Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Cars3

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why was Ronald driving tense, and how did his exercise help him relax when he was on the treadmill?

to:

Why was Ronald driving tense, and how did his exercise help him relax when he was on the treadmill?treadmill?
** Because treadmills smooth you.
!! Mater’s dents
Where are Mater’s dents from the second film if he said kept them?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!! Lightning's Speed
If Lightning can do 19something on sand - a soft surface that continuously breaks away under pressure - how exactly would he not be doing 20something on a hard tarmac racetrack? With no bits of the racing surface continuously collapsing under him, he could apply full power and get full traction all the time, and hence achieve a higher maximum speed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This film in particular shows the flaw in using cars and drivers interchangeably, because of the whole aging thing, but ''also'' shows all the reasons why aging shouldn't be a problem. It's one thing if you're going to claim that the Cars in these movies are like people, where they're "born" how they are, and paint is the equivalent of clothing, and tires, shoes. But in the same film they show Cruz getting a spoiler, and having exhaust work done. Not to mention whatever happened offscreen to get Lightning McQueen put back together. So the question remains, if the cars in the film are mechanically just like the real thing, then why should age ''ever'' be an issue? True, tech has indeed advanced considerably from decade to decade, and even in the real world, a new family car could give a 90's sports car a run for its money. But there's also nothing stopping someone from upgrading that 90's car with modern equipment and parts. Let alone comparatively trivial things like reducing the drag co-efficient.

to:

* This film in particular shows the flaw in using cars and drivers interchangeably, because of the whole aging thing, but ''also'' shows all the reasons why aging shouldn't be a problem. It's one thing if you're going to claim that the Cars in these movies are like people, where they're "born" how they are, and paint is the equivalent of clothing, and tires, shoes. But in the same film they show Cruz getting a spoiler, and having exhaust work done. Not to mention whatever happened offscreen to get Lightning McQueen [=McQueen=] put back together. So the question remains, if the cars in the film are mechanically just like the real thing, then why should age ''ever'' be an issue? True, tech has indeed advanced considerably from decade to decade, and even in the real world, a new family car could give a 90's sports car a run for its money. But there's also nothing stopping someone from upgrading that 90's car with modern equipment and parts. Let alone comparatively trivial things like reducing the drag co-efficient.



After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens? Realistically, he AND Cal both had at least five or maybe more years left in their careers if real life NASCAR is to be believed.

to:

After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen [=McQueen=] is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens? Realistically, he AND Cal both had at least five or maybe more years left in their careers if real life NASCAR is to be believed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Maybe they developed the nearby field (building new commercial and residential districts) , while keep the old town center as a historical attraction.

to:

* Maybe they developed the nearby field (building new commercial and residential districts) , while keep the old town center as a historical attraction.attraction site.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Maybe they developed the nearby field (building new commercial and residential districts) , while keep the old town center as a historical attraction.

Added: 124

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the original film, it was stated that Radiator Springs was a DyingTown, and that they dearly missed company. The town got better, but we haven’t seen signs of any new businesses opened up there, or older ones re-opening aside from the Wheel Well. Why?

to:

In the original film, it was stated that Radiator Springs was a DyingTown, and that they dearly missed company. The town got better, but we haven’t seen signs of any new businesses opened up there, or older ones re-opening aside from the Wheel Well. Why?Why?
!! "I am a fluffy cloud."
Why was Ronald driving tense, and how did his exercise help him relax when he was on the treadmill?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Since it's in a way meant to be he in his "Beard of Sorrow" mode. Maybe it's the equipment of him "wearing a old rundown sweatshirt from his old merchandise/just some old , more casual (and more Saturday morning laziness) type of clothes".

to:

** Since it's in a way meant to be he in his "Beard of Sorrow" mode. Maybe it's the equipment of him "wearing a old rundown sweatshirt from his old merchandise/just some old , more casual (and more Saturday morning laziness) type of clothes". clothes".....Slightly tidier than just wearing his undies , but still not tidy enough for what people usually wear when they left their house for some day to day activities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since it's in a way meant to be he in his "Beard of Sorrow" mode. Maybe it's the equipment of him "wearing a old rundown sweatshirt from his old merchandise/just some old , more casual (and more Saturday morning laziness) type of clothes".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Agree to above comment, The age is more likely based on the mileage , and "soul"(as for "experience"...like how IRL ECU today can learn about driver's driving style and regular route condition , than adjust the system setting to got best performance. And for Cars universe , the ECU is more likely to be the same as brain , which you can't just swap a new one. So even if you can replace all the body parts , you still can't erase the mileage and the brain(aka mind set).)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the original film, it was stated that Radiator Springs was a DyingTown, and that they dearly missed company. The town got better, but we haven’t seen signs of any new businesses opened up there, or older ones re-opening. Why?

