Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / YuGiOh5Ds

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I think The biggest mystery in all of Yu-Gi-Oh! has nothing to do with timelines or dimensions--it's how the heck did two ten-year-olds (Rua and Ruka) get an unconscious grown man (Yusei) up to their top floor apartment? And then they had to get his heavy motorcycle up there, too... ''And''' they had to do both those things before the big police officer (Ushio) who was actively pursuing said unconscious man could catch up to them. [[https://images-ext-1.discordapp.net/external/-pHsEthxBQYa7d9iz-H6tfnvZkIwVFdTpttWjnm17rA/https/i.pinimg.com/564x/3a/55/0c/3a550cd167b17cb20ff7b707e38c46a6.jpg The logistics just don't make sense!]]

to:

* I think The biggest mystery in all of Yu-Gi-Oh! has nothing to do with timelines or dimensions--it's how the heck did two ten-year-olds (Rua and Ruka) get an unconscious grown man (Yusei) up to their top floor apartment? And then they had to get his heavy motorcycle up there, too... ''And''' ''And'' they had to do both those things before the big police officer (Ushio) who was actively pursuing said unconscious man could catch up to them. [[https://images-ext-1.discordapp.net/external/-pHsEthxBQYa7d9iz-H6tfnvZkIwVFdTpttWjnm17rA/https/i.pinimg.com/564x/3a/55/0c/3a550cd167b17cb20ff7b707e38c46a6.jpg The logistics just don't make sense!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Figured this should be up here, because it IS a huge issue.

Added DiffLines:


* I think The biggest mystery in all of Yu-Gi-Oh! has nothing to do with timelines or dimensions--it's how the heck did two ten-year-olds (Rua and Ruka) get an unconscious grown man (Yusei) up to their top floor apartment? And then they had to get his heavy motorcycle up there, too... ''And''' they had to do both those things before the big police officer (Ushio) who was actively pursuing said unconscious man could catch up to them. [[https://images-ext-1.discordapp.net/external/-pHsEthxBQYa7d9iz-H6tfnvZkIwVFdTpttWjnm17rA/https/i.pinimg.com/564x/3a/55/0c/3a550cd167b17cb20ff7b707e38c46a6.jpg The logistics just don't make sense!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because Armstrong had multiple cards that (at least by their anime effects) sent more of the opponent's Deck to the Graveyard if they had a high Level. If Yusei had summoned Tri-Horned Dragon, and Armstrong had revived Iron Chain Snake again — or used Iron Chain Dragon like he did later, though Yusei didn't know about that specific card yet — then its destruction would have cost Yusei 8 cards, while The Kick Man's only cost him 3.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Falsifying history with the Infinity machine seems to work differently than "just" changing things via time travel, and there seem to be limits on how much can be changed. Otherwise they could just RetGone Duel Monsters or Synchro Monsters away to stop the Momentum issue instead of having to do it the hard way. It's possible that either the altered reality's consequences don't ripple out as far as one would logically expect, or else that the Emperors were careful to alter things in a way that minimized unforeseen changes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Turbo Warrior would not have worked. Yes, it wouldn't be absorbed. But it has 2500 ATK just like Wisel Infinity. Even if it tried to go for a double-KO, or if he tried using it against Lucciano instead, Wisel/Skiel Guard — whose effect does not target and thus wouldn't be blocked — would just redirect the attack to itself. All Placido/Lucciano would have to do is upgrade any of its parts to Level 3 or above and the Emperor would be free to destroy Turbo by battle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Remember that they broke Greiger/Bommer out of jail around the same time that Carly died and resurrected. It's likely that they'd already been planning to make him their fifth member since the end of the Fortune Cup, and that they were reasonably certain the throw-him-into-Momentum plan would guarantee he became a Dark Signer. Plus, fairly soon after the the Fortune Cup, Misty read Carly's future through her face — she probably worked out that Carly would become the Hummingbird Dark Signer sooner or later without need for direct intervention.

to:

