Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / XamdLostMemories

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* I have a question about the [[BlindIdiotTranslation very badly translated]] PSN version (I'm assuming that it's an english dub, since the entry on the MisBlamed page for this show says so. Correct me if I'm wrong) and Sentai Filmworks' DVD/Blu-Ray release of the show. I know for a fact that the DVD/Blu-Ray release includes an english dub. Is the PSN dub included on the DVD/Blu-Ray release, or did Sentai Filmworks (hopefully) give the show a redub? (Again, if I got any details wrong, please correct me.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing that spoiler alert..


* How does [[spoiler: Akiyuki, isshu and Raygo]] all survive? Turned to stone, crushed and blown apart was not enough? They really stretch the [[WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief suspense of disbelief.]]
[[spoiler:Akiyuki's]] appearance in the end, like it's nothing, is a complete deus-ex-machina. [[spoiler: Nakiami told him that one day he will hear his name again, bringing him to life.
9 years later, he just resurrected like it's nothing, without even fulfilling Nakiami's prophesy. The ending is a complete asspull.]]

ALSO, FRIDGE LOGIC : [[spoiler: If Akiyuki gets his name back, does that mean the Hiruku emperor loses his name? Or is he now embedded with Akiyuki? Both are the same, light and darkness. And regardless of that, if Akiyuki has managed to dismantle the Emperor's wrath, why did Nakiami had to sacrifice herself? Akiyuki took on the darkness and conquered it, the 1000 years of darkness is over.]] So, why? Explain show, explain.

to:

* How *How does [[spoiler: Akiyuki, isshu and Raygo]] all survive? Turned to stone, crushed and blown apart was not enough? They really stretch the [[WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief suspense of disbelief.]]
[[spoiler:Akiyuki's]] appearance in the end, like it's nothing, is a complete deus-ex-machina. [[spoiler: Nakiami told him that one day he will hear his name again, bringing him to life.
life. 9 years Years later, he just resurrected like it's nothing, without even fulfilling Nakiami's prophesy. The ending is a complete asspull.]]

ALSO, FRIDGE LOGIC : :
[[spoiler: If Akiyuki gets his name back, does that mean the Hiruku emperor loses his name? Or is he now embedded with Akiyuki? Both are the same, light and darkness. And regardless of that, if Akiyuki has managed to dismantle the Emperor's wrath, why did Nakiami had to sacrifice herself? Akiyuki took on the darkness and conquered it, the 1000 years of darkness is over.]] So, why? Explain show, explain.

Added: 746

Changed: 197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*How does [[spoiler: Akiyuki, isshu and Raygo]] all survive? Turned to stone, crushed and blown apart was not enough? They really stretch the [[WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief suspense of disbelief.]]
[[spoiler:Akiyuki's]] appearance in the end, like it's nothing, is a complete deus-ex-machina. [[spoiler: Nakiami told him that one day he will hear his name again, bringing him to life.
9 years later, he just resurrected like it's nothing, without even fulfilling Nakiami's prophesy. The ending is a complete asspull.]]

ALSO, FRIDGE LOGIC : [[spoiler: If Akiyuki gets his name back, does that mean the Hiruku emperor loses his name? Or is he now embedded with Akiyuki? Both are the same, light and darkness. And regardless of that, if Akiyuki has managed to dismantle the Emperor's wrath, why did Nakiami had to sacrifice herself? Akiyuki took on the darkness and conquered it, the 1000 years of darkness is over.]] So, why? Explain show, explain.



