Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / AmericanDad

Go To




to:

*** The device that projects an image of god into your head was the thing that made your head explode. The orientation swapper seemed to work without a flaw.


* Why did Stan planning on killing either Jeff or Roger after the former discovered the latter is a real alien when he could've just taken Jeff to the CIA's secret lab and had his memories of Roger erased?

to:

* Why did Stan planning on killing either Jeff or Roger after the former discovered the latter is a real alien when he could've just taken Jeff to the CIA's secret lab and had his memories of Roger erased?erased?

!!Hideki putting a hit on his wife
* Why did he want her dead in the first place?


* Why did Stan have to kill either Jeff or Roger after the former discovered the latter is a real alien when he could've just taken Jeff to the CIA's secret lab and had his memories of Roger erased?

to:

* Why did Stan have to kill planning on killing either Jeff or Roger after the former discovered the latter is a real alien when he could've just taken Jeff to the CIA's secret lab and had his memories of Roger erased?


** That question has already been asked before and it has been answered.

to:

** That question has already been asked before and it has been answered.answered.

!!Memory Neutralizer
* Why did Stan have to kill either Jeff or Roger after the former discovered the latter is a real alien when he could've just taken Jeff to the CIA's secret lab and had his memories of Roger erased?


* In the episode the Longest Distance Relationship Jeff tells to wait for him and uses a black hole that brings him to earth but its 60 years in the future and Millionaire Matt Davis is still alive but after Hayley dies and Jeff feels bad for making her waste her life he goes out the same black hole and tells her to move on but then Roger enters Hayley's room followed by Matt who roger kills so... paradox i have a few theory but they make little sense?

to:

* In the episode the "The Longest Distance Relationship Relationship", Jeff tells Hayley to wait for him and uses a black hole that brings him to earth earth, but its 60 years in the future and future. Millionaire Matt Davis is still alive in this future, but after Hayley dies and Jeff feels bad for making her waste her life waiting, he goes out the same black hole and tells her to move on on. Jeff changes the timeline, but then Roger enters Hayley's room followed by Matt who roger kills so... paradox i so. Jeff's decision couldn't have changed Roger or Matt's to enter the room, thus a time paradox. I have a few theory theories but they make little sense?sense, What happened?


!!Garbage Stan
* In the episode "Garbage Stan" how did Steve get away with purchasing a garbage trunk and then driving it around to collect trash. Should not have the police caught Steve driving without a driver's license. As far as I know Steve is currently around 14-15 and is not known to have a learner's permit, let alone a driver's license?



* When Jeff fisher was discovered to have been killed by aliens and one of the aliens gives up his/her body for Jeff to be revived, then why did the smiths have roger convert Jeff back into a human, when Stan could have brought Jeff's brain to the CIA, clone a body for Jeff, and put the brain in the cloned body. It seems like a waste on Jeff's character and the status quo.

to:

* When Jeff fisher was discovered to have been killed by aliens and one of the aliens gives up his/her body for Jeff to be revived, then why did the smiths have roger convert Jeff back into a human, when Stan could have brought Jeff's brain to the CIA, clone a body for Jeff, and put the brain in the cloned body. It seems like a waste on Jeff's character and the status quo.quo?

Added DiffLines:

*When Jeff fisher was discovered to have been killed by aliens and one of the aliens gives up his/her body for Jeff to be revived, then why did the smiths have roger convert Jeff back into a human, when Stan could have brought Jeff's brain to the CIA, clone a body for Jeff, and put the brain in the cloned body. It seems like a waste on Jeff's character and the status quo.


