Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / KPax

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BizarreAlienReproduction: According to prot, the [=K-PAX=]ian mating process is profoundly painful and associated with a terrible smell.

to:

* BizarreAlienReproduction: According to prot, the [=K-PAX=]ian mating process is profoundly painful and associated with a terrible smell. As a result, lust is an entirely foreign concept to them, and they consider sex an unpleasant chore that must be performed with utmost care and patience to minimize the suffering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DawsonCasting: Kevin Spacey, especially in the flashback scene, as Spacey was 41 at the time of filming, whereas prot/Robert was 28 (and 23 in the origin flashback).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*DawsonCasting: Kevin Spacey, especially in the flashback scene, as Spacey was 41 at the time of filming, whereas prot/Robert was 28 (and 23 in the origin flashback).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* DoctorDoctorDoctor: At the planetarium when Prot and Dr. Powell meet four astrophysicists. [[http://www.metacafe.com/watch/an-_PIsJmY2nhbmmY/k_pax_2001_planetarium/ See the clip here.]]
-->'''Prot:''' "Doctor — Doctor — Doctor — Doctor. How many doctors are there on this planet?"

to:

* DoctorDoctorDoctor: At the planetarium when Prot prot and Dr. Powell meet four astrophysicists. [[http://www.metacafe.com/watch/an-_PIsJmY2nhbmmY/k_pax_2001_planetarium/ See the clip here.]]
-->'''Prot:''' -->'''prot:''' "Doctor — Doctor — Doctor — Doctor. How many doctors are there on this planet?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mary Suetopia has been cut per TRS: [1]. Appropriate examples are moved to Utopia

Added DiffLines:

* {{Utopia}}: The description of prot's homeworld is basically a perfect anarchist, agnostic society with no violence, everyone is vegetarian, and there are no schools. Criminals are not punished; they are simply "reasoned" with (or they ''would'' be reasoned with if there were any there in the first place).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: A slight example in Russell, the highly religious patient. The book has him being very antagonistic to prot, considering him to be the work of the Devil and wanting nothing to do with him. The film keeps him in the background, but asks if he can take his Bible to K-PAX.

to:

* AdaptationalHeroism: A slight example in AdaptationalNiceGuy: The book has Russell, the highly religious patient. The book has him patient, being very antagonistic to prot, considering him to be the work of the Devil and wanting nothing to do with him. The film keeps him in the background, but asks if he can take his Bible to K-PAX.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
null edit
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hollywood Personality Disorders has been converted to UsefulNotes.Personality Disorders, and U Ns are not to be listed on trope pages. If the depiction is incorrect, use Hollywood Psych.


* HollywoodPersonalityDisorders: The patients of Dr. Powell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenderFlip: Dr. Klaus Villars, a white, bearded, German-accented, classically Freud-reminiscent psychiatrist in the novel becomes Dr. Claudia Villars, a female black American in the film.

to:

* GenderFlip: GenderFlip / RaceLift: Dr. Klaus Villars, a white, bearded, German-accented, classically Freud-reminiscent psychiatrist in the novel becomes Dr. Claudia Villars, a female black American in the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NapoleonDelusion: One of the patients is a woman who claims she is the Queen of England.

to:

* NapoleonDelusion: One of the patients is a woman who claims she is the Queen of England. Dr. Powell also Discusses the trope when he first learns he's getting a new patient in prot, quipping, "Who is it this time, Jesus Christ or Joan of Arc?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Typo


** Though he doesn't get nearly as irate as in the novel, the first time prot is noticeably annoyed by Powell is when he tries to ask about how crime on K-PAX is punished, and he proceeds to launch into a prolonged lecture on how flaws and stupid the "eye for an eye" mentality behind the human criminal justice system is.

to:

** Though he doesn't get nearly as irate as in the novel, the first time prot is noticeably annoyed by Powell is when he tries to ask about how crime on K-PAX is punished, and he proceeds to launch into a prolonged lecture on how flaws flawed and stupid the "eye for an eye" mentality behind the human criminal justice system is.

