Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / PiratesOfTheCaribbeanOnStrangerTides

Go To



-->'''Jack:''' The Fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh]]? ''[air quotes]'' "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs... [[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]

to:

-->'''Jack:''' The Fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your entire being ''alive'' to the very infinite mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh]]? ''[air quotes]'' "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs... [[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]


* [[AntiVillain The Spaniard]] taking a moment to request one of his men make a note of [[spoiler: Lieutenant Graves']] bravery in claiming the Fountain for England in the face of an entire force of elite Spanish soldiers, even though the act was his last. A WorthyOpponent moment at its finest between two hostile powers.

to:

* [[AntiVillain The Spaniard]] taking a moment to request one of his men make a note of [[spoiler: Lieutenant Graves']] Groves']] bravery in claiming the Fountain for England in the face of an entire force of elite Spanish soldiers, even though the act was his last. A WorthyOpponent moment at its finest between two hostile powers.

Added DiffLines:

* [[AntiVillain The Spaniard]] taking a moment to request one of his men make a note of [[spoiler: Lieutenant Graves']] bravery in claiming the Fountain for England in the face of an entire force of elite Spanish soldiers, even though the act was his last. A WorthyOpponent moment at its finest between two hostile powers.


-->'''Barbossa:''' ''[reveals a hidden stash of rum in his [[spoiler: peg leg]]]''\\

to:

-->'''Barbossa:''' ''[reveals -->'''Barbossa''' ''reveals a hidden stash of rum in his [[spoiler: peg leg]]]''\\leg]]''\\



'''Barbossa:''' [[PetTheDog ''[immediately shares his rum]'']]

to:

'''Barbossa:''' [[PetTheDog ''[immediately ''[[[PetTheDog immediately shares his rum]'']]rum]]]''


* The previous two films had showed Jack's interest in becoming immortal, hence why he was looking for the Fountain of Youth to begin with. But once Angelica tells him that the fountain requires the sacrifice of another life, Jack ''immediately'' comments that he's suddenly no longer as eager to make use of it.

to:

* The previous two films had showed Jack's interest in becoming immortal, hence why he was looking for the Fountain of Youth to begin with. But once Angelica tells him that the fountain requires the sacrifice of another life, Jack ''immediately'' comments that he's suddenly no longer as eager to make use of it.it.
** Also acts as a CallBack to [[Film/PiratesOfTheCaribbeanAtWorldsEnd the last time he had to choose between becoming immortal and saving a life]].


--> '''Jack:''' Hello, [[spoiler:dad.]]

to:

--> '''Jack:''' Hello, [[spoiler:dad.]]]]
* The previous two films had showed Jack's interest in becoming immortal, hence why he was looking for the Fountain of Youth to begin with. But once Angelica tells him that the fountain requires the sacrifice of another life, Jack ''immediately'' comments that he's suddenly no longer as eager to make use of it.


'''Barbossa:''' ''[immediately shares his rum]''

to:

'''Barbossa:''' [[PetTheDog ''[immediately shares his rum]''rum]'']]


* The whole opening scene where Jack saved Gibbs from being hanged.
* Mr. Gibbs making Captain Jack Sparrow [[spoiler: admit to having ''feelings'' about Angelica and she wasn't just like any other girl in his past]].
** [[spoiler:The ending, which shows that despite their screwed up relationship, Jack and Angelica ''still'' love each other, and always will]].

to:

* The whole opening scene where Jack saved saves Gibbs from being hanged.
* Mr. Gibbs making Captain Jack Sparrow [[spoiler: admit to having ''feelings'' about Angelica and that she wasn't isn't just like any other girl in his past]].
** [[spoiler:The ending, which shows that despite their screwed up screwed-up relationship, Jack and Angelica ''still'' love each other, and always will]].



