Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / JonathanCreek

Go To


Added DiffLines:

!!The Wrestler's Tomb

* Why isn't Martin (Husband of Katrina, [[spoiler:with whom Hedley was having an affair]]) ever considered as a suspect?

Added DiffLines:


!!Gorgons Wood
* Surely given the contract Carla signed was signed without Carla’s knowledge of what she was signing (believing it was just an autograph), and given the time frame involved (no more than a few weeks), couldn’t Carla sue or cancel the contract on the basis of lack of knowledge of what she was signing up for, and that the company must have had the items with her likeness/name on made up in advance of her signing it, since there were items already in the adult shop for sale? Especially given that Carla can prove, with witnesses as to where she was and what she was doing on the date in question, and Jonathan can also attest to the diversion tactics used to obtain said signature.


Added DiffLines:

** For a real life example of this, John Barrowman and his sister Carole. They were born and raised in Glasgow, but he has a pretty American sounding accent. When the two are together, the Scottish comes out, especially in older sister Carole.

Added DiffLines:

***As I recall he met and married her when he was living abroad and they had only recently moved to the UK. Since she isn't British and hadn't lived there for long it wouldn't be such a big deal to leave.




to:

\n*** Adam Klaus' accent is almost certainly fake in-universe - just as his real name is Chester. The guy's a full-time fake. Plus, of course, RuleOfFunny.



to:

** Yeah, it's ludicrous to suppose that the Marella's husband and twelve year old daughter wouldn't instantly have known that Beryl was taking their wife/mother's place, but there ''is'' an attempt to handwave it when the butler says: "you were blinded by her love - for you, for Charlotte."

Added DiffLines:


!!Black Canary

* Beryl Carney's estranged daughter Hannah figures out that her mother is actually alive and masquerading as her twin sister Marella Carney within seconds of meeting her again just by intuition. Why then, were the dead Marella Carney's own family not able to deduce that it was not Marella who had survived but Beryl? Surely Marella's husband and daughter would have been able to work this out because they knew the sisters so well - there must have been differences between the two that the husband and daughter would have known about, especially if estranged daughter Hannah is able to work out what had happened so quickly.




to:

\n** Maybe Lance Gessler [[spoiler:knew about the trap and regularly maintained and cleaned it (but figured it would be too risky to remove the bodies from the tank.)]]



<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>

to:

<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>


** So much of the hidden mystery is dependant on the fact that the police are completely incompetent in every faccet of thier job. Why the hell didn't anyone do a background check on Emily to see if she had any prior criminal history? Wouldn't someone doing basic paperwork have noticed that Emily had been on trial for another murder? And looked up what happened to to the murder victim's family? Even though the husband had changed his name, someone might have looked into his history as part of the case. Even if the police decided it was unrelated and ignored it, there WOULD be a nosy reporter who would want to track down and interview the family of Emily's previous victim to get their thoughts on the current trial. (Especially the press of the Jonathan's Creek's world, who are regularly portrayed as [[CompleteMonster insanely biased]].) Hell, on finding out that Emily had a former murder case, SOMEONE would have tried to track down the other accused. Or better yet, '''realize that the victim of her last case had the same damn home address as the victim of the current case.'''
** Also, any competant medical examiner, on noticing a murder victim was pregnant, would have done a DNA test on the baby to make sure it was the husband's. If it wasn't, then that might have bearing on the friggin' case. ("Hmm...maybe the husband was in on it...")
** Secondly, why didn't the medical examiner do a simply tox test and see that the murder victim had a serious amount of tranquilzers in her blood? Far too much to even be walking, let alone struggle against someone pushing her out a window.

to:

** So much of the hidden mystery is dependant on the fact that the police are completely incompetent in every faccet of thier job. Why the hell didn't anyone do a background check on Emily to see if she had any prior criminal history? Wouldn't someone doing basic paperwork have noticed that Emily had been on trial for another murder? And looked up what happened to to the murder victim's family? Even though the husband had changed his name, someone might have looked into his history as part of the case. Even if the police decided it was unrelated and ignored it, there WOULD be a nosy reporter who would want to track down and interview the family of Emily's previous victim to get their thoughts on the current trial. (Especially the press of the Jonathan's Creek's world, who are regularly portrayed as [[CompleteMonster insanely biased]].biased.) Hell, on On finding out that Emily had a former murder case, SOMEONE would have tried to track down the other accused. Or better yet, '''realize that the victim of her last case had the same damn home address as the victim of the current case.'''
** Also, any competant competent medical examiner, on noticing a murder victim was pregnant, would have done a DNA test on the baby to make sure it was the husband's. If it wasn't, then that might have bearing on the friggin' case. ("Hmm...maybe the husband was in on it...")
** Secondly, why didn't the medical examiner do a simply tox test and see that the murder victim had a serious amount of tranquilzers tranquilizers in her blood? Far too much to even be walking, let alone struggle against someone pushing her out a window.



** Also, the entire plan is dependant on the idea that, I don't know...''Emily wouldn't just quit.'' No matter how good the money if I started seeing ghosts, having hallucinations [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and my boss was a bitch]] I would '''leave'''.

to:

** Also, the entire plan is dependant dependent on the idea that, I don't know...''Emily wouldn't just quit.'' No matter how good the money if I started seeing ghosts, having hallucinations [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and my boss was a bitch]] I would '''leave'''.

Added DiffLines:

**** [[spoiler:The bathtub may get rid of the body, but what about clothes? Mina may have left hers in the bedroom, but surely some would have done what Joey did and got changed in the bathroom leaving clothes and underwear on the floor? - surely if they did that would have been a giveaway for what they were doing when they vanished.]]


Added DiffLines:



* In 'The Omega Man', Jonathan says that he freezes up whenever he's in front of a television camera, but is seen in front of a camera, [[spoiler:stepping in as as a double for an actor who had taken the day off sick]] at the end of the previous episode, 'The Eyes of Tiresias'.

to:

* In 'The Omega Man', Jonathan says that he freezes up whenever he's in front of a television camera, but is seen in front of a camera, [[spoiler:stepping in as as a double for an actor who had taken the day off sick]] at the end of the previous episode, 'The Eyes of Tiresias'.




to:

*In 'The Omega Man', Jonathan says that he freezes up whenever he's in front of a television camera, but is seen in front of a camera, [[spoiler:stepping in as as a double for an actor who had taken the day off sick]] at the end of the previous episode, 'The Eyes of Tiresias'.



to:

** Probably; it would depend also on how early the accent shift occurred and how hard they worked at it. It's also possible that Adam, being something of a pretentious twat, is the kind of guy who'd not only adopt a false accent but stubbornly maintain it around people who know full well that it's a complete act.



to:

* Adam Klaus is played by an actor from Boston with a [[HollywoodNewEngland strong New England accent]], but his sister Kitty has a broad Scottish accent. While it's not so far-fetched that one of them may have picked up a local accent upon relocation (and maintained it), can siblings' accents really be that different? And where do Klaus and Kitty come from originally?


** I don't think it ever stated about him not telling regading 'Jack in A Box' did it? And the implication running through those scenes was that it was in Maddy's book (since the fanclub were getting everything from the book). So that would be my explination for that.

to:

** I don't think it was ever stated that he did not talk about him not telling regading 'Jack in A Box' did it? Box'. And the implication running through those scenes was that it was in Maddy's book (since the fanclub were getting everything from the book). So that would be my explination for that.

Showing 15 edit(s) of 25

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report