* ** Remember that they broke Greiger/Bommer out of jail around the same time that Carly died and resurrected. It's likely that they'd already been planning to make him their fifth member since the end of the Fortune Cup, and that they were reasonably certain the throw-him-into-Momentum plan would guarantee he became a Dark Signer. Plus, fairly soon after the the Fortune Cup, Misty read Carly's future through her face — she probably worked out that Carly would become the Hummingbird Dark Signer sooner or later without need for direct intervention.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Remember that they broke Greiger/Bommer out of jail around the same time that Carly died and resurrected. It's likely that they'd already been planning to make him their fifth member since the end of the Fortune Cup, and that they were reasonably certain the throw-him-into-Momentum plan would guarantee he became a Dark Signer. Plus, fairly soon after the the Fortune Cup, Misty read Carly's future through her face — she probably worked out that Carly would become the Hummingbird Dark Signer sooner or later without need for direct intervention.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It seems that there's a little bit of Timey-Wimey nonsense going on at the moment, as it seems that 5Ds takes place around 2020. ''However'', given what we already know of the timeline (And the fact that DM, GX, and 5Ds are all confirmed to be one timeline through both [[NoExportForYou Japanese books on it]] and the [[Anime/YuGiOhBondsBeyondTime the movie]], it would mean that Yuusei was roughly born during Season 4 of GX (Assuming he's around 16-18, given that he's apparently allowed to ride a D-Wheel and all) - and that Zero Reverse happened soon after the end of GX. So it's still up in the air. But no, no WordOfGod as to how far in the future it is.

to:

** It seems that there's a little bit of Timey-Wimey nonsense going on at the moment, as it seems that 5Ds takes place around 2020. ''However'', given what we already know of the timeline (And the fact that DM, GX, and 5Ds are all confirmed to be one timeline through both [[NoExportForYou Japanese books on it]] and the [[Anime/YuGiOhBondsBeyondTime the movie]], it would mean that Yuusei was roughly born during Season 4 of GX (Assuming he's around 16-18, given that he's apparently allowed to ride a D-Wheel and all) - and that Zero Reverse happened soon after the end of GX. So it's still up in the air. But no, no WordOfGod as to how far in the future it is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the first 2 episodes following the Fortune Cup, the Dark Signers appear acting like they're ready to strike and put their plan into motion now and challenge the Signers. How? They're still short one member! They have no one with the sign of the Hummingbird yet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That whole series of duels was an egregious case of TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot. Look how many episodes past where Jack must have simply been driving the whole time everyone else was reaching their opponents and dueling. Mikage and Aki spent all those episode ''and 2 more'' (Jack's whole duel with Carly just driving). Sure, the map Mikage showed of the control towers shows them spread out but with similar distances between all of them -- everyone's first duels should have logically started at roughly similar times. The show could have still shown them to the viewers individually by simply devoting different episodes to showing what was happening at the same time in different locations but instead chose to make everyone TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot so no one was dueling at the same time.

to:

** That whole series of duels was an egregious case of TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot. Look how many episodes past where Jack must have simply been driving the whole time everyone else was reaching their opponents and dueling. Mikage and Aki spent all those episode ''and 2 more'' (Jack's whole duel with Carly Carly) just driving).driving. Sure, the map Mikage showed of the control towers shows them spread out but with similar distances between all of them -- everyone's first duels should have logically started at roughly similar times. The show could have still shown them to the viewers individually by simply devoting different episodes to showing what was happening at the same time in different locations but instead chose to make everyone TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot so no one was dueling at the same time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That whole series of duels was an egregious case of TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot. Look how many episodes past where Jack must have simply been driving the whole time everyone else was reaching their opponents and dueling. Mikage and Aki spent all those episode ''and 2 more'' (Jack's whole duel with Carly just driving). Sure, the map Mikage showed of the control towers shows them spread out but with similar distances between all of them -- everyone's first duels should have logically started at roughly similar times. The show could have still shown them to the viewers individually by simply devoting different episodes to showing what was happening at the same time in different locations but instead chose to make everyone TravelingAtTheSpeedOfPlot so no one was dueling at the same time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible it's not a function of the D-Wheels themselves, but of the "Speed World" field spell. Cards in this franchise have frequently been connected to magic to some extent, and to a point D-Wheels are essentially a form of {{Magitek}}. They're not just cool motorcycles, but conduits for the Dueling energy called Moment (or [[DubNameChange Ener-D]]) which it both generates and employs to operate. When Sector Security Officers like Ushio use "Speed World"'s Imposed Activation, maybe what they're actually doing (probably without fully realizing it) is casting a spell that acts upon the Moment that D-Wheels use and forces them and their player(s) into a Turbo Duel—sort of like a Shadow Game. Since all D-Wheels use Moment this way, it's impossible for anyone to build a D-Wheel that doesn't respond this way—a D-Wheel without Momentum ''would'' just be a cool-looking motorcycle and wouldn't work well for Dueling.

