Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Weeds

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Judah was a high earner and sole provider for his family. Most large employers offer life insurance as part of their benefits packages for their high earners. Even if that was not available, rates for an individual term life insurance policy are cheap (a typical $1M policy costs under $500/year for a 45 year old man in good health). It is not mentioned on the show once - not even as a lament on their misfortunes.

to:

Judah was a high earner and sole provider for his family. Most large employers offer life insurance as part of their benefits packages for their high earners. Even if that was not available, rates for an individual term life insurance policy are cheap (a typical $1M policy costs under $500/year for a 45 year old man in good health). It is not mentioned on the show once - not even as a lament on their misfortunes.misfortunes.
* Unfortunately, it's often TruthInTelevision for people to overlook such things; it's also been known to happen with basic estate planning documents like wills and powers of attorney. Some people procrastinate until the decades slip by without ever getting around to it, or they assume that such things are only for "rich," "fancy," or "old" people (which they don't consider themselves to be). It can be common even for presumably well-informed professionals like Judah, whom a person would think should know better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Possibly RealLifeWritesThePlot, with a child actor starting to grow into an adolescent with limited acting range. When that happens, you either end up with Carrie Ingalls, or you start writing the character in a way that plays to strengths while downplaying liabilities - so Shane became a DeadpanSnarker with a flat affect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a new issue for headscratchers.


* As far as the accent, it would have to do with their respective ages when they emigrated. The way the language center of the brain develops, kids under the age of 12 or so immersed in a new language will speak it without a trace of their native accent. After that, the older they are, the more pronounced their native accent will be, and it's a steep curve with each additional year. If you assume the age gap is comparable to the actors portraying the roles (6 years), big sister Zoya learning English her mid-teens would sound fresh off the tundra while kid brother Demetri who was in elementary school would sound pretty American.

to:

* As far as the accent, it would have to do with their respective ages when they emigrated. The way the language center of the brain develops, kids under the age of 12 or so immersed in a new language will speak it without a trace of their native accent. After that, the older they are, the more pronounced their native accent will be, and it's a steep curve with each additional year. If you assume the age gap is comparable to the actors portraying the roles (6 years), big sister Zoya learning English her mid-teens would sound fresh off the tundra while kid brother Demetri who was in elementary school would sound pretty American.American.

[[WMG: Why didn't the Botwins have life insurance?]]
Judah was a high earner and sole provider for his family. Most large employers offer life insurance as part of their benefits packages for their high earners. Even if that was not available, rates for an individual term life insurance policy are cheap (a typical $1M policy costs under $500/year for a 45 year old man in good health). It is not mentioned on the show once - not even as a lament on their misfortunes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing outdated mark-up


<<|JustBugsMe|>>

to:

<<|JustBugsMe|>>
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
answering question


During the 5-6 episodes he appeared in, why is he shown wearing the exact same clothes every time (dark green shirt and blue jeans))? He smuggles everything from drugs, to electronics, to motorcycles and hand grenades but he couldn't manage to afford more than one outfit? I also had trouble understanding why his sister Zoya spoke with a Russian accent and his was non-existent.

to:

During the 5-6 episodes he appeared in, why is he shown wearing the exact same clothes every time (dark green shirt and blue jeans))? He smuggles everything from drugs, to electronics, to motorcycles and hand grenades but he couldn't manage to afford more than one outfit? I also had trouble understanding why his sister Zoya spoke with a Russian accent and his was non-existent.non-existent.
* As far as the accent, it would have to do with their respective ages when they emigrated. The way the language center of the brain develops, kids under the age of 12 or so immersed in a new language will speak it without a trace of their native accent. After that, the older they are, the more pronounced their native accent will be, and it's a steep curve with each additional year. If you assume the age gap is comparable to the actors portraying the roles (6 years), big sister Zoya learning English her mid-teens would sound fresh off the tundra while kid brother Demetri who was in elementary school would sound pretty American.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None






to:

* This troper says derailment, possibly in an attempt at averting NotAllowedToGrowUp.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[http://www.spoilertv.com/2011/09/weeds-season-7-finale-who-shot-nancy.html Tim Scottson]] son of Nancys 2 late husband Peter Scottson

to:

* [[http://www.spoilertv.com/2011/09/weeds-season-7-finale-who-shot-nancy.html Tim Scottson]] son of Nancys 2 late husband Peter ScottsonScottson

