Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / PiratesOfTheCaribbeanTheCurseOfTheBlackPearl

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding trope

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotBall: In the leadup to the final battle, Norrington has the bulk of his crew waiting outside of Isla de Muerta. As Pintel and Ragetti row by in their small ship, he apparently doesn't think it worth investigating why two random "women" in fine dresses and parasols are leaving a pirate hideout in the middle of the night, allowing Pintel and Ragetti to reach the Dauntless. Nor does Norrington notice the numerous shots fired (which are quite loud) aboard the Dauntless until after a bell is rung.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The legend about UsefulNotes/HernanCortez at the story's background, which has Cortés receiving a gold tribute by the Aztecs and still callously slaughtering them, seems to be rather inspired by the conquest of the Inca by UsefulNotes/FranciscoPizarro, who did gain an immense rescue in gold for capturing their emperor Atahualpa and still ended up going back on his word and executing the man.[[note]]Surely a dishonourable decision, although not born of cruelty as in the movie, but desperation, as freeing Atahualpa would have meant to let him gather his armies to attack the Spaniards and his local allies (Pizarro had actually befriended Atahualpa and had to be pressed into executing him, and he cried upon doing so). No slaughter followed either, as Pizarro was in a precarious position on a largely intact Inca Empire and depended on politics to keep control.[[/note]] Cortés only conquered the Aztec Empire by allying with their ancestral enemies and their discontent imperial subjects, and by the point he was in position to attack the Aztec core, the conflict had devolved into total war and no diplomacy or tribute was possible anymore. Moreover, Cortés himself actually attempted to avoid any slaughter - it were rather his native allies who saw the chance to take revenge on their Aztec opressors and took it with massive gusto, never better said.
** The Aztecs of the movie delivered Cortés a chest full of round gold coins, but real life Aztecs didn't have anything of the like until after their Hispanicization. The closest to a native coin-like currency were small axe-shaped pieces named ''tajaderas'', which were also made of raw copper, not artistically wrought gold. In fact, the whole association between gold and currency was also introduced by the Spaniards, as up to that point Amerindians mostly used their gold to make ornaments and decorations.

to:

** The legend about UsefulNotes/HernanCortez at the story's background, which has Cortés receiving a gold tribute by the Aztecs and still callously slaughtering them, seems to be rather inspired by the conquest of the Inca by UsefulNotes/FranciscoPizarro, who did gain an immense rescue in gold for capturing their emperor Atahualpa and still ended up going back on his word and executing the man.[[note]]Surely a dishonourable decision, although but not born of cruelty as in the movie, but desperation, of a previous lack of forethought, as freeing Atahualpa would have meant to let him gather his armies to attack the Spaniards and his local allies (Pizarro had actually befriended Atahualpa and had intended to be pressed into send him to Spain as a royal hostage rather than executing him, and he cried upon doing so).but his people didn't want to run any risk). No slaughter followed either, as Pizarro was in a precarious position on a largely intact Inca Empire and depended on politics to keep control.[[/note]] Cortés only conquered the Aztec Empire by allying with their ancestral enemies and their discontent imperial subjects, and by the point he was in position to attack the Aztec core, the conflict had devolved into total war and no diplomacy or tribute was possible anymore. Moreover, Cortés himself actually attempted to avoid any slaughter - it were rather his native allies who saw the chance to take revenge on their Aztec opressors and took it with massive gusto, never better said.
** The Aztecs of the movie delivered Cortés a chest full of round gold coins, but real life Aztecs didn't have anything of the like use such coins until well after their Hispanicization. The closest to a native coin-like currency were small axe-shaped pieces named ''tajaderas'', which were also made of raw copper, not artistically wrought gold. In fact, the whole association between gold and currency was also introduced by the Spaniards, as up to that point Amerindians mostly used their gold to make ornaments and decorations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* AndIMustScream: It's revealed that Bootstrap Bill is somewhere at the bottom of the ocean, tied to a cannon but still alive and unable to die. To make matters worse [[spoiler:the second movie revealed that Will undoing the curse didn't free him]].

to:

* AndIMustScream: It's revealed that Bootstrap Bill is somewhere at the bottom of the ocean, tied to a cannon but still alive and unable to die. To make matters worse worse, [[spoiler:the second movie revealed that Will undoing the curse didn't free him]].



* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: At one point Jack's numerous crimes are being read aloud including, among the many piracy related ones, "impersonating a cleric of the Church of England; this solicits a brief, reminiscent smile from Jack.

to:

* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: At one point Jack's numerous crimes are being read aloud including, among the many piracy related ones, "impersonating a cleric of the Church of England; England"; this solicits a brief, reminiscent smile from Jack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


'''Jack Sparrow:''' You're welcome.

to:

'''Jack Sparrow:''' You're welcome.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse


** The fight between Will Turner and Jack Sparrow in the smithy starts as a swordfight but quickly devolves into escalating degrees of CombatPragmatist. This culminates in [[SandInMyEyes Jack throwing sand in Will's face]], blinding him long enough to get him at pistol-point.

to:

** The fight between Will Turner and Jack Sparrow in the smithy starts as a swordfight but quickly devolves into escalating degrees of CombatPragmatist. This culminates in [[SandInMyEyes [[AHandfulForAnEye Jack throwing sand in Will's face]], blinding him long enough to get him at pistol-point.

Changed: 433

Removed: 564

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse


* LivingForeverIsAwesome: Whoever placed the curse on the Aztec Gold (supposedly "heathen gods") made [[DefiedTrope absolutely certain that its victims would not be able to enjoy eternal life]]. You are eternally hungry, eternally thirsty, you have no physical sensations at all (no "pleasurable company" for you), and you have to be careful around moonlight or you'll spook whoever sees your skeletal form. Even though the curse removes all the risk from their occupation, a group of hedonistic pirates like Barbossa's crew are made absolutely miserable from it.



* WhoWantsToLiveForever: The motivation for breaking the curse, as Bootstrap Bill can attest. The pirates would probably be quite happy to live forever, except that the curse prevents them from deriving any enjoyment from their endless life.

to:

* WhoWantsToLiveForever: The motivation for breaking the curse, as Bootstrap Bill can attest. The pirates would probably be quite happy to live forever, except that the curse prevents them from deriving any enjoyment from their endless life.life. They're eternally hungry, eternally thirsty, have no physical sensation at all (no "pleasurable company"), and [[GlamourFailure reveal their monstrous, undead forms]] in the moonlight. Even though the curse [[CursedWithAwesome removes all the risk]] from their occupation, a group of hedonistic pirates like Barbossa's crew are made absolutely miserable from it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LivingForeverIsAwesome: Whoever placed the curse on the Aztec Gold (supposedly "heathen gods") made [[DefiedTrope absolutely certain that its victims would not be able to enjoy eternal life]]. You are eternally hungry, eternally thirsty, you have no physical sensations at all (no "pleasurable company" for you), and you have to be careful around moonlight or you'll spook whoever sees your skeletal form. Even though the curse removes all the risk from their occupation, a group of hedonistic pirates like Barbosa's crew are made absolutely miserable from it.

to:

* LivingForeverIsAwesome: Whoever placed the curse on the Aztec Gold (supposedly "heathen gods") made [[DefiedTrope absolutely certain that its victims would not be able to enjoy eternal life]]. You are eternally hungry, eternally thirsty, you have no physical sensations at all (no "pleasurable company" for you), and you have to be careful around moonlight or you'll spook whoever sees your skeletal form. Even though the curse removes all the risk from their occupation, a group of hedonistic pirates like Barbosa's Barbossa's crew are made absolutely miserable from it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShipwreckStart: The film begins with [[AMinorKidroduction 10-year-old Elizabeth Swann]], sailing with her father, Norrington, and Gibbs, coming across a burning shipwreck caused by pirates, spotting one of its victims, young Will Turner, in the water.

