Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HansBrinkerOrTheSilverSkates

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: The tale about the boy with his finger in the dike, which is only a small StoryWithinAStory, is actually more famous than Hans and his skates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
he's not a priest


Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. They skate all right, but on homemade wooden skates that stick after a few strokes. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a successful doctor.

to:

Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. They skate all right, but on homemade wooden skates that stick after a few strokes. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Meneer Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a successful doctor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS disambig


* BetaBitch: Rychie is the kind who is a PoisonousFriend to the Alpha Bitch Katrinka. Rychie can be nasty and even cruel; Katrinka is flighty and easily influenced.

to:

* BetaBitch: Rychie is the kind who is a PoisonousFriend ToxicFriendInfluence to the Alpha Bitch Katrinka. Rychie can be nasty and even cruel; Katrinka is flighty and easily influenced.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
revert


* IAmNotShazam: Many people call the dike-plugging boy Hans Brinker. In fact, he's never named and is the protagonist of a StoryWithinAStory told to Hans and his classmates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IAmNotShazam: Many people call the dike-plugging boy Hans Brinker. In fact, he's never named and is the protagonist of a StoryWithinAStory told to Hans and his classmates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UrbanLegend: The story of the boy who stuck his finger in the hole in the dike is BasedOnAGreatBigLie, with no basis in history or fact, nor is it even part of Dutch folklore. Interestingly, in 1953 there was an instance of a man whose quick thinking blocked a hole in a dike— using an entire cargo ship!

to:

* UrbanLegend: The story of the boy who stuck his finger in the hole in the dike is BasedOnAGreatBigLie, with no basis in history or fact, nor is it even part of Dutch folklore.folklore - for a good reason: Dutch dikes don't spring finger-sized leaks, they crumble in large sections. Interestingly, in 1953 there was an instance of a man whose quick thinking blocked a hole in a dike— using an entire cargo ship!

Changed: 35

Removed: 116

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ThatDidntHappen: The finger-in-the-dike story wasn't an actual historical event, nor is it part of Dutch folklore.



* UrbanLegend: The story of the boy who stuck his finger in the hole in the dike is BasedOnAGreatBigLie, with no basis in history or fact. Interestingly, in 1953 there was an instance of a man whose quick thinking blocked a hole in a dike— using an entire cargo ship!

to:

* UrbanLegend: The story of the boy who stuck his finger in the hole in the dike is BasedOnAGreatBigLie, with no basis in history or fact.fact, nor is it even part of Dutch folklore. Interestingly, in 1953 there was an instance of a man whose quick thinking blocked a hole in a dike— using an entire cargo ship!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UrbanLegend: The story of the boy who stuck his finger in the hole in the dike is BasedOnAGreatBigLie, with no basis in history or fact. Interestingly, in 1953 there was an instance of a man whose quick thinking blocked a hole in a dike— using an entire cargo ship!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"finger" isn't used in this way in the work itself.


* HaveAGayOldTime: [[AllLesbiansWantKids A little boy sticking his finger inside a hole in a dike]]? To prevent a ''"flood"''? Meaning the dyke is being fingered? Errrr...

Changed: 3

Removed: 215

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There is a subplot that often gets forgotten in the retelling of the story. A group of Dutch boys - Peter van Holp, Carl Schummel, Lambert van Mounen, Ludwig van Holp, Jacob Poot and Ben Dobbs - go on a multi-day skating journey to several of Holland' more famous towns. Much of the subplot consists of long conversations between Lambert and Ben on the history of Holland and the places they journey through.

to:

There is a subplot that often gets forgotten in the retelling of the story. A group of Dutch boys - Peter van Holp, Carl Schummel, Lambert van Mounen, Ludwig van Holp, Jacob Poot and Ben Dobbs - go on a multi-day skating journey to several of Holland' Holland's more famous towns. Much of the subplot consists of long conversations between Lambert and Ben on the history of Holland and the places they journey through.



* CompletelyDifferentTitle: The story is sometimes shortened to ''"Hans Brinker"'' or ''"Hans Brinker ''and'' the Silver Skates"'', while the original title is actually ''"Hans Brinker, ''or'' the Silver Skates"''.



