Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / IfThereBeThorns

Go To



* AccidentalMisnaming[=/=]MaliciousMisnaming: Madam Marisha calls Emma "Amy." It's not entirely clear which is ''why'', but Emma takes it as MaliciousMisnaming at any rate.

to:

* AccidentalMisnaming[=/=]MaliciousMisnaming: Madam Marisha calls Emma "Amy." It's not entirely clear which is ''why'', trope this actually is, but Emma takes it as MaliciousMisnaming at any rate.



* AdaptationPersonalityChange: A relatively small but significant one for Chris. In the movie, when Chris finds Cathy setting up beds in the attic, he calls her out on in in no uncertain terms and refuses to let her change the subject. In the movie, this is ''way'' downplayed. Then later, in the movie it's ''Chris'' who sends Bart to the attic after he tries to drown Cindy. This represents a significant change from the books, there it's ''Cathy'' who does that, while Chris lets Bart out as soon as he gets home and asks Cathy WhatTheHellHero

to:

* AdaptationPersonalityChange: A relatively small but significant one for Chris. In the movie, when Chris finds Cathy setting up beds in the attic, he calls her out on in it in no uncertain terms terms, and refuses to let her change the subject. In the movie, this is ''way'' downplayed. Then later, in the movie it's ''Chris'' who sends Bart to the attic after he tries to drown Cindy. This represents a significant change from the books, there it's ''Cathy'' who does that, while Chris lets Bart out as soon as he gets home and asks Cathy WhatTheHellHero



* AffairLetters: Jory finds a letter Chris wrote to Cathy in the attic. Unique for this trope, it's not who the letter is between that's the issue--it's the mention of Cathy being 13, when they'd told Jory they didn't meet until they were adults.
* AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts the book at age 9. Jory and Melodie, meanwhile, are on the brink of college. Cindy, meanwhile, is closer to 3 than 2.
* BlatantLies: Along with therapy appointment, the therapist meets with his parents to get some background info.

to:

* AffairLetters: Jory finds a letter Chris wrote to Cathy in the attic. Unique for this trope, it's not who ''who'' the letter is between that's the issue--it's the mention of Cathy being 13, when they'd told Jory they didn't meet until they were adults.
* AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts 12 (age 9 in the book at age 9. book). Jory and Melodie, meanwhile, are on the brink of college.college (14 in the book). Cindy, meanwhile, is closer to 3 than 2.
* BlatantLies: Along with therapy appointment, the therapist meets with his Bart's parents to get some background info.



-->'''Corrine:''' Lots of people resemble each other, it must be a concidance. I've been told I look like Creator/JeanHarlow.
* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: Cindy’s birth mother dies of cancer rather than a car crash as in the book. This is less in keeping with the theme of deadly car crashes through the books, but more in keeping with the drawn-out framing of the event in which Cathy and Chris have time to argue about it.

to:

-->'''Corrine:''' Lots of people resemble each other, it must be a concidance.coincidence. I've been told I look like Creator/JeanHarlow.
* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: Cindy’s birth mother dies of cancer cancer, rather than a car crash as in the book. This is less in keeping with the reoccurring theme of deadly car crashes through the books, but more in keeping with the drawn-out framing of the event in which Cathy and Chris have time to argue about it.



* * PsychoPsychologist: In the book, Bart's therapists are never sinister--the first one is helpful, and the second one is ineffective but benign. In the movie he is strapped to a bed and there is discussion of electroshock therapy. Cathy, thankfully, goes MamaBear and protects him, insisting that shock therapy is off the table an staying with him at the hospital overnight.

to:

* * PsychoPsychologist: In the book, Bart's therapists are never sinister--the first one is helpful, and the second one is ineffective but benign. In the movie he is strapped to a bed and there is discussion of electroshock therapy. Cathy, thankfully, goes MamaBear and protects him, insisting that shock therapy is off the table an staying with him at the hospital overnight.

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalHeroism: Bart threatening John Amos at arrowpoint.


Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalKarma: John Amos gets an arrow through the chest.


Added DiffLines:

* CallBack: At the very end, Chris says he's gonna get some pie, which is a call back to the final scene of the previous movie, where Cathy mentions pie as his favorite.


Added DiffLines:

* GroupHug: Chris, Cathy, and Jory are active participants in a hug after the fire. Bart is sort of reluctantly sandwiched in there.


* AccidentalMisnaming[=/=]MaliciousMisnaming: Madam Marisha calls Emma "Amy." It's not entirely clear which is ''why'', but Emma takes it as MaliciousMisnaming at any rate.



