
In 1940, Creator/AlfredHitchcock directed [[TheFilmOfTheBook [[Film/Rebecca1940 the film version]], his first American project, which starred Creator/JoanFontaine and Creator/LaurenceOlivier. It received 11 UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}} nominations, winning for Best Picture and Best Cinematography (Black and White). It was the only Hitchcock film to win Best Picture, and Hitchcock didn't win Best Director--he never did, in fact, and had to settle for a lifetime achievement Oscar late in life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hardsplitting Film.Rebecca 1940~
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* AccidentalMurder: In the Hitchcock film, [[spoiler:Maxim accidentally killed Rebecca; he got angry and pushed her, and she fell and struck her head.]] In the original novel, [[spoiler:he shot her, very much on purpose. She rather had it coming, to the point of taunting him into doing it.]] In the musical, [[spoiler: it's the same as the Hitchcock version, he pushed her and she fell, though he says he's not entirely sure whether it was an accident or not.]] In the 2020 film, [[spoiler: Rebecca loaded the gun, put it in Maxim's hand, pushed the gun against her body and ''then'' taunted him into pulling the trigger.]] In the 1997 miniseries, [[spoiler:he strangled her to death after she provoked him.]]
to:
* AccidentalMurder: In the Hitchcock film, [[spoiler:Maxim accidentally killed Rebecca; he got angry and pushed her, and she fell and struck her head.]] In the original novel, [[spoiler:he shot her, very much on purpose. She rather had it coming, to the point of taunting him into doing it.]] In the musical, [[spoiler: it's the same as the Hitchcock version, he Maxim pushed her Rebecca and she fell, though he says he's not entirely sure whether it was an accident or not.]] In the 2020 film, [[spoiler: Rebecca loaded the gun, put it in Maxim's hand, pushed the gun against her body and ''then'' taunted him into pulling the trigger.]] In the 1997 miniseries, [[spoiler:he strangled her to death after she provoked him.]]
Changed line(s) 33 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalHeroism: Both the Hitchcock film and the musical do this to Maxim by [[spoiler:eliminating his murder of Rebecca, the former by necessity of the Hays Code.]] By extension, this removes the potentially psychotic element from [[spoiler:his wife's decision to help him,]] helping to make her more sympathetic and heroic after TheReveal. The musical in particular portrays her as becoming a confident woman that doesn't take Mrs. Danvers's bullying any longer so that the audience can root for her. She and Maxim [[spoiler: are seen as very happy together and kiss at the end]], which is much clearer than the ambiguous future of their relationship in the novel.
to:
* AdaptationalHeroism: Both the Hitchcock film and the The musical do does this to Maxim by [[spoiler:eliminating his murder of Rebecca, the former by necessity of the Hays Code.Rebecca.]] By extension, this removes the potentially psychotic element from [[spoiler:his wife's decision to help him,]] helping to make her more sympathetic and heroic after TheReveal. The musical in particular It portrays her as becoming a confident woman that doesn't take Mrs. Danvers's bullying any longer so that the audience can root for her. She and Maxim [[spoiler: are seen as very happy together and kiss at the end]], which is much clearer than the ambiguous future of their relationship in the novel.
Changed line(s) 35,36 (click to see context) from:
* AdaptationalKarma: In the book, Mrs. Danvers escapes Manderly after she burns it to the ground. The film — by order of the Hays Code — shows her dying in the fire. In the 2020 film, after burning Manderly and the boathouse, she jumps from the cliff to drown in the same waters where Rebecca's body was found.
* AdaptationalVillainy: A consequence of the elimination of [[spoiler:Maxim's murder of Rebecca]] in the Hitchcock film is that Jack Favell's persecution of Maxim is now based completely on a falsehood. To his credit though, he seems to be as shocked as anyone when the truth is revealed - it seems that he genuinely thought that Maxim had killed Rebecca.
* AdaptationalVillainy: A consequence of the elimination of [[spoiler:Maxim's murder of Rebecca]] in the Hitchcock film is that Jack Favell's persecution of Maxim is now based completely on a falsehood. To his credit though, he seems to be as shocked as anyone when the truth is revealed - it seems that he genuinely thought that Maxim had killed Rebecca.
to:
* AdaptationalKarma: In the book, Mrs. Danvers escapes Manderly after she burns it to the ground. The film — by order of the Hays Code — shows her dying in the fire. In the 2020 film, after burning Manderly and the boathouse, she jumps from the cliff to drown in the same waters where Rebecca's body was found.
* AdaptationalVillainy: A consequence of the elimination of [[spoiler:Maxim's murder of Rebecca]] in the Hitchcock film is that Jack Favell's persecution of Maxim is now based completely on a falsehood. To his credit though, he seems to be as shocked as anyone when the truth is revealed - it seems that he genuinely thought that Maxim had killed Rebecca.found.