to:

In the original film, it was stated that Radiator Springs was a DyingTown, and that they dearly missed company. The town got better, but we haven’t seen signs of any new businesses opened up there, or older ones re-opening.re-opening aside from the Wheel Well. Why?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Honestly, these movies pretty much zigzag with their adoption of NASCAR. Presumably using original NASCAR rules (i.e. actual ''stock'' cars), in a modern setting. Ironically, if they fully adopted modern NASCAR rules, where every car was more or less the same, with a different shell, the "aging" theme would make a lot more sense. After all, if the cars were mechanically the same, actual driving ability would be far more important. However, by using completely different vehicles, where their performance is a major part of being competitive, one has to ask why doesn't Lightning simply get upgraded, with all that new tech and design improvements that the "next gen" racers have?

to:

* Honestly, these movies pretty much zigzag with their adoption of NASCAR. Presumably using original NASCAR rules (i.e. actual ''stock'' cars), in a modern setting. Ironically, if they fully adopted modern NASCAR rules, where every car was more or less the same, with a different shell, the "aging" theme would make a lot more sense. After all, if the cars were mechanically the same, actual driving ability would be far more important. However, by using completely different vehicles, where their performance is a major part of being competitive, one has to ask why doesn't Lightning simply get upgraded, with all that new tech and design improvements that the "next gen" racers have?have?
!! Status of Radiator Springs
In the original film, it was stated that Radiator Springs was a DyingTown, and that they dearly missed company. The town got better, but we haven’t seen signs of any new businesses opened up there, or older ones re-opening. Why?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, that and it was a self-deprecating TakeThat against accusations of Pixar primarily relying on the Cars brand for merchandising purposes. It was simply the company poking fun at themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Seriously are the mass produced compared to the older generation racers? The tie in book 'meet the cars' kinda implies as such with regards to the 4 next gens who are voiced by real NASCAR racers and the next gen Apple car. Is it possible that Jackson Storm is SuperPrototype of the next gens since his tie in origins book suggests that he was created in some lab.

to:

Seriously are Are the mass produced compared to the older generation racers? The tie in book 'meet the cars' kinda implies as such with regards to the 4 next gens who are voiced by real NASCAR racers and the next gen Apple car. Is it possible that Jackson Storm is the SuperPrototype of the next gens since his tie in origins book suggests that he was created in some lab.



What exactly is the purpose of the temporary 95 stickers on both of [=McQueen=]’s door panels? We can still tell it’s him without them since he’s a costom build. Is their some obscure rule for Piston Cup racers to still wear their number after being repaired to indicate where the number goes when they get repainted? Or is it for identifying purposes to show that; yes this primer-grey ghost of a hot rod with azure blue eyes is in fact Lightning [=McQueen=], and... [[HeroicBSOD he ain’t doing so hot...]]

to:

What exactly is the purpose of the temporary 95 stickers on both of [=McQueen=]’s door panels? We can still tell it’s him without them since he’s a costom custom build. Is their some obscure rule for Piston Cup racers to still wear their number after being repaired to indicate where the number goes when they get repainted? Or is it for identifying purposes to show that; yes this primer-grey ghost of a hot rod with azure blue eyes is in fact Lightning [=McQueen=], and... [[HeroicBSOD he ain’t doing so hot...]]



* Secondly, Lightning also mentions how he is at the same speed a month ago, even though, according to Sally, [[TenMinuteRetirement he basically shut himself in Doc’s garage for 4 straight months doing nothing but watching his mentor’s crash and thinking he’s going to be forced into retirement just like Doc.]] Basically suffering from what appears to be...well clinical depression. Hell, even the Junior novel states that he hasn’t even practiced around Willie’s Butte (though that may be debatable if its canon to the film).

to:

* Secondly, Lightning also mentions how he is at the same speed a month ago, even though, according to Sally, [[TenMinuteRetirement he basically shut himself in Doc’s garage for 4 straight months doing nothing but watching his mentor’s crash and thinking he’s going to be forced into retirement just like Doc.]] Basically suffering from what appears to be...well clinical depression. Hell, even the Junior novel states that he hasn’t even practiced around Willie’s Willy’s Butte (though that may be debatable if its canon to the film).



