Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / CriminalMinds

Go To





















* The whole ending for Demonology bothered me to no end. In a show that at least tries to pretend some semblance of realism trying to do something that might hint at there being real demons or whatever seems fairly jarring not to mention the fact that it would actually justify the murdering priest.
* A minor thing but in Seven Seconds what happened to Jeremy after his parents were arrested? His aunt and uncle don't seem all that concerned about him (justified as they were focused on Katie) but did they take him in later? Or did they abandon him to foster care due to what his parents did?
* Another minor thing but in Mosley Lane it's revealed that the oldest kidnap victim (a teenage boy who been held by the kidnappers since he was a young child) had helped kidnap more kids (by driving the get away car I think). I have always wondered was he charged (by the police) for his role in the crimes?

to:


* The whole ending for Demonology "Demonology" bothered me to no end. In a show that at least tries to pretend some semblance of realism trying to do something that might hint at there being real demons or whatever seems fairly jarring not to mention the fact that it would actually justify the murdering priest.
priest.

* A minor thing but in Seven Seconds "Seven Seconds" what happened to Jeremy after his parents were arrested? His aunt and uncle don't seem all that concerned about him (justified as they were focused on Katie) but did they take him in later? Or did they abandon him to foster care due to what his parents did?
did?

* Another minor thing but in Mosley Lane "Mosley Lane" it's revealed that the oldest kidnap victim (a teenage boy who been held by the kidnappers since he was a young child) had helped kidnap more kids (by driving the get away car I think). I have always wondered was he charged (by the police) for his role in the crimes?






* How did Samantha Malcolm, the [=UnSub=] of 'Uncanny Valley' get a stun-gun? She's a woman known to be mentally disturbed and legally incompetent in a state that has restrictions on the item in question. You need a permit to own one.

to:


* How did Samantha Malcolm, the [=UnSub=] of 'Uncanny Valley' "Uncanny Valley" get a stun-gun? She's a woman known to be mentally disturbed and legally incompetent in a state that has restrictions on the item in question. You need a permit to own one.












* In If The Shoe Fits JJ is angry at her mom for telling JJ's son about Rosaline and makes a point that she discussed telling him with Will. Yet she never bothered to tell her mom about the decision to not tell the kid ?

to:


* In If "If The Shoe Fits Fits", JJ is angry at her mom for telling JJ's son about Rosaline and makes a point that she discussed telling him with Will. Yet she never bothered to tell her mom about the decision to not tell the kid ?kid?


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:




to:

** Clearly there's more wrong with him mentally than ''just'' hearing painful noise a lot, considering most people would react to that by seeking medical help, ''not'' attacking people and sewing their mouths shut. Besides which, if he'd acknowledged that he could write responses when first arrested he'd have had to tell them who he was, and that would make it ''much'' more likely he'd be convicted of his mom's murder too. So he probably just tore up any writing paper they offered him in protest, same as he'd refused to identify himself in sign language.



* In "P911", the young boy is being kept in a soundproofed cell with no door. The team eventually realises that the cell was built around him. However: 1, wouldn't that A, take a while and B, be highly problematic considering that there's someone in there while it was built? 2, the boy was kept in there for several days. The room wasn't that big and there was no ventilation, so wouldn't he have run out of air? 3, if the room was soundproofed, then how did that scene where he calls to his captor, asking to be let out, and his captor yells at him to shut up work?

to:

* In "P911", the young boy is being kept in a soundproofed cell with no door. The team eventually realises realizes that the cell was built around him. However: 1, wouldn't that A, take a while and B, be highly problematic considering that there's someone in there while it was built? 2, the boy was kept in there for several days. The room wasn't that big and there was no ventilation, so wouldn't he have run out of air? 3, if the room was soundproofed, then how did that scene where he calls to his captor, asking to be let out, and his captor yells at him to shut up work?work?
** The cell was part of a larger room once, and the kidnapper laid the boy's body down in the middle of it, probably unconscious. The captor built the walls around him to fit tight against the floor and ceiling. The walls weren't soundproofed or airtight, just too sturdy for the kid to bust out through.