--->'''Barbossa:''' *reveals a hidden stash of rum in his [[spoiler: peg leg]]*
--->'''Jack:''' [[PuppyDogEyes I want one of those.]]
--->'''Barbossa:''' *immediately shares his rum*
* After Barbossa admits to Jack that what he really wants is [[spoiler: revenge against Blackbeard for stealing the Black Pearl and costing Barbossa his leg]], Jack's response is a surprisingly heartfelt, "I'll see you get the chance, Mate." The heartwarming part comes when you realize that, while "Mate" is a [[TalkLikeAPirate fairly common pirate term]], he's using it here with the utmost sincerity to address his former ''first mate.''
** It's an acknowledgement that the two of them both loved the Black Pearl and Jack understands Barbossa's wish to avenge it.

to:

--->'''Barbossa:''' *reveals -->'''Barbossa:''' ''[reveals a hidden stash of rum in his [[spoiler: peg leg]]*
--->'''Jack:'''
leg]]]''\\
'''Jack:'''
[[PuppyDogEyes I want one of those.]]
--->'''Barbossa:''' *immediately
]]\\
'''Barbossa:''' ''[immediately
shares his rum*
rum]''
* After Barbossa admits to Jack that what he really wants is [[spoiler: revenge against Blackbeard for stealing the Black Pearl ''Black Pearl'' and costing Barbossa his leg]], Jack's response is a surprisingly heartfelt, "I'll see you get the chance, Mate." The heartwarming part comes when you realize that, while "Mate" is a [[TalkLikeAPirate fairly common pirate term]], he's using it here with the utmost sincerity to address his former ''first mate.''
**
'' It's an acknowledgement that the two of them both loved the Black Pearl ''Black Pearl'' and Jack understands Barbossa's wish to avenge it.



* Gibbs ''waited'' for Jack. There was nothing to stop him from walking off with the sackful of [[spoiler:bottled ships]], not Captain's orders (there were none) and certainly not the Pirate's Code. ''He'' got that prize all on his lonesome, with a little help from the compass, and it's his by rights. "Take what you can, give nothing back..." But Gibbs ''waits''.

to:

* Gibbs ''waited'' ''waits'' for Jack. There was There's nothing to stop him from walking off with the sackful of [[spoiler:bottled ships]], not Captain's orders (there were are none) and certainly not the Pirate's Code. ''He'' got that prize all on his lonesome, with a little help from the compass, and it's his by rights. "Take what you can, give nothing back..." But Gibbs ''waits''.



-->'''Gibbs:''' Jack, I have to ask...you had the chalices, the water, the tear...you could have lived, maybe forever!
-->'''Jack:''' The Fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh]]? (''air quotes'') "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...[[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]

to:

-->'''Gibbs:''' Jack, I have to ask... you had the chalices, the water, the tear...tear... you could have lived, maybe forever!
-->'''Jack:''' The Fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh]]? (''air quotes'') ''[air quotes]'' "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...Gibbs... [[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]



--> '''Jack:''' Hello, [[spoiler:dad.]]
----

to:

--> '''Jack:''' Hello, [[spoiler:dad.]]
----
]]

Added DiffLines:

* Jack's [[spoiler:father]] showing up out of the blue to save him from a random mook then giving him as much helpful advice as he can. Their short greeting, complete with genuine smiles and a little salute, really sells how happy they are to see each other.
--> [[spoiler:'''Teague:''']] Hello, Jackie.
--> '''Jack:''' Hello, [[spoiler:dad.]]

Added DiffLines:

** Might even be more touching as this might be what they were like ''before'' the mutiny. Barbossa was Jack's first mate, essentially his right hand man, so there had to be trust there at some point. Rather then seeing a new friendship forming this might be the two finally burying the hatch and ''restoring'' the friendship they had years ago.


* After Barbossa admits to Jack that what he really wants is [[spoiler: revenge against Blackbeard]], Jack's response is a surprisingly heartfelt, "I'll see you get the chance, Mate." The heartwarming part comes when you realize that, while "Mate" is a [[TalkLikeAPirate fairly common pirate term]], he's using it here with the utmost sincerity to address his former ''first mate.''

to:

* After Barbossa admits to Jack that what he really wants is [[spoiler: revenge against Blackbeard]], Blackbeard for stealing the Black Pearl and costing Barbossa his leg]], Jack's response is a surprisingly heartfelt, "I'll see you get the chance, Mate." The heartwarming part comes when you realize that, while "Mate" is a [[TalkLikeAPirate fairly common pirate term]], he's using it here with the utmost sincerity to address his former ''first mate.''