* Honestly, these movies pretty much zigzag with their adoption of NASCAR. Presumably using original NASCAR rules (i.e. actual ''stock'' cars), in a modern setting. Ironically, if they fully adopted modern NASCAR rules, where every car was more or less the same, with a different shell, the "aging" theme would make a lot more sense. After all, if the cars were mechanically the same, actual driving ability would be far more important. However, by using completely different vehicles, where their performance is a major part of being competitive, one has to ask why doesn't 95 simply get upgraded, with all that new tech and design improvements that the "next gen" racers have?

to:

* Honestly, these movies pretty much zigzag with their adoption of NASCAR. Presumably using original NASCAR rules (i.e. actual ''stock'' cars), in a modern setting. Ironically, if they fully adopted modern NASCAR rules, where every car was more or less the same, with a different shell, the "aging" theme would make a lot more sense. After all, if the cars were mechanically the same, actual driving ability would be far more important. However, by using completely different vehicles, where their performance is a major part of being competitive, one has to ask why doesn't 95 Lightning simply get upgraded, with all that new tech and design improvements that the "next gen" racers have?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Humans permanently repair and replace their cells, we can even have prosthetics - but still we age. So what's the essential difference? Just imagine that there exist some things in the cars that make up their "soul" and thus are irreplacable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I think the case is the "age" based on the years they've existed since manufacturing. Either that or based on their mileage.

to:

* I think the case is the "age" is based on the years they've existed since manufacturing. Either that or based on their mileage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* I think the case is the "age" based on the years they've existed since manufacturing. Either that or based on their mileage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens? Realistically, he AND Cal both had at least five or maybe more years left in their careers if real life NASCAR is to be believed.

to:

After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens? Realistically, he AND Cal both had at least five or maybe more years left in their careers if real life NASCAR is to be believed.believed.
*Honestly, these movies pretty much zigzag with their adoption of NASCAR. Presumably using original NASCAR rules (i.e. actual ''stock'' cars), in a modern setting. Ironically, if they fully adopted modern NASCAR rules, where every car was more or less the same, with a different shell, the "aging" theme would make a lot more sense. After all, if the cars were mechanically the same, actual driving ability would be far more important. However, by using completely different vehicles, where their performance is a major part of being competitive, one has to ask why doesn't 95 simply get upgraded, with all that new tech and design improvements that the "next gen" racers have?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Considering primer goes ''under'' the paint of all cars, how paint is the Cars universe equivalent of clothes, and his pretty lethargic attitude until Sally coaxed it out of him, it's more likely it's supposed to represent him sitting around in his underwear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This film in particular shows the flaw in using cars and drivers interchangeably, because of the whole aging thing, but ''also'' shows all the reasons why aging shouldn't be a problem. It's one thing if you're going to claim that the Cars in these movies are like people, where they're "born" how they are, and paint is the equivalent of clothing, and tires, shoes. But in the same film they show Cruz getting a spoiler, and having exhaust work done. Not to mention whatever happened offscreen to get Lightning McQueen put back together. So the question remains, if the cars in the film are mechanically just like the real thing, then why should age ''ever'' be an issue? True, tech has indeed advanced considerably from decade to decade, and even in the real world, a new family car could give a 90's sports car a run for its money. But there's also nothing stopping someone from upgrading that 90's car with modern equipment and parts. Let alone comparatively trivial things like reducing the drag co-efficient.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens?

to:

After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens?Next-Gens? Realistically, he AND Cal both had at least five or maybe more years left in their careers if real life NASCAR is to be believed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens?

to:

After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. Hell, during the Florida 500, he handily makes his way through the field, with a projected finish within the top 10 according to Smokey. Top 10's are very respectable in real life stock car racing. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens?

Added: 822

Changed: -20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Secondly, Lightning also mentions how he is at the same speed a month ago, even though, according to Sally, [[TenMinuteRetirement he basically shut himself in Doc’s garage for 4 straight months doing nothing but watching his mentor’s crash and thinking he’s going to be forced into retirement just like Doc.]] Basically suffering from what appears to be...well clinical depression. Hell, even the Junior novel states that he hasn’t even practiced around Willie’s Butte (though that may be debatable if its canon to the film).

to:

* Secondly, Lightning also mentions how he is at the same speed a month ago, even though, according to Sally, [[TenMinuteRetirement he basically shut himself in Doc’s garage for 4 straight months doing nothing but watching his mentor’s crash and thinking he’s going to be forced into retirement just like Doc.]] Basically suffering from what appears to be...well clinical depression. Hell, even the Junior novel states that he hasn’t even practiced around Willie’s Butte (though that may be debatable if its canon to the film).film).
!!Lightning's Performance
After the Next-Gens appear, the dialogue explains that Lightning McQueen is suffering badly against his new opponents, yet his finishes (and performance at the Los Angeles 500, at least before his crash) seem to suggest otherwise. During the montage, Lightning finishes no lower than 8th place, and by NASCAR standards, that's pretty good, ESPECIALLY against cars of a completely different classification. The waning of a drivers' finishes is kind of a normal thing in real racing (just look at Jeff Gordon and Dale Jr. at the ends of their careers), yet both those drivers continue(d) to have a large following. Wouldn't Lightning have absolutely no problem staying in until his career unwinds like most normal race drivers with the fact that he's still clearly capable of beating most Next-Gens?

Top