* AdaptationalVillainy: A consequence of the elimination of [[spoiler:Maxim's murder of Rebecca]] in the Hitchcock film is that Jack Favell's persecution of Maxim is now based completely on a falsehood. To his credit though, he seems to be as shocked as anyone when the truth is revealed - it seems that he genuinely thought that Maxim had killed Rebecca.
Deleted line(s) 62 (click to see context) :
* BitchAlert: The famous EstablishingCharacterMoment for Mrs. Danvers in the 1940 film, as she enters the room, sweeps out in front of the rest of the servants and walks toward the camera, with a fearsome, sour expression of disapproval on her face. Before Danvers even says one word you know the second Mrs. de Winter is going to have a major ordeal on her hands. Rather fittingly, the [[{{Film/Heartbreakers}} the trope namer]] was dressed to resemble Mrs Danvers.
Deleted line(s) 81 (click to see context) :
* CreatorCameo: In the 1940 film, Creator/AlfredHitchcock makes one of his signature cameos when he walks past Favell and the constable while they talk. There's about three minutes left in the film at that point, making it the latest Hitchcock cameo in any of his films.[[note]]After a while, he started to place his cameos very early in films, so the audience wouldn't spend all their time looking for him instead of paying attention to the story.[[/note]]
Changed line(s) 86 (click to see context) from:
* DeathByAdaptation: [[spoiler: Mrs. Danvers in the film. In the novel she escaped the burning house, but the Hays Code [[LaserGuidedKarma wouldn't allow her to survive]]. The musical takes this further and shows that this is a suicide]].
to:
* DeathByAdaptation: [[spoiler: Mrs. Danvers in the film. musical. In the novel she escaped the burning house, but in the Hays Code [[LaserGuidedKarma wouldn't allow her to survive]]. The musical takes this further and shows that this is a suicide]].she commits suicide.]]
Deleted line(s) 105 (click to see context) :
* EvilSoundsDeep: Creator/GeorgeSanders playing the role in the 1940 film adds this element to Jack Favell.
Deleted line(s) 134 (click to see context) :
* HonestJohnsDealership: In the 1940 film, it's revealed that Favell is a "motor car salesman", which suits his sleazy personality (presumably he tries to hustle wealthy customers to buy luxury cars, which again is perfectly in character for him).
Deleted line(s) 137,140 (click to see context) :
* ImpracticallyFancyOutfit: Played with in the film. The heroine, having just married [[TroubledButCute former widower]] [[IdleRich Maxim]], is desperate to prove herself a ProperLady (and not an InadequateInheritor to the titular [[PosthumousCharacter Rebecca]]). Hoping to [[ErmineCapeEffect appear elegant and tasteful]], she buys a [[PimpedOutDress fancy party dress]] from a fashion magazine... but quickly learns that it's completely out of place for a quiet evening at home, BigFancyHouse and FictionFiveHundred-status be damned.
* InCaseYouForgotWhoWroteIt: A particularly pompous example at the start of the 1940 film.
-->SELZNICK INTERNATIONAL presents its picturization of [[Creator/DaphneDuMaurier DAPHNE DU MAURIER'S]] celebrated novel ''REBECCA''
* INeedAFreakingDrink: In the 1940 film, Jack Favell, who was visibly crushed and devastated when he learned from Dr. Baker that [[spoiler:Rebecca had terminal cancer, which also let Maxim off the hook for her death]], says "I wish I had a drink."
* InCaseYouForgotWhoWroteIt: A particularly pompous example at the start of the 1940 film.
-->SELZNICK INTERNATIONAL presents its picturization of [[Creator/DaphneDuMaurier DAPHNE DU MAURIER'S]] celebrated novel ''REBECCA''
* INeedAFreakingDrink: In the 1940 film, Jack Favell, who was visibly crushed and devastated when he learned from Dr. Baker that [[spoiler:Rebecca had terminal cancer, which also let Maxim off the hook for her death]], says "I wish I had a drink."
Deleted line(s) 180 (click to see context) :
* PrimAndProperBun: Mrs. Danvers in the 1940 film always wears her hair in a tight bun, befitting her stern persona. It's not the usual type however, as she wears it in a plaited bun.
Deleted line(s) 200,201 (click to see context) :
* SingingInTheShower: Maxim is heard singing in his shower at the Monte Carlo hotel in the 1940 film. It prevents him from hearing an important phone call.
* SmugSnake: Slimy, conceited, amoral, constantly-smirking Jack Favell, especially as played by Creator/GeorgeSanders, is one of the smuggest snakes in media history. His getting sucker punched by Maxim at the climax is probably the most satisfying moment in the Hitchcock version.