* MusclesAreMeaningful: During the big race, Hans realizes that he isn't fit to win the race because he wasn't able to go on the skating tour of Holland with the other boys and is out of shape compared to them. [[Spoiler:So when Peter's skate string snaps, Hans, realizing he isn't going to win anyway and preferring that Peter win instead of Carl, drops out of the race and gives Peter his skate string.]]

to:

* MusclesAreMeaningful: During the big race, Hans realizes that he isn't fit to win the race because he wasn't able to go on the skating tour of Holland with the other boys and is out of shape compared to them. [[Spoiler:So [[spoiler:So when Peter's skate string snaps, Hans, realizing he isn't going to win anyway and preferring that Peter win instead of Carl, drops out of the race and gives Peter his skate string.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpoiledSweet: Hilda Van Gleck, unlike Rychie and Katrinka, thinks it's wrong to mistreat the Brinker family because of their misfortune. When Greta is too proud to accept charity, Hilda finds her a job. She's also willing to tell off Rychie for being nasty.

Added: 777

Changed: 211

Removed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBigRace

to:

* TheBigRaceTheBigRace: There is a big event with one race for the boys and one for the girls scheduled by the community, with a pair of fine silver skates as the prize for the winner. Most of the book builds up towards the big race.



* ChildrenAreInnocent



* FatAndSkinny: Jacob Poot, described by the narration as 'portly', and his very skinny English cousin Ben Dobbs. Someone compares the pair of them to a good slice of bacon - part lean part fat.



* TheGreatFlood


Added DiffLines:

* MusclesAreMeaningful: During the big race, Hans realizes that he isn't fit to win the race because he wasn't able to go on the skating tour of Holland with the other boys and is out of shape compared to them. [[Spoiler:So when Peter's skate string snaps, Hans, realizing he isn't going to win anyway and preferring that Peter win instead of Carl, drops out of the race and gives Peter his skate string.]]


Added DiffLines:

* StepfordSmiler: Katrinka grows up to be one of these - the narration often compares her to tinkling bells, and the epilogue says that some of the bells have grown out of tune.

Added: 233

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigFun: Jacob Poot is an understated example; overweight but extremely good natured and quick to laugh.



* LemonyNarrator: Most of the book was written with standard narration. In a few places it lapsed into Lemony Narration, such as when the narrator pondered why SantaClaus didn't visit the destitute Brinker household on Christmas. Most jarring, however, is the ending, when the narrator declared that the reader didn't care whether Hans or Peter won the race.
* MacGuffin: The skates

to:

* LemonyNarrator: Most of the book was written with standard narration. In a few places it lapsed into Lemony Narration, such as when the narrator pondered why SantaClaus didn't visit the destitute Brinker household on Christmas. Most jarring, however, is the ending, when the narrator declared that the reader didn't care whether Hans or Peter won the race.
race. The epilogue implies that [[spoiler:Rychie]] of all people might have been the narrator.
* MacGuffin: The skatesskates.


Added DiffLines:

* OverlyLongName: A 9 year old boy named Voostenwalbert Schimmelpenninck. He gets called 'a monkey with a long name for a tail.'

Added: 72

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilRedhead: Local lout and ruffian Janzoon Kolp has scruffy red hair.



* {{Jerkass}}: Almost everyone to the Brinkers. Carl and Rychie in particular are nasty towards anyone they consider below their social class. There's also Janzoon Koolp, who's essentially the town delinquent.

to:

* {{Jerkass}}: Almost everyone to the Brinkers. Carl and Rychie in particular are nasty towards anyone they consider below their social class. There's also Janzoon Koolp, Kolp, who's essentially the town delinquent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/edelm_brinker_1.png]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadSanta: There's a chapter involving the northern European tradition of having a guy playing St. Nicholas come to the house and tell all the children their good and bad deeds in detail. TruthInTelevision, and [[http://books.google.com/books?id=zxm--aRPUOgC&pg=PR14&dq=%22Alice+miller+relates+the+following+personal+experience%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=u81bUc2zI6n0iwLv_IDYBw&ved=0CDEQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22Alice%20miller%20relates%20the%20following%20personal%20experience%22&f=false some educators now discourage it]] as it can scare the crap out of younger children. [[note]]This tradition is also where the "[[BigBrotherIsWatching he sees you when you're sleeping]]" verse comes from, which [[http://www.neighborhoodarchive.com/publications/newsletters/atn0106/index.html Fred Rogers famously denounced]].[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: A poor brother and sister named [[HanselAndGretel Hans and Gretel]]? Hmm...