!!Stan's Best Friend




!!The Worst Stan




!!Location




!!Beauregard



!!Jeff




* In the Rapture episode, when Jesus/Stan ask Roger to fly them to the Anti-Christ, he says the ship needs precious metals/gems for power. So Jesus whips out what looks suspiciously like Roger's solid gold/jewel-encrusted poo-pile. Did Roger want off the planet so badly he forgot he craps gold and jewels?
** I'm pretty sure he never knew to begin with, considering he didn't seem aware of his crapping gold ability.
*** If I remember correctly, Roger was ill during the episode that led to the golden turd. Maybe it's just something that happens to his species when they're (that particular kind of) sick?

to:

\n* In the Rapture episode, when Jesus/Stan ask ****One episode stated that Roger had convinced Jeff he was an imaginary friend (and we get an episode that shows how he does this). When Jeff realized he wasn't an imaginary friend, he gets PutOnABus.
!!!Jeff's absence
* Why hasn't Hayley beaten the snot out of Roger for [[spoiler:shoving Jeff in a UFO?]]
** Probably for the same reason they haven't surrendered him
to fly the CIA for the even more horrible crap he's done, like sending Steve to prison with his "Ricky Spanish" persona. There are times he does these things and I just wish the victim would just lift off his wig in public and say "He's an alien!"
** Best guess is that its because they care about Roger. Sure, Roger is a Jerkass with some psychotic episodes and can be generally horrible to them, but [[PetTheDog is nice enough to be a family member in the first place.]] Imagine you have a murderer for a sibling/loved one-you'd be hesitant to simply send
them to the Anti-Christ, he says the ship needs precious metals/gems for power. So Jesus whips out what looks suspiciously like Roger's solid gold/jewel-encrusted poo-pile. Did prison. Basically Roger want off hasn't been sold out because of a DracoInLeatherPants effect in-universe.
*** Better yet, why hasn't Hayley beaten up Stan for being in on
the planet so badly plan to send Jeff to space, she knows that he forgot he craps gold hates Jeff and jewels?
** I'm pretty sure
would've saw it coming that he never knew would favor Roger over Jeff.
*** On the same subject, Roger murdered Millionaire Matt Davis, the one who was supposed
to begin with, considering he give Hayley a good future... WHY THE FUCK HASN'T HALEY RETALIATED FOR THAT ACT OF MURDER!?! It's one thing that Roger is responsible for sending Jeff to space and didn't seem aware of his crapping gold ability.
*** If I remember correctly,
retaliated but then this happened... What's holding her back from giving Roger serious hurt? Is she that dumb of a hippy?
*** She
was ill during a) probably shocked (the murder seemed random) and b) probably for the same reasons mentioned above.
** Two words: CreatorsPet. This was
the episode that led to the golden turd. Maybe it's just something that happens to his species when changed my questioning of how they're (that particular kind of) sick?able to let Roger get away with what he does from "why do they still let him live in their house?" to "why do they sill let him live period?!". Suspension of disbelief can only save you for so long before people like me start to call you out for it (which I've been doing for a lot of things on this show for at least five years).
!!The Best Christmas Story Never Told




!!Toshi



* Why does Toshi hang out with Steve, Snot, and Barry if he hates them?
** It's been implied that none of the other kids at their school like Toshi either. So he seems to hang out with them purely because they aren't as mean to him and consider him a legit friend.
**That and, according to a lot of episodes, it's not like he hates them per say, he just finds them annoying.

!!American Dream Factory




!!The Poker game




!!Stan crying




!!Rough Trade Manual.




!!Stanny Get Your Gun




!!Fear of Needles




!!Fake [=IDs=]




!!Con Heir continuity




!!Stanny Boy and Frantastic




!!Music Choice




!!Flirting With Disaster



***Well, she does teeter on the heavier side and her doctor said it was part of the reason her ankle was hurt.

!!Rapturing Hayley



!!!Stan's personal heaven




!!The Heroin Snowglobe




!!Dealing with Roger.




* If Stan hates gay people so much (at first) why doesn't he seem to mind Roger being interested in men and women?
** Roger is an alien, so gender might be different for his species.
** Plus Stan doesn't seem to care what Roger does as long as he won't be found out as an alien and it doesn't harm the Smith family.
* In season one it's established that Roger isn't supposed to leave the house at all for fear of being exposed but he constantly keeps leaving the house in disguise, just why did Stan change his mind about Roger leaving the house as the show progresses? At least the people are too dumb to realize that's a alien in a PaperThinDisguise.
** Stan has a government job, a family, and his own wants/needs. Once he realized that Roger is good at disguising himself, he may have stopped caring and/or found that it's just not worth it to argue with Roger all the time.