Added: 1914

Changed: 2586

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Elizabeth Swann is shown being torturously tied into an extremely tight corset, which [[OfCorsetHurts restricts her breathing and causes her great pain]]. Corsets being a type of torture device [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNwTqanp0Aw is a modern myth]]. Properly fitted and made corsets (which must also be broken in and the wearer acclimatise herself to it, which films usually don't have time for), as opposed to costume replicas, do not overly constrict one's breathing or movement. Even tightlacing -- which was first recorded in the 1840s, a century after the film's setting, nor was it even possible with the corsets of the 1730s-40s (metal eyelets were introduced in the 1840s) -- doesn't cause the severe discomfort or restricted breathing and movement often depicted (and [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_tightlacing_on_the_body many of the health effects claimed are false]], due to inaccurate medical knowledge of the time and a campaign by MoralGuardians of the late Victorian Era to make women stop wearing corsets).
* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Jack and Will go undercover by dragging an upturned rowing boat down to the seabed and using the trapped pocket of air to keep breathing. The force required to achieve this would be well beyond the combined strength of two men, and even if they did, the oxygen would very quickly run out.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: ArtisticLicenseHistory:
** The legend about UsefulNotes/HernanCortez at the story's background, which has Cortés receiving a gold tribute by the Aztecs and still callously slaughtering them, seems to be rather inspired by the conquest of the Inca by UsefulNotes/FranciscoPizarro, who did gain an immense rescue in gold for capturing their emperor Atahualpa and still ended up going back on his word and executing the man.[[note]]Surely a dishonourable decision, although not born of cruelty as in the movie, but desperation, as freeing Atahualpa would have meant to let him gather his armies to attack the Spaniards and his local allies (Pizarro had actually befriended Atahualpa and had to be pressed into executing him, and he cried upon doing so). No slaughter followed either, as Pizarro was in a precarious position on a largely intact Inca Empire and depended on politics to keep control.[[/note]] Cortés only conquered the Aztec Empire by allying with their ancestral enemies and their discontent imperial subjects, and by the point he was in position to attack the Aztec core, the conflict had devolved into total war and no diplomacy or tribute was possible anymore. Moreover, Cortés himself actually attempted to avoid any slaughter - it were rather his native allies who saw the chance to take revenge on their Aztec opressors and took it with massive gusto, never better said.
** The Aztecs of the movie delivered Cortés a chest full of round gold coins, but real life Aztecs didn't have anything of the like until after their Hispanicization. The closest to a native coin-like currency were small axe-shaped pieces named ''tajaderas'', which were also made of raw copper, not artistically wrought gold. In fact, the whole association between gold and currency was also introduced by the Spaniards, as up to that point Amerindians mostly used their gold to make ornaments and decorations.
**
Elizabeth Swann is shown being torturously tied into an extremely tight corset, which [[OfCorsetHurts restricts her breathing and causes her great pain]]. Corsets being a type of torture device [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNwTqanp0Aw is a modern myth]]. Properly fitted and made corsets (which must also be broken in and the wearer acclimatise herself to it, which films usually don't have time for), as opposed to costume replicas, do not overly constrict one's breathing or movement. Even tightlacing -- which was first recorded in the 1840s, a century after the film's setting, nor was it even possible with the corsets of the 1730s-40s (metal eyelets were introduced in the 1840s) -- doesn't cause the severe discomfort or restricted breathing and movement often depicted (and [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_tightlacing_on_the_body many of the health effects claimed are false]], due to inaccurate medical knowledge of the time and a campaign by MoralGuardians of the late Victorian Era to make women stop wearing corsets).
* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Jack and Will go undercover by dragging an upturned rowing boat down to the seabed and using the trapped pocket of air to keep breathing. The force required to achieve this would be well beyond the combined strength of two men, men unless the boat was very heavily ballasted, and even if they did, it was, the oxygen would very quickly run out.



