Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** FridgeSadness: It's possible some of Snape's happiest memories are from when he and Lily were children, which would have been before his own prejudices and involvement with the Death Eaters drove them apart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A flashback in the first chapter has Fudge notify the Muggle Prime Minister about the upcoming importation of three foreign dragons and a sphinx for the Triwizard Tournament, in accordance with regulations set by the Department for the Regulation and Control of Magical Creatures. There is no mention of the Prime Minister being notified about a fourth dragon due to unforeseen circumstances, but that's because the Ministry of Magic didn't need to ''import'' another one. The First Task of the Triwizard Tournament featured three foreign dragons (Swedish Short-Snout, Chinese Fireball, Hungarian Horntail), and one domestic dragon: the Welsh Green. Instead of going through the trouble of finding a fourth dragon overseas and telling the Prime Minister about it, they just grabbed one from Wales and called it a day. Fudge's comment also confirms that the Welsh Green wasn't part of the original plans for the Triwizard Tournament.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It also explain why the Dumbledore's Army was the only organization in Deadly Hollows that suffers the least amount of casualties. Harry was more consistent in his teachings in a single year, than several DADA teachers put together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Perhaps the Draught of Living Death and "love" potions are there for cross curriculum purposes with Defence against the Dark Arts? The principle of 'offense informs defense' is common in advanced courses, and since NEWT potions is a requirement for Aurors, that would explain why these dangerous potions are in the 6th and 7th year syllabi.

to:

** Perhaps the Draught of Living Death and "love" potions are there for cross curriculum purposes with Defence against the Dark Arts? The principle of 'offense informs defense' is common in advanced courses, and since NEWT potions is a requirement for Aurors, that would explain why these dangerous potions are in the 6th and 7th year syllabi. In short, you need to know how the potions are made (i.e. what ingredients are needed) and what they do, in order to prevent some shady operations that use those potions.

Added: 732

Changed: 1094

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Most people wouldn't realize


* The Gaunts' birth defects are very pronounced, as if they've been marrying within their own family for several generations. While the number of pure-blood families was declining in Britain, there were still at least [[https://www.wizardingworld.com/features/who-are-the-sacred-twenty-eight 27 other such families at the time]], many of whom were also wizard supremacists, like the Blacks, Lestranges, and Malfoys. But considering the Gaunts were proud of not just being pure-blood, but being Parseltongues and descended from Salazar Slytherin and Cadmus Peverell, they may have been arrogant and entitled even by their peers' standards. Crosses over with Fridge Horror.

to:

* The Gaunts' birth defects are very pronounced, as if they've been marrying within their own family for several generations. While the number of pure-blood families was declining in Britain, there were still at least [[https://www.wizardingworld.com/features/who-are-the-sacred-twenty-eight 27 other such families at the time]], many of whom were also wizard supremacists, like the Blacks, Lestranges, and Malfoys. But considering the Gaunts were proud of not just being pure-blood, but being Parseltongues and descended from Salazar Slytherin and Cadmus Peverell, they may have been arrogant and entitled even by their peers' standards. Alternatively/additionally, their poverty and, let's face it, total lack of anything resembling manners (especially compared to, say, the upper-class Malfoys) would probably mean none of the others would ''want'' to marry into that family. Crosses over with Fridge Horror.



* Harry writes a Defense Against the Dark Arts essay at one point and later reflects that he "fully expected to receive low marks on his, because he had disagreed with Snape on the best way to tackle dementors”. Harry almost definitely wrote about the Patronus Charm, but it seems odd that Snape would have tried teaching the students an alternative way, since the Patronus is the only thing we've ever seen have any effect on dementors whatsoever. It becomes FridgeBrilliance when you realize that of course Snape wouldn't want to teach the class Patronuses because he'd certainly be expected to produce one as a demonstration, which [[spoiler:would reveal his Patronus's form and might cause someone to realize that it matches Lily's]]. Snape may have even had to come up with his own way to counteract dementors over the years so that he could avoid casting a Patronus for this reason.
* Imperiusing Stan Shunpike might seem like an odd move for the Death Eaters, but it actually makes sense when you think about it. Stan is the conductor of the Knight Bus, which is not only one of the biggest modes of transportation for wizards, but is also fairly discreet in its own way. Apparition and the Floo Network can both be traced, but the Knight Bus doesn't seem to magically track its passengers. Having control over Stan allows the Death Eaters to keep an eye on anyone who might be travelling by Knight Bus to hide from them, and also to ride it themselves without being apprehended.

to:

* Harry writes a Defense Against the Dark Arts essay at one point and later reflects that he "fully expected to receive low marks on his, because he had disagreed with Snape on the best way to tackle dementors”. Harry almost definitely wrote about the Patronus Charm, but it seems odd that Snape would have tried teaching the students an alternative way, since the Patronus is the only thing we've ever seen have any effect on dementors whatsoever. It becomes FridgeBrilliance when you realize that of course Snape wouldn't want to teach the class Patronuses because he'd certainly be expected to produce one as a demonstration, which [[spoiler:would reveal his Patronus's form and might cause someone Harry to realize that it matches Lily's]]. Snape may have even had to come up with his own way to counteract dementors over the years so that he could avoid casting a Patronus for this reason.
** Additionally, as we saw in Book 3, a Patronus needs a truly joyful memory or idea, not just somewhat happy, to cast. It's doubtful Snape has many of those.
* Imperiusing Stan Shunpike might seem like an odd move for the Death Eaters, but it actually makes sense when you think about it. Stan is the conductor of the Knight Bus, which is not only one of the biggest modes of transportation for wizards, but is also fairly discreet in its own way. Apparition and the Floo Network can both be traced, but the Knight Bus doesn't seem to magically track its passengers. Having control over Stan allows the Death Eaters to keep an eye on anyone who might be travelling by Knight Bus to hide from them, and also to ride it themselves without being apprehended. Additionally, how easy would it be for Stan to kidnap lone travellers here and there and turn them to the Death Eaters' cause in turn?



* The Sectumsempra spell which [[spoiler:almost made Draco bleed out]] is noted as "for enemies" by its creator...Gee, who were those enemies? Answer? [[spoiler:Sirius and James.]] And if the memory in ''Order'' is anything to go by, he tried to use it on [[spoiler:James]], though it was weak, nonverbal, and to the face instead of to the chest. However, the very fact that he didn't massacre them, [[spoiler:especially after that trick with the Whomping Willow when Lupin was transformed]], shows tremendous self-control.

to:

* The Sectumsempra spell which [[spoiler:almost made Draco bleed out]] is noted as "for enemies" by its creator...Gee, who were those enemies? Answer? [[spoiler:Sirius and James.]] And if the memory in ''Order'' is anything to go by, he tried to use it on [[spoiler:James]], though it was weak, nonverbal, and to the face instead of to the chest. However, the very fact that he didn't massacre them, [[spoiler:especially after that trick with the Whomping Willow when Lupin was transformed]], shows tremendous self-control.self-control (though it's probable that Dumbledore would've kicked him out of Hogwarts if he had).



* By the early twentieth century, the Gaunts are down just Marvolo, Morfin and Merope. The Gaunts were infamous for marrying their own cousins to "keep their family pure". [[BrotherSisterIncest And there are no cousins left for Morfin and Merope to marry]]. Yikes.

to:

* By the early twentieth century, the Gaunts are down just Marvolo, Morfin and Merope. The Gaunts were infamous for marrying their own cousins to "keep their family pure". [[BrotherSisterIncest And there are no cousins left for Morfin and Merope to marry]]. Yikes. The more you think about it, the squickier it gets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Harry writes a Defense Against the Dark Arts essay at one point and later reflects that he "fully expected to receive low marks on his, because he had disagreed with Snape on the best way to tackle dementors”. Harry almost definitely wrote about the Patronus Charm, but it seems odd that Snape would have tried teaching the students an alternative way, since the Patronus is the only thing we've ever seen have any effect on dementors whatsoever. It becomes FridgeBrilliance when you realize that of course Snape wouldn't want to teach the class Patronuses because he'd certainly be expected to produce one as a demonstration, which [[spoiler:would reveal his Patronus's form and might cause someone to realize that it matches Lily's]]. Snape may have even had to come up with his own way to counteract dementors over the years so that he could avoid casting a Patronus for this reason.
* Imperiusing Stan Shunpike might seem like an odd move for the Death Eaters, but it actually makes sense when you think about it. Stan is the conductor of the Knight Bus, which is not only one of the biggest modes of transportation for wizards, but is also fairly discreet in its own way. Apparition and the Floo Network can both be traced, but the Knight Bus doesn't seem to magically track its passengers. Having control over Stan allows the Death Eaters to keep an eye on anyone who might be travelling by Knight Bus to hide from them, and also to ride it themselves without being apprehended.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* With the reveal that Snape is the Half-Blood Prince, the title of the book can also be read as "Harry and Snape." This makes perfect sense, as this book is by far Snape's biggest role in the entire series, and he's arguably the most important character in the book. In other words, Snape is pretty much the protagonist of the book along with Harry, with his advice (his notes in the potions textbook, giving him dueling tips) even guiding Harry along the way. Series-wide, this book is also the point where we finally catch on that Snape has much more of a role than previously thought, and shows that he was ''always'' looking out for Harry since the first book. Essentially, the "Harry and Snape" title could also apply to the ''entire series'', since both characters by far have the biggest impact on the events of the series.