[[WMG: Nancy's Russian fxxk buddy in season 7 Demetri Ravitch]]
During the 5-6 episodes he appeared in, why is he shown wearing the exact same clothes every time (dark green shirt and blue jeans))? He smuggles everything from drugs, to electronics, to motorcycles and hand grenades but he couldn't manage to afford more than one outfit? I also had trouble understanding why his sister Zoya spoke with a Russian accent and his was non-existent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fact that after getting punched by her father, Silus just gives up on Megan and the subplot is not resolved at all. Then Shane's girlfriend with the braces disappears after the season 2 finale with no mention of what happened. It just seems like whenever a Botwin boy gets a girlfriend, they will abruptly disappear for some reason.

to:

* The fact that after getting punched by her father, Silus Silas just gives up on Megan and the subplot is not resolved at all. Then Shane's girlfriend with the braces disappears after the season 2 finale with no mention of what happened. It just seems like whenever a Botwin boy gets a girlfriend, they will abruptly disappear for some reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Even if the guards are basically mall cops (and they're probably at least armed, if not moonlighting or retired actual police officers) , he can either;

to:

Even if the guards are basically mall cops (and they're probably at least armed, if not moonlighting or retired actual police officers) , he can either;



The inconsistency of Shane's character really bothers me, especially in the newest season. Is he a [[CompleteMonster sociopath]] or a JerkassWoobie with a heart of gold? Is he a naive kid or ManipulativeBastard? The writers just seem to go with whatever makes him look cool, but to this troper his actions just make him seem extremely arrogant and unsympathetic.

to:

The inconsistency of Shane's character really bothers me, especially in the newest season. Is he a [[CompleteMonster sociopath]] sociopath or a JerkassWoobie with a heart of gold? Is he a naive kid or ManipulativeBastard? The writers just seem to go with whatever makes him look cool, but to this troper his actions just make him seem extremely arrogant and unsympathetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[http://www.spoilertv.com/2011/09/weeds-season-7-finale-who-shot-nancy.html Tim Scottson]] son of Nancys 2 late husband Peter Scottson

to:

* [[http://www.spoilertv.com/2011/09/weeds-season-7-finale-who-shot-nancy.html Tim Scottson]] son of Nancys 2 late husband Peter Scottson
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


And Jenji Kohan, the creator of Weeds, has stated the gunman is someone we know from past seasons which Esteban surely qualifies, but I'm unsure because that would be the obvious person.

to:

And Jenji Kohan, the creator of Weeds, has stated the gunman is someone we know from past seasons which Esteban surely qualifies, but I'm unsure because that would be the obvious person.person.
[[http://www.spoilertv.com/2011/09/weeds-season-7-finale-who-shot-nancy.html Tim Scottson]] son of Nancys 2 late husband Peter Scottson
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Her neighborhood may not have cops. Most gated communities don't- just a gate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Seriously the show not simply being about how self absorbed white people are [[SarcasmMode is a bad thing? The show actually using its platform to show people with real problems (shit that goes down under ninety percent of the audiences noses every damn day and no one really cares btw) and actually introducing its audience to new ideas makes it bad.]] I can understand saying its not as funny or that Esteban was boring but seriously anyone complaining about how the show is not [[OpinionMyopia about YOU]] anymore is seriously [[CompletelyMissingthePoint missing the point]].

to:

Seriously the show not simply being about how self absorbed white people are [[SarcasmMode is a bad thing? The show actually using its platform to show people with real problems (shit that goes down under ninety percent of the audiences noses every damn day and no one really cares btw) and actually introducing its audience to new ideas makes it bad.]] I can understand saying its not as funny or that Esteban was boring but seriously anyone complaining about how the show is not [[OpinionMyopia about YOU]] anymore is seriously [[CompletelyMissingthePoint missing the point]].point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The gunman looks an awful lot like Esteban who is supposedly dead. Just hope he's not BackFromTheDead.

to:

The gunman looks an awful lot like Esteban who is supposedly dead. Just hope he's not BackFromTheDead.BackFromTheDead.
And Jenji Kohan, the creator of Weeds, has stated the gunman is someone we know from past seasons which Esteban surely qualifies, but I'm unsure because that would be the obvious person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The gunman looks an awful lot like Esteban who is supposedly dead.

to:

