Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / TheMuppetChristmasCarol

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's subtle, but the Ghost of Christmas Yet-To-Come is shown wrapping an arm around Scrooge several times whilst guiding him through the future, making him come off as slightly more friendly than usual. [[FridgeBrilliance It makes a fair bit of sense though]], given that despite his frightening appearance, his entire reason for existing is to ''help'' Scrooge.

to:

* It's subtle, but the Ghost of Christmas Yet-To-Come is shown wrapping an arm around Scrooge several times whilst guiding him through the future, making him come off as slightly more friendly than usual. [[FridgeBrilliance It makes a fair bit of sense though]], given that despite his frightening appearance, his entire reason for existing is he's ultimately there to ''help'' Scrooge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In one of the outtakes, after Bunsen flubs a line, Beaker playfully tickles him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There's also the exchange where Scrooge confesses to having never understood Christmas. Present assures him that he will "before this day is done."

Changed: 48

Removed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:''The love we found… the love we found…
we carry with us so we're never quite alone…'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''The love we found… found, the love we found…
found, we carry with us so we're never quite alone…'']]

Added: 48

Changed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:''The Love We Found'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''The Love We Found'']]love we found… the love we found…
we carry with us so we're never quite alone…'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As further example of Caine's commitment, his delivery of, "it's Fozziwig's rubber chicken factory!" It's a patently ridiculous line for any actor, and yet the way Scrooge says it is one of delighted, sincere nostalgia -- he hasn't thought in years about the good times he spent here, but he's never truly forgotten them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some versions of the Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come go all NightmareFuel on Scrooge, with the Mickey Mouse version burying him alive in his coffin. That doesn't happen here; the ghost gently but firmly gestures for Scrooge to go to his grave, and lets the man hug him while crying.

to:

* Some versions of the Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come go all NightmareFuel on Scrooge, with the Mickey Mouse version burying straight up knocking him alive in into his coffin.grave. That doesn't happen here; the ghost gently but firmly gestures for Scrooge to go to his grave, and lets the man hug him while crying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Actually, the Ghost himself is probably a walking heartwarming moment. The Ghost of Christmas Past has no sympathy for Scrooge and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is outright menacing. By contrast, this one is chuckling almost all the time he's around Scrooge. He really embodies the joy and brotherliness of Christmas, viewing Scrooge more a man who's gone astray, gently correcting him most of the time, and passing him off to the next ghost with an encouraging 'Go forth and know him better, man!' All of this can be attributed to Jerry Nelson's brilliant voice and puppeteering performance.
*** Not only that, the way the Ghost says it seems like he's also saying 'Go forth and know him, better man.' He was hinting that Scrooge had ''already'' become a better man.

to:

** Actually, the Ghost himself is probably a walking heartwarming moment. The Ghost of Christmas Past has no doesn't show sympathy for Scrooge and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is outright menacing. By contrast, this one is chuckling almost all the time he's around Scrooge. He really embodies the joy and brotherliness of Christmas, viewing Scrooge more a man who's gone astray, gently correcting him most of the time, and passing him off to the next ghost with an encouraging 'Go forth and know him better, man!' All of this can be attributed to Jerry Nelson's brilliant voice and puppeteering performance.
*** Not only that, the way the Ghost says it seems like he's also saying 'Go forth and know him, better man.' He was hinting that Scrooge had ''already'' become a better man.man, even as he's essentially saying a variation of his first sentence to Scrooge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During the first song, the other characters sincerely wonder if Scrooge only acts mean because he's secretly lonely and sad, and if there's a good person in there who just needs a chance to show himself. They brush the idea off when he acts like a jerk to them, but still, it's a surprising display of compassion towards someone who, at that point, has done basically nothing to deserve it. And in the end, they were right--Scrooge ''is'' capable of being a really good person!

to:

* During the first song, the other characters sincerely wonder if Scrooge only acts mean because he's secretly lonely and sad, and if there's a good person in there who just needs a chance to show himself. They brush the idea off when he acts like a jerk to coldly ignores them, but still, it's a surprising display of compassion towards someone who, at that point, has done basically nothing to deserve it. And in the end, they were right--Scrooge ''is'' capable of being a really good person!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Jacob:''' Without these visits, you cannot hope to avoid the fate ''we'' did!

to:

-->'''Jacob:''' Without these visits, you cannot hope to avoid the fate path ''we'' did!tread!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** To top it all off, Bunsen gives Beaker a proud little pat on the shoulder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fred invites his uncle to spend Christmas with him and his wife. When Scrooge refuses, Fred leaves a wreath for decoration, gives some coin to Beaker and Honeydew collecting charity money, and says the invitation is open. He has a good heart.