* AdaptationInducedPlotHole: In the book, there is very little attention given to what Corrine thinks of Cathy and Chris's marriage. The one time she asks about it, she says, "But I'd understand"--she had her own incestuous marriage, after all. In the movie, however, she's weird about it.
* AdaptationPersonalityChange: Bart is ''less'' of a LargeHam than in the book.

to:

* AdaptationInducedPlotHole: In the book, there is very little attention given to what Corrine thinks of Cathy and Chris's marriage. The one time she asks about it, she says, "But I'd understand"--she had her own incestuous marriage, after all. In boys are aged up in the movie, however, she's weird about it.
so while Jory is 14 in the book, in the movie him and his girlfriend are discussing colleges. This means that the conflict between Cathy and Madam Marisha--Marisha threatens to expose the incest and get custody of Jory--falls a little flat. Jory is nearly a legal adult, and so custody of him will become a non-issue very soon, and regardless of where he's living, he's going to be leaving to go to college soon.
* AdaptationPersonalityChange: Bart is ''less'' of a LargeHam than A relatively small but significant one for Chris. In the movie, when Chris finds Cathy setting up beds in the book.attic, he calls her out on in in no uncertain terms and refuses to let her change the subject. In the movie, this is ''way'' downplayed. Then later, in the movie it's ''Chris'' who sends Bart to the attic after he tries to drown Cindy. This represents a significant change from the books, there it's ''Cathy'' who does that, while Chris lets Bart out as soon as he gets home and asks Cathy WhatTheHellHero



* AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts the book at age 9. Jory and Melodie, meanwhile, are on the brink of college.

to:

* AffairLetters: Jory finds a letter Chris wrote to Cathy in the attic. Unique for this trope, it's not who the letter is between that's the issue--it's the mention of Cathy being 13, when they'd told Jory they didn't meet until they were adults.
* AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts the book at age 9. Jory and Melodie, meanwhile, are on the brink of college. Cindy, meanwhile, is closer to 3 than 2.



* BuyThemOff: Madam Marisha found out about Chris and Cathy a few years ago, and Chris has been bribing her to stay quiet ever since then. [[PoorCommunicationKills He did not tell Cathy about this]], and now they're running out of money.
* CallingParentsByTheirName:
** Both Bart and Jory call Chris "Dad" most of the time, only calling him "Chris" in moments of "I found out family secrets and I'm angry." They also really put emphasis on his name when they say it.
--->'''Chris''': ''[to Jory]'' Why are you calling me Chris?
** Chris calls Corrine by her name when he sees her.
--->'''Chris''': Corrine.
--->'''Corrine''': Call me "Mother," and give me a hug.



* {{Hypocrite}}: Cathy and Chris have a "No Secrets Policy" for their family... need we say more?
-->'''Bart:''' My dad's come up with a "No Secrets Policy" in our family.
-->'''Corrine:''' He did? That's [[DramaticIrony very ironic]].
* RelatedInTheAdaptation: Of course, Corrine is both Chris and Cathy's mother in all versions. But in the book, they ''tell'' their kids that Corrine is Chris's mother, and that Cathy's mother is dead. This because Chris still considers her his mother--a bad mother, sure, but still his mother--and visits her in the asylum, while Cathy wants ''nothing'' to do with her. In the movie, they claim Corrine as ''Cathy's'' mother, while saying Chris's mother is dead.

to:

* {{Hypocrite}}: {{Hypocrite}}:
**
Cathy and Chris have a "No Secrets Policy" for their family... need we say more?
-->'''Bart:''' --->'''Bart:''' My dad's come up with a "No Secrets Policy" in our family.
-->'''Corrine:''' --->'''Corrine:''' He did? That's [[DramaticIrony very ironic]].
** In the book, there is very little attention given to what Corrine thinks of Cathy and Chris's marriage. The one time she asks about it, she says, "But I'd understand"--she had her own incestuous marriage, after all. In the movie, however, she's weird about it.
* MultitaskedConversation: Bart tries to drown Cindy, and then yells at his parents that
-->'''Bart:''' No! I shouldn't! Brothers shouldn't ''love'' their sisters! Isn't that right, [[CallingParentsByTheirName Chris]]?
* ThePeepingTom: Bart sees both his brother having sex with his girlfriend, and his parents having sex. While there’s lots of voyeurism in the books, this scene specifically is an adaptation addition.
* * PsychoPsychologist: In the book, Bart's therapists are never sinister--the first one is helpful, and the second one is ineffective but benign. In the movie he is strapped to a bed and there is discussion of electroshock therapy. Cathy, thankfully, goes MamaBear and protects him, insisting that shock therapy is off the table an staying with him at the hospital overnight.
* SmokingIsNotCool: Chris, as a doctor, is pretty disdainful of Madam Marisha's smoking.
* RelatedInTheAdaptation: Of course, course Corrine is both Chris and Cathy's mother in all versions. But in the book, they ''tell'' their kids that Corrine is Chris's mother, and that Cathy's mother is dead. This because Chris still considers her his mother--a bad mother, sure, but still his mother--and visits her in the asylum, while Cathy wants ''nothing'' to do with her. In the movie, they claim Corrine as ''Cathy's'' mother, while saying Chris's mother is dead.