* CutleryEscapeAid: Elizabeth Swann sneaks a knife from the table while she's dining with [[BigBad Barbossa]] on the ''Black Pearl''. She does end up stabbing him with, but since he's [[FateWorseThanDeath undead]] this doesn't do anything to him and he even lampshades the FridgeLogic by asking what she intended on doing after killing him, seeing as how she's trapped on a pirate ship in the middle of the ocean.

to:

* CutleryEscapeAid: Elizabeth Swann sneaks a knife from the table while she's dining with [[BigBad Barbossa]] on the ''Black Pearl''. She does end up stabbing him with, but since he's [[FateWorseThanDeath undead]] undead]], this doesn't do anything to him and he even him. He also lampshades the FridgeLogic by asking what she intended on doing after killing him, seeing as how she's trapped on a pirate ship in the middle of the ocean.



* LosingAShoeInTheStruggle: When Will rescues Elizabeth in the cave of treasure, she’s wearing shoes and stockings. When she and Will make it back to the ‘’Interceptor’’, a brief shot shows that she’s now barefoot, and remains shot from then until the beginning of the third act. The possible cause could be from the process of swimming back, or she possibly removed them to swim easier while wearing her dress.

to:

* LosingAShoeInTheStruggle: When Will rescues Elizabeth in the cave of treasure, she’s she's wearing shoes and stockings. When she and Will make it back to the ‘’Interceptor’’, ''Interceptor'', a brief shot shows that she’s she's now barefoot, and remains shot s from then until the beginning of the third act. The possible cause could be from the process of swimming back, or she possibly removed them to swim easier while wearing her dress.



* {{Mayincatec}}: The cursed Aztec gold, supposedly from modern day México, comes in a stone chest engraved with the Staff God of Tiwanaku, an artwork piece found in modern day ''Bolivia''.

to:

* {{Mayincatec}}: The cursed Aztec gold, supposedly from modern day México, comes in a stone chest engraved with the Staff God of Tiwanaku, an artwork piece found in modern day ''Bolivia''. The story given about UsefulNotes/HernanCortez also resembles more that of UsefulNotes/FranciscoPizarro.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Finally, Barbossa, who earlier in the film complained that under the curse he could feel nothing, is freed of the curse just in time to feel his own death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Consider the fate of the ''Black Pearl'''s crew. Their unquenchable greed and thirst for gold drove them to take all the Aztec gold ... so they were cursed to be greedy and lustful forever, unable to satisfy their hunger and thirst. The only way to break the curse was to ''stop'' being greedy, and return all the stolen gold to the chest.

to:

** Consider the fate of the ''Black Pearl'''s crew. Their unquenchable greed and thirst lust for gold drove them to take all the Aztec gold ... so they were cursed to be greedy and lustful forever, unable to satisfy their hunger and thirst.forever. The only way to break the curse was to ''stop'' being greedy, and return all the stolen gold to the chest.

Added: 916

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccordionToMostSailors: During the "Moonlight Serenade" sequence where Elizabeth first sees the pirates for what they truly are, one of the pirates sitting on the capstan is playing a concertina. The instrument's bellows is as rotted and decrepit as the pirates are, raising the question of how it can still produce music.



* AlarmSOS: During the pirates' attack on the Dauntless, a British sailor manages to ring the ship's bell, alerting Norrington and the rest of the Marines to the chaos.

to:

* AlarmSOS: During the pirates' attack on the Dauntless, ''Dauntless'', a British sailor manages to ring the ship's bell, alerting Norrington and the rest of the Marines to the chaos.


Added DiffLines:

-->'''Barbossa:''' For too long I've been parched with thirst, and unable to quench it! Too long I've been starvin' to death, and haven't died. I feel nothing -- not the wind on my face or the spray of the sea, or the warmth of a woman's flesh.