to:

* Fred invites his uncle to spend Christmas with him and his wife. When Scrooge refuses, Fred leaves a wreath for decoration, gives some coin to Beaker and Honeydew collecting charity money, and says the invitation is open. He While this version of Fred may be [[AdaptationalJerkass a bit more harsh and sarcastic]], he still has a good heart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Scrooge, for his part, seemed to genuinely like the Ghost of Christmas Present and was saddened when he disappeared.

to:

*** The extent to which Present, by Scrooge's own admission, changes him. Something about Present's warmth and guidance just talks to Scrooge, for his part, seemed to visibly defrosting him before our eyes. As Scrooge himself puts it, he genuinely like the Ghost of "had no idea" how wonderful Christmas Present was and was saddened when he disappeared. how good being good felt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Gonzo gets knocked off a carriage and knocked unconscious, Rizzo is so immediately and desperately concerned that he forgets he's supposed to be referring to him as Charles Dickens and just calls him Gonzo.

to:

** When Gonzo gets knocked thrown off a carriage and knocked unconscious, Rizzo is so immediately and desperately concerned that he forgets he's supposed to be referring to him as Charles Dickens and just calls him Gonzo.

Added: 453

Changed: 512

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A cut verse from [[VillainSong "Marley and Marley"]] actually manages to be this on some level--it can easily be read as the brothers sincerely telling their friend that it's not too late for him to redeem himself and be saved from the fate they suffered, which really hammers home how, as in the source material, this was likely their first and ''only'' true act of selflessness. Even better, it's on the soundtrack and on certainprints of the film:

to:

** When Gonzo gets knocked off a carriage and knocked unconscious, Rizzo is so immediately and desperately concerned that he forgets he's supposed to be referring to him as Charles Dickens and just calls him Gonzo.
* A cut verse from [[VillainSong "Marley and Marley"]] actually manages to be this on some level--it can easily be read as the brothers sincerely telling their friend that it's not too late for him to redeem himself and be saved from the fate they suffered, which really hammers home how, as in the source material, this was likely their first and ''only'' true act of selflessness. Even better, it's on the soundtrack and on certainprints certain prints of the film:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Bob gets home, his children all shriek "DADDY!" and {{glomp}} him, knocking the poor frog right over! It's utterly adorable. He also doesn't mind, just groaning a little and accepting Emily's smooches.

to:

** When Bob gets home, his children all shriek "DADDY!" and {{glomp}} GroupHug him, knocking the poor frog right over! It's utterly adorable. He also doesn't mind, just groaning a little and accepting Emily's smooches.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Jacob:''' Without these visits, you cannot hope to avoid the fate ''we'' did!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A cut verse from [[VillainSong "Marley and Marley"]] actually manages to be this on some level--it can easily be read as the brothers sincerely telling their friend that it's not too late for him to redeem himself and be saved from the fate they suffered, which really hammers home how, as in the source material, this was likely their first and ''only'' true act of selflessness. Even better, it's on the soundtrack:

to:

* A cut verse from [[VillainSong "Marley and Marley"]] actually manages to be this on some level--it can easily be read as the brothers sincerely telling their friend that it's not too late for him to redeem himself and be saved from the fate they suffered, which really hammers home how, as in the source material, this was likely their first and ''only'' true act of selflessness. Even better, it's on the soundtrack:soundtrack and on certainprints of the film:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Scrooge is terrified of the ghosts, and who could blame him for the way the Marleys appeared in chains? Then the Ghost of Christmas Past comes, and he says with wonder, "[[WouldntHurtAChild You are a child]]." Christmas Past is not nice, but they ease Scrooge's worries about the visitations. What's more, they promise Scrooge that they will keep him from falling when taking him into the past.

to:

* Scrooge is terrified of the ghosts, and who could blame him for the way the Marleys appeared in chains? Then the Ghost of Christmas Past comes, and he says with wonder, "[[WouldntHurtAChild You are a child]]." Christmas Past is not exactly nice, but they ease Scrooge's worries about the visitations. What's more, they promise Scrooge that they will keep him from falling when taking him into the past.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Scrooge:''' What an employer he was *chuckles* about as hard and as ruthless as a rose petal!

to:

-->'''Scrooge:''' What an employer he was was! *chuckles* about as As hard and as ruthless as a rose petal!