Added DiffLines:

** Or at least believes he is, so strongly that he developed a psychosomatic nosebleed.


























* In Supply and Demand, the season six finale, it's revealed that [[spoiler:JJ's coming back.]] Earlier in the episode, it's revealed that the FBI's going to have budget cuts. So, if they're having budget cuts, how do they have the money to hire [[spoiler:JJ?]]

to:


* In Supply "Supply and Demand, Demand", the season six finale, it's revealed that [[spoiler:JJ's coming back.]] Earlier in the episode, it's revealed that the FBI's going to have budget cuts. So, if they're having budget cuts, how do they have the money to hire [[spoiler:JJ?]]



* This is a really minor thing, but the episode ''Roadkill'' was set in Oregon. The unsub has to keep replacing his front bumper and license plate because he's killing people with his car. We see this again and again, and, appropriately, he always replaces Oregon plates. Rossi and Morgan find his discards... and they're California plates.

to:


* This is a really minor thing, but the episode ''Roadkill'' "Roadkill" was set in Oregon. The unsub has to keep replacing his front bumper and license plate because he's killing people with his car. We see this again and again, and, appropriately, he always replaces Oregon plates. Rossi and Morgan find his discards... and they're California plates.









* In "Mayhem" [[spoiler: the terrorist cell's plan is to set off a bomb in an ambulance to kill someone protected by the secret service. But the bomb doesn't seem large enough, especially since it would be in the underground concrete parking garage while the target was being airlifted off the roof. Were they planning to bring down the entire building? ]]

to:


* In "Mayhem" [[spoiler: the terrorist cell's plan is to set off a bomb in an ambulance to kill someone protected by the secret service. But the bomb doesn't seem large enough, especially since it would be in the underground concrete parking garage while the target was being airlifted off the roof. Were they planning to bring down the entire building? ]]building?]]












* In Safe Haven, Jeremy was supposedly one of twins and absorbed his brother in the womb. If the pregnancy was advanced enough for the mother to know she was having twins, is that even possible? One mostly-developed twin could die, certainly, but how could it just disappear?

to:


* In Safe Haven, "Safe Haven", Jeremy was supposedly one of twins and absorbed his brother in the womb. If the pregnancy was advanced enough for the mother to know she was having twins, is that even possible? One mostly-developed twin could die, certainly, but how could it just disappear?












* In ''The Silencer'': why didn't John Myers just '''write''' what his problem is? We know he's intelligent, well read, so why didn't he just write on a piece of paper "My defective earing implant is making every sound a torture, I need to be put in a place without noise"? I can understand why he never tried to tell his mother since she was probably just looking for excuses to abuse him, but he must have had teachers, neighbours, and after that the jail personnel must know this since they provided him books: someone should have at some point said "Maybe he does not speak because he's deaf and/or mute but he writes so I'll try that way to communicate"

to:


* In ''The Silencer'': why didn't John Myers just '''write''' what his problem is? We know he's intelligent, well read, so why didn't he just write on a piece of paper "My defective earing hearing implant is making every sound a torture, I need to be put in a place without noise"? I can understand why he never tried to tell his mother since she was probably just looking for excuses to abuse him, but he must have had teachers, neighbours, neighbors, and after that the jail personnel must know this since they provided him books: someone should have at some point said "Maybe he does not speak because he's deaf and/or mute mute, but he writes so I'll try that way to communicate"communicate".









* In the episode Cradle To Grave when the team arrive at the unsub's house it's revealed that one of the captive women had already given birth to a boy (now about four or five years old). Why then did the unsubs continue abducting and impregnating women if the female unsub already had her Michael?

to:

* In the episode Cradle "Cradle To Grave Grave" when the team arrive at the unsub's house it's revealed that one of the captive women had already given birth to a boy (now about four or five years old). Why then Why, then, did the unsubs continue abducting and impregnating women if the female unsub already had her Michael?