Added: 670

Changed: 60

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Snape so furious when Harry uses Sectumsempra on Malfoy? Because it's a lapse in Snape's Unbreakable Vow to protect him from harm at all costs. And it's a spell ''Snape invented himself.''

to:

* Why is Snape so furious when Harry uses Sectumsempra on Malfoy? Because it's a lapse in Snape's Unbreakable Vow to protect him from harm at all costs. Meaning Harry unintentionally almost killed ''two people''. And it's a spell ''Snape invented himself.'' ''
** Imagine if Snape hadn't been there in time to save Draco. Not only would that mean Harry is now a murderer with two bodies under his name, it would also completely derail Dumbledore's plan to destroy Voldemort, as Snape would obviously no longer be there to help guide Harry behind the scenes, or to look after the school. Meaning Hogwarts would have been a much, much, worse place, and Harry likely ''almost caused Voldemort to be immortal forever'' since Snape's patronus wouldn't have led him to the locket horcrux in the lake. All because Harry just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time and used a random spell that he found in a book out of panic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's another reason: With Harry casting Sectumsempra and Slughorn's comments during the Christmas party about his sudden potions expertise, Snape no doubt put two and two together, [[spoiler: hence revealing his identity as the Half-Blood Prince to Harry at the end of the book ]]. With Slughorn also constantly gushing about Lily's natural talent in potions, it becomes clear that Snape was pissed off because Harry was essentially insulting Lily's memory by cheating in a subject that she actually had talent in and put work into. The fact that Harry was doing so by using Snape's own notes was an even bigger slap in the face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Snape's anger at Harry for [[spoiler: using the Sectumsempra spell on Draco]] is probably the most enraged we've ever seen him in the series. Obviously, he's pissed that Harry attacked and nearly killed one of his students, but there's another reason: at the beginning of the book, Snape made an Unbreakable Vow with Narcissa Malfoy to protect her son. Ron mentions that if an Unbreakable Vow is broken, whoever was involved dies. So Snape was pissed because Harry not only nearly killed Draco, but him as well! [[spoiler: With one of his own spells, to boot]].
** Adding onto this, if Draco and Snape had been killed from this (Draco from the spell, Snape from breaking the unbreakable vow), then Dumbledore's plan would have completely gone up in smoke [[spoiler: as Dumbledore was already dying, and there would be no Snape to guide Harry behind the scenes and keep watch over the school in the next book]]. It's very likely that Snape knew this, so his anger is completely justified: Harry very nearly completely screwed up their plan to destroy Voldemort!

Added: 219

Removed: 319

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
What "organizations?" It was just Dumbledore's Army and the Order, and for that matter, we don't know all of the casualties of the Battle


** It also explain why, of all the organizations fighting Voldemort during the Battle of Hogwarts in Book 7, the Dumbledore's Army is the one that suffer less casualties ([[spoiler:Fred Weasley, Colin Creevey and Lavender Brown]]). Harry's teaching style was more consistent that all the teachers they had put together.


Added DiffLines:

** He also teaches about Inferi, because, as he notes, Voldemort used them a lot in the last war and is likely to do so again. In essence, Snape is doing his best to specifically train Harry and co for the task ahead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's not a mistake: Riddle never asks Slughorn about seven ''horcruxes'', he asks splitting a soul into seven parts. Dumbledore spells this out: Voldemort wanted a seven-part soul; six Horcruxes, and the seventh part of the soul remained in his body. [[spoiler:Granted, Voldemort ''did'' end up creating a seventh horcrux, but that was by complete accident.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The students are never taught how to make Amortentia in class, Slughorn just shows it to them to test if any of them can recognize it


** Not only is it distributed openly--''they teach sixteen-year-olds how to make it.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tom Riddle Sr was raped. Okay, he ''did'' marry Merope, but he ''was'' under Amortentia, basically uberpowerful roofies. She kept him enslaved to her will for several years after forcing him to leave his family for her, stopping only when she fell pregnant with his child. And we readers blame him for ''getting the fuck away from her when he realized what she did to him''.

to:

* Tom Riddle Sr was raped. Okay, he ''did'' marry Merope, but he ''was'' under Amortentia, basically uberpowerful roofies. She kept him enslaved to her will for several years months after forcing him to leave his family for her, stopping only when she fell pregnant with his child. And we readers blame him for ''getting the fuck away from her when he realized what she did to him''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It’s not just implied, it’s stated.