Added: 545

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also the fact that Emily Crachit is devoted to her husband [[ViolentlyProtectiveGirlfriend to the point where she threatens Scrooge with physical violence when it looks like he's come to their home to berate Bob.]]

to:

** Also the fact that Emily Crachit Cratchit is devoted to her husband [[ViolentlyProtectiveGirlfriend to the point where she threatens Scrooge with physical violence when it looks like he's come to their home to berate Bob.]]


Added DiffLines:

* "Spirit... tell me if Tiny Tim will live." Scrooge has only known the kid for five minutes and has no idea of the BadFuture yet, but upon seeing how sick Bob's youngest is, he's immediately concerned and just wants to know if he'll be okay. When the Ghost of Christmas Present says that he sees an empty chair in the future, Scrooge's face falls, and he looks [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone intensely remorseful]] at the realization of how Bob's poverty--and by extension, Scrooge's own greed--will devastate his family, and rob a young boy of his life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mixed with a TearJerker, but Scrooge's declaration when he slowly realizes the hated dead man in the future is him, resolving to be better and change this awful fate, and create a better future not only for himself, but for everyone. Just before he reads the name on the gravestone, he asks the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come if the future can be changed, and then, when he gets no answer, declares that it can, and it ''will'', sobbing, "A life ''can'' be made right!" It's a moment that just screams HeroicResolve, and shows just how much Scrooge has changed. For most men, this would be the DespairEventHorizon. For Scrooge, it's his rebirth.
-->'''Scrooge:''' [[ArmorPiercingQuestion Why would you show me this if I am past all hope?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Bob Cratchit/Kermit:''' "He told me that he hoped the people saw him in church because it might be pleasant for them to remember upon Christmas Day, [[GodIsGood who made lame beggars walk and blind men see.]]"

to:

-->'''Bob Cratchit/Kermit:''' "He He told me that he hoped the people saw him in church because it might be pleasant for them to remember upon Christmas Day, [[GodIsGood who made lame beggars walk and blind men see.]]"]]



'''Behind The Scenes:'''

to:

'''Behind !!Behind The Scenes:'''Scenes:



-->"There have been countless variants of Dickens’ yuletide redemption story, including versions starring [[WesternAnimation/MickeysChristmasCarol Mickey Mouse]], WesternAnimation/TheJetsons and [[WesternAnimation/MrMagoosChristmasCarol Mr. Magoo]]. But the greatest of these by far is ''The Muppet Christmas Carol''. Having Jim Henson’s famous felt creations anchor the film automatically punches up the fantastical elements of Dickens’ narrative – after all, this is a story of ghosts, magic, and time travel. But it is Michael Caine’s performance that makes it, and he acts opposite the Muppets as if they are flesh and blood. The seriousness with which he invests his performance makes it an explosion of emotion, a deeply felt interpretation of Dickens’ story rather than a parody of it – showing that the smartest way to renew a classic isn’t always with irony, but sincerity."

to:

-->"There have been countless variants of Dickens’ Dickens' yuletide redemption story, including versions starring [[WesternAnimation/MickeysChristmasCarol Mickey Mouse]], WesternAnimation/TheJetsons and [[WesternAnimation/MrMagoosChristmasCarol Mr. Magoo]]. But the greatest of these by far is ''The Muppet Christmas Carol''. Having Jim Henson’s Henson's famous felt creations anchor the film automatically punches up the fantastical elements of Dickens’ Dickens' narrative – after all, this is a story of ghosts, magic, and time travel. But it is Michael Caine’s Caine's performance that makes it, and he acts opposite the Muppets as if they are flesh and blood. The seriousness with which he invests his performance makes it an explosion of emotion, a deeply felt interpretation of Dickens’ Dickens' story rather than a parody of it – showing that the smartest way to renew a classic isn’t isn't always with irony, but sincerity."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Bob Cratchit/Kermit:''' "He said he hoped people saw him at church because it would be good for them to remember, on Christmas Day, [[GodIsGood Who made lame men walk and blind men see.]]"

to:

-->'''Bob Cratchit/Kermit:''' "He said told me that he hoped the people saw him at in church because it would might be good pleasant for them to remember, on remember upon Christmas Day, [[GodIsGood Who who made lame men beggars walk and blind men see.]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rizzo praises him for telling the story well. Gonzo's advice to read the book also comes off as sincere and heartwarming.

to:

* * Rizzo praises him for telling the story well. Gonzo's advice to read the book also comes off as sincere and heartwarming.

Top