<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>

to:

<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*What exactly happened to the Hiruken Emperor [[spoiler:after Akiyuki gave him his name?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaning up trope misuse as per TRS thread


** It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally ([[OrIsIt or not]]), this is also when the plot really kicks in).

to:

** It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally ([[OrIsIt or not]]), not), this is also when the plot really kicks in).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The more thought I put into this, I realized I wasn't understanding it either, until I started comparing it directly to Blassreiter. Much like in that show, those who receive hiruko have problems maintaining their mental faculties. Much like how in Blassreiter, Gerd fell victim to his own insecurities and lost his mind, so did Furuichi. And much like Gerd, Furuichi realized that once he had no chance of going back to a normal life, that he had little motivation to maintain his grip on reality, and even less motivation to live. The difference is that Furuichi has one last moment of clarity, and kills himself before he can lose his mind again.

to:

*** The more thought I put into this, I realized I wasn't understanding it either, until I started comparing it directly to Blassreiter. Much like in that show, those who receive hiruko power (in the case of this show, hiruko) have problems maintaining their mental faculties. Much like how in Blassreiter, Gerd fell victim to his own insecurities and lost his mind, so did Furuichi. And much like Gerd, Furuichi realized that once he had no chance of going back to a normal life, that he had little motivation to maintain his grip on reality, and even less motivation to live. The difference is that Furuichi has one last moment of clarity, and kills himself before he can lose his mind again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** The more thought I put into this, I realized I wasn't understanding it either, until I started comparing it directly to Blassreiter. Much like in that show, those who receive hiruko have problems maintaining their mental faculties. Much like how in Blassreiter, Gerd fell victim to his own insecurities and lost his mind, so did Furuichi. And much like Gerd, Furuichi realized that once he had no chance of going back to a normal life, that he had little motivation to maintain his grip on reality, and even less motivation to live. The difference is that Furuichi has one last moment of clarity, and kills himself before he can lose his mind again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**I saw it like this. life and death plays a very large role in xam'd. This was the only path he had, he couldn't form his xam'd mask, he couldn't promise to live. if he couldn't do that then he was awaiting death. He just took the fastest way he knew. this could be just me however.

Changed: 688

Removed: 1083

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting so that the main point is clearer; the translation talked about it is in fact the sub, when it was initially released in the US before Japan. They hadn\'t dubbed it yet.


**** This troper has watched the entire run and is on his second rewatch, having yet to find a significant or plausible answer.
** This separate troper has watched the show once and honestly can't understand why you guys can't get it. It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally ([[OrIsIt or not]]), this is also when the plot really kicks in). Also, just a question, but are you guys watching the sub or the dub? I've heard really, really bad things about the dub. So bad that there's even a mention of how bad the dub is on the main page. Maybe that's why you don't understand the story yet (I'm not trying to start a sub/dub war, just stating what I think/have heard).

to:

**** This troper has watched the entire run and is on his second rewatch, having yet to find a significant or plausible answer.
** This separate troper has watched the show once and honestly can't understand why you guys can't get it. It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally ([[OrIsIt or not]]), this is also when the plot really kicks in). Also, just a question, but are you guys watching the sub or the dub? I've heard really, really bad things about the dub. So bad that there's even a mention of how bad the dub is on the main page. Maybe that's why you don't understand the story yet (I'm not trying to start a sub/dub war, just stating what I think/have heard).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This separate troper has watched the show once and honestly can't understand why you guys can't get it. It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally [[OrIsIt or not]], this is also when the plot really kicks in). Also, just a question, but are you guys watching the sub or the dub? I've heard really, really bad things about the sub. So bad that there's even a mention of how bad the dub is on the main page. Maybe that's why you don't understand the story yet (I'm not trying to start a sub/dub war, just stating what I think).

to:

** This separate troper has watched the show once and honestly can't understand why you guys can't get it. It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally [[OrIsIt ([[OrIsIt or not]], not]]), this is also when the plot really kicks in). Also, just a question, but are you guys watching the sub or the dub? I've heard really, really bad things about the sub.dub. So bad that there's even a mention of how bad the dub is on the main page. Maybe that's why you don't understand the story yet (I'm not trying to start a sub/dub war, just stating what I think).think/have heard).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This separate troper has watched the show once and honestly can't understand why you guys can't get it. It's fairly simple: Humanforms are people embedded with hiruko (whether artificially or naturally) who can change form; they become the "monsters" and it's why Nakiami [[spoiler: wants to save them, because inside, they're human]]. Xam'd are humanforms who are more human-like and can think, which seems to be the way they stay alive and not [[spoiler:crystalize]]. People turn into humanforms when they're embedded with a hiruko. And what chick are you talking about? I think you need to watch the show a bit longer; around the 20th episode, things get a lot clearer (coincidentally [[OrIsIt or not]], this is also when the plot really kicks in). Also, just a question, but are you guys watching the sub or the dub? I've heard really, really bad things about the sub. So bad that there's even a mention of how bad the dub is on the main page. Maybe that's why you don't understand the story yet (I'm not trying to start a sub/dub war, just stating what I think).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why ''did'' Prois let Haru [[spoiler:leave her confinement]]?\

to:

* Why ''did'' Prois let Haru [[spoiler:leave her confinement]]?\confinement]]?

Added: 165

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why ''did'' Prois let Haru [[spoiler:leave her confinement]]?

to:

* Why ''did'' Prois let Haru [[spoiler:leave her confinement]]?confinement]]?\
** Perhaps she realized how much saving her sister meant to Haru. The fact that she was offering her [[spoiler:body, whether for consensual sex or rape]] shows that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Experience!

Added DiffLines:

**** This troper has watched the entire run and is on his second rewatch, having yet to find a significant or plausible answer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well it is [[PermaStubble ''Perma'' Stubble]], so it's always there; you just couldn't see it under the beard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Anime Network. This show has not gotten any clearer in the ensuing weeks either. Its amazing how nobody even bothers attempting to define the word "X'amd". Its like if in Star Wars they never bothered to tell you what "The Force" was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** He'd served his purpose in the story, so the writers *cough* 'headed off' his becoming a loose plot thread. I'm sorry, that was bad. But really, he'd illustrated their point about blind hatred, which is one of the major aesops, as much as he could. He was no longer useful to the plot, and since no major characters had died yet he got offed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What was the point to Furuichi Teraoka dieing the way he did?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Okay, I've been trying to enjoy this show so far. TV Tropes says it needs more love, and I have love to give. Only one problem: THIS SHOW NEVER EXPLAINS ANYTHING!! What is a Humanform? What is a Xam'D? Why do people turn into Humanforms? Why does the chick with tatoos on her face care about Xam'ds at all? Can you just give me thirty of exposition to explain this? It isn't hard. This won't ruin your entire show's flow. Just explain yourself! I'm left screaming at my TV screen "WHAT IS GOING ON??" I so want to like this show, but I simply cannot until this is explained.
** Since you said TV screen, I assume you're watching anime network on demand?

to:

* Okay, I've been trying to enjoy this show so far. TV Tropes says it needs more love, and I have love to give. Only one problem: THIS SHOW NEVER EXPLAINS ANYTHING!! What is a Humanform? What is a Xam'D? Why do people turn into Humanforms? Why does the chick with tatoos tattoos on her face care about Xam'ds at all? Can you just give me thirty of exposition to explain this? It isn't hard. This won't ruin your entire show's flow. Just explain yourself! I'm left screaming at my TV screen "WHAT IS GOING ON??" I so want to like this show, but I simply cannot until this is explained.
** Since you said TV screen, I assume you're watching anime network on demand?demand. Or are you watching it on dvd and haven't finished?.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since you said TV screen, I assume you're watching anime network on demand?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Okay, I've been trying to enjoy this show so far. TV Tropes says it needs more love, and I have love to give. Only one problem: THIS SHOW NEVER EXPLAINS ANYTHING!! What is a Humanform? What is a Xam'D? Why do people turn into Humanforms? Why does the chick with tatoos on her face care about Xam'ds at all? Can you just give me thirty of exposition to explain this? It isn't hard. This won't ruin your entire show's flow. Just explain yourself! I'm left screaming at my TV screen "WHAT IS GOING ON??" I so want to like this show, but I simply cannot until this is explained.

Top