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: A poor brother and sister named [[HanselAndGretel [[Literature/HanselAndGretel Hans and Gretel]]? Hmm...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
zce are not allowed


* SpoiledSweet: Hilda Van Gleck, unlike the two other rich girls in the story [[RoyalBrat (Rychie and Katrinka).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheIngenue: Annie, an upper class girl Hans' age.

to:

* TheIngenue: Annie, an upper class girl Hans' Hans's age.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpoiledSweet: Hilda Van Gleck, unlike the two others rich girls in the story [[RoyalBrat (Rychie and Katrinka).]]

to:

* SpoiledSweet: Hilda Van Gleck, unlike the two others other rich girls in the story [[RoyalBrat (Rychie and Katrinka).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LandOfTulipsAndWindmills: This novel is easily the TropeCodifier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FlatCharacter: Lambert has precisely one characteristic - he speaks fluent English. This way, he can give Ben (and the reader) a lot of exposition and historical facts about Holland without having it colored by a personality.


Added DiffLines:

* TheIngenue: Annie, an upper class girl Hans' age.
* {{Jerkass}}: Almost everyone to the Brinkers. Carl and Rychie in particular are nasty towards anyone they consider below their social class. There's also Janzoon Koolp, who's essentially the town delinquent.


Added DiffLines:

* UnclePennybags: Peter and Hilda respectively try to find ways to help Hans and Gretel earn money, since the Brinkers are too proud to beg or accept charity. They both got it from their families.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a successful doctor.

to:

Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. They skate all right, but on homemade wooden skates that stick after a few strokes. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a successful doctor.

Added: 725

Changed: 108

Removed: 95

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. Gretel wins the girls' race, but Hans lets a friend--who is worse off than himself--win the boys' race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a succesful doctor.

to:

Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. Gretel wins the girls' race, but Hans lets a friend--who is worse off than himself--win the boys' race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a succesful doctor.
successful doctor.

There is a subplot that often gets forgotten in the retelling of the story. A group of Dutch boys - Peter van Holp, Carl Schummel, Lambert van Mounen, Ludwig van Holp, Jacob Poot and Ben Dobbs - go on a multi-day skating journey to several of Holland' more famous towns. Much of the subplot consists of long conversations between Lambert and Ben on the history of Holland and the places they journey through.

In the end, Gretel wins the Girls' Race. When Peter's skate strap breaks before the third heat of the Boys' Race, Hans gives Peter his own skate strap allowing Peter to win.



* BittersweetEnding: Gretel and Peter win the skates, and almost everyone turns out fairly well. [[spoiler:Except for poor Jacob, who dies.]]



* HappyEnding



* NoBudget: Hans and his sister have no money to pay for their father's operation.



* StoryWithinAStory: In a case of PopculturalOsmosis The story about the dike-plugging boy is actually read to Hans Brinker in class.

to:

* StoryWithinAStory: In a case of PopculturalOsmosis The PopculturalOsmosis, the story about the dike-plugging boy is actually read to Hans Brinker in class.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlphaBitch: Katrinka. She's not bad as alpha bitches go and the narrator points out that she'd be a kinder person if her best friend was Hilda instead of Rychie.
* BetaBitch: Rychie is the kind who is a PoisonousFriend to the Alpha Bitch Katrinka. Rychie can be nasty and even cruel; Katrinka is flighty and easily influenced.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A lot of common misconceptions are attributed to this novel:

to:

A There are a lot of common misconceptions are attributed to surrounding this novel:

Changed: 38

Removed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hans and Gretel\'s father is never drunk in the book.


Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father became a short-tempered alcoholic as a result and the children have to work to support the family. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. Gretel wins the girls' race, but Hans lets a friend--who is worse off than himself--win the boys' race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a succesful doctor.

to:

Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father became a short-tempered alcoholic has mental problems as a result and the children have to work to support the family. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. Gretel wins the girls' race, but Hans lets a friend--who is worse off than himself--win the boys' race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a succesful doctor.