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationDyeJob: In the books, both Jory and Bart take after their dark-haired fathers, and--particularly when they're older--there's said to be some resemblance been the two of them. In the movie, Jory is blond, while Bart is still dark-haired. This means Bart ''looks'' different from the rest of his family, visually reinforcing the idea of him as a BlackSheep.


* TheEighties: It goes nearly unmentioned in the novel, but the movie plays up the setting a little more with fashions and technology--Bart has a handheld Donkey Kong video game; Corrine takes a Polaroid of the Sheffield boys; etc.
* AdaptationInducedPlotHole: In the book, there is very little attention given to what Corrine thinks of Cathy and Chris's marriage. The one time she asks about it, she says, "But I'd understand"--she had her own incestuous marriage, after all. In the movie, however, she's weird about it.



* AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts the book at age 9.

to:

* AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts the book at age 9. Jory and Melodie, meanwhile, are on the brink of college.
* BlatantLies: Along with therapy appointment, the therapist meets with his parents to get some background info.
-->'''Therapist:''' Has there been any history of abuse, inversion, deviance, or mental illness in the family?
-->'''Cathy:''' No, not at all.


-->'''Corrine:''' He did? That's [[DramaticIrony very ironic]].

to:

-->'''Corrine:''' He did? That's [[DramaticIrony very ironic]].ironic]].
* RelatedInTheAdaptation: Of course, Corrine is both Chris and Cathy's mother in all versions. But in the book, they ''tell'' their kids that Corrine is Chris's mother, and that Cathy's mother is dead. This because Chris still considers her his mother--a bad mother, sure, but still his mother--and visits her in the asylum, while Cathy wants ''nothing'' to do with her. In the movie, they claim Corrine as ''Cathy's'' mother, while saying Chris's mother is dead.

Added DiffLines:

* CelebrityResemblance
-->'''Corrine:''' Lots of people resemble each other, it must be a concidance. I've been told I look like Creator/JeanHarlow.


* Jedidiah Goodacre as Jory

to:

* Jedidiah Goodacre Creator/JedidiahGoodacre as Jory


* Mason Cook as Bart

to:

* Mason Cook Creator/MasonCook as Bart



to:

* Mason Cook as Bart
* Jedidiah Goodacre as Jory
* Bailey Skodje as Cindy



* AdaptationPersonalityChange: Bart is ''less'' of a LargeHam than in the book.
* AdaptationSpeciesChange: The pet Bart wants but his parents won't let him get is a snake, not a pony. The pet Corrine gets him is a snake, not a dog.



* {{Hypocrite}}: Cathy and Chris have a "No Secrets Policy" for their family... need we say more?

to:

* {{Flashback}}: Bart reading Malcolm's journal is combined with flashback scenes of Malcolm writing it.
* {{Hypocrite}}: Cathy and Chris have a "No Secrets Policy" for their family... need we say more?more?
-->'''Bart:''' My dad's come up with a "No Secrets Policy" in our family.
-->'''Corrine:''' He did? That's [[DramaticIrony very ironic]].

Added DiffLines:

*AgeLift: Bart starts the movie at age 12, while he starts the book at age 9.

Added DiffLines:

* DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation: Cindy’s birth mother dies of cancer rather than a car crash as in the book. This is less in keeping with the theme of deadly car crashes through the books, but more in keeping with the drawn-out framing of the event in which Cathy and Chris have time to argue about it.


[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/tvmovie_itbt.jpg]]



Starring Rachael Carpani as Cathy, Jason Lewis as Chris, and Creator/HeatherGraham as Corrine.

to:

Starring Starring:
*
Rachael Carpani as Cathy, Cathy
*
Jason Lewis as Chris, and Chris
*
Creator/HeatherGraham as Corrine.
Corrine

Added DiffLines:

In 2015, {{Creator/Lifetime}} did a MadeForTVMovie adaptation of [[Literature/IfThereBeThorns the book]].

Starring Rachael Carpani as Cathy, Jason Lewis as Chris, and Creator/HeatherGraham as Corrine.

----
!!Tropes associated with the movie include:

* {{Hypocrite}}: Cathy and Chris have a "No Secrets Policy" for their family... need we say more?

Showing 14 edit(s) of 14

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report