Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / TheIronGiant

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Hogarth and the Giant go out walking at night, pay attention to the moon in one scene. Just to the right of it, one of the stars can be seen moving. That's [[RedsWithRockets Sputnik]].

to:

* When Hogarth and the Giant go out walking at night, pay attention to the moon in one scene. Just to the right of it, one of the stars can be seen moving. That's [[RedsWithRockets [[UsefulNotes/RedsWithRockets Sputnik]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In addition to being an unstoppable war machine, the Giant shows us at the very end that it can recover from being blown to hell. So imagine if it was still in battle mode and got scrapped? It may take months, may take years, but it ''will'' self-repair and resume its mission eventually.

Added: 4

Changed: 316

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the bright side, if the politicians and government figures ''are'' reasonable enough to realize that the Giant is alien in origin and might've been deliberately sent to Earth as part of an AlienInvasion before he went IAmNotAGun, it could actually cause tensions between nations to ''decrease'' and improve their cooperation, feeling the need to prepare for a possible future attack from a greater enemy from the stars who's even more technologically advanced.

to:

** On the bright side, if the politicians and government figures ''are'' reasonable enough to realize that the Giant is alien in origin and might've been deliberately sent to Earth as part of an AlienInvasion before he went IAmNotAGun, it could actually cause act as a ConflictKiller, causing Cold War tensions between nations to ''decrease'' and improve their cooperation, feeling in the need to prepare for face of a possible future attack from a greater enemy from the stars who's even more technologically advanced.advanced having potentially turned their attention to Earth.



* The Giant grows to abhor killing over the film. How would he react if he found out about humans eating farmed or hunted meat, and how commonplace and socially-acceptable it is among bad and good humans? Also bear in mind, Annie's mention of cold chicken in the ice-box indicates she and Hogarth aren't vegetarians. This is a Fridge Horror point you could probably apply to quite a few stories, but it's a valid point considering how the Giant reacted to the deer's death.

to:

* The Giant grows to abhor killing over the film. film, with his first introduction to it being the killing of a deer by hunters which leaves him shocked and dismayed afterwards. How would he the Giant react if he found out about humans eating farmed or hunted meat, and how commonplace and socially-acceptable it is among bad and good humans? Also bear in mind, Annie's mention of cold chicken in the ice-box indicates she and Hogarth aren't vegetarians. This is a Fridge Horror point you could probably apply to quite a few other stories, but it's a valid point considering how the Giant reacted to the deer's death.



* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Any other ships in the blast radius would have been vaporized.

to:

* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Any other ships in the blast radius would have been vaporized.vaporized.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This one could be considered FridgeBrilliance AND FridgeHorror: Hogarth is able to speak so eloquently about death because his DisappearedDad (presumably, judging by the picture on his bedside table) may have died in the UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar.

to:

* This one could be considered FridgeBrilliance AND FridgeHorror: Hogarth is able to speak so eloquently about death because his DisappearedDad (presumably, judging by the picture on his bedside table) may have died in the UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* While Hogarth certainly broke the eight o'clock bedtime and Annie's "no late snacks" rule, he could have been interpreted as using LoopholeAbuse for her "no scary movies" rule, since while it was a horror movie, it was a bad B-movie and he didn't seem scared of it at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Let's hope nothing was within its blast radius...

to:

* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Let's hope nothing was within its Any other ships in the blast radius...radius would have been vaporized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As fridge brilliance points out above, the Giant's landing on Earth definitely wasn't intended. It landed hard enough to damage its memory, and unlike in the dream Earth only has one giant arriving, not an army of them. So Earth at least wasn't deliberately targeted by whatever made the Giant. That does leave the fridge horror of whether the Giant's creators might still deliberately target Earth at some point anyway, given it's completely unknown what their motives are for deploying planet-destroying mechanical armies (but it'd be a safe bet the motive isn't a very friendly one).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Let's hope nothing was within it's blast radius...

to:

* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Let's hope nothing was within it's its blast radius...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a Fridge Brilliance



to:

*Major Spoiler [[spoiler:The Giant wasn't destroyed because the nuclear bomb didn't explode. To be specific; there was an explosion, but that came from the impact. The explosions of Nuclear weapons are the result of a precise detonation process, they don't detonate on impact. Impacts to the missile are more than likely to ruin the entire trigger mechanism. Since the Giant purposefully impacted the missile, there was a lesser conventional explosion from the components of the missile that knocked him apart like the train.]]

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This Troper. Altering accordingly.