Added: 720

Changed: 469

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BerserkButton: Though he doesn't get nearly as irate as in the novel, the first time prot is noticeably annoyed by Powell is when he tries to ask about how crime on K-PAX is punished.
** He does however essentially dodge the question with his rant and never actually answers it.

to:

* BerserkButton: BerserkButton:
**
Though he doesn't get nearly as irate as in the novel, the first time prot is noticeably annoyed by Powell is when he tries to ask about how crime on K-PAX is punished.
** He does however essentially dodge
punished, and he proceeds to launch into a prolonged lecture on how flaws and stupid the question with his rant and never actually answers it."eye for an eye" mentality behind the human criminal justice system is.


Added DiffLines:

* HeroicSafeMode [[spoiler:prot is Robert Porter's alter-ego that took over his body to invoke this trope. Robert crossed the DespairEventHorizon '''big time''' after the death of his family and his killing of their murderer, and prot has been in control ever since because Robert is mentally broken to the point of catatonia, even after five years.]]


Added DiffLines:

* WhamShot: When Powell brings prot to his home for a barbeque, prot gets along just fine with everyone and is enjoying himself, as are they. Then Powell's kids [[spoiler:turn on the law sprinkler]], complete with a close-up. prot snaps his head up and turns to stare at it, and his entire demeanor completely changes: another of his {{Berserk Button}}s has been found.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheShrink: Psychiatrist Dr. Powell is Type 2. He does want to help his patients and truly cares abotu him, and while he acknowledges medications can be useful aids he prefers not to rely on them and recognizes they can sometimes do more harm than good. His critical hinderance as a doctor is that he can't emotionally connect with his patients and see their problems from their angle. This is evident in his first scene, where he lets Ernie ramble about germs without paying much attention to him, dismisses his concerns, and tells him he wants him to start sleeping again because "sleep is good!" This is what allows prot to work towards curie Ernie and Howie, which infuriates Powell (and in the novels, Brewer grumbles of some of his ideas "why didn't I think of that?").

to:

* TheShrink: Psychiatrist Dr. Powell is Type 2. He does want to help his patients and truly cares abotu him, about them, and while he acknowledges medications can be useful aids he prefers not to rely on them and recognizes they can sometimes do more harm than good. His critical hinderance as a doctor is that he can't emotionally connect with his patients and see their problems from their angle. This is evident in his first scene, where he lets Ernie ramble about germs without paying much attention to him, dismisses his concerns, and tells him he wants him to start sleeping again because "sleep is good!" This is what allows prot to work towards curie Ernie and Howie, which infuriates Powell (and in the novels, Brewer grumbles of some of his ideas "why didn't I think of that?").

Changed: 978

Removed: 358

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: Powell could very likely lose his license to practice medicine with how he treats prot. For just one example-discussing his handling of a patient with others.
** Maybe. The only people outside of the facility he discusses prot with are his family. But he also never names prot, so it's little different than a writeup in a medical journal would be. Things like bringing prot to the planetarium or the picnic are done in an attempt to cure him by seeing him in a family setting and attempting to disprove his delusion.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: Powell Powell's behavior with prot, like talking about him to friends and family, could very likely lose possibly cost him his license to practice medicine with how depending on the specifics of what he treats prot. For just one example-discussing his handling of told them (doctor-patient confidentiality laws would mostly rule that he shouldn't discuss intimate details about a patient with others.
** Maybe. The only people outside of the facility he discusses prot with are his family. But he also never names prot, so it's little different than a writeup in a medical journal would be. Things like bringing prot to the planetarium or the picnic are done in an attempt to cure him by seeing him in a family setting
and attempting to disprove his delusion.their care).



* PrecisionFStrike: In the film.

to:

* PrecisionFStrike: In prot ''never'' curses, even the film.soft words, which makes the next line a very striking one indeed.



* TheShrink: Psychiatrist Dr. Powell is Type 2. He does want to help his patients and sees medication as a useful aide and not a universal solution, but it's evident early in the film where he doesn't fully listen to Ernie and casually tells him he needs to start sleeping again because "sleep is good!", that he has trouble connecting with his patients.

to:

* TheShrink: Psychiatrist Dr. Powell is Type 2. He does want to help his patients and sees medication as a truly cares abotu him, and while he acknowledges medications can be useful aide aids he prefers not to rely on them and not recognizes they can sometimes do more harm than good. His critical hinderance as a universal solution, but it's doctor is that he can't emotionally connect with his patients and see their problems from their angle. This is evident early in the film his first scene, where he doesn't fully listen to lets Ernie ramble about germs without paying much attention to him, dismisses his concerns, and casually tells him he needs wants him to start sleeping again because "sleep is good!", that he has trouble connecting with good!" This is what allows prot to work towards curie Ernie and Howie, which infuriates Powell (and in the novels, Brewer grumbles of some of his patients.ideas "why didn't I think of that?").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> ''prot'': "Is that a papaya I smell?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He does however essentially dodge the question with his rant and never actually answers it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There's no such thing as unaccented


* AliensSpeakingEnglish: Dr. Powell specifically asks about this, given prot's complete mastery of unaccented, idiom-filled English. prot responds that English is not a difficult language to learn compared to his native language, the name of which alone is about ten syllables long and contains multiple grunts and clicks.

to:

* AliensSpeakingEnglish: Dr. Powell specifically asks about this, given prot's complete mastery of unaccented, a New Jerseyan accent with idiom-filled English. prot responds that English is not a difficult language to learn compared to his native language, the name of which alone is about ten syllables long and contains multiple grunts and clicks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TraumaInducedAmnesia: [[spoiler: The murder of Robert Porter's wife and young daughter, followed by his killing of the murderer, and then his attempting suicide. The question is whether it turned him into a disassociative-personality delusional with savant-like intelligence, especially for astronomy, or if it was the catalyst for his lifelong alien friend prot to reunite with him.]]

to:

* TraumaInducedAmnesia: [[spoiler: The murder of Robert Porter's wife and young daughter, followed by his killing of the murderer, and then his attempting suicide. The question is whether it turned him into a disassociative-personality delusional with savant-like intelligence, especially for astronomy, or if it was the catalyst for his lifelong alien friend prot to reunite merge consciousnesses with him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousEnding: [[spoiler:Hoo boy...]]

to:

* AmbiguousEnding: [[spoiler:Hoo Hoo boy...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptatinalHeroism: A slight example in Russell, the highly religious patient. The book has him being very antagonistic to prot, considering him to be the work of the Devil and wanting nothing to do with him. The film keeps him in the background, but asks if he can take his Bible to K-PAX.

to:

* AdaptatinalHeroism: AdaptationalHeroism: A slight example in Russell, the highly religious patient. The book has him being very antagonistic to prot, considering him to be the work of the Devil and wanting nothing to do with him. The film keeps him in the background, but asks if he can take his Bible to K-PAX.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptatinalHeroism: A slight example in Russell, the highly religious patient. The book has him being very antagonistic to prot, considering him to be the work of the Devil and wanting nothing to do with him. The film keeps him in the background, but asks if he can take his Bible to K-PAX.


Added DiffLines:

** Sal's character is named Chuck in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationDyeJob: prot is described in the book as having hair that is "thick and coal black". Kevin Spacey's portrayal is his natural hair - medium brown and slightly balding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


An adaptation of the [[Literature/KPax 1990 novel of the same name]], ''K-PAX'' is the story of a clinical psychiatrist (Creator/JeffBridges) who takes on a patient claiming to be an extraterrestrial from an advanced alien civilization. The patient (Creator/KevinSpacey), named prot (rhymes with "goat" and spelled with all lowercase letters) displays vast academic knowledge and remarkable philosophical outlooks, which begin having positive effects on the patients and staff of the Manhattan Psychiatric Institute... while leading to increasing uncertainty over his true origins.

to:

An A 2001 adaptation of the [[Literature/KPax 1990 novel of the same name]], ''K-PAX'' is the story of a clinical psychiatrist (Creator/JeffBridges) who takes on a patient claiming to be an extraterrestrial from an advanced alien civilization. The patient (Creator/KevinSpacey), named prot (rhymes with "goat" and spelled with all lowercase letters) displays vast academic knowledge and remarkable philosophical outlooks, which begin having positive effects on the patients and staff of the Manhattan Psychiatric Institute... while leading to increasing uncertainty over his true origins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe. The only people outside of the facility he discusses prot with are his family. But he also never names prot, so it's little different than a writeup in a medical journal would be. Things like bringing prot to the planetarium or the picnic are done in an attempt to cure him by seeing him in a family setting and attempting to disprove his delusion.

Top