* By the early twentieth century, it's heavily implied that the Gaunts are down just Marvolo, Morfin and Merope. The Gaunts were infamous for marrying their own cousins to "keep their family pure". [[BrotherSisterIncest And there are no cousins left for Morfin and Merope to marry]]. Yikes.

to:

* By the early twentieth century, it's heavily implied that the Gaunts are down just Marvolo, Morfin and Merope. The Gaunts were infamous for marrying their own cousins to "keep their family pure". [[BrotherSisterIncest And there are no cousins left for Morfin and Merope to marry]]. Yikes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It’s not just implied, it’s stated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility is that the school recognizes him as headmaster and allows him to bypass everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It also explain why, of all the organizations fighting Voldemort during the Battle of Hogwarts in Book 7, the Dumbledore's Army is the one that suffer less casualties ([[spoiler:Fred Weasley, Colin Creevey and Lavender Brown]]). Harry's teaching style was more consistent that all the teachers they had put together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is being dewicked.


* The Gaunts' birth defects are very pronounced, as if they've been marrying within their own family for several generations. While the number of pure-blood families was declining in Britain, there were still at least [[https://www.wizardingworld.com/features/who-are-the-sacred-twenty-eight 27 other such families at the time]], many of whom were also wizard supremacists, like the Blacks, Lestranges, and Malfoys. But considering the Gaunts were proud of not just being pure-blood, but being Parseltongues and descended from Salazar Slytherin and Cadmus Peverell, they [[UpToEleven may have been arrogant and entitled even by their peers' standards]]. Crosses over with Fridge Horror.

to:

* The Gaunts' birth defects are very pronounced, as if they've been marrying within their own family for several generations. While the number of pure-blood families was declining in Britain, there were still at least [[https://www.wizardingworld.com/features/who-are-the-sacred-twenty-eight 27 other such families at the time]], many of whom were also wizard supremacists, like the Blacks, Lestranges, and Malfoys. But considering the Gaunts were proud of not just being pure-blood, but being Parseltongues and descended from Salazar Slytherin and Cadmus Peverell, they [[UpToEleven may have been arrogant and entitled even by their peers' standards]].standards. Crosses over with Fridge Horror.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's also hard to imagine that either Marvolo or Morphin was a good and patient teacher.

to:

*** It's also hard to imagine that either Marvolo or Morphin Morfin was a good and patient teacher.teacher. Especially Marvolo. Since even Morfin seems to have been afraid of his father’s temper (as shown in the first Pensieve scene and when he expressed fear over how Marvolo would react to the family ring being gone), and Morfin was AxCrazy, one can only imagine how much Marvolo would have terrified Merope, who doesn’t seem to have been as crazy as her brother ''or'' her father. Marvolo could have so frightened Merope while teaching her that she couldn’t perform magic well, which led to a vicious cycle that only ended when Marvolo and Morfin were arrested, only for Merope to succumb to despair when Tom Riddle Sr. fled once she stopped drugging/cursing him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That would also explain why Tom Riddle Sr. never bothered to figure out what had happened to Merope or his child. If he believed that Merope was associated with the Devil, and that the child he fathered was little more than a demon, it’s no wonder why Riddle never bothered to find out what happened to the mother or the child. Who’d want to find out what happened to satanic figures? Ironically, Voldemort becomes a SatanicArchetype in part ''because'' Riddle never tried to find him (though there were certainly other factors involved)!

Added: 955

Changed: 1112

Removed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pretty sure that's explicitly stated


** As Potions Master, of course Snape would only want the highest scoring students, because at this point, [[FridgeHorror if something goes wrong]] you end up with BodyHorror instead of HilarityEnsues.

to:

** As Potions Master, of course Snape would only want the highest scoring students, because at this point, [[FridgeHorror if something goes wrong]] you end up with BodyHorror instead of HilarityEnsues. Not only that, but he has a very low tolerance for anyone who isn't a very good potioneer. By restricting his N.E.W.T. students to only those with an "O," he ensures that the only sixth- and seventh-years he'll have to deal with are the cream of the crop.



* Dumbledore has an ulterior motive for wanting Slughorn back at Hogwarts -- he needs Slughorn's Horcrux memory.



** Alternately/additionally, if Draco ''does'' successfully go into hiding, Voldy (hopefully) won't be able to kill him. Which means that Draco would remain the master of the Elder Wand...but he'd have no idea of it himself, and then the ownership of the Wand would become confused enough it'd be pretty much impossible for anyone to trace it.



