Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Coco

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** But Héctor didn't even see who Miguel was related to. If Miguel did just go back at that moment instead of sneaking away, what would happen?

to:

*** But Héctor didn't even see who Miguel was related to. If Miguel did just go back at that moment instead of sneaking away, what would happen?happen? At least he knows about who his real ancestor is.

Added: 146

Changed: -29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** True, but he also still cares a lot for Imelda, and giving Miguel a blessing that goes against her wishes would be a poor way to help win her over again. After all, when Imelda agrees to help them later, Héctor doesn’t argue with her stipulating the “no music” condition. He even seemed to think that the music ban might be in Miguel’s best interest, since he told him something like “You’ll thank me later” as he prepared to return him to his family.

to:

*** **** True, but he also still cares a lot for Imelda, and giving Miguel a blessing that goes against her wishes would be a poor way to help win her over again. After all, when Imelda agrees to help them later, Héctor doesn’t argue with her stipulating the “no music” condition. He even seemed to think that the music ban might be in Miguel’s best interest, since he told him something like “You’ll thank me later” as he prepared to return him to his family.family.
***** But Héctor didn't even see who Miguel was related to. If Miguel did just go back at that moment instead of sneaking away, what would happen?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not only that, she sang (with feeling) the words to a song that not just everyone is going to be familiar with. If she were as strict as the rest of the family implies she was, there’s no way she would’ve exposed herself to any music long enough to have the lyrics memorized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** True, but he also still cares a lot for Imelda, and giving Miguel a blessing that goes against her wishes would be a poor way to help win her over again. After all, when Imelda agrees to help them later, Héctor doesn’t argue with her stipulating the “no music” condition. He even seemed to think that the music ban might be in Miguel’s best interest, since he told him something like “You’ll thank me later” as he prepared to return him to his family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** He’d obviously take the former option because he and Miguel played together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Considering the timespans involved, that doesn’t have much to do with what atrocities the Europeans committed against native Americans. It’s not as though the Aztecs would’ve had more detailed records going that far back if they hadn’t been overtaken; many modern family trees aren’t able to be traced back that far. It’s an unfortunate fact of life that not every single individual in history is able to be remembered long after they’re gone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It would have probably cut Ernesto out of the equation, though given this is before Miguel finds out that Hé was murdered, perhaps that’s not for the best, since that was one of the two reasons Imelda was able to forgive him. And while Héctor would be able to give Miguel his blessing anyway, it is unclear whether he would be more understanding than Imelda was or if he would rather cede to his wife’s wishes and bar Miguel from playing music, too.

to:

** It would have probably cut Ernesto out of the equation, though given this is before Miguel finds out that Héctor was murdered, perhaps that’s not for the best, since that was one of the two reasons Imelda was able to forgive him. And while Héctor would be able to give Miguel his blessing anyway, it is unclear whether he would be more understanding than Imelda was or if he would rather cede to his wife’s wishes and bar Miguel from playing music, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It would have probably cut Ernesto out of the equation, though given this is before Miguel finds out that Héctor, perhaps that’s not for the best, since learning of the murder was one of the two reasons Imelda was able to forgive him. And while Héctor would be able to give Miguel his blessing anyway, it is unclear whether he would be more understanding than Imelda was or if he would rather cede to his wife’s wishes and bar Miguel from playing music, too.

to:

** It would have probably cut Ernesto out of the equation, though given this is before Miguel finds out that Héctor, Hé was murdered, perhaps that’s not for the best, since learning of the murder that was one of the two reasons Imelda was able to forgive him. And while Héctor would be able to give Miguel his blessing anyway, it is unclear whether he would be more understanding than Imelda was or if he would rather cede to his wife’s wishes and bar Miguel from playing music, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It would have probably cut Ernesto out of the equation, though given this is before Miguel finds out that Héctor, perhaps that’s not for the best, since learning of the murder was one of the two reasons Imelda was able to forgive him. And while Héctor would be able to give Miguel his blessing anyway, it is unclear whether he would be more understanding than Imelda was or if he would rather cede to his wife’s wishes and bar Miguel from playing music, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: Héctor returning Miguel]]
* What would’ve happened if Héctor returned Miguel to their family at the talent show?

to:

[[folder: Héctor returning Miguel]]
* What would’ve happened if Héctor returned Miguel to their family at the talent show?show? The plot [[CouldHaveAvoidedThisPlot could’ve been easily avoided]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Héctor returning Miguel]]
* What would’ve happened if Héctor returned Miguel to their family at the talent show?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Coco had letters from Hector. The letters contained all his songs. If Coco and her family never banned music, they would have heard Ernesto's songs. Coco would have notice his songs were the same as her father's letters and would have lead to suspicions. This would have lead to invesitagtion and eventually learn that Ernesto stole Hector's songs and confront him while Ernesto was alive. He would have been force to tell the truth and also reveal to them that he murder Hector. Ernesto would have been exposed while he was alive. Coco and her family would have known the truth long ago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If Ernesto was any good at writing, he probably wouldn't have had to murder his friend to steal his works ''or'' life film dialogue ''directly from'' that very murder.

to:

** If Ernesto was any good at writing, he probably wouldn't have had to murder his friend to steal poach his works ''or'' life film lift movie dialogue ''directly from'' that very murder.

Top