Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DoctorStrange2016

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The whole projection clearly depicts something like ley-lines. Apparently, grand nexuses (nexi?) of these are attractive places both for great cities and great magics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Or Strange promised to break the loop right after Dormammu withdraws his pawns and slurps back the current incursion. This way when the loop is broken he has no proxies to cause havok until the next idiot skips the warning in a book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* At least one RL occultic "textbook" from 19th century actually listed the summoning details before warnings, and this part had a direct plagia-descent from ''Ars Goetia'' (though never got to read AG itself to check), so it is sort of authentic, even if ass-headed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
namespacing


*** On the question of what they're for and why they appear, my best educated guess is that the magic circles- arrays, mandalas, whatever word you want to use- are something along the lines of channelling devices: something that helps to lock, anchor or guide magical energy to where it needs to go, sustaining the flow or sealing it where it is. Think Dormammu's sigil on the foreheads of those who draw power from the Dark Dimension, maybe even compare to how the triquetra appears on Mjolnir in {{Thor}} after Odin enchants it, reappearing when the enchantment is triggered: magic is either being channelled or held in place, with the help of a symbol. It would also make sense that a sorcerer might need to use something to help hold magical energy in place, since we know they need relics to hold immense amounts of power for them. You can also say that's why the green arrays from the Eye of Agamotto remain throughout the final confrontation- the magic creating the time loop is being sustained by them.

to:

*** On the question of what they're for and why they appear, my best educated guess is that the magic circles- arrays, mandalas, whatever word you want to use- are something along the lines of channelling devices: something that helps to lock, anchor or guide magical energy to where it needs to go, sustaining the flow or sealing it where it is. Think Dormammu's sigil on the foreheads of those who draw power from the Dark Dimension, maybe even compare to how the triquetra appears on Mjolnir in {{Thor}} ''Film/{{Thor}}'' after Odin enchants it, reappearing when the enchantment is triggered: magic is either being channelled or held in place, with the help of a symbol. It would also make sense that a sorcerer might need to use something to help hold magical energy in place, since we know they need relics to hold immense amounts of power for them. You can also say that's why the green arrays from the Eye of Agamotto remain throughout the final confrontation- the magic creating the time loop is being sustained by them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps but then what was the justification for the Ancient One interacting with the Dark Dimension? She's using its power to live forever while also saying "don't mess with the Dark Dimension." Crossing lines set by your mentor as a matter of accomplishing some greater good, sure, that's an acceptable choice one must make in times of duress and possible loss of life (and Mordo finding a difference of values with Strange's violation is seeing things overly black-and-white, that is agreeable). But for the sole purpose of outliving one's lifespan? That benefits no one but the person doing so -- the same person who is saying no good could come of summoning its power and pointing to Kaecilius as an example of someone who didn't do what she told him (and also bear in mind she's not telling anyone she's doing this, painting her use of the power as either selfish or regrettable due to their hypocrisy). Again, fractured from the top and a key failing in how Mordo perceives the importance of what he was taught vs. the one who taught it to him (magic is not as restrictive as the Ancient One taught him, the rules she laid down not necessarily reflecting the reality of using it and it is not as dangerous to experiment with as she claimed).

to:

** Perhaps but then what was the justification for the Ancient One interacting with the Dark Dimension? She's using its power to live forever while also saying "don't mess with the Dark Dimension." Crossing lines set by your mentor as a matter of accomplishing some greater good, sure, that's an acceptable choice one must make in times of duress and possible loss of life (and Mordo finding a difference of values with Strange's violation is seeing things overly black-and-white, that is agreeable). But for the sole purpose of outliving one's lifespan? That benefits no one but the person doing so -- the same person who is saying no good could come of summoning its power and pointing to Kaecilius as an example of someone who didn't do what she told him (and also bear in mind she's not telling anyone she's doing this, painting her use of the power as either selfish or regrettable due to their hypocrisy). Again, fractured from the top and a key failing in how Mordo perceives the importance of what he was taught vs. the one who taught it to him (magic is not as restrictive as the Ancient One taught him, the rules she laid down not necessarily reflecting the reality of using it and it is not as dangerous to experiment with as she claimed). Kaecilius and his followers becoming slaves to Dormmamu could simply be down to seeking power over virtue, which is an easy line in the sand to draw and one that explicitly points out the threshold at which the rules matter rather than making the blanket statement that the power of the Dark Dimension is ''never'' to be trusted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Perhaps but then what was the justification for the Ancient One interacting with the Dark Dimension? She's using its power to live forever while also saying "don't mess with the Dark Dimension." Crossing lines set by your mentor as a matter of accomplishing some greater good, sure, that's an acceptable choice one must make in times of duress and possible loss of life (and Mordo finding a difference of values with Strange's violation is seeing things overly black-and-white, that is agreeable). But for the sole purpose of outliving one's lifespan? That benefits no one but the person doing so -- the same person who is saying no good could come of summoning its power and pointing to Kaecilius as an example of someone who didn't do what she told him (and also bear in mind she's not telling anyone she's doing this, painting her use of the power as either selfish or regrettable due to their hypocrisy). Again, fractured from the top and a key failing in how Mordo perceives the importance of what he was taught vs. the one who taught it to him (magic is not as restrictive as the Ancient One taught him, the rules she laid down not necessarily reflecting the reality of using it and it is not as dangerous to experiment with as she claimed).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** My second two kids were born c-section, I was in the operating room with my wife as the surgeons worked behind a screen. Radio was on the whole time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* I think in movies "natural law" is on the level of "changing the factory settings". When you mess with time, life, death, fate, etc - you're a little close to the edge in many people's opinions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** DC comics in the Marvel Universe were later verified in ''Film/{{Eternals}}'', which name-drops Superman and Batman.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ahem. ''Why the bloody hell do the warnings come '''after''' the spells!?'' That's a sure-fire way to cause some serious accidents. Strange nearly destroys time because he doesn't ''know'' that can happen! All I can imagine is that it's a security measure meant for the exact purpose it's put to in the film; if someone's too eager for power to actually read the whole thing and just casts the spell, they get HoistByTheirOwnPetard. Which of course means that someone just non-maliciously studying magic is likely to kill themselves if not make some big messes in the process ''of'' killing themselves before they figure that out. Though the curriculum at Kamar-Taj is implied to be about that lethal, given how [[SinkOrSwimMentor the Ancient One]] ''[[DieOrFly strands Strange on Mount Everest]]'' because he can't quite grasp how to use his Sling Ring.[[note]]Oh, and I put in front of everything because that's where Strange suggests that's where warnings belong.[[/note]]

to:

* Ahem. ''Why the bloody hell do the warnings come '''after''' the spells!?'' That's a sure-fire way to cause some serious accidents. Strange nearly destroys time because he doesn't ''know'' that can happen! All I can imagine is that it's a security measure meant for the exact purpose it's put to in the film; if someone's too eager for power to actually read the whole thing and just casts the spell, they get HoistByTheirOwnPetard. Which of course means that someone just non-maliciously studying magic is likely to kill themselves if not make some big messes in the process ''of'' killing themselves before they figure that out. Though the curriculum at Kamar-Taj is implied to be about that lethal, given how [[SinkOrSwimMentor the Ancient One]] ''[[DieOrFly strands Strange on Mount Everest]]'' because he can't quite grasp how to use his Sling Ring.[[note]]Oh, and I put in front of everything because that's where Strange suggests that's where warnings belong.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that film took place circa 2012-2013, as evidenced by the characters mentioning that their meeting on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award on Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 2, 2016.

to:

*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that film took place circa 2012-2013, as evidenced by the characters mentioning that their meeting on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 thirteen years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by given that an award on Strange's wall before his accident is dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 2, 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Perhaps one of the books Strange has read during his learning montage was about the deals with supernatural beings and the magically binding oaths of various sorts developed specifically to keep them from reneging? Then, after Dormammu agreed to Strange's terms they performed the whole 6-hour ceremony off-screen to conserve details.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that film took place circa 2012-2013, as evidenced by the characters mentioning that their meeting on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 2, 2016.

to:

*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that film took place circa 2012-2013, as evidenced by the characters mentioning that their meeting on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in on Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 2, 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that fit took place circa 2012-2013, as evidences by the characters mentioning that their meeting in on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 2, 2016.

to:

*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that fit film took place circa 2012-2013, as evidences evidenced by the characters mentioning that their meeting in on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 2, 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that fit took place circa 2012-2013, as evidences by the characters mentioning that their meeting in on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 1, 2016.

to:

*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that fit took place circa 2012-2013, as evidences by the characters mentioning that their meeting in on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 1, 2, 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The film does not take place before ''Iron Man 3'', as that fit took place circa 2012-2013, as evidences by the characters mentioning that their meeting in on New Years Eve 1999 happened 13 years prior, while ''Doctor Strange'' begins no earlier than 2016, as shown by an award in Strange's wall before his accident dated 2016, and a close up shot of his watch on the day of his accident shows the current date as February 1, 2016.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since this film took place before Iron Man 3, it seems unlikely that anybody bothers to mention a treatment (which would make him explode anyway) to the Sorcerer Supreme.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: Misplaced FridgeBrilliance and/or GeniusBonus entry]]
* I'm pretty certain that I read something on one of these pages[[note]]Side question: what's the correct term for a group of the pages (Main, Fridge, YMMV, etc.) that are all about a specific works?[[/note]] that explained why Strange took issue with Thor calling him "wizard" that had to do with the origins of the word. Was it deleted for whatever reason, am I looking in the wrong place, or what?
** I don't know what happened to it, but I do know that it was a misunderstanding of the etymology of "wizard" - it just means "one who is wise" like how "drunkard" means "one who is drunk" or "dullard" means "one who is dull.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because Strange can just trap him in time again. That's the whole point of the entire climax.

to:

** Because Strange can has just trap trapped him in time again.time. That's the whole point of the entire climax. They both now exist solely within that span of a few moments, minutes at most. Whether he kills Doctor Strange or not is not the point, time will continue to reset anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which would you prefer to do? Live forever but you also drain a small amount of power from a nice, friendly ally that would otherwise have used that same energy for something good? Or be just as immortal, but also you get to drain a small amount of the power from one of your sworn foes, who would have otherwise given that power to a supervillain and killed many people?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Whether Dormammu can lie or not is irrelevant. Once Doctor Strange has convinced it not to attack Earth ''now'', it never has and never will. Dormammu is outside of time except for when Doctor Strange brought to it. He introduced it to time just enough to give "time" to change its mind about attacking Earth then left, which means that it was, is, and always will be freshly put off about the idea of an attack on Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You're correct. I didn't get the impression that we were meant to agree with Christine thinking that he should be nicer to Nic (the surgeon who made the mistake). I got the impression that this was to demonstrate Doctor Strange ''already'' being set apart from the everyday world by his genius and their coddling of idiots, to set up his ascendance to Sorcerer Supreme once he finally starts the path he was truly supposed to be on, as a part of the more magical world of Kamar-Taj and the Ancient One. To demonstrate that even the closest people to his level of skill in the regular world (Christine) were too involved in petty niceties and frivolous material world matters to achieve what he achieves. You might also notice that, despite his obvious wealth, his fancy car and huge flat, and lots of expensive watches (themselves a sign of his soon to be position as a master of time) he had very few other possessions. His home was expensive but minimalist, since the vast majority of his ''time'' was spent working, and not enjoying the rewards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Pangborn's file already lists informed consent for Doctor Stephen Strange to see it, since he actively sought out treatment from Doctor Strange.

Top