Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MagiaRecordPuellaMagiMadokaMagicaSideStory

Go To


Added DiffLines:

**** As of October 2019 Matsuri and Haruka are playable in the JP servers as part of a second Suzune event, so it isn't out of the question for other spinoff girls to make it into the game.


* Why are some of the girls' ascended, chibified, or swimsuit forms treated as separate characters? Couldn't they have been separate skins or second forms for the same characters in question?

to:

* Why are some of the girls' ascended, chibified, or swimsuit forms treated as separate characters? Couldn't they have been separate skins or second forms for the same characters in question?question?
** The chibified forms (Madoka-senpai as well as related Felicia and Iroha) are treated as separate characters because '''[[AlternateUniverse they are.]]''' Ascended, depends; Ultimate Madoka is technically Madoka only on some level, the other don't have that excuse. Swimsuits... Well, it's gacha. Just look at Fate Grand Order.

Added DiffLines:

*** Well, turns out that at least [[https://wiki.puella-magi.net/Matsuri_Hinata#Magia_Record Matsuri]] and [[https://wiki.puella-magi.net/Haruka_Kanade#Magia_Record Haruka]] have in fact appeared in the game, even if they still aren't playable.


** There was something mentioned about rerunning events during Howa Howa event, so it's possible they're trying to save other girls for the re-runs by applying RuleOfThree (there's also speculation of uncapping existing spinoff girls during reruns, and possibly even Oriko event).

to:

** There was something mentioned about rerunning events during Howa Howa event, so it's possible they're trying to save other girls for the re-runs by applying RuleOfThree (there's also speculation of uncapping existing spinoff girls during reruns, and possibly even Oriko event).event).
* Why are some of the girls' ascended, chibified, or swimsuit forms treated as separate characters? Couldn't they have been separate skins or second forms for the same characters in question?


* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)

to:

* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)them?)
** There was something mentioned about rerunning events during Howa Howa event, so it's possible they're trying to save other girls for the re-runs by applying RuleOfThree (there's also speculation of uncapping existing spinoff girls during reruns, and possibly even Oriko event).


* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)

to:

* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? Matsuri? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)


* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''ws'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)

to:

* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''ws'' ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)


* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari was ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)

to:

* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari was is ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' ''ws'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)


* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari was ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all absence long, so what about them?)

to:

* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari was ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all former absence long, so what about them?)


** Given that the OP has her standing in front of Walpurgis Night, I'm pretty sure it just hasn't come up in the story yet.

to:

** Given that the OP has her standing in front of Walpurgis Night, I'm pretty sure it just hasn't come up in the story yet.yet.
* Is there some kind of limit in place for three characters from each installment beyond Madoka itself? I know Oriko, Kirika, and Yuma were the only three to appear in the original Oriko Magica, and Kazumi, Kaoru, and Umika were always treated as the "core" members of the Pleiades Saints, but Suzune and Tart Magica both had tight-knit groups of four, the former which didn't include Suzune herself. I know Pernelle played second fiddle, and Kagari was ''evil'', but ''are'' there any plans in place for Eliza, Haruka, and Matsuri in place? (I understand Sayaka ''was'' planned for a proper appearance all absence long, so what about them?)


* So, did Homura just forget about Walpurgisnacht? Am I missing something here?

to:

* So, did Homura just forget about Walpurgisnacht? Am I missing something here?here?
** Given that the OP has her standing in front of Walpurgis Night, I'm pretty sure it just hasn't come up in the story yet.

Added DiffLines:

* So, did Homura just forget about Walpurgisnacht? Am I missing something here?

Showing 12 edit(s) of 12

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report