* AbusiveParents: Hans and Gretel's father is a violent drunk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Hans Brinker,'' also known as ''"Hans Brinker, or the Silver Skates"'' and ''"Hans Brinker ''and'' the Silver Skates"'' is an 1865 children's novel written by American author Mary Mapes Dodge.

Hans is a 15-year-old boy who, together with his younger sister Gretel, yearns to participate in a great ice-skating race on the canal. The main prize is a pair of silver skates. Unfortunately, they come from a very poor family with a father who is unable to work since a fall from a dike. The father became a short-tempered alcoholic as a result and the children have to work to support the family. After Dr. Boekman is persuaded to examine their father, the doctor concludes that Father Brinker could be cured by a risky and expensive operation involving trephining. Despite saving money to buy himself some steel skates, Hans offers the doctor everything he has. This touches Dr. Boekman so much that he offers to provide the surgery for free, thus enabling Hans to buy good skates and participate in the race. Gretel wins the girls' race, but Hans lets a friend--who is worse off than himself--win the boys' race. The operation is a success and from now on, Dr. Boekman is a much kinder man who helps Hans into becoming a succesful doctor.

A lot of common misconceptions are attributed to this novel:
# The best-known part is the scene where a boy plugs a dike with his finger and thus prevents a large flood from happening. This tale is actually only a StoryWithinAStory. Hans reads about it in class. It has nothing to do with Hans Brinker himself.
# Never in Dutch history has a small boy ever prevented a flood by sticking his finger inside a hole in a dike. Nor did Mary Mapes Dodge think it up. It already circulated a few years earlier and is clearly a legend.
# Neither story is part of Dutch folklore. In fact, the story is hardly known in the Netherlands itself. The only reason you can find statues of a boy plugging a dike in Madurodam, Harlingen and Spaarlingen is to please tourists.
----
!!This novel provides examples of:
* AbusiveParents: Hans and Gretel's father is a violent drunk.
* TheBigRace
* ChildhoodFriendRomance: As revealed by the final chapter, Hans and Annie.
* ChildrenAreInnocent
* CompletelyDifferentTitle: The story is sometimes shortened to ''"Hans Brinker"'' or ''"Hans Brinker ''and'' the Silver Skates"'', while the original title is actually ''"Hans Brinker, ''or'' the Silver Skates"''.
* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: A poor brother and sister named [[HanselAndGretel Hans and Gretel]]? Hmm...
* TheGreatFlood
* HappyEnding
* HaveAGayOldTime: [[AllLesbiansWantKids A little boy sticking his finger inside a hole in a dike]]? To prevent a ''"flood"''? Meaning the dyke is being fingered? Errrr...
* HeelFaceTurn: Dr. Boekman, who was gruffy and sympathetic at first, but was so touched by Hans and Gretel's innocence and unselfishness that he changed his ways.
* KidHero: The ''"Hero of Haarlem"'' and Hans himself as well, of course
* LemonyNarrator: Most of the book was written with standard narration. In a few places it lapsed into Lemony Narration, such as when the narrator pondered why SantaClaus didn't visit the destitute Brinker household on Christmas. Most jarring, however, is the ending, when the narrator declared that the reader didn't care whether Hans or Peter won the race.
* MacGuffin: The skates
* NoBudget: Hans and his sister have no money to pay for their father's operation.
* NoNameGiven: The dike-plugging boy is never named but is simply called ''"The Hero of Haarlem"''.
* SmallRoleBigImpact: The tale about the boy with his finger in the dike, which is only a small StoryWithinAStory, is actually more famous than Hans and his skates.
* SpoiledSweet: Hilda Van Gleck, unlike the two others rich girls in the story [[RoyalBrat (Rychie and Katrinka).]]
* StoryWithinAStory: In a case of PopculturalOsmosis The story about the dike-plugging boy is actually read to Hans Brinker in class.
* ThatDidntHappen: The finger-in-the-dike story wasn't an actual historical event, nor is it part of Dutch folklore.
----

Top