* Jack and Barbossa's relationship as a whole in this movie is pretty touching, considering that they went from hating each other in the first movie to an antagonistic rivalry in the third, but now that they finally have the same goal, the two seem more like old friends than rivals. It makes one wonder how things might have turned out if Barbossa hadn't mutinied back in the first movie.

to:

* Jack and Barbossa's relationship as a whole in this movie is pretty touching, considering that they went from hating each other in the first movie to an antagonistic rivalry in the third, but now that they finally have the same goal, the two seem more like old friends than rivals. It makes one wonder how things might have turned out if Barbossa hadn't mutinied against Jack back in the first movie.movie.
* When faced with the SadisticChoice of [[spoiler: who to save and who to let die]] with the cursed chalices and the water from the Fountain of Youth, Jack [[spoiler: urges Blackbeard to give his own life to save his daughter]]. Granted, [[spoiler: Blackbeard crosses the MoralEventHorizon by making his daughter drink (what he thinks is) the fatal chalice, and Jack's BatmanGambit suggests that he KNEW Blackbeard would sink that low]], but the way that Jack [[spoiler: urges Blackbeard to save his daughter's life]] suggests that his request was sincere.


* As Jack and Gibbs reflect on their adventure, our favorite LovableRogue has a surprisingly poignant and insightful commentary on the prospect of immortality, suggesting that he [[WhoWantsToLiveForever understands the heavy weight of eternal life]], particularly [[ImmortalityImmorality when it comes at a price]]:

to:

* As Jack and Gibbs reflect on their adventure, our favorite LovableRogue has a [[HiddenDepths surprisingly poignant and insightful insightful]] commentary on the prospect of immortality, suggesting that he [[WhoWantsToLiveForever understands the heavy weight of eternal life]], particularly [[ImmortalityImmorality when it comes at a price]]:



-->'''Jack:''' The fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh]]? (''air quotes'') "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...[[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]

to:

-->'''Jack:''' The fountain Fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh]]? (''air quotes'') "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...[[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]


-->'''Jack:''' The fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' live forever, eh? (''air quotes'') "[[YouCannotKillAnIdea Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth.]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...[[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]

to:

-->'''Jack:''' The fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' [[YouCannotKillAnIdea live forever, eh? eh]]? (''air quotes'') "[[YouCannotKillAnIdea "[[LivingLegend Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth.]]" Youth!]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...[[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]


* As Jack and Gibbs reflect on their adventure, our favorite LovableRogue has a surprisingly poignant and insightful insight on the prospect of immortality, suggesting that he [[WhoWantsToLiveForever understands the heavy weight of eternal life]], particularly [[ImmortalityImmorality when it comes at a price]]:

to:

* As Jack and Gibbs reflect on their adventure, our favorite LovableRogue has a surprisingly poignant and insightful insight commentary on the prospect of immortality, suggesting that he [[WhoWantsToLiveForever understands the heavy weight of eternal life]], particularly [[ImmortalityImmorality when it comes at a price]]:

Added DiffLines:

* As Jack and Gibbs reflect on their adventure, our favorite LovableRogue has a surprisingly poignant and insightful insight on the prospect of immortality, suggesting that he [[WhoWantsToLiveForever understands the heavy weight of eternal life]], particularly [[ImmortalityImmorality when it comes at a price]]:
-->'''Gibbs:''' Jack, I have to ask...you had the chalices, the water, the tear...you could have lived, maybe forever!
-->'''Jack:''' The fountain ''does'' [[SadisticChoice test you, Gibbs.]] But better to ''not'' know which moment may be your last--every ''morsel'' of your being ''alive'' to the very mystery of it all. And who's to say I ''won't'' live forever, eh? (''air quotes'') "[[YouCannotKillAnIdea Discoverer of the Fountain of Youth.]]" I have no say in it, Gibbs...[[ArcWords it's a pirate's life for me.]] [[CatchPhrase Savvy?]]

Showing 15 edit(s) of 18

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report