Added DiffLines:

** And then the local police investigating the "suicide" turn them on again, so they can check if the dead teen left a note on their computer. Really, the recordings should have been found long before the BAU got involved.

Added DiffLines:

*** Well according to 13x20 it is her mother and stepfather that were killed in a car accident when she was eighteen. I guess she considered her stepfather more of a real father to her then her biological father.


** Usually based on the victims, the area of the killings, and things like that.
** To elaborate: If the victims were white women abducted in a mostly white neighborhood and no one noticed anything out of the ordinary, you can rule out a ScaryBlackMan. Or if the victims were African-Americans abducted in a predominantly African-American neighborhood and no one noticed anything out of the ordinary, you can rule out a creepy white guy. Generally serial killers who abduct people in populated areas as opposed to waiting in the woods or something, do so from areas in which they can blend in, which is either going to be a very crowded area or a neighborhood where most people match their racial background. I am not sure but I'm fairly certain they're much more likely to state a probable race in the profile if the abductions happened in a neighborhood setting as opposed to a rural area or a crowded commerce area.
*** OP Here: Thank you.

to:

** Usually based on the victims, the area of the killings, and things like that. \n** To elaborate: If the victims were white women abducted in a mostly white neighborhood and no one noticed anything out of the ordinary, you can rule out a ScaryBlackMan. Or if the victims were African-Americans abducted in a predominantly African-American neighborhood and no one noticed anything out of the ordinary, you can rule out a creepy white guy. Generally serial killers who abduct people in populated areas as opposed to waiting in the woods or something, do so from areas in which they can blend in, which is either going to be a very crowded area or a neighborhood where most people match their racial background. I am not sure but I'm fairly certain they're much more likely to state a probable race in the profile if the abductions happened in a neighborhood setting as opposed to a rural area or a crowded commerce area. \n*** OP Here: Thank you.


* In "Red Light" it was never explained how Cat and Lindsay met, particularly given that Lindsay has been in jail for nearly two years in Iowa while Lindsay operates primarily in border states. Lindsay's dad was relocated to Wisconsin, a bordering state of Iowa, by WITSEC, but Lindsay left the program and headed south three years before Cat met Spencer. This may later be explained by the "mole in the BAU" theory, but as of this writing it's a plot hole.

to:

* In "Red Light" it was never explained how [[spoiler: Cat and Lindsay met, particularly given that Lindsay has been in jail for nearly two years in Iowa while Lindsay operates primarily in border states. Lindsay's dad was relocated to Wisconsin, a bordering state of Iowa, by WITSEC, but Lindsay left the program and headed south three years before Cat met Spencer. ]] This may later be explained by the "mole in the BAU" theory, but as of this writing it's a plot hole.


* In "Lo-Fi", comparison of video which captured two of the shootings indicates that one killer was significantly shorter than the other, and left the area at a different speed. Based on this information, the BAU presents two possible profiles: either it's a two-person team of serial killers, or it's a gang-initiation ritual. But the killings had been on the news for some time, so a rough description of what the suspect(s) wore during the attacks has presumably become public knowledge. So why was there no mention of a plausible third possibility: that someone who ''specifically'' had a grudge against the second victim heard about the shootings on the news, dressed up like the unsub, and copied his methods to eliminate the person they wanted dead?

to:

**He went to the unsub's house to convince her to commit suicide. He'd already convinced her that the killings were Dante's will and the final step of being at Dante's side forever as his vampire queen was to kill herself. His intentions were that if she was connected to the killings, he could disavow all knowledge. She's just some bat shit fan. No one would know that he had told her to kill those people or that he'd convinced her to kill herself. It would have been a "perfect" crime if JJ hadn't shown up. The manager didn't know who JJ was, but he knew she was someone who had seen him with the unsub and could possibly link him to the murders so he knocked her out and tried to convince the unsub to murder JJ as well so there would be no loose ends.
* In "Lo-Fi", comparison of video which captured two of the shootings indicates that one killer was significantly shorter than the other, and left the area at a different speed. Based on this information, the BAU presents two possible profiles: either it's a two-person team of serial killers, or it's a gang-initiation ritual. But the killings had been on the news for some time, so a rough description of what the suspect(s) wore during the attacks has presumably become public knowledge. So why was there no mention of a plausible third possibility: that someone who ''specifically'' had a grudge against the second victim heard about the shootings on the news, dressed up like the unsub, and copied his methods to eliminate the person they wanted dead?dead?
* In "Red Light" it was never explained how Cat and Lindsay met, particularly given that Lindsay has been in jail for nearly two years in Iowa while Lindsay operates primarily in border states. Lindsay's dad was relocated to Wisconsin, a bordering state of Iowa, by WITSEC, but Lindsay left the program and headed south three years before Cat met Spencer. This may later be explained by the "mole in the BAU" theory, but as of this writing it's a plot hole.