* Now that I'm an adult and know just how much it costs to run a national military, I've realized that we humans give our troops the bare minimum necessary to complete the task they're assigned. Our guys get M1 Tanks, F-35s and Nimitz Class Carriers because that's the minimum things necessary for the US military to do it's job. So here's my fridge horror: this minimum necessary doctrine should theoretically apply to aliens too, and if the Giant's armed as it is, and there's hundreds of them available, just what the hell was it built to fight against?

to:

* Now that I'm an adult and know just how much it costs to run a national military, I've realized that we We humans give our troops the bare minimum necessary to complete the task they're assigned.assigned based upon how much it costs to run a military. Our guys get M1 Tanks, F-35s and Nimitz Class Carriers because that's the minimum things necessary for the US military to do it's job. So here's my fridge horror: this minimum necessary This "minimum necessary" doctrine should theoretically apply to aliens too, and if the Giant's armed as it is, and there's hundreds of them available, just what the hell was it built to fight against?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Now that I'm an adult and know just how much it costs to run a national military, I've realized that we humans give our troops the bare minimum necessary to complete the task they're assigned. Our guys get M1 Tanks, F-35s and Nimitz Class Carriers because that's the minimum things necessary for the US military to do it's job. So here's my fridge horror: this minimum necessary doctrine should theoretically apply to aliens too, and if the Giant's armed as it is, and there's hundreds of them available, just what the hell was it built to fight against?

to:

* Now that I'm an adult and know just how much it costs to run a national military, I've realized that we humans give our troops the bare minimum necessary to complete the task they're assigned. Our guys get M1 Tanks, F-35s and Nimitz Class Carriers because that's the minimum things necessary for the US military to do it's job. So here's my fridge horror: this minimum necessary doctrine should theoretically apply to aliens too, and if the Giant's armed as it is, and there's hundreds of them available, just what the hell was it built to fight against?against?
* The giant fires a WaveMotionGun meant for a battleship out into the ocean. Let's hope nothing was within it's blast radius...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Bulldog tanks. In each case the animators make sure to show the crews bailing out before the tanks themselves are destroyed. This could just be [[TanksButNoTanks sloppy research]] on the part of the writers, but [[InferredHolocaust if not. . .]]

to:

* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Bulldog tanks. In each case the animators make sure to show the crews bailing out before the tanks themselves are destroyed. The thing is, the M41 had a crew of four, yet we only see two people escaping from the tanks. This could just be [[TanksButNoTanks sloppy research]] on the part of the writers, but [[InferredHolocaust if not. . .]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Bulldog tanks. In each case the animators make sure to show the crews bailing out before the tanks themselves are destroyed. This could just be [[TanksButNoTanks sloppy research]] on the part of the writers, but [[InferredHolocause if not. . .]]

to:

* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Bulldog tanks. In each case the animators make sure to show the crews bailing out before the tanks themselves are destroyed. This could just be [[TanksButNoTanks sloppy research]] on the part of the writers, but [[InferredHolocause [[InferredHolocaust if not. . .]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Light Tanks. In each case the animators are sure to show the crews bailing out before bad things happen. The only problem is that the M41 has a four man crew- we only ever see the Tank Commander and Driver escape the doomed vehicles, leaving the gunners and loaders trapped and more than likely horribly killed.

to:

* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Light Tanks. Bulldog tanks. In each case the animators are make sure to show the crews bailing out before bad things happen. The only problem is that the M41 has a four man crew- we only ever see tanks themselves are destroyed. This could just be [[TanksButNoTanks sloppy research]] on the Tank Commander and Driver escape part of the doomed vehicles, leaving the gunners and loaders trapped and more than likely horribly killed.writers, but [[InferredHolocause if not. . .]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Giant grows to abhor killing over the film. How would he react if he found out about humans eating farmed or hunted meat, and how commonplace and socially-acceptable it is among bad and good humans? Also bear in mind, Annie's mention of cold chicken in the ice-box indicates she and Hogarth aren't vegetarians. This is a Fridge Horror point you could probably apply to quite a few stories, but it's a valid point considering how the Giant reacted to the deer's death.

to:

* The Giant grows to abhor killing over the film. How would he react if he found out about humans eating farmed or hunted meat, and how commonplace and socially-acceptable it is among bad and good humans? Also bear in mind, Annie's mention of cold chicken in the ice-box indicates she and Hogarth aren't vegetarians. This is a Fridge Horror point you could probably apply to quite a few stories, but it's a valid point considering how the Giant reacted to the deer's death.death.
* Now that I'm an adult and know just how much it costs to run a national military, I've realized that we humans give our troops the bare minimum necessary to complete the task they're assigned. Our guys get M1 Tanks, F-35s and Nimitz Class Carriers because that's the minimum things necessary for the US military to do it's job. So here's my fridge horror: this minimum necessary doctrine should theoretically apply to aliens too, and if the Giant's armed as it is, and there's hundreds of them available, just what the hell was it built to fight against?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Speaking of Russia... The first thing they'll know will be that the US deployed a lieutenant general and a large Army[=/=]Navy combined force, including a ''battleship'', to a small coastal town, and they then ''detonated a nuke'' above it, high enough it didn't destroy the place. What will they think about it? Especially when the US admits there was a giant robot of unknown origin...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Light Tanks. In each case the animators are sure to show the crews bailing out before bad things happen. The only problem is that the M41 has a four man crew- we only over see the Tank Commander and Driver escape the doomed vehicles, leaving the gunners and loaders trapped and more than likely horribly killed.

to:

* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existence several M41 Light Tanks. In each case the animators are sure to show the crews bailing out before bad things happen. The only problem is that the M41 has a four man crew- we only over ever see the Tank Commander and Driver escape the doomed vehicles, leaving the gunners and loaders trapped and more than likely horribly killed.

Added: 1997

Changed: 75

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While deserved, depending on your point of view, Mansley might've been more than just incarcerated for his actions when the general arrested him. He committed crimes against his own country in his crusade to kill the Giant (nearly bombing an entire town and fleeing in the face of duty). Given the General wanted to have Mansley ''die'' along with the town when the missile hit, he likely had Mansley executed during the time skip at the end.
* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existance several M41 Light Tanks. In each case the animators are sure to show the crews bailing out before bad things happen. The only problem is that the M41 has a four man crew- we only over see the Tank Commander and Driver escape the doomed vehicles, leaving the gunners and loaders trapped and more than likely horribly killed.

to:

* While deserved, deserved to the point of probably fitting more in the Fridge Brilliance section; depending on your point of view, Mansley might've been more than just incarcerated for his actions when the general arrested him. He committed crimes against his own country in his crusade to kill the Giant (nearly bombing an entire town and fleeing in the face of duty). Given the General wanted to have Mansley ''die'' along with the town when the missile hit, he likely had Mansley executed during the time skip at the end.
* In the battle sequence near the end of the film, the Giant's seen blowing up, shooting holes in and deleting from existance existence several M41 Light Tanks. In each case the animators are sure to show the crews bailing out before bad things happen. The only problem is that the M41 has a four man crew- we only over see the Tank Commander and Driver escape the doomed vehicles, leaving the gunners and loaders trapped and more than likely horribly killed.killed.
* Note that this film is set at the height of the Cold War, and Mansley and General Rogard think (albeit before the Giant goes berserk and reveals the extent of his weaponry) that the Giant was sent to the U.S. by Russia or another foreign ''human'' power, and there's nothing for the rest of the film to explicitly confirm that they realized the Giant was extraterrestrial in origin. Despite the upbeat ending with the Giant being rightfully regarded and remembered as a hero for his actions, in the bigger picture; it's possible the Rockwell incident could've heightened Cold War tensions within the film's AlternateHistory if the politicians and military leaders never realized the Giant was alien in origin, since it'd be obvious from the Giant's weaponry array that he's an AntiAntichrist by origin. Bare in mind, looking at the Cold War's history will tell you there were a few points in the Cold War including the 60s' Cuban Missile Crisis where we passed within inches of having WorldWarIII and were mostly only saved by minute decisions and chances.
** On the bright side, if the politicians and government figures ''are'' reasonable enough to realize that the Giant is alien in origin and might've been deliberately sent to Earth as part of an AlienInvasion before he went IAmNotAGun, it could actually cause tensions between nations to ''decrease'' and improve their cooperation, feeling the need to prepare for a possible future attack from a greater enemy from the stars who's even more technologically advanced.
* The Giant grows to abhor killing over the film. How would he react if he found out about humans eating farmed or hunted meat, and how commonplace and socially-acceptable it is among bad and good humans? Also bear in mind, Annie's mention of cold chicken in the ice-box indicates she and Hogarth aren't vegetarians. This is a Fridge Horror point you could probably apply to quite a few stories, but it's a valid point considering how the Giant reacted to the deer's death.

Top