Added DiffLines:

** Consider the fate of the ''Black Pearl'''s crew. Their unquenchable greed and thirst for gold drove them to take all the Aztec gold ... so they were cursed to be greedy and lustful forever, unable to satisfy their hunger and thirst. The only way to break the curse was to ''stop'' being greedy, and return all the stolen gold to the chest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeNamedTheMonkeyJack: {{Trope Namer|s}}. Barbossa reveals they named their undead pet monkey Jack as a joke on the real Jack.
-->'''Barbossa:''' ''[takes medallion from the monkey]'' Why thank you, Jack.\\
'''Jack Sparrow:''' You're welcome.
'''Barbossa:''' Not you, we named the monkey "Jack".

Added: 314

Changed: -12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: Jack and Will go undercover by dragging an upturned rowing boat down to the seabed and using the trapped pocket of air to keep breathing. The force required to achieve this would be well beyond the combined strength of two men, and even if they did, the oxygen would very quickly run out.



** When Jack arrives in Port Royal, and he leaves the dock after that bribing scene, one can hear a sailor : "Ce soir? Pas de problème!" [[note]]Tonight? No problem![[/note]]
** When he arrives in Tortuga with Will, one can hear another sailor : "Oh mais dis donc, arrête!" [[note]]What the hell, stop it![[/note]]

to:

** When Jack arrives in Port Royal, and he leaves the dock after that bribing scene, one can hear a sailor : "Ce soir? Pas de problème!" [[note]]Tonight? No problem![[/note]]
** When he arrives in Tortuga with Will, one can hear another sailor : "Oh mais dis donc, arrête!" [[note]]What the hell, stop it![[/note]]



* {{Mayincatec}}: The cursed Aztec gold, supposedly from modern day México, comes in a stone chest engraved with the Staff God of Tiwanaku, an artwork piece found in modern day ''Bolivia''.

to:

* {{Mayincatec}}: The cursed Aztec gold, supposedly from modern day México, comes in a stone chest engraved with the Staff God of Tiwanaku, an artwork piece found in modern day ''Bolivia''.



* MortalityGreyArea: As the result of plundering the cursed treasure chest of Hernán Cortés, Barbossa and his crew's desires cannot be sated; their hunger cannot be sated, their thirst cannot be quenched, their lust cannot be slaked. Under direct moonlight, they transform into rotting skeletons. And on top of all of this, they cannot die, no matter the state they are in[[note]]this includes a group of pirates impaled through the chest and then blown to bits by a hand-bomb, and a pirate tied to a cannon and then dropped into the ocean[[/note]], not until each piece of Aztec gold is returned to the chest it came from, along with a blood price from the one who took it.

to:

* MortalityGreyArea: As the result of plundering the cursed treasure chest of Hernán Cortés, Barbossa and his crew's desires cannot be sated; their hunger cannot be sated, their thirst cannot be quenched, their lust cannot be slaked. Under direct moonlight, they transform into rotting skeletons. And on top of all of this, they cannot die, no matter the state they are in[[note]]this includes a group of pirates impaled through the chest and then blown to bits by a hand-bomb, and a pirate tied to a cannon and then dropped into the ocean[[/note]], not until each piece of Aztec gold is returned to the chest it came from, along with a blood price from the one who took it.



* ThePowerOfBlood: The blood of those who took coins from the Chest of [[UsefulNotes/HernanCortez Cortés]] (or that of their children) is required in order to end the curse.

to:

* ThePowerOfBlood: The blood of those who took coins from the Chest of [[UsefulNotes/HernanCortez Cortés]] (or that of their children) is required in order to end the curse.

Added: 278

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking.


-->'''Jack:''' It's the Pearl!
-->'''Prisoner:''' The Black Pearl? I've heard stories. She's been preying on ships and settlements for near ten years. Never leaves any survivors.
-->'''Jack:''' No survivors? Then where do the stories come from, I wonder?

to:

-->'''Jack:''' It's the Pearl!
-->'''Prisoner:'''
Pearl!\\
'''Prisoner:'''
The Black Pearl? I've heard stories. She's been preying on ships and settlements for near ten years. Never leaves any survivors.
-->'''Jack:'''
survivors.\\
'''Jack:'''
No survivors? Then where do the stories come from, I wonder?