Added DiffLines:

** Dining areas also tend to get cleaned more often than most places. It's possible that someone spilled their drink or fries or whatever on the floor where the little girl had walked, and the mall's custodial staff wiped her trail away along with the mess.


** The male unsub was a sexual sadist. When he met his wife, he temporarily became calm, but soon regressed again, abusing her. However, because she was willing, he couldn't derive any pleasure out of it. In order to avoid killing her, they made a deal: he could rape and kill the abductees as long as she could raise the children that she chose. She was in it for Michael (and eventually more children, when she found out her cancer would kill her). He was in it mostly to satisfy his sadism.

to:

** The male unsub was a sexual sadist. When he met his wife, he temporarily became calm, but soon regressed again, abusing her. However, because she was willing, he couldn't derive any pleasure out of it. In order to avoid killing her, they made a deal: he could rape and kill the abductees as long as she could raise the children that she chose. She was in it for Michael (and eventually more children, when she found out her cancer would kill her). He was in it mostly to satisfy his sadism.sadism, so there was no reason for him to stop just because she got her Michael.

Added DiffLines:

** The male unsub was a sexual sadist. When he met his wife, he temporarily became calm, but soon regressed again, abusing her. However, because she was willing, he couldn't derive any pleasure out of it. In order to avoid killing her, they made a deal: he could rape and kill the abductees as long as she could raise the children that she chose. She was in it for Michael (and eventually more children, when she found out her cancer would kill her). He was in it mostly to satisfy his sadism.


* In "The Performer", why did Dante's agent go to the unsub's house, and more important, why did he attack JJ if he had no idea who she was?

to:

* In "The Performer", why did Dante's agent go to the unsub's house, and more important, why did he attack JJ if he had no idea who she was?was?
* In "Lo-Fi", comparison of video which captured two of the shootings indicates that one killer was significantly shorter than the other, and left the area at a different speed. Based on this information, the BAU presents two possible profiles: either it's a two-person team of serial killers, or it's a gang-initiation ritual. But the killings had been on the news for some time, so a rough description of what the suspect(s) wore during the attacks has presumably become public knowledge. So why was there no mention of a plausible third possibility: that someone who ''specifically'' had a grudge against the second victim heard about the shootings on the news, dressed up like the unsub, and copied his methods to eliminate the person they wanted dead?


** We don't know how long Hotch has been using the same address book. It's possible he wrote down that information when he first moved into the house and hadn't yet memorized its address.

to:

** We don't know how long Hotch has been using the same address book. It's possible he wrote down that information when he first moved into the house and hadn't yet memorized its address. Or the house may have originally been Hayley's home before they were married, and he filled it in when they were still dating.

Added DiffLines:

** We don't know how long Hotch has been using the same address book. It's possible he wrote down that information when he first moved into the house and hadn't yet memorized its address.


** Also, it's a statistical fact, apparently, that serial killers have never been known to choose victims outwith their own race. White killers kill white victims, black killers kill black victims...and so on.

to:

** Also, it's a statistical fact, apparently, that serial killers have never been known tend to choose victims outwith within their own race. White killers kill white victims, black killers kill black victims...and so on. Chalk it up to mommy/daddy issues in a lot of cases.

Showing 15 edit(s) of 181

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report