* How would Stan react to Roger murdering Millionaire Matt Davis? The one guy he wants Hayley to marry and provide a good future that Jeff sacrificed his trip back to Earth for, and Roger ruined it! I bet this would be enough for Stan to surrender Roger back to the CIA.
** Probably anger, but you have forgotten ''why'' he had to hide Roger from the CIA. If he surrenders Roger, he could come around and say the Smiths have been harboring him and they may get brutally punished.

* Why does Steve continue to trust Roger whenever they do their schemes that involve either money or getting Steve a girlfriend when 99% of the time Roger would just betray Steve anyway? I hope "Not learning lessons" isn't hereditary!
** Steve is just probably so desperate to get a lasting relationship to keep going with Roger's schemes.

* One of the major plot points of American Dad is that Roger cannot be discovered as an alien, lest unpleasant, possibly butt-related, fates befall the Smiths courtesy of the CIA. At the same time, Klaus the fish and Reginald the koala can interact with the public without raising an eyebrow. It's been established in Seth [=McFarlanverses=] that anthropomorphic animals exist [[RuleOfFunny because]]. But unlike Brian and the family of bears in The Cleveland Show, we know that Klaus and Reginald take on their human characteristics because of CIA tinkering. If the CIA is desperate to cover up an alien that can disguise himself so well that he can walk into CIA headquarters and get a management job there, why would they turn a blind eye to Klaus being a talking fish in public and flat-out allowing Reginald to take Hayley to the Shaggy (SHAGGY!) concert as a fully-outed agent in a koala's body?
** The CIA believes that aliens are more threatening than talking animals which they created.
* If Rodger is (somehow) able to fool the humans with his costumes and disguises for decades then how the hell did the CIA catch him in the first place?
** In "A.T. The Abusive Terrestrial" he blacks out drunk and wakes up in that kid's backyard without his disguise. Change "random eight year old child" to "adult with a fully functioning brain" and you got what seems as good an explanation as any.


!!A Smith in the Hand




!!Roger's Drug habits




!!The Hurricane




!!Hideki's Sex doll




!!Haylias




!!Spaceship Note




!!Gold Turd



***The lady who got a hold of the turd was executed on death row and then one of their relatives (?) got it.
* In the Rapture episode, when Jesus/Stan ask Roger to fly them to the Anti-Christ, he says the ship needs precious metals/gems for power. So Jesus whips out what looks suspiciously like Roger's solid gold/jewel-encrusted poo-pile. Did Roger want off the planet so badly he forgot he craps gold and jewels?
** I'm pretty sure he never knew to begin with, considering he didn't seem aware of his crapping gold ability.
*** If I remember correctly, Roger was ill during the episode that led to the golden turd. Maybe it's just something that happens to his species when they're (that particular kind of) sick?


!!The Orientation Device




!!Hayley's age



**WritersCannotDoMath. However, you could presume that the episode where this comes up actually takes place before 2012.

!!Stan's Potty Faliure




!!Stelio Kontos




!!Stan's wrestling record.




!!The Kidney Killer




!!Stan's mental health




!!Toshi's Mom




!!Big Trouble In Little Langely




!!Cyborg Stan vs Regular Stan



* Despite all the times Barry, Toshi, and Snot betray Steve, why does he still hang out with those three? I mean we all know what Barry was like without his "vitamins", Toshi has mentioned wanting to kill Steve numerous times and actually attacked him, and Snot has turned on him several times, and then there's the incident they caused in "Escape from Pearl Bailey" and yet Steve still hangs out with them? Perhaps just like Stan, Steve doesn't learn lessons...
** Because for all the times all 4 of them have betrayed each other, they still care about each other. At their age the world is a big, scary place. They're all each other has got.

to:

* Despite all the times Barry, Toshi, and Snot betray Steve, why does he still hang out with those three? I mean we all know what Barry was like without his "vitamins", Toshi has mentioned wanting to kill Steve numerous times and actually attacked him, and Snot has turned on him several times, and then there's the incident they caused in "Escape from Pearl Bailey" and yet Steve still hangs out with them? Perhaps just like Stan, Steve doesn't learn lessons...
** Because for all the times all 4 of them have betrayed each other, they still care about each other. At their age the world is a big, scary place. They're all each other has got.