** Even if the luck potion only benefits the drinker, the effects still make sense. Ron was becoming increasingly paranoid about even being seen by Lavender, it was only a matter of time before he started pestering Harry to borrow his Invisibility Cloak so he could vanish from her completely. The longer Ron puts off the breakup, the more annoying it is for Harry. Ron and Lavender finally breaking up is really lucky for Harry.

to:

** Even if the luck potion only benefits the drinker, the effects still make sense. Ron was becoming increasingly paranoid about even being seen by Lavender, it was only a matter of time before he started pestering Harry to borrow his Invisibility Cloak so he could vanish from her completely.completely, and it's fairly heavily implied that Harry's getting irritated by Ron's constant diving for cover every time he sees a girl he thinks is Lavender. The longer Ron puts off the breakup, the more annoying it is for Harry. Ron and Lavender finally breaking up is really lucky for Harry.



* The Felix Felicis Harry won from Slughorn in this year's first Potions Lesson. As it needs half a year to be made and Slughorn had only one month and a half, there wouldn't have been enough time to create it just for this occasion. This Felix Felicis was actually Slughorn's emergency stash in case the Death eaters got hold of him, he wanted to drink it in order to make it easier to escape. But now when he was safe and sound in Hogwarts, he felt safe enough to give it away as he was under Dumbledore's protection.

to:

** There's also the fact that, say what you like about Scrimgeour, but he does seem to recognize and use talent wherever it can be found. While Fudge would've dismissed Arthur as a slightly eccentric odd-job man, Scrimgeour realized that Arthur really is much more than that.
* The Felix Felicis Harry won from Slughorn in this year's first Potions Lesson. As it needs half a year to be made and Slughorn had only one month and a half, there wouldn't have been enough time to create it just for this occasion. This Felix Felicis was actually Slughorn's emergency stash in case the Death eaters Eaters got hold of him, he wanted to drink it in order to make it easier to escape. But now when he was safe and sound in Hogwarts, he felt safe enough to give it away as he was under Dumbledore's protection.



* One from the film: in the book, Harry and Dumbledore have to walk to Hogsmeade in order to apparate to the horcrux cave, and then return to Hogsmeade before flying back to Hogwarts. Because of time constraints in the film, this gets changed to them apparating directly to and from Hogwarts, with Dumbledore addressing the impossibility by saying "Well, being me...has its privileges." How so? Well, since he's taught there for almost all his adult life (several decades), he would know better than anyone else about the protective enchantments (both the ones that have been there for centuries and the recent additions in the wake of Voldemort's return) and would therefore know how to penetrate them.

to:

* One from the film: in the book, Harry and Dumbledore have to walk to Hogsmeade in order to apparate to the horcrux cave, and then return to Hogsmeade before flying back to Hogwarts. Because of time constraints in the film, this gets changed to them apparating directly to and from Hogwarts, with Dumbledore addressing the impossibility by saying "Well, being me...has its privileges." How so? Well, since he's taught there for almost all his adult life (several decades), he would know better than anyone else about the protective enchantments (both the ones that have been there for centuries and the recent additions in the wake of Voldemort's return) and would therefore know how to penetrate them. Especially since he was probably the one who placed at least some of them himself.



*** It's also hard to imagine that either Marvolo or Morphin was a good and patient teacher.



* The Gaunts' birth defects are very pronounced, as if they've been marrying within their own family for several generations. While the number of pure-blood families was declining in Britain, there were still at least [[https://www.wizardingworld.com/features/who-are-the-sacred-twenty-eight 27 other such families at the time]], many of whom were also wizard supremacists, like the Blacks, Lestranges, and Malfoys. But considering the Gaunts were proud of not just being pure-blood, but being Parseltongue and descended from Salazar Slytherin and Cadmus Peverell, they [[UpToEleven may have been arrogant and entitled even by their peers' standards]]. Crosses over with Fridge Horror.

to:

* The Gaunts' birth defects are very pronounced, as if they've been marrying within their own family for several generations. While the number of pure-blood families was declining in Britain, there were still at least [[https://www.wizardingworld.com/features/who-are-the-sacred-twenty-eight 27 other such families at the time]], many of whom were also wizard supremacists, like the Blacks, Lestranges, and Malfoys. But considering the Gaunts were proud of not just being pure-blood, but being Parseltongue Parseltongues and descended from Salazar Slytherin and Cadmus Peverell, they [[UpToEleven may have been arrogant and entitled even by their peers' standards]]. Crosses over with Fridge Horror.

Top