to:

** It's possible it's not a function of the D-Wheels themselves, but of the "Speed World" field spell. Cards and Dueling in this franchise have frequently been connected to magic to some extent, and to a point D-Wheels are essentially a form of {{Magitek}}. They're not just cool motorcycles, but conduits for the Dueling energy called Moment (or [[DubNameChange Ener-D]]) which Ener-D]]), it both generates and employs to operate.for function and has known supernatural properties we learn about later on. When Sector Security Officers like Ushio use "Speed World"'s Imposed Activation, maybe what they're actually doing (probably without fully realizing it) is casting a spell that acts upon the Moment that D-Wheels use and forces them and their player(s) into a Turbo Duel—sort of like a Shadow Game. Since all D-Wheels use Moment this way, it's impossible for anyone to build a D-Wheel that doesn't respond this way—a D-Wheel without Momentum ''would'' just be a cool-looking motorcycle and wouldn't work well for Dueling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible it's not a function of the D-Wheels themselves, but of the "Speed World" field spell. Cards in this franchise have frequently been connected to magic to some extent, and to a point D-Wheels are essentially a form of {{Magitek}}. They're not just motorcycles, but conduits for the Dueling energy called Moment (or [[DubNameChange Ener-D]]) which it both generates and employs to operate. When Sector Security Officers like Ushio use "Speed World"'s Imposed Activation, what they're actually doing (probably without fully realizing it) is casting a spell that "drags" the D-Wheel and the player riding it into a Turbo Duel and forces them to compete in it—sort of like a Shadow Game.

to:

** It's possible it's not a function of the D-Wheels themselves, but of the "Speed World" field spell. Cards in this franchise have frequently been connected to magic to some extent, and to a point D-Wheels are essentially a form of {{Magitek}}. They're not just cool motorcycles, but conduits for the Dueling energy called Moment (or [[DubNameChange Ener-D]]) which it both generates and employs to operate. When Sector Security Officers like Ushio use "Speed World"'s Imposed Activation, maybe what they're actually doing (probably without fully realizing it) is casting a spell that "drags" acts upon the D-Wheel and the player riding it into a Turbo Duel Moment that D-Wheels use and forces them to compete in it—sort and their player(s) into a Turbo Duel—sort of like a Shadow Game.Game. Since all D-Wheels use Moment this way, it's impossible for anyone to build a D-Wheel that doesn't respond this way—a D-Wheel without Momentum ''would'' just be a cool-looking motorcycle and wouldn't work well for Dueling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Fridges are magic. Just ask Indiana Jones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Aporia is a massive HopeCrusher. Grannel Infinity is what caused him to become hopeless, so he uses it to do the same to others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible it's not a function of the D-Wheels themselves, but of the "Speed World" field spell. Cards in this franchise have frequently been connected to magic to some extent, and to a point D-Wheels are essentially a form of Magitek. They're not just motorcycles, but conduits for the Dueling energy called Moment (or [[DubNameChange Ener-D]]) which it both generates and employs to operate. When Sector Security Officers like Ushio use "Speed World"'s Imposed Activation, what they're actually doing (probably without fully realizing it) is casting a spell that "drags" the D-Wheel and the player riding it into a Turbo Duel and forces them to compete in it—sort of like a Shadow Game.

to:

** It's possible it's not a function of the D-Wheels themselves, but of the "Speed World" field spell. Cards in this franchise have frequently been connected to magic to some extent, and to a point D-Wheels are essentially a form of Magitek.{{Magitek}}. They're not just motorcycles, but conduits for the Dueling energy called Moment (or [[DubNameChange Ener-D]]) which it both generates and employs to operate. When Sector Security Officers like Ushio use "Speed World"'s Imposed Activation, what they're actually doing (probably without fully realizing it) is casting a spell that "drags" the D-Wheel and the player riding it into a Turbo Duel and forces them to compete in it—sort of like a Shadow Game.

Top