!Hayley's paternity



* One of the major plot points of American Dad is that Roger cannot be discovered as an alien, lest unpleasant, possibly butt-related, fates befall the Smiths courtesy of the CIA. At the same time, Klaus the fish and Reginald the koala can interact with the public without raising an eyebrow. It's been established in Seth [=McFarlanverses=] that anthropomorphic animals exist [[RuleOfFunny because]]. But unlike Brian and the family of bears in The Cleveland Show, we know that Klaus and Reginald take on their human characteristics because of CIA tinkering. If the CIA is desperate to cover up an alien that can disguise himself so well that he can walk into CIA headquarters and get a management job there, why would they turn a blind eye to Klaus being a talking fish in public and flat-out allowing Reginald to take Hayley to the Shaggy (SHAGGY!) concert as a fully-outed agent in a koala's body?
** The CIA believes that aliens are more threatening than talking animals which they created.

to:

* One of the major plot points of American Dad is that Roger cannot be discovered as an alien, lest unpleasant, possibly butt-related, fates befall the Smiths courtesy of the CIA. At the same time, Klaus the fish and Reginald the koala can interact with the public without raising an eyebrow. It's been established in Seth [=McFarlanverses=] that anthropomorphic animals exist [[RuleOfFunny because]]. But unlike Brian and the family of bears in The Cleveland Show, we know that Klaus and Reginald take on their human characteristics because of CIA tinkering. If the CIA is desperate to cover up an alien that can disguise himself so well that he can walk into CIA headquarters and get
!!Klaus Being
a management job there, why would they turn a blind eye to Klaus being a talking fish in public and flat-out allowing Reginald to take Hayley to the Shaggy (SHAGGY!) concert as a fully-outed agent in a koala's body?
** The CIA believes that aliens are more threatening than talking animals which they created.
Fish




!!Funeral




!!Snot's Crush on Hayley




!Clones




!!Expies?




!!Vacation Goo



* Why hasn't Hayley beaten the snot out of Roger for [[spoiler:shoving Jeff in a UFO?]]
** Probably for the same reason they haven't surrendered him to the CIA for the even more horrible crap he's done, like sending Steve to prison with his "Ricky Spanish" persona. There are times he does these things and I just wish the victim would just lift off his wig in public and say "He's an alien!"
** Best guess is that its because they care about Roger. Sure, Roger is a Jerkass with some psychotic episodes and can be generally horrible to them, but [[PetTheDog is nice enough to be a family member in the first place.]] Imagine you have a murderer for a sibling/loved one-you'd be hesitant to simply send them to prison. Basically Roger hasn't been sold out because of a DracoInLeatherPants effect in-universe.
*** Better yet, why hasn't Hayley beaten up Stan for being in on the plan to send Jeff to space, she knows that he hates Jeff and would've saw it coming that he would favor Roger over Jeff.
*** On the same subject, Roger murdered Millionaire Matt Davis, the one who was supposed to give Hayley a good future... WHY THE FUCK HASN'T HALEY RETALIATED FOR THAT ACT OF MURDER!?! It's one thing that Roger is responsible for sending Jeff to space and didn't retaliated but then this happened... What's holding her back from giving Roger serious hurt? Is she that dumb of a hippy?
*** She was a) probably shocked (the murder seemed random) and b) probably for the same reasons mentioned above.
** Two words: CreatorsPet. This was the episode that changed my questioning of how they're able to let Roger get away with what he does from "why do they still let him live in their house?" to "why do they sill let him live period?!". Suspension of disbelief can only save you for so long before people like me start to call you out for it (which I've been doing for a lot of things on this show for at least five years).