* SmugSnake: Slimy, conceited, amoral, constantly-smirking Jack Favell, especially as played by Creator/GeorgeSanders, is one of the smuggest snakes in media history. His getting sucker punched by Maxim at the climax is probably the most satisfying moment in the Hitchcock version.
Deleted line(s) 207 (click to see context) :
* TableSpace: In the film, the table isn't quite as oversized as some examples, but they do sit on opposite ends.
Changed line(s) 226,232 (click to see context) from:
* WhamLine:
** In the novel.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I hated her!]]
** It's included in the 1940 film, but it's preceded by an equally potent example.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I knew where Rebecca's body was. Lying on that cabin floor on the bottom of the sea.]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Mrs. de Winter''': How did you know?]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': Because I put it there.]]
** In the novel.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I hated her!]]
** It's included in the 1940 film, but it's preceded by an equally potent example.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I knew where Rebecca's body was. Lying on that cabin floor on the bottom of the sea.]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Mrs. de Winter''': How did you know?]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': Because I put it there.]]
to:
* WhamLine:
**WhamLine: In the novel.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': -->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I hated her!]]
** It's included in the 1940 film, but it's preceded by an equally potent example.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I knew where Rebecca's body was. Lying on that cabin floor on the bottom of the sea.]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Mrs. de Winter''': How did you know?]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': Because I put it there.]]her!]]
**
** It's included in the 1940 film, but it's preceded by an equally potent example.
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': I knew where Rebecca's body was. Lying on that cabin floor on the bottom of the sea.]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Mrs. de Winter''': How did you know?]]
--->[[spoiler:'''Maxim''': Because I put it there.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"relative" is so funny and unnecessarily bc the man is literally in his 40s and 50s... yes early 20s is young. especially bc 21 was the legal age of majority in england at the time
Changed line(s) 40 (click to see context) from:
* AgeGapRomance: Downplayed. Maxim is a widower in his forties or fifties when he marries the heroine, who is in her early twenties. As much as they love one another, and even without the spectre of Rebecca haunting them, there is a lot of insecurity on both sides due to the age gap. Maxim occasionally wonders whether he is too old to relate to her, and if she would have been better off with someone her age, while the heroine is resentful of being treated like a child, and feels inferior to Maxim due to her relative youth and naivete.
to:
* AgeGapRomance: Downplayed. Maxim is a widower in his forties or fifties when he marries the heroine, who is in her early twenties. As much as they love one another, and even without the spectre of Rebecca haunting them, there is a lot of insecurity on both sides due to the age gap. Maxim occasionally wonders whether he is too old to relate to her, and if she would have been better off with someone her age, while the heroine is resentful of being treated like a child, and feels inferior to Maxim due to her relative youth and naivete.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 188 (click to see context) from:
* RewatchBonus: A literary example. [[spoiler:Rereading the book while knowing ahead of time that Rebecca was a monstrously cruel and manipulative person surfaces plenty of proof from others, and not just Maxim (who killed her), that that was the case. Bea's comments that the second Mrs de Winter is nothing like her seem far more firmly approving, Ben's terror that Rebecca was going to have him institutionalized stands out from the very beginning, Mrs. Danvers [[NightmareFetishist proudly recounts]] Rebecca [[CruellaToAnimals whipping a horse to death]]... Despite the book's reputation in pop culture as romanticizing a wife-murderer on his words alone, it's clear that plenty of other characters had nothing good to say about her either, or approved of her bad behavior, and the heroine's insecurity obscured it to both her and the audience.]]
to:
* RewatchBonus: A literary example. [[spoiler:Rereading the book while knowing ahead of time that Rebecca was a monstrously cruel and manipulative person surfaces plenty of proof from others, and not just Maxim (who killed her), that that was the case. Bea's comments that the second Mrs de Winter is nothing like her seem far more firmly approving, Ben's terror that Rebecca was going to have him institutionalized stands out from the very beginning, Mrs. Danvers [[NightmareFetishist proudly recounts]] Rebecca [[CruellaToAnimals whipping a horse to death]]...bloody]]... Despite the book's reputation in pop culture as romanticizing a wife-murderer on his words alone, it's clear that plenty of other characters had nothing good to say about her either, or approved of her bad behavior, and the heroine's insecurity obscured it to both her and the audience.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* FatalFlaw: For Rebecca, it's [[spoiler: her pride and overconfidence. Mrs. Danvers noted that she despised doctors and refused to see one unless absolutely necessary. This ends up costing her dearly, as her ovarian cancer goes unnoticed until it's too late.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* FishOutOfWater: The marked class differences between Maxim and the narrator are a significant source of insecurity for the latter. Unlike Rebecca, who was born in that world and was considered a shining example of an upper class woman, the narrator is looked down upon, sneered at and perceived as inadequate by the staff and feels overwhelmed by the amount of knowledge she lacks. She does not know anything about running an estate, dealing with servants and even the simple act of making tea for her guests is stressful to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
* TwentiesBobHaircut: Mrs Danvers relates how, against the advice of everyone who believed LongHairIsFeminine, Rebecca cut her hair into a modish short style that frames her face like 'a cloud of curls' a few years into her marriage. The second Mrs. de Winter also has a bob, but her hair is (at least, according to her) unflatteringly straight, childish and lank - yet another source of insecurity.
