Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Undertale

Go To


Added DiffLines:

*I was bothered about this for a while until I realized something. Frisk can bypass the barrier because they do have two souls with them. They have their own and they have ''you''. We are the reason Frisk can escape the Underground in Neutral Endings, our two souls together allow them to pass through the Barrier.

Added DiffLines:

* She might not think she can judge you too harshly considering her own crimes.

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Alphys during a violent neutral route]]
Alphys has been watching you pretty closely, and she ALWAYS helps you in a neutral route. If you've been playing in a borderline-genocide manner, does that mean she's knowingly "assisting" a murderer?


* * As noted above, the soul stealing mechanic has never been properly explained. Presumably, Frisk would just seal Asgores soul in a spare soul jar or whatever by using DETERMINATION, or something.

to:

* * As noted above, the soul stealing mechanic has never been properly explained. Presumably, Frisk would just seal Asgores soul in a spare soul jar or whatever by using DETERMINATION, or something.

Added DiffLines:

* * As noted above, the soul stealing mechanic has never been properly explained. Presumably, Frisk would just seal Asgores soul in a spare soul jar or whatever by using DETERMINATION, or something.

Added DiffLines:

*** [[MemeticMutation Scandalous!]]

Added DiffLines:

** Considering that humans know magic in this universe, it is possible that magic has severely regressed the evolutionary line of technology.

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Humans can take monster souls?]]

Ok, so, the writing on the wall says that the monsters ability to steal souls is just that; the monsters special ability. But just before you go to face Asgore, Alphys tell you the terrible truth: that in order to cross the barrier, you'll have to take Asgore's soul. Um, what? Even Asgore at some point offers you his soul himself to help you cross the barrier. If humans can't absorb monster souls, and Asgore and Alphys would definitely be two monsters who should know a lot about this, then how would that even work?

Added DiffLines:

*** ...Except that "Only ages after reproducing" rule only applies to Boss Monsters - all other monsters age normally (though at slower pace than humans, as evidenced by Gerson). And Asriel was a child, so even they aren't born adult.

Added DiffLines:

** It's possible that 'kid' is just a classification of monster, given that monsters don't age until they reproduce and give their life energy to a child, or that Monster Kid is a child who's applying blanket logic that doesn't really work. Most likely the latter.


**** There are plenty of mountain communities with limited electricity and technology, especially since many people don't live in the heart of the village proper. Besides, no one said Frisk was in America.




to:

** The big thing about the weapons is that it's never stated that they're 'real' items. Like real as in existing, yes, but the empty gun could just as easily be a plastic nerf, given that it's not the weapon that matters but the intent behind it. What's more realistic: someone running around in an apron with a real frying pan, or a child playing in the woods with a plastic toy frying pan and a cutesy little apron? Maybe the person with the gun was having a tricked-out paintball fight while playing cowboys. All of these things make sense if you account for children running around playing make-believe.


Added DiffLines:

** It could be that only children can get into the Underground for whatever reason. Malice is a real and tangible force in the Monster world, and adults accumulate a whole lot more ill intent by that age, so it would make sense that they'd have done something to the barrier to keep overly malicious humans out (especially considering that ''one'' could wipe them from existence entirely) and just forgotten that children can also be overly malicious.

Added DiffLines:

** Same reason you can't see Mettaton's ghost form. Chara's possessing you, albeit not strong enough to take control, so there's no reason for Napstablook to be able to see her.

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Future?]]
* As revealed during the fight with [[spoiler:Asriel, Chara was the one who fell in the year 201X. Given the fact that most of the monsters don't recognize Frisk as a human, that would mean many years have passed since at least the sixth human's fall. So why doesn't the surface world look more futuristic in the True Pacifist credits?]]

Showing 15 edit(s) of 992

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report