* If Stan hates gay people so much (at first) why doesn't he seem to mind Roger being interested in men and women?
** Roger is an alien, so gender might be different for his species.
** Plus Stan doesn't seem to care what Roger does as long as he won't be found out as an alien and it doesn't harm the Smith family.

to:

* Why hasn't Hayley beaten the snot out of Roger for [[spoiler:shoving Jeff in a UFO?]]
** Probably for the same reason they haven't surrendered him


!!Stan talking
to the CIA for the even more horrible crap he's done, like sending Steve to prison with his "Ricky Spanish" persona. There are times he does these things and I just wish the victim would just lift off his wig in public and say "He's an alien!"
** Best guess is that its because they care about Roger. Sure, Roger is a Jerkass with some psychotic episodes and can be generally horrible to them, but [[PetTheDog is nice enough to be a family member in the first place.]] Imagine you have a murderer for a sibling/loved one-you'd be hesitant to simply send them to prison. Basically Roger hasn't been sold out because of a DracoInLeatherPants effect in-universe.
*** Better yet, why hasn't Hayley beaten up Stan for being in on the plan to send Jeff to space, she knows that he hates Jeff and would've saw it coming that he would favor Roger over Jeff.
*** On the same subject, Roger murdered Millionaire Matt Davis, the one who was supposed to give Hayley a good future... WHY THE FUCK HASN'T HALEY RETALIATED FOR THAT ACT OF MURDER!?! It's one thing that Roger is responsible for sending Jeff to space and didn't retaliated but then this happened... What's holding her back from giving Roger serious hurt? Is she that dumb of a hippy?
*** She was a) probably shocked (the murder seemed random) and b) probably for the same reasons mentioned above.
** Two words: CreatorsPet. This was the episode that changed my questioning of how they're able to let Roger get away with what he does from "why do they still let him live in their house?" to "why do they sill let him live period?!". Suspension of disbelief can only save you for so long before people like me start to call you out for it (which I've been doing for a lot of things on this show for at least five years).

* If Stan hates gay people so much (at first) why doesn't he seem to mind Roger being interested in men and women?
** Roger is an alien, so gender might be different for his species.
** Plus Stan doesn't seem to care what Roger does as long as he won't be found out as an alien and it doesn't harm the Smith family.
past self



* In season one it's established that Roger isn't supposed to leave the house at all for fear of being exposed but he constantly keeps leaving the house in disguise, just why did Stan change his mind about Roger leaving the house as the show progresses? At least the people are too dumb to realize that's a alien in a PaperThinDisguise.
** Stan has a government job, a family, and his own wants/needs. Once he realized that Roger is good at disguising himself, he may have stopped caring and/or found that it's just not worth it to argue with Roger all the time.
* How would Stan react to Roger murdering Millionaire Matt Davis? The one guy he wants Hayley to marry and provide a good future that Jeff sacrificed his trip back to Earth for, and Roger ruined it! I bet this would be enough for Stan to surrender Roger back to the CIA.
** Probably anger, but you have forgotten ''why'' he had to hide Roger from the CIA. If he surrenders Roger, he could come around and say the Smiths have been harbouring him and they may get brutally punished.
* Why does Steve continue to trust Roger whenever they do their schemes that involve either money or getting Steve a girlfriend when 99% of the time Roger would just betray Steve anyway? I hope "Not learning lessons" isn't hereditary!
** Steve is just probably so desperate to get a lasting relationship to keep going with Roger's schemes.

to:

* In season one it's established that Roger isn't supposed to leave

!!Man in
the house at all for fear of being exposed but he constantly keeps leaving the house in disguise, just why did Stan change his mind about Roger leaving the house as the show progresses? At least the people are too dumb to realize that's a alien in a PaperThinDisguise.
** Stan has a government job, a family, and his own wants/needs. Once he realized that Roger is good at disguising himself, he may have stopped caring and/or found that it's just not worth it to argue with Roger all the time.
* How would Stan react to Roger murdering Millionaire Matt Davis? The one guy he wants Hayley to marry and provide a good future that Jeff sacrificed his trip back to Earth for, and Roger ruined it! I bet this would be enough for Stan to surrender Roger back to the CIA.
** Probably anger, but you have forgotten ''why'' he had to hide Roger from the CIA. If he surrenders Roger, he could come around and say the Smiths have been harbouring him and they may get brutally punished.
* Why does Steve continue to trust Roger whenever they do their schemes that involve either money or getting Steve a girlfriend when 99% of the time Roger would just betray Steve anyway? I hope "Not learning lessons" isn't hereditary!
** Steve is just probably so desperate to get a lasting relationship to keep going with Roger's schemes.
Moonbounce