to:
* TwentiesBobHaircut: Mrs Danvers relates how, against the advice of everyone who believed LongHairIsFeminine, Rebecca cut her hair into a modish short style that frames her face like 'a cloud of curls' a few years into her marriage. The second Mrs. de Winter also has a bob, but her hair is (at least, according to her) unflatteringly straight, childish and lank - yet another source of insecurity. This isn't the case in the film, which has her with longer hair.
* BeautyIsBad: Rebecca was considered beautiful, fashionable and elegant, [[spoiler: and turns out to be an utterly rotten human]]. This contrasts to the heroine's look, who is considered plain, but she is a much nicer person.
Changed line(s) 61 (click to see context) from:
* BitchAlert: The famous EstablishingCharacterMoment for Mrs. Danvers in the 1940 film, as she enters the room, sweeps out in front of the rest of the servants and walks toward the camera, with a fearsome, sour expression of disapproval on her face. Before Danvers even says one word you know the second Mrs. de Winter is going to have a major ordeal on her hands.
to:
* BitchAlert: The famous EstablishingCharacterMoment for Mrs. Danvers in the 1940 film, as she enters the room, sweeps out in front of the rest of the servants and walks toward the camera, with a fearsome, sour expression of disapproval on her face. Before Danvers even says one word you know the second Mrs. de Winter is going to have a major ordeal on her hands. Rather fittingly, the [[{{Film/Heartbreakers}} the trope namer]] was dressed to resemble Mrs Danvers.
* LittleBlackDress: The second Mrs De Winter tries to impress Maxim by dressing up in a black dress she found in a fashion magazine, but he's put off because he can tell it's not her style.
Changed line(s) 164 (click to see context) from:
* OddFriendship: Aloof, judgmental Danvers and outgoing, sleazy Favell form a strange alliance in the story.
to:
* OddFriendship: OddFriendship:
** Aloof, judgmental Danvers and outgoing, sleazy Favell form a strange alliance in thestory.story.
** The blunt, no-filter Beatrice takes a fancy to the shy, demure heroine.
** Aloof, judgmental Danvers and outgoing, sleazy Favell form a strange alliance in the
** The blunt, no-filter Beatrice takes a fancy to the shy, demure heroine.
Changed line(s) 174 (click to see context) from:
%%* PrimAndProperBun: Mrs. Danvers in the film.
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example to Unwitting Instigator of Doom
Changed line(s) 209 (click to see context) from:
** The main character is the second wife of the eponymous Rebecca's husband. She's compared unfavorably to Rebecca without ever being told anything about her by his staff. Nothing is revealed aobut her as they figure she doesn't need to know, except that she died. In the end the protagonist learns more about Rebecca and [[spoiler:gains the respect of the inhabitants by saving them from a fire]].
to:
** The main character is the second wife of the eponymous Rebecca's husband. She's compared unfavorably to Rebecca without ever being told anything about her by his staff. Nothing is revealed aobut about her as they figure she doesn't need to know, except that she died. In the end the protagonist learns more about Rebecca and [[spoiler:gains the respect of the inhabitants by saving them from a fire]].
Added DiffLines:
** Before that, Frank Crawley. [[spoiler: When Maxim berates Mrs. Danvers for letting Jack Favell in the house, she assumes that the narrator informed him and decides to get even with her. This is the cause of the cruel trick at the fancy dress ball. It was actually ''Frank'' who told Maxim, after he saw Jack's car turn off to Manderley. Mrs. Danvers had no idea that he was even around.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 114,115 (click to see context) from:
*** Even more eloquent, in a subtle AbsenceOfEvidence way, is his answer to the narrator's question what Rebecca was like: [["I suppose she was the most
beautiful creature I ever saw." ''Period.'' For Frank, there was nothing to say for Rebecca apart from her extraordinary beauty.]]
beautiful creature I ever saw." ''Period.'' For Frank, there was nothing to say for Rebecca apart from her extraordinary beauty.]]
to:
*** Even more eloquent, in a subtle AbsenceOfEvidence way, is his answer to the narrator's question what Rebecca was like: [["I [[spoiler: "I suppose she was the most
most beautiful creature I ever saw." ''Period.'' For Frank, there was nothing to say for Rebecca apart from her extraordinary beauty.]]