The gunman looks an awful lot like Esteban who is supposedly dead. Just hope he's not BackFromTheDead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I disagree with this, I think there were seeds of the Shane we see now, right from the beginning. I mean, even in Season 1, Shane was shooting animals, making faux terrorist videos, and biting people he couldn't beat in karate. I think the whole point for him was how his dad's death and his mom's turn to crime in his formative years messed him up, and turned him into a sociopath who will do anything to defend his family. If you view his actions through this lens, his character is consistent, and retains at least a little bit of sympathy.

to:

* I disagree with this, I think there were seeds of the Shane we see now, right from the beginning. I mean, even in Season 1, Shane was shooting animals, making faux terrorist videos, and biting people he couldn't beat in karate. I think the whole point for him was how his dad's death and his mom's turn to crime in his formative years messed him up, and turned him into a sociopath who will do anything to defend his family. If you view his actions through this lens, his character is consistent, and retains at least a little bit of sympathy.sympathy.

[[WMG: Who shot/is about to shoot Nancy?]]
The gunman looks an awful lot like Esteban who is supposedly dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The inconsistency of Shane's character really bothers me, especially in the newest season. Is he a [[CompleteMonster sociopath]] or a JerkassWoobie with a heart of gold? Is he a naive kid or ManipulativeBastard? The writers just seem to go with whatever makes him look cool, but to this troper his actions just make him seem extremely arrogant and unsympathetic.

to:

The inconsistency of Shane's character really bothers me, especially in the newest season. Is he a [[CompleteMonster sociopath]] or a JerkassWoobie with a heart of gold? Is he a naive kid or ManipulativeBastard? The writers just seem to go with whatever makes him look cool, but to this troper his actions just make him seem extremely arrogant and unsympathetic.unsympathetic.

* I disagree with this, I think there were seeds of the Shane we see now, right from the beginning. I mean, even in Season 1, Shane was shooting animals, making faux terrorist videos, and biting people he couldn't beat in karate. I think the whole point for him was how his dad's death and his mom's turn to crime in his formative years messed him up, and turned him into a sociopath who will do anything to defend his family. If you view his actions through this lens, his character is consistent, and retains at least a little bit of sympathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Way to frame your argument in a way that completely vilifies anyone who dares disagree with you, you could have quite a future in news punditry. What you see as "using its platform to show people with real problems" others see as exploitative and sensationalistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fact that after getting punched by her father, Silus just gives up on Megan and the subplot is not resolved at all. Then Shane's girlfriend with the braces disappears after the season 2 finale with no mention of what happened. It just seems like whenever a Botwin boy gets a girlfriend, they will abruptly disappear for some reason.

to:

* The fact that after getting punched by her father, Silus just gives up on Megan and the subplot is not resolved at all. Then Shane's girlfriend with the braces disappears after the season 2 finale with no mention of what happened. It just seems like whenever a Botwin boy gets a girlfriend, they will abruptly disappear for some reason.reason.

[[WMG: Shane: Character Development or Derailment?]]
The inconsistency of Shane's character really bothers me, especially in the newest season. Is he a [[CompleteMonster sociopath]] or a JerkassWoobie with a heart of gold? Is he a naive kid or ManipulativeBastard? The writers just seem to go with whatever makes him look cool, but to this troper his actions just make him seem extremely arrogant and unsympathetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Part of the show's original appeal was that its premise was, for the most part, realistic - something that his nothing to do with the skin color or socioeconomic status of the main character. The reason why people complain is because it lost this sense of realism: you went from the quirky, fun premise of "middle-aged suburban woman deals minor amounts of pot to get by after husband's passing" to "middle-aged sociopath weds Mexican drug lord, goes on the run from said drug lord for an entire season, ships her family off to Copenhagen, and finally makes a deal with the FBI to save herself." Add in the oodles of Cerberus Syndrome / Karma Houdini, and any sensible person should realize that these complaints are tied to shark-jumping, and NOT a lack of self-absorbed white people (you still have Nancy for that).

to:

* Part of the show's original appeal was that its premise it was, for the most part, realistic - something that his has nothing to do with the skin color or socioeconomic status of the main character. The reason why people complain is because it lost this sense of realism: you went from the quirky, fun premise of "middle-aged suburban woman deals minor amounts of pot to get by after husband's passing" to "middle-aged sociopath weds Mexican drug lord, goes on the run from said drug lord for an entire season, ships her family off to Copenhagen, and finally makes a deal with the FBI to save herself." Add in the oodles of Cerberus Syndrome / Karma Houdini, and any sensible person should realize that these complaints are tied to shark-jumping, and NOT a lack of self-absorbed white people (you still have Nancy for that).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Part of the show's original appeal was that its premise was, for the most part, realistic - something that his nothing to do with the skin color or socioeconomic status of the main character. The reason why people complain is because it lost this sense of realism: you went from the quirky, fun premise of "middle-aged suburban woman deals minor amounts of pot to get by after husband's passing" to "middle-aged sociopath weds Mexican drug lord, goes on the run from said drug lord for an entire season, ships her family off to Copenhagen, and finally makes a deal with the FBI to save herself." Add in the oodles of Cerberus Syndrome / Karma Houdini, and any sensible person should realize that these complaints are tied to shark-jumping, and NOT a lack of self-absorbed white people (you still have Nancy for that).



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I enjoyed the show more when it was in the suburbs, and not because it was about me. Before Nancy started growing, the extent of her trouble was maybe that her weed for one month got jacked. She was in control. However, once she started working for U-Turn, and everything was life or death, she was no longer in control, and suddenly it just began to feel a lot more like all the other stuff on the air.

to:

** * I enjoyed the show more when it was in the suburbs, and not because it was about me. Before Nancy started growing, the extent of her trouble was maybe that her weed for one month got jacked. She was in control. However, once she started working for U-Turn, and everything was life or death, she was no longer in control, and suddenly it just began to feel a lot more like all the other stuff on the air.
** Nancy was never in control. No matter how much she says otherwise, Nancy has never been in control from the second she started selling drugs. She never has the slightest clue about how deep she's in it until a circumstance that she was entirely unprepared for walks up and slaps her in the face. Now, admittedly, her problems in Season One were small potatoes compared to later issues (that's sort of the point), but since the very first scene Nancy was riding a bike with no handlebars, barreling ever forward bouncing off one obstacle headlong into the next hoping beyond hope that she doesn't hit a wall.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


<<|JustBugsMe|>>

to:

<<|JustBugsMe|>><<|JustBugsMe|>>

* The fact that after getting punched by her father, Silus just gives up on Megan and the subplot is not resolved at all. Then Shane's girlfriend with the braces disappears after the season 2 finale with no mention of what happened. It just seems like whenever a Botwin boy gets a girlfriend, they will abruptly disappear for some reason.

Added: 578

Changed: 588

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* People who complain about the show is not about the suburbs anymore. Seriously the show not simply being about how self absorbed white people are [[SarcasmMode is a bad thing? The show actually using its platform to show people with real problems(shit that goes down under ninety percent of the audiences noses every damn day and no one really cares btw) and actually introducing its audience to new ideas makes it bad.]] I can understand saying its not as funny or that Esteban was boring but seriously anyone complaining about how the show is not [[OpinionMyopia about YOU]] anymore is seriously [[CompletelyMissingthePoint missing the point]].

to:

* [[WMG: People who complain about how the show is not about the suburbs anymore. anymore.]]
Seriously the show not simply being about how self absorbed white people are [[SarcasmMode is a bad thing? The show actually using its platform to show people with real problems(shit problems (shit that goes down under ninety percent of the audiences noses every damn day and no one really cares btw) and actually introducing its audience to new ideas makes it bad.]] I can understand saying its not as funny or that Esteban was boring but seriously anyone complaining about how the show is not [[OpinionMyopia about YOU]] anymore is seriously [[CompletelyMissingthePoint missing the point]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I enjoyed the show more when it was in the suburbs, and not because it was about me. Before Nancy started growing, the extent of her trouble was maybe that her weed for one month got jacked. She was in control. However, once she started working for U-Turn, and everything was life or death, she was no longer in control, and suddenly it just began to feel a lot more like all the other stuff on the air.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*People who complain about the show is not about the suburbs anymore. Seriously the show not simply being about how self absorbed white people are [[SarcasmMode is a bad thing? The show actually using its platform to show people with real problems(shit that goes down under ninety percent of the audiences noses every damn day and no one really cares btw) and actually introducing its audience to new ideas makes it bad.]] I can understand saying its not as funny or that Esteban was boring but seriously anyone complaining about how the show is not [[OpinionMyopia about YOU]] anymore is seriously [[CompletelyMissingthePoint missing the point]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

...but he didn't show up in a pizza delivery getup.

Top