!!Steve's personality




!!Culling Chicks




!!Steve's Girlfriends



* After so many failed relationships and attempts to get a girlfriend (or sex) ruined, why doesn't Steve realize nor lampshade this streak of bad luck and do anything about to prevent it from happening... are the Smiths THAT GenreBlind?
** Giving up is a bad idea in general. But he has lampshaded it on occasion. Most notably in the first appearance of Lindsay and Jewel, when Lindsay offers to go back to his place and make out and Steve responds by dejectedly saying he understood and walking out of the restaurant in sorrow. He figures it out eventually though.
* If Steve wanted to lose his virginity so bad, why didn't he have sex with his only girlfriend Debbie when he had the chance?
** She may not have been willing to do so before getting to know Steve more.

!!Janet Lewis



***One episode established that Lewis was divorced, so it's most likely he has joint custody.

!!Klaus' Soul




!!American Dad Jesus vs Family Guy Jesus



* If Steve wanted to lose his virginity so bad, why didn't he have sex with his only girlfriend Debbie when he had the chance?
** She may not have been willing to do so before getting to know Steve more.

to:

* If Steve wanted to lose his virginity so bad, why didn't he have sex with his only girlfriend Debbie when he had the chance?
** She may not have been willing to do so before getting to know Steve more.


!!Klaus' body



* If Rodger is (somehow) able to fool the humans with his costumes and disguises for decades then how the hell did the CIA catch him in the first place?
** In "A.T. The Abusive Terrestrial" he blacks out drunk and wakes up in that kid's backyard without his disguise. Change "random eight year old child" to "adult with a fully functioning brain" and you got what seems as good an explanation as any.

to:

* If Rodger is (somehow) able to fool **Much of the humans humor with his costumes and disguises for decades then how the hell did the CIA catch him in the first place?
** In "A.T. The Abusive Terrestrial" he blacks out drunk and wakes up in that kid's backyard without his disguise. Change "random eight year old child"
has being a fish, plus they wanted to "adult with a fully functioning brain" and you got what seems as good an explanation as any.change it but couldn't because of ExecutiveMeddling

!!Oedipial Panties



* After so many failed relationships and attempts to get a girlfriend (or sex) ruined, why doesn't Steve realize nor lampshade this streak of bad luck and do anything about to prevent it from happening... are the Smiths THAT GenreBlind?
** Giving up is a bad idea in general. But he has lampshaded it on occasion. Most notably in the first appearance of Lindsay and Jewel, when Lindsay offers to go back to his place and make out and Steve responds by dejectedly saying he understood and walking out of the restaurant in sorrow. He figures it out eventually though.
* Why does Toshi hang out with Steve, Snot, and barry if he hates them?
** It's been implied that none of the other kids at their school like Toshi either. So he seems to hang out with them purely because they aren't as mean to him and consider him a legit friend.

to:

* After so many failed relationships and attempts to get a girlfriend (or sex) ruined, why doesn't Steve realize nor lampshade this streak of bad luck and do anything about to prevent it from happening... are the Smiths THAT GenreBlind?
** Giving up is a bad idea in general. But he has lampshaded it on occasion. Most notably in the first appearance of Lindsay and Jewel, when Lindsay offers to go back to his place and make out and Steve responds by dejectedly saying he understood and walking out of the restaurant in sorrow. He figures it out eventually though.
* Why does Toshi hang out with Steve, Snot, and barry if he hates them?
** It's been implied that none of the other kids at their school like Toshi either. So he seems to hang out with them purely because they aren't as mean to him and consider him a legit friend.

!!The 200th episode



** Nope. It's non-canon just like "Hot Water" and debatably the Christmas episodes.
* In the episode the longest distance relationship jeff tells to wait for him and uses a black hole that brings him to earth but its 60 years in the future and millionaire matt davis is still alive but after hayley dies and jeff feels bad for making her waste her life he goes out the same black hole and tells her to move on but then roger enters haley's room followed by matt who roger kills so... paradox i have a few theory but they make little sense?

to:

** Nope. It's non-canon just like "Hot Water" and debatably and, possibly, the Christmas episodes.
episodes.

!!Time Paradox
* In the episode the longest distance relationship jeff Longest Distance Relationship Jeff tells to wait for him and uses a black hole that brings him to earth but its 60 years in the future and millionaire matt davis Millionaire Matt Davis is still alive but after hayley Hayley dies and jeff Jeff feels bad for making her waste her life he goes out the same black hole and tells her to move on but then roger Roger enters haley's Hayley's room followed by matt Matt who roger kills so... paradox i have a few theory but they make little sense?sense?
**Well, first off, Hayley didn't die, actually, she just had a heart attack and fell comatose. Second, from what I got, Matt was most likely healthier than the former. Also, time went faster in the wormhole, so it would be 60 approximate regular time years.

!!Religious Beliefs


Added DiffLines:


!!Roger's Bar


Added DiffLines:

**According to a few episodes, they do know he runs a bar up there but it's possible he does that when everyone isn't home, likewise. there's probably other entrances to the attic.

!!Hayley's breakups


Added DiffLines:

***It's possible that they tried and it ended bad.

!!Idiot Plot

Added DiffLines:

**OR Stan eventually found himself getting bored with his initial personal heaven and decided that he'd be happier if his life had continued on without the Rapture happening. And he wanted to think/act like he would if that were the case. So we have Stan, forgetting he's in his heaven on a conscious level, living his life how he imagines it could've gone otherwise. Which would explain all of the snap back/ really weird happenings later on.
He really did like his life as it was, Klaus alive and Roger in his attic included, and he's got a crazy imagination.


*** He doesn't generally agree with the group. He can probably speak English well enough, but when you find out secrets easily and are generally insulting towards your friend, would you speak the language your friends can understand.

to:

*** He doesn't generally agree with the group. He can probably speak English well enough, but when you find out secrets easily and are generally insulting towards your friend, would you speak the language your friends can understand.understand?


Added DiffLines:

** How is Lorraine fat?

Added DiffLines:

**** Perhaps FridgeBrilliance, Reginald was in love with Hayley, and turning in Roger would mean that Hayley would likely have been arrested and disappear into a CIA blacksite.

Added DiffLines:

** In "A.T. The Abusive Terrestrial" he blacks out drunk and wakes up in that kid's backyard without his disguise. Change "random eight year old child" to "adult with a fully functioning brain" and you got what seems as good an explanation as any.


Added DiffLines:

** Giving up is a bad idea in general. But he has lampshaded it on occasion. Most notably in the first appearance of Lindsay and Jewel, when Lindsay offers to go back to his place and make out and Steve responds by dejectedly saying he understood and walking out of the restaurant in sorrow. He figures it out eventually though.


** Probably necessity. While Stan, Steve, Roger and Hayley are all capable of sewing it's not at all in character for any of them to devote time to doing so as a chore. Still, Stan is the only breadwinner in the family and has been said to have a crappy paying job, so Francine gets over her fear simply because she has no choice; they can't just keep buying new things.



** We're only shown the events in that order because of the time slots. Who's to say that the events of all three shows weren't happening simultaneously? Granted that would require an obscenely massive hurricane but Rhode Island could have just been on the fringe.

to:

** We're only shown the events in that order because of the time slots. Who's to say that the events of all three shows weren't happening simultaneously? Granted that would require an obscenely massive hurricane hurricane, one with an eye somewhere in New Jersey, but Rhode Island could have just been on that's the fringe.most plausible explanation for something like this.

Added DiffLines:

** We're only shown the events in that order because of the time slots. Who's to say that the events of all three shows weren't happening simultaneously? Granted that would require an obscenely massive hurricane but Rhode Island could have just been on the fringe.

Added DiffLines:

** [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] in this instance as the entire plot [[spoiler:ends up being an undercover CIA operation [[ItMakesSenseInContext to test Mt. Rushmore's Missile Defense System]]. Even though Stan wasn't aware of this the CIA would have gone to any lengths to keep it under wraps and ensure nothing went wrong anyway.]]

Showing 15 edit(s) of 308

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report