Added DiffLines:

* AsskickingLeadsToLeadership: When the crew of the ''Black Pearl'' is seconds away from mutinying, [[BigBad Captain Barbossa]] draws his sword and asks which one of them would be willing to challenge him for the captaincy. Everyone backs down, even though they're all immortal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForWantOfANail: The main plot basically kicks off because of Elizabeth's corset being laced too tightly. It was because of that that she fell into the sea and the medallion summoned the ''Pearl'' to Port Royal. Had it not been for that, the main plot wouldn't have happened.

Added: 310

Changed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGun: Jack's pistol with only one shot in it, which was left to him by Barbossa when Jack was marooned by him many years ago.

to:

* ChekhovsGun: ChekhovsGun:
**
Jack's pistol with only one shot in it, which was left to him by Barbossa when Jack was marooned by him many years ago. ago.
** Pintel and Ragetti accidentally open up a trunk full of dresses. They're forced to don said dresses later on as a distraction while the rest of the cursed crew attack the ''Dauntless''.



* ContrivedCoincidence: A ''lot'' of pieces had to fall into place for the main plot to kick off the way it does. First Elizabeth had a dream of when she first met Will and acquired the medallion, driving her to take it out of it's hiding place for the first time in a long time (going from the thick layer of dust) and wear it. Then her father comes in before she can put it away, so she sticks it under her clothes in a panic. It just so happens that it's the day of Norrington's promotion, so she gets dressed in a corset laced so tight that she passes out and falls into the sea, where the medallion can call to the ''Black Pearl.'' And finally, Jack Sparrow just so happens to arrive at Port Royal that day and is in just the right location at just the right time to save Elizabeth from drowning. If a single one of these factors had been different, then the main plot wound't have happened, or would've played out very differently.

to:

* ContrivedCoincidence: A ''lot'' of pieces had to fall into place for the main plot to kick off the way it does. First Elizabeth had a dream of when she first met Will and acquired the medallion, driving her to take it out of it's its hiding place for the first time in a long time (going from the thick layer of dust) and wear it. Then her father comes in before she can put it away, so she sticks it under her clothes in a panic. It just so happens that it's the day of Norrington's promotion, so she gets dressed in a corset laced so tight that she passes out and falls into the sea, where the medallion can call to the ''Black Pearl.'' And finally, Jack Sparrow just so happens to arrive at Port Royal that day and is in just the right location at just the right time to save Elizabeth from drowning. If a single one of these factors had been different, then the main plot wound't have happened, or would've played out very differently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When describing the Aztec Gold, Barbossa states it was cursed by "heathen gods". This throaway bit of exposition establishes the presence of divine entities in the ''Pirates'' mythos. This will become ''very'' important over the course of the next two films (and in ''At World's End'' in particular).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItOnlyWorksOnce: A variation with [[spoiler:Jack's escape from Rum-runner's Isle. The first time, he got off within 3 days thanks to the bootlegers dropping off their cargo. By the time Barbossa maroons Jack and Elizabeth, the isle's bene long-abandoned. Jack speculates the rum-runners went out of business at some point in the last decade.]]

to:

* ItOnlyWorksOnce: A variation with [[spoiler:Jack's escape from Rum-runner's Isle. The first time, he got off within 3 days thanks to the bootlegers bootleggers dropping off their cargo. By the time Barbossa maroons Jack and Elizabeth, the isle's bene been long-abandoned. Jack speculates the rum-runners went out of business at some point in the last decade.]]

Changed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanding the example.


* StopOrIShootMyself: Will does this to get Elizabeth released from Barbossa's crew. It almost doesn't work; Barbossa's initial reply is a confused "Who ''are'' you?".

to:

* StopOrIShootMyself: Will does this puts a gun to his own throat while standing next to the ship's edge, in order to get Elizabeth released from Barbossa's crew. It almost doesn't work; Initially, however, it only really leaves the pirates confused as to why they should care; Barbossa's initial reply is a confused "Who ''are'' you?".you?"

Top