Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / AladdinAndTheKingOfThieves

Go To


Added DiffLines:

** And since water is transparent, that just might be the way the animators are "showing" that everything behind or under the water is turning to gold. If the hand could turn water into gold, that would happen to the ocean every time the vanishing isle submerged.

Added DiffLines:

** Pretty sure the Oracle could guess that the invitation question was sarcastic. Perhaps if she is an all-knowing being, she is bound by the rules but is able to stretch them a little - and wanted to help reunite father and son. She used Iago's question to reveal herself to the protagonists, but not when Aladdin and Cassim first meet, because that would just mean Cassim finds the hand and goes about his way. The way it did happen, Aladdin found his father, and Cassim learned a valuable lesson.


Added DiffLines:

** He also didn't know Aladdin that well at this point, and for all he knew asking could get him a no and turned out of the palace - requiring another elaborate plan to sneak in and get it.


Added DiffLines:

** Men often angst about not having a father to teach them how to be men. Jasmine as a woman - and one who had a father and mother for a good while at that - just wouldn't understand.


* the whole reason Cassim wanted the hand of Midas was so he could provide for himself and his family. So why did he still need to steal the oracle the second time? His son is already about to become part of the royal family and he as Aladdin's father would have lived a rich mans life too. But hell, even if he had such a fetish for unlimited gold, why didn't he ask Genie to turn things into gold for him or even ask Genie if he could help, rather than stealing his sons scepter and getting thrown in prison.

to:

* the whole reason Cassim wanted the hand of Midas was so he could provide for himself and his family. So why did he still need to steal the oracle the second time? His son is already about to become part of the royal family and he as Aladdin's father would have lived a rich mans life too. But hell, even if he had such a fetish for unlimited gold, why didn't he ask Genie to turn things into gold for him or even ask Genie if he could help, rather than stealing his sons scepter and getting thrown in prison.prison.
** They go into that a bit in the movie. Cassim is just to deep into the criminal life to just back out. Remember what the Oracle says when Aladdin asks about his father "Follow the trail of the Forty Thieves. Your father is ''trapped within their world''." While Aladdin immediately assumes Cassim is a prisoner, Cassim himself is the King of Thieves leader of the Forty Thieves and doesn't know how (or even seemed inclined) to get himself out. At the end of the movie he leaves to become a wandering adventurer, because he doesn't know how to leave the lifestyle he's lived for over a decade. To summarize: The leopard can't change his spots.


** A) There's no reason to assume the Oracle is ''just'' for the Hand of Midas. Presumably she was just the only magical method for finding the treasure Cassim knew about. Remember when he hears Aladdin has a Genie ("have you used all three wishes yet?"). As for the question, Aladdin only asked ''where'' his father was and the Oracle told him. Cassim asked to ''find'' the Hand of Midas - and the location was very specific and only there for a brief amount of time - so the Oracle was bound by her laws or whatever to show him ''exactly'' where it was. B) Yes we can assume the handle is enchanted. The hand would be pretty useless as treasure if one couldn't even hold it somehow. The Oracle's image being in the Vanishing Isle might imply a connection between the two, such as the person or group created both and wanted the Hand to be secure while also possessing a way to get it back if necessary but this is going into WMG territory.

to:

** A) There's no reason to assume the Oracle is ''just'' for the Hand of Midas. Presumably she was just the only magical method for finding the treasure Cassim knew about. Remember when he hears Aladdin has a Genie ("have you used all three wishes yet?"). As for the question, Aladdin only asked ''where'' his father was and the Oracle told him. Cassim asked to ''find'' the Hand of Midas - and the location was very specific and only there for a brief amount of time - so the Oracle was bound by her laws or whatever to show him ''exactly'' where it was. B) Yes we can assume the handle is enchanted. The hand would be pretty useless as treasure if one couldn't even hold it somehow. The Oracle's image being in the Vanishing Isle might imply a connection between the two, such as the person or group created both and wanted the Hand to be secure while also possessing a way to get it back if necessary but this is going into WMG territory.territory.
* the whole reason Cassim wanted the hand of Midas was so he could provide for himself and his family. So why did he still need to steal the oracle the second time? His son is already about to become part of the royal family and he as Aladdin's father would have lived a rich mans life too. But hell, even if he had such a fetish for unlimited gold, why didn't he ask Genie to turn things into gold for him or even ask Genie if he could help, rather than stealing his sons scepter and getting thrown in prison.

Added DiffLines:

** Jasmine also grew up being tended to by servants in the palace. The problem with her life in the first film was that she was ''too'' looked after by others. She'd probably understand Aladdin's situation even ''less'' than a normal person would.


* The Oracle says that every holder of the staff only gets to ask one question. And Iago's experience seems to imply that ''anyone'' who touches the staff and asks a question will be answered by the Oracle, whether they were expecting her or not. And yet when the Forty Thieves crash his wedding Aladdin asks "Where's the King of Thieves?" while holding the thing. See [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GdeyxEL3T8s&feature=context-vrec this video]] starting at 1:11. The Oracle does not appear, and Aladdin gets to ask a question later. In addition, Cassim asks a question of the Oracle while someone ''else'' is holding the staff. I know, I know, kid's movie, but would it have been too much to ask for an additional rule? Something like "The Oracle will appear when someone within earshot says 'Oracle', followed by a question?"
** This has been asked and discussed on this very page, so I'll just repeat my original thoughts on it: Iago is the series' designated ButtMonkey. Of ''course'' he would be the only one not to be given a fair chance to save his question for when he actually needed it.



** A) There's no reason to assume the Oracle is ''just'' for the Hand of Midas. Presumably she was just the only magical method for finding the treasure Cassim knew about. Remember when he hears Aladdin has a Genie ("have you used all three wishes yet?"). As for the question, Aladdin only asked ''where'' his father was and the Oracle told him. Cassim asked to ''find'' the Hand of Midas - and the location was very specific and only there for a brief amount of time - so the Oracle was bound by her laws or whatever to show him ''exactly'' where it was. B) Yes we can assume the handle is enchanted. The hand would be pretty useless as treasure if one couldn't even hold it somehow.
*** All good points. However, one thing still not addressed is why there was statuary and carvings that looked like the Oracle inside the Vanishing Isle. This still suggests that even if there were other ways to find the Hand, and the Oracle can tell you about all kinds of things, she still has some special connection to it.

to:

** A) There's no reason to assume the Oracle is ''just'' for the Hand of Midas. Presumably she was just the only magical method for finding the treasure Cassim knew about. Remember when he hears Aladdin has a Genie ("have you used all three wishes yet?"). As for the question, Aladdin only asked ''where'' his father was and the Oracle told him. Cassim asked to ''find'' the Hand of Midas - and the location was very specific and only there for a brief amount of time - so the Oracle was bound by her laws or whatever to show him ''exactly'' where it was. B) Yes we can assume the handle is enchanted. The hand would be pretty useless as treasure if one couldn't even hold it somehow.
*** All good points. However, one thing still not addressed is why there was statuary and carvings that looked like the Oracle inside
somehow. The Oracle's image being in the Vanishing Isle. This still suggests that even if there were other ways to find the Hand, and the Oracle can tell you about all kinds of things, she still has some special Isle might imply a connection between the two, such as the person or group created both and wanted the Hand to it.be secure while also possessing a way to get it back if necessary but this is going into WMG territory.


** Living somewhere alone on the street, most likely. It's a big city, and Cassim may not have had much of a way to find him.

to:

** Living somewhere alone on the street, most likely. It's a big city, and Cassim may not have had much of a way to find him.him.
* The rules for the Oracle seem to be contradictory. When Iago asks why anyone would want it, not knowing what it was, she appeared and answered his question. This would seem to imply that ''any'' question spoken by ''anyone'' touching the staff qualifies for a formal appearance and answer. But during the first fight with Cassim Al asks him "Do you have an invitation?" while holding the thing, and nothing happens.
** And later on Cassim asks a question when someone else is holding it! So what, now it's any question asked within earshot?
** To be fair, the Oracle is fully sentient, and, among other things, actually ''guided'' Aladdin on asking the right question. Presumably, since it ''is'' a all-knowing Oracle, it would know which people are worth of helping, and which ones are better if tricked out of their questions.
** Or maybe, if you ask a question that isn't directed at anyone in particular while near the Oracle / if you ask the Oracle directly, then it will answer you. If however you ask a question that you were directing toward someone specifically, the Oracle doesn't answer that question, so that's maybe why the invitation question didn't get answered.
** Simple explanation: Iago is the series' designated ButtMonkey. Of ''course'' he would be the only one not to be given a fair chance to save his question for when he actually needed it.
* Irrelevant, but why exactly is Sa'luk gray?
** Even more headscratchingly, he's normal flesh colors on the VHS cover.
** He probably has argyria (silver poisoning), which permanently turns the skin a bluish-grey. Possibly he was attempting to smuggle some silver coins by ''eating them'' one day.
* The Oracle says that every holder of the staff only gets to ask one question. And Iago's experience seems to imply that ''anyone'' who touches the staff and asks a question will be answered by the Oracle, whether they were expecting her or not. And yet when the Forty Thieves crash his wedding Aladdin asks "Where's the King of Thieves?" while holding the thing. See [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GdeyxEL3T8s&feature=context-vrec this video]] starting at 1:11. The Oracle does not appear, and Aladdin gets to ask a question later. In addition, Cassim asks a question of the Oracle while someone ''else'' is holding the staff. I know, I know, kid's movie, but would it have been too much to ask for an additional rule? Something like "The Oracle will appear when someone within earshot says 'Oracle', followed by a question?"
** This has been asked and discussed on this very page, so I'll just repeat my original thoughts on it: Iago is the series' designated ButtMonkey. Of ''course'' he would be the only one not to be given a fair chance to save his question for when he actually needed it.
* Why does Cassim try to steal the Oracle after he knew who Aladdin was? Why not just ask Aladdin to use it? The Hand of Midas doesn't seem to belong to anyone, so it's not like he or Jasmine would have a moral objection to a treasure hunt. (Even if Aladdin didn't believe in the Hand, there was no reason not to let Cassim try to find it.) He didn't just destroy his relationship with Aladdin out of greed, he destroyed it when it was completely unnecessary.
** It's a lot like the point mentioned about Aladdin and Iago in ''Return of Jafar''. Cassim was just used to being a thief and stealing was second nature to him. He seems very materialistic and he only agrees to go to the wedding when Iago reminds him about the treasure. His plan all along was to use the wedding as a distraction so he could sneak into the treasury.
* When Cassim uses the Hand of Midas inside its temple/palace/whatever, it turns everything to gold, even the water. Later he throws it onto the deck of the ship, the ship turns to gold and sinks...and the water remains normal. Shouldn't the whole oceanic system be gold now?
** The water itself didn't turn gold. Since everything around the water was gold, the water reflected that color.
* Why does Aladdin think [[MissingMom Jasmine]] wouldn't be able to understand what it's like to grow up without a father?
** Could be because she didn't grow up without a father. We don't know when her mother died, but since we never get to see any of Jasmine's childhood, it's possible that Jasmine grew up with both parents and only lost her mother after she'd entered her teens or something similar.
** Not to mention they're talking about ''fathers'', and Jasmine still has hers.
** Also, Jasmine at least has one parent; Aladdin didn't get squat.
** Aladdin had assumed his father was dead. Now all he knows is that his father is alive but has been missing his whole life. He's referring to growing up now knowing that his father ''left'' him.
* Two points: Cassim acts as if the Oracle exists solely to help someone find the Hand of Midas, so why is it you can ask her anything you want as if she's all-knowing? And the Genie states she is ''an'' Oracle rather than ''the'' Oracle, implying there are others. Perhaps they all have the same general purpose omniscience, but each also has individual things, like the Hand of Midas, that they know a lot more about? When she is asked about the Hand, she does become a guiding star to show the way, hovers over the Vanishing Isle as it rises, and declares "You have arrived", all things she didn't do when Aladdin asked about his father. And the interior of the Hand's chamber ''is'' adorned with statues and carvings cast in the Oracle's likeness... Second, if everything the Hand touches turns to gold, why doesn't the wooden handle it's mounted on? Is it specifically enchanted to be immune, so that you can handle it without dooming yourself?
** A) There's no reason to assume the Oracle is ''just'' for the Hand of Midas. Presumably she was just the only magical method for finding the treasure Cassim knew about. Remember when he hears Aladdin has a Genie ("have you used all three wishes yet?"). As for the question, Aladdin only asked ''where'' his father was and the Oracle told him. Cassim asked to ''find'' the Hand of Midas - and the location was very specific and only there for a brief amount of time - so the Oracle was bound by her laws or whatever to show him ''exactly'' where it was. B) Yes we can assume the handle is enchanted. The hand would be pretty useless as treasure if one couldn't even hold it somehow.
*** All good points. However, one thing still not addressed is why there was statuary and carvings that looked like the Oracle inside the Vanishing Isle. This still suggests that even if there were other ways to find the Hand, and the Oracle can tell you about all kinds of things, she still has some special connection to it.


* Cassim mentions that when he returned to Agrabah, he could not find his wife or son. His wife was probably dead already but where was Aladdin?

to:

* Cassim mentions that when he returned to Agrabah, he could not find his wife or son. His wife was probably dead already but where was Aladdin?Aladdin?
** Living somewhere alone on the street, most likely. It's a big city, and Cassim may not have had much of a way to find him.


Cassim mentions that when he returned to Agrabah, he could not find his wife or son. His wife was probably dead already but where was Aladdin?

to:

Cassim *Cassim mentions that when he returned to Agrabah, he could not find his wife or son. His wife was probably dead already but where was Aladdin?

Added DiffLines:

Cassim mentions that when he returned to Agrabah, he could not find his wife or son. His wife was probably dead already but where was Aladdin?

Showing 10 edit(s) of 10

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report