Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MagicKnightRayearth

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Christmas Cake was merged with Old Maid some time ago


** Probably Alceone is a ChristmasCake from Umi's perspective.

to:

** Probably Alceone is a ChristmasCake [[OldMaid Christmas Cake]] from Umi's perspective.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Probably Alceone is a ChristmasCake from Umi's perspective.

to:

* ** Probably Alceone is a ChristmasCake from Umi's perspective.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Probably Alceone is a ChristmasCake from Umi's perspective.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Hikaru, the magic knight of fire is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.

to:

* So Hikaru, the magic knight of fire fire, is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Hikaru, the magic knight of fire is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.

to:

* So Hikaru, the magic knight of fire is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.knights.
** It isn't the wind sign, but it ''is'' the Archer sign, and Fuu is an archer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Hilary, the magic knight of fire is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.

to:

* So Hilary, Hikaru, the magic knight of fire is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The implication I got was that Nova was created because Hikaru has a stronger will/heart (remember Hikaru was [[spoiler: chosen as the new Pillar]] at the end of the second season) than the other girls. Basically, Hikaru being [[spoiler:Pillar-worthy]] meant that she could accidently will her grief and pain into a physical form to punish herself.

to:

** The implication I got was that Nova was created because Hikaru has a stronger will/heart (remember Hikaru was [[spoiler: chosen as the new Pillar]] at the end of the second season) than the other girls. Basically, Hikaru being [[spoiler:Pillar-worthy]] meant that she could accidently will her grief and pain into a physical form to punish herself.herself.
* Why does Umi keep calling Alceone middle-aged? The icey sorceress looks like she's in her mid 30's at most.
* So Hilary, the magic knight of fire is a Leo, which is a fire sign. Umi, the magic knight of water, is a Pisces, which is a water sign. But then Fuu, the magic knight of wind, is a Sagittarius, which is a fire sign. Why wasn't a girl with a wind zodiac sign summoned to be the wind knight if the other roles were assigned to girls with a matching astrological element? As much as I love Fuu, this discrepancy wouldn't stand out as much to me if Umi and Hikaru's astro elements didn't match up with the elements they respectively wield as magic knights.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a flashback scene in one of the later episodes taking place after the trio's first battle with one of Ascot's monsters [[spoiler: showing that Fuu did try using her healing magic to revive Presea only for the blacksmith to be too far gone for it to work.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also in the anime, since Nova is a manifestation of Hikaru's dark side, how come Umi and Fuu never gained dark doppelgangers of their own since they felt the same despair that she did?

to:

* Also in the anime, since Nova is a manifestation of Hikaru's dark side, how come Umi and Fuu never gained dark doppelgangers of their own since they felt the same despair that she did?did?
** The implication I got was that Nova was created because Hikaru has a stronger will/heart (remember Hikaru was [[spoiler: chosen as the new Pillar]] at the end of the second season) than the other girls. Basically, Hikaru being [[spoiler:Pillar-worthy]] meant that she could accidently will her grief and pain into a physical form to punish herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the anime, why didn't Fuu try to [[spoiler: use her healing spell on Presea?]]

to:

* In the anime, why didn't Fuu try to [[spoiler: use her healing spell on Presea?]]Presea?]]
* Also in the anime, since Nova is a manifestation of Hikaru's dark side, how come Umi and Fuu never gained dark doppelgangers of their own since they felt the same despair that she did?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the anime, why didn't Fuu try to [[spoiler: